Phoenix, Arizona. April 27, 2010 - Some people from Arizona, or those who have lived here for quite a while, may be appalled but not surprised about the dramatic turn the volatile issue of immigration has taken in this state during the last few days.
The passage of Senate Bill 1070, signed into law on Friday, April 23, 2010 by Governor Janice Brewer, could be only considered the straw that broke the camel's back, since Arizona's legislators have been implementing similar laws for at least the last 15 years.
From laws regarding driver licenses, public assistance programs, education, smuggling of people and many others, Arizona has taken their own initiative to supposedly fight illegal immigration in the state.
SB 1070 is considered the most strict immigration law at the state level, and is targeted to immigrants who lack legal status in the United States. The law makes it a crime to be in Arizona without legal papers, and allows local police agencies to enforce federal immigration law. The passage of SB 1070 makes Arizona the first state that criminalizes immigrants who entered without permit.
Arizona has taken immigration law into its own hands for the last decade and a half, and in such an aggressive way anyone would think immigrants without documents are a thing of the past, that the problem of immigration has been solved thanks to strong legislation, and that this state could be a model on how to tackle such a polarizing and complicated issue. Nothing could be so far from the truth.
Instead, Arizona was dubbed "immigration ground" zero when a series of volatile street protests burst in Phoenix in the fall of 2007, and now with the passage of 1070, it has also become the epicenter of sharp criticism and mockery around the nation and the world in 2010.
Arizona has also become a failed and shameful laboratory where immigrants from Latin America are a demographic experiment for politicians who have decided to play enforcing immigration law at the expense of brown people, legally in the country or not.
According to a 2008 report by the Southern Poverty Law Center, Arizona is now home to 19 documented hate groups, 10 of them Neo-Nazi, which thrive thanks to politicians like Senator Russell Pearce who promote so-called immigration state laws targeted to specific ethnic groups.
A revealing National Geographic Channel documentary titled "American Skinheads" that aired on Wednesday, March 19, 2008, included a segment about Arizona's growing and violent racist activities by white supremacists, neo-nazis, skinheads and others. The documentary affirmed that "racist skinheads and white supremacists are flooding into Arizona and heading toward the U.S.-Mexico border..."
Seeking to fix a problem beyond its reach and resources, Arizona has earned a dumb reputation, brewed hate and racism, and become the subject of understandable mockery across the nation and other countries. Arizona has also proven that it has forgotten a fundamental economic lesson, when the state refused to adopt Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Day as a paid holiday years ago.
With the new 1070 law, Arizona is clearly determined to continue on the path of failure not only as an enforcer of immigration law, but also of economic collapse. Arizona's quest to become the national laboratory of local immigration laws has positioned it to become another laboratory, one for likely successful economic boycotts.
After the passage of this new law, the United States and other countries have awaken to a reality that Arizona residents have endured and fought for years. The reaction of people who live outside the state against SB 1070 has intensified the daily struggle Arizonans who oppose this type of legislation, as well as increasing the level of support. This would surely strengthen a movement that many of us embraced from the beginning, and hopefully persuade some locals who are still in disbelief.
Providing amnesty permits individuals to come out of the shadows.
Then they and their employers can start paying taxes.
Many of them may opt for a 5-10 year work visa.
If these immigrants were given amnesty, perhaps they could move out of the border state and then we could try what you propose.
In upstate NY, recent immigrants from war-torn parts of the world (Bosnia, Burma, Somalia, etc.) have helped the local economy. Their children achieve above average in school grades.
The minorities and progressivs within state of Arizona cloud implement their own economic boycott and punish the Republican Party within their state.
As a first step they could select the LARGEST CONTRIBUTOR to the Republican Party in 3-5 sectors of the economy, and boycott them. As a suggestion the sectors I would look at would be Retail, Grocery, Gas station-operators, Fast-food chain operators, Soft-drink beverage, Beer company, Hotel chain.
Economic Pressure from within the state, which will only grow with every month, would work faster than any legal action.
Those who are in jobs that are on the books using fraudulent documents and false SS numbers are paying taxes, but they have committed other crimes in addition to crossing the border illegally. In ALL the jobs I have held, I would be FIRED for lying on an application form. Think that illegals should be exempt from the norms? Should they get a pass on ID theft,fraud, perjury, forgery, SS fraud, failing to register for the draft, etc..? Obviously some people think that illegals should be exempt from all of our laws. Will Americans who are convicted of all those crimes have to be released because of unequal application of those laws? IN short, an amnesty creates a superior class of people in the US who have committed a crime!
What is wrong with just enforcing the law. Arizona's new law does not allow racial profiling.
The interaction between laws and markets is complex, and often the best regulation makes the market orderly and more efficient. Forget about borders and just think about the labor market here. Supply and demand absolutely dictate more people will come, even at risk of death. To regulate this market away would take so much state force that it would be tyrrany. Citizens and non-citizens alike would get swept up in dragnet operations, curfews, raids, surveillance, random checks, etc. It's the same with the market for illegal drugs. We can kill and incarcerate thousands, build Skynet, and even then, the drug trade might still occur.
When law goes completely against markets, it often loses. The whole USSR could not overcome this. Good regulation allows facilitates orderly exchange. Amnesty, followed by an extremely facilitative immigration policy is the most rational first step in regulating this labor market, and the second most rational step is drug legalization. However, it's a permissive-parent instead of a strict-father policy approach, and it feeds reason over rage, so it won't win the day, and change will not happen - just more jingoism and militarization of society (fascism).
Do it legal or stay out!!
We don't need you here if you can't follow the law!!
MAKE ILLEGAL ENTRY A FELONY
MANDATE E-VERIFY FOR ALL EMPLOYERS, AMD ALL EMPLOYEES
END BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP FOR ILLEGALS
BUILD MORE FENCE
IT'S WORKING!!
Tucson Border Patrol Sector Monthly Apprehensions Of Illegals---Length 262 miles
----------OCT---NOV---DEC---JAN----FEB---MAR---APR---MAY---JUN----JUL---AUG---SEP
FY2010-23211-16999-10922-16096-21223-31203
FY2009-18814-12845--9862-18649-20943-31433-28072-24084-20822-20144-20805-15178
FY2008-21725-18232-11722-26348-34297-45222-45436-32851-24290-21074-18404-18044
FY2007-25135-21323-16136-29459-34148-52692-49044-41789-34103-30373-24388-19649
FY2006-27316-24270-16447-33229-43153-63583-51588-40190-25049-21187-23256-22806
If people are sincerely concerned with "White supremacists" they might ask the SPLC why NOT ONE of their top ten, highest paid officers is a minority. http://wp.me/pCLYZ-3r
You can't always take the SPLC's fund-raising propaganda as the gospel truth. They've put nearly $190 MILLION donor-dollars into their slush fund by peddling such spurious "reports".
states.