Going, Going, Gone? Will Chicago Tear Down Buildings by Mies van der Rohe and Walter Gropius?

Remember when this summed up Chicago?

(Chicago Sun-Times, 1953)

We don't want to be like that anymore. We have learned the value of our history, right? We have a mayor who promotes local culture and beauty and Chicago as a tourist destination, right? We are America's "architecture homeland."

Ludwig Mies van der Rohe and Walter Gropius are, along with Le Corbusier, the three fathers of Modern Architecture. They changed the way the world looks. Chicago is lucky to have some of Mies' original works, such as the Illinois Institute of Technology, with its world-renowned masterpiece, Crown Hall. We also have a large campus designed with great involvement from Walter Gropius. Gropius founded and Mies later joined the influential German design school, the Bauhaus, before emigrating to America in the 1930s. How interesting that their works and thought are reunited in the 1950s on the South Side of Chicago.

Now, Mayor Daley and the city want to tear down the buildings that Gropius was involved in designing. We know he was a consultant to the local architects. New evidence is coming to light that Gropius may have been very involved in designing, along with the local firms, eight or more of the buildings at Michael Reese Hospital.

These buildings form the campus of Michael Reese Hospital. The Mayor wants the land for his Olympic Village Plaza. Great! These buildings, adaptively reused, would make a wonderful Olympic Village, with history. Even the landscape there is historic. I've written about it, with more photos and video, here.

Mayor Daley wants to be America's Green mayor. Good for him. But he has got to back it up with action. The best way to promote sustainable, environmentally responsible architecture is to adaptively reuse buildings where possible. The Michael Reese campus is the perfect place. What's there is historic and international, and restoring it would leave a great Olympic legacy: A story of German architects finding a home in America, and doing great work, after World War II. At Michael Reese the work was even for a Jewish organization.

The Mies building that would come down is a little brick structure designed and built to mark the southwest corner of the IIT campus, among other things. Metra wants to yank it down to put up a rail station. They have vacant land to the south and the west, and moving it south would make it more convenient for the many White Sox fans who will use the stop. But the rail company wants to put it right where a little brick building with two long brick walls built by Ludwig Mies van der Rohe stands. More information and photos here. If Mies said, "Less is more," he did not mean of his own work.

The walls and building by Mies to be torn down start at the tracks on the left, make the corner, and then run all the way to the power plant.

Dear Metra, do the right thing. Either move your station to the west side of the tracks, closer to U.S. Cellular Field, or to the south side of 35th Street, saving baseball fans from having to cross that street, busy with traffic at game time. Or, keep the Mies buildings, and work the station around them. That does not look difficult. You could even work with IIT to put up an information booth in the station about the worldwide importance of Mies van der Rohe. You'll have a station incorporating historic architecture. "Win-win," as they say. Isn't this better than tearing it down?

A note, in jest: If Chicago is going to tear down works by Mies and Gropius, then I think it's only fair that Cambridge, Massachusetts, knock down the only building in America wholly designed by Le Corbusier, the Carpenter Center. Let's knock down all those modernists. Before people come around to really appreciating them.

Edward Lifson blogs about cities, buildings and beauty, at Hello Beautiful! He loves a lot of contemporary architecture, and understands the profit to be made in demolition and new construction. He just wants to keep the best of the old, and believes that great cities are layers of their history, demonstrating who the people were who lived there during a series of eras.

Comments

[BushBites]

And, by the way.

Daley's so-called "environmentalism" is nothing but "greenwashing."

He's the same as his dad, just in a new package.

[BushBites]

Don't worry.

He'll keep the historical columns and stick a stadium in the middle.

It'll look great!

[REGONE]

Where are all the so called "green enviromental activist" to question the Daley administration on the possible usage of parks during the Olympic games? The media in Chicago are only writing and blogging about little poor Todd Stroger on patronage hiring to deflect attention from bigger issues. For some reason beyond my comprehension, they will not report on policies that has consequences like tax increment financing that starves CPS schools from funding so children can compete long term the global economy. By the way, Daley will use tax increment financing to build the Olympic village and tear down the Gropius designs.

[MrVinegar]

Bertrand Goldberg's Prentice Women's Hospital is likely to be torn down soon also. Now that Northwestern Memorial Hospital has completed the new Prentice eyesore, err excuse me, building. The University owns the land and the Hospital the building (or something like that) so neither will get the full blame.

http://www.bertrandgoldberg.org/works/prentice_hospital.html

[BushBites]

Aren't they using that for psych now?

I thought it was being repurposed?

[MrVinegar]

The Institute for Psychiatry is still in the lower portion of the building where it has always been. As far as I know there have been no plans to repurpose the building yet.

[mergina]

If there is a backroom under the table deal to be had between Daley and one of his cronies, THERE IS NOT A BUILDING IN THIS CITY THAT CAN BE SPARED. He is a thug. He is not a lover or arts. He is a boss, a mob boss who is allowed to hide behind the so called laws of a city he thinks he owns. VOTE DALEY OUT OF OFFICE. VOTE EVERY SINGLE ALDERMAN OUT OF OFFICE. They are all a pack of worthless criminals.

[Totto]

His dad demolished Sullivan's Stock Exchange. Like father, like son.

[astridc]

Why can't Chicago get this right? Mayor Daley is one of the few mayors across the country that can make things happen and has a demonstrated commitment to improving the urban environment. But here he is on the way to making an architectural and cultural tragedy and a terrible waste of environmental resources. The modern buildings by Gropius, etc., are an ASSET to Chicago -- adding to the city's significance as an 20th century architectural mecca to visitors from around the world. Why lose them when there's a better solution? It's not too late. The beauty of the major world cities - Paris, London, Barcelona, Berlin, Tokyo, Shanghai, to name a few - thrives on the thrilling juxtaposition of old and new. Finally, and this is key, it is more "green" to adapt, repurpose and reuse old buildings. Please slow down and reconsider these options. It's not too late. Tell us it's not too late, please.