More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Edward Zwick

GET UPDATES FROM Edward Zwick
 

The Sad Truth About the Fight Against Blood Diamonds

Posted: 12/ 4/2011 12:53 pm

It is a tragic paradox of our time that poor nations with abundant resources should suffer unimaginably while their political leaders appropriate riches that might otherwise mitigate poverty and foster economic growth. This brutal phenomenon is known as the "resource curse." With a global economy increasingly defined by access to natural resources, and emerging nations with growing populations industrializing and creating new scarcities, this pattern of corruption and abuse grows more appalling each day.

Five years ago I made the film Blood Diamond -- a story of the illicit diamond trade and its funding of the bloody civil war in Sierra Leone. While doing my research, I discovered that the NGO Global Witness had been the first to expose the blood diamond trade and call for action. The pressure brought to bear by this small but remarkably effective group helped create what many hoped would be a lasting solution -- the Kimberley Process -- a certification scheme that brought together governments, industry and civil society in an effort to guarantee that diamonds would no longer be sourced from conflict zones in order to finance war.

Unfortunately, the Kimberley Process's refusal to address the clear links between diamonds, violence and tyranny has rendered it hopelessly ineffectual. In effect, it has become an accomplice to diamond laundering -- as well as the corruption and depredations that inevitably follow -- by offering the illusion of institutional cover to endemic and escalating corruption. Despite intensive efforts over nine years by a determined coalition of NGOs, the sad truth is that most consumers still cannot be sure where their diamonds come from. And so, Monday, Global Witness is announcing its withdrawal as an official Observer to the process.

The reasons for this are many and sadly irrefutable. Last month the Kimberley Process allowed the government of Zimbabwe to cash in diamonds mined in the infamous Marange fields -- site of a state-sponsored massacre of hundreds of civilian miners. Currently under the control of the Zanu PF military-political elite, this ill-gotten windfall will serve to finance President Robert Mugabe's re-election campaign, assuring his stranglehold on that benighted country for years to come. That the diamond industry and the Kimberly Process' member states chose to disregard this blatant corruption is unconscionable. Rather than share in its complicity, the group had no choice but to withdraw its support. Nor is this the first instance of such abuse. The Kimberly Process has also failed to deal with the trade in conflict diamonds from Côte d'Ivoire, and was unwilling to take action in the face of equally flagrant disregard by Venezuela.

Although Global Witness will continue to work with other NGOs in the Civil Society Coalition, it befalls the rest of us to do our part. In addition to supporting legislation that will oblige the diamond industry to comply with independent audits and public disclosure, we must finally become responsible consumers. It is time we awaken to the reality that what we buy and where it comes from is inherently political. We must call on companies to become transparent and call out those who don't. We need to make sure that the diamond we buy to express our love is not destroying the life of someone we will never know.

Edward Zwick, a writer-director of film and television, serves on the advisory board of Global Witness.

 
It is a tragic paradox of our time that poor nations with abundant resources should suffer unimaginably while their political leaders appropriate riches that might otherwise mitigate poverty and foste...
It is a tragic paradox of our time that poor nations with abundant resources should suffer unimaginably while their political leaders appropriate riches that might otherwise mitigate poverty and foste...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 297
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
two 'alves of coconut!
10:31 PM on 12/11/2011
This all sounds really great, but what about the 'blood oil' and 'blood minerals' probably being lifted out of the ground in dear ol' Afghanistan? 

There's valuable stuff in the ground. Activists try to get in the way of the stuff getting mined or whatever, and people get hurt and killed when the mercenaries roll in.   Anytime there's Large Sums Of Money 'on the table', regardless of what country you're talking about, anywhere in the world, the potential's there.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
orcinous
Obama has made things better.
10:31 PM on 12/11/2011
We should all be minimalists. Diamonds should be at the bottom, if not off the list of things we buy.
garystartswithg
el sueno de la razon produce republicans
09:45 PM on 12/11/2011
Vanity is ugly. I don't know why anyone "needs" diamonds, furs, etc. You can't take it with you.
02:44 PM on 12/11/2011
I was very surprised to learn from an NPR program today that Canada is now the 3rd largest producer of diamonds in the world. The were only discovered in 1991. They still export most of them to be cut; I have to wonder how they can track them once they get to Antwerp or whatever. I don't care for diamonds personally, but if I were going to buy one I'd make sure it was from Canada where there are human rights laws and environmental ethics.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=96564952
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lrae2007
10:31 AM on 12/11/2011
Edward, I appreciate the position you take on this and agree. To further complicate any control is the fact that diamonds are in demand in China now and you know their record on human rights.

They are exporting fine jewelry(rings, necklaces, etc.) assembled with diamonds from who knows where. Of course one their biggest customers would be U.S. importers.
06:54 AM on 12/10/2011
Just don't buy diamonds. The zirconias are so real most experts can't tell them from the real thing. I'm perfectly happy with a man made diamond. It costs less and has no flaws. No diamonds for this girl.
11:36 AM on 12/11/2011
Right on and if we could extrapolate that even further and buy fake fur instead of the real thing, Brutal Chinese furfarms would also become a thing of the past. The west is so cosy up with China now, it is impossible to boycott Chinese goods, they are in everything we buy. Big business and advertising brainwash the world. Most people don't care anyway as long as they can continue to pamper themselves in their vain shallow lives.
02:40 AM on 12/08/2011
I'm steering clear from diamonds, since I don't really get the appeal anyway (my toilet can sparkle, too!). Decades of marketing have made these rings the 'acceptable' expression of a desire to commit to someone, but honestly I'd be pretty offended if I got one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mu chowdhury
Truth is elusive
02:23 PM on 12/09/2011
Uncommon ethics of 'our time' and highly laudable.
10:08 PM on 12/07/2011
There are actually posts online from "Greg" at brilliant Earth saying that one of the places they get cut diamonds from is Israel. Yet another example of a fundamental flaw in the Kimberly process (does not cover cut diamonds) and the hypocrisy in the industry (promoting diamonds cut in Israel as "conflict free" when the industry there helps fund occupation and human rights abuses).
07:22 PM on 12/06/2011
The Brilliant Earth representative GKBrilliant posting below was very quick to use this thread to promote thier "ethical origin" diamonds which they claim are conflict free. But when some people asked where thier diamonds are cut and polished they deleted the post from thier Facebook Wall and blocked them. What have BE got to hide? Why not let people know if their "ethical origin" conflict free diamonds are cut and polished in Israel?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:42 PM on 12/07/2011
Good point....
08:09 AM on 12/09/2011
Brilliant Earth deleted my comments requesting information about the origin of their diamonds and whether any were cut and polished in Israel as well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Queen
I am a disabled nam vet
02:42 PM on 12/06/2011
Yep,and it's still happening today in africa mainly.Children are forced to dig thu the mud for diamonds.Rebel groups there actually have their very own diamond mines and they use chilren,women and men,no mate how young or how old,no matter if their dying sick or not.Their constantly beaten to make them work harfer and faster.Ya,it's still a major ongoing problem for sure.So why haven't we cut back or cut off aide to these certain african states that this takes place in?No,we keep sending those billions which ends up in the bank accounts of cruel dictaters and or cruel rebel leaders.What we need to do as one certain politician said is to start over at zero concerning foreign aide.Tale a close look at each aplicant,do the background cheks and intelligence sources to find out just what really i going on and why they need the money,and where it's been goin in the past etc.Then we start deciding who is eligible and who is not.If their playing it straight across the board woth no corruption involved at all then we can send those country's the aide they need.The way we have been and are oing it is making us lose mega billions a year and most of it go's to dictaters,corrupt rulers,or hijacked by rebel forces etc and it never ends up going to where it's supose to go,same with food and medical aide,most of it is taken by rebel forces
11:15 AM on 12/06/2011
If you’re looking for fully conflict-free diamond jewelry, check out http://bynataliefrigo.com She designed our wedding rings and uses only recycled metals and all ethical origin gems. Her gem dealers buy their diamonds from Australia and Canada, where regulations assure that all workers are treated fairly. Don't support war and suffering by wearing unethical materials!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LaFemmeSASE
09:03 AM on 12/06/2011
Your movie inspired me to do a paper on the Civil Wra in Sierra Leone and what I read in my research was most disturbing. Most dont know that the very peacekeepers who were sent to protect people during the war were mining diamonds as well and making deals with the RUF. It was so bad that the RUF was able to destroy a whole town because the peacekeepers left their guns behind and were in the river searching for diamonds. I think it is very sad that what I thought was the progress made with the Kimberly Porcess was not really progress but puff, a smokescreen cover the horrific activities which blood diamonds are used to fund today.
11:30 PM on 12/05/2011
Thanks for your movie. It really helped raise awareness. Thanks also for continuing to advocate for a more ethical diamond trade and for speaking up now about what's going on now with the Kimberley Process. I absolutely agree. It's unconscionable that the Kimberley Process is giving its "conflict free" stamp of approval to diamonds tied to serious human rights violations­, not to mention helping to sustain a brutal dictator, Robert Mugabe.

But also troublesom­e is that the diamond industry -- as represente­d by the World Diamond Council -- continues to publicize to consumers that the diamond supply is more than 99% conflict free.This statistic misleads consumers about the true state of affairs. (Zimbabwe is actually poised to produce 10% to 15% of the diamond supply.) It also deflates consumer momentum for more substantiv­e changes, like the transparen­cy measures you propose. Over the past week, we've been blogging about this issue at http://blog.brilliantearth.com/ . Brilliant Earth is a leading provider of ethical origin diamond jewelry -- all of it conflict free and ethically sourced. -- GK, www.brilliantearth.com
04:08 AM on 12/06/2011
While Brilliant Earth may be a supplier of “ethical origin” diamonds it has consistently refused to answer queries from Facebook fans about where Brilliant Earth diamonds are cut and polished and has censored anyone who asks if any of their diamonds are cut and polished in Israel. It's no consolation to the victims of Israel's diamond-funded war crimes in Gaza that BE diamonds are of "ethical origin" when revenue from the Israeli cutting and polishing industry funds the white phosphors and flechette nail bombs raining down on their heads. If Brilliant Earth is selling diamond cut and polished in Israeli then it is helping to fund a nuclear-armed belligerent regime that stands accused of war crimes and possible crimes against humanity by the UN HRC and its diamonds are not conflict free.
04:53 PM on 12/06/2011
I asked Brilliant Earth questions about Israeli cut & polished diamonds on their Facebook page but my questions were deleted and I have been blocked from their page.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:49 PM on 12/07/2011
Took the words right out of my mouth ...thanks WARDIAMOND....
05:40 PM on 12/05/2011
Organized crime has evolved to become institutionalized crime ...globally. Its why the US has bases in 70 countries around the world and spends more on military than the entire rest of the world combined ...natural resources make the world go round. Thats the chess global chess match.

We hate Chavez because he decided the profit from oil in Venezualan soil should belong to his countrymen. Africa will probably never reach that level of self determination ...Trillions of dollars are at stack in the Congo alone. Read "King Leopolds Ghost"
01:58 PM on 12/05/2011
Amazing diamonds come from Australia. The jewelry stores in Sydney had amazing diamonds in colors I had never seen before, and as brilliant as any I've seen. Perhaps this is an alternative.