iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Eldon Taylor

GET UPDATES FROM Eldon Taylor
 

Is This the Law of Attraction at Work?

Posted: 12/09/11 11:50 AM ET

The Secret and The Law of Attraction have drawn a great deal of interest from main street folks, not just the so-called new age followers. Bob Proctor, a Secret teacher, asserts that a fellow teacher, James Arthur Ray attracted his own demise -- the Sedona disaster. So let me start by asking you to participate in a mind experiment. The idea behind a mind experiment is to actually explore an idea by participating in a sort of vicarious way. So, let's use some imagination and see where it leads.

What if you found yourself at a retreat? The leader is excited as he invites everyone to experience their real unlimited selves. The tempo of his voice increases as the pitch and cadence of his delivery rise and fall like a compositional masterpiece. The excitement is contagious and soon everyone in attendance is feeling the excitement --some are even experiencing genuine goosebumps. All of this is leading to a special exercise that will cleanse everyone forever of their doubts and fears. It's as if you're about to get asked to walk the hot coals -- but that's not the deal today. No, today it's not a fire walk, not repelling down some steep building edge or cliff, not a bungee jump or anything like that -- no, today it sounds much safer and so you have ventured here to undertake the Native American sweat lodge tradition.

When the group is adequately prepared, the leader shows them into the lodge, a large tent. The air is very hot and thick. Some chanting begins and the leader speaks much softer now, as though he is about to guide all through a dream. As time passes the air grows ever heavier and you have more and more trouble breathing. You are all told not to leave the tent. "Don't quit when you're almost there. Don't quit just before the miracle," the leader urges.

The person next to you is gasping. You look at her and can tell that she is about to collapse. Across from you someone else falls backward from her sitting position as though she has just passed out. You can't believe how hard it is to breathe. The sweat pours off of you. You are oscillating between some form of full ordinary consciousness and some sort of out-there trip. You question yourself, "Am I supposed to feel this way? Are they burning some kind of hallucinogenic? You're about to speak out when another woman attempts to stand, only to fall on her face. You think, "2 down and a third, maybe a fourth counting me, are about to fall." It then dawns on you like a sudden epiphany -- "You could die in here and no one would know until much later." Then you think, "Are those two women OK?"

At what point do you take the initiative to check on yourself and others? At what juncture do you realize that your leader may just be a little unreliable for this kind of thing? Let's assume that you are lucid enough to recount how you got here. You did not fill out any health record, or any other form for that matter that might disclose either physical or mental conditions. No one asked you about your fitness for this sort of thing. Some of those in the lodge are clearly fitter than others and some are closer to the tent entrance and so they are both further from the fire and more able to breathe easily.

You are here to gain spiritual insight. Are you responsible for what is going on around you? Are you responsible for those that are going through this with you? Or have you abrogated your responsibility by turning everything over to the leader? Do you just blindly do as you are told or do you take responsibility for everything you do?

In October, 2009, the New York Times reported, "Midway through a two-hour sweat lodge ceremony intended to be a rebirthing experience, participants say, some people began to fall desperately ill from the heat, even as their leader, James Arthur Ray, a nationally known New Age guru, urged them to press on." The Times article continues,

"There were people throwing up everywhere," said Dr. Beverley Bunn, 43, an orthodontist from Texas, who said she struggled to remain conscious in the sweat lodge.... Dr. Bunn said Mr. Ray told the more than 50 people jammed into the small structure -- people who had just completed a 36-hour "vision quest" in which they fasted alone in the desert -- that vomiting "was good for you, that you are purging what your body doesn't want, what it doesn't need." But by the end of the ordeal on Oct. 8, emergency crews had taken 21 people to hospitals. Three have since died.

Did Ray somehow attract this? Is this how the Secret works? Did the participants receive their just deserts based on the law of attraction, as well? Is there a dark side to the so-called law of attraction?

According to the Arizona Republic, on November 19th, James Arthur Ray "was sentenced Friday to two years in prison for the deaths of three people at a sweat-lodge ceremony he led near Sedona, punishment years less than what relatives of the victims had hoped for."

You decide -- law of attraction?

Thanks for the read,

Eldon

For more mind experiments testing one's beliefs, see my book, What If?.

 

Follow Eldon Taylor on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DrEldonTaylor

 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:41 PM on 01/01/2012
Yes, indeed it is the law of attraction at work, but not quite as the movie "The Secret" lines out as much is missing from it. When driving for "things you want" from a place of ego/fear/control (i.e. his apparent desire to be a top-dog personal development guru), there are "backlash" effects where things like this happen. JAR let his ego fly way out of control, and this is what happened to him. Unfortunately, the others who died believed and bought his egoic persuasion, and by believing it to the end died to that effect. Being in the personal development industry myself - JAR as the leader of the event, is ultimately responsible for the well-being of his clients. Talk about not being a warrior and owning up to it by saying "I did not know it would happen." JAR is still playing the victim, and not learned too much apparently. Perhaps that's part of his learning, and it's a shame it's at the cost of three lives.
07:51 PM on 12/11/2011
Okay, for a moment, lets pretend that the families of the three who died are all scam artists who wanted to take James Arthur Ray for every penny they could get? Just for a moment let's pretend this is the absolute truth. If they were scam artists how would they go about taking Mr Ray for every penny they could get?
BY DOING EXACTLY WHAT THEY DID!!!
That's how
On the one hand they would have you believe those three were GREAT WARRIORS and at the very same time they want you to believe they should have been treated like irresponsible children who can't decide for themselves and, here's the thing, the suckers fell for it!
Make no mistake about this: When truly GREAT WARRIORS say they are going to take full responsibility for their actions at ANY EVENT that is what they do and they don't need to sign any agreement to keep that promise. By breaking the agreement those three supposed "warriors" made with Mr Ray they have proven them to be lying phonies who were always ready to break ANY PROMISES if they felt they could make a lot of money by doing so.
10:56 AM on 12/11/2011
It seems to me those three were trying to prove how tough they were by staying in the sweat lodge longer than they should have and not asking for help when they knew they needed it. I don't see why Mr Ray should be held responsible for that.
photo
E Elizabeth
I live in Chicago w/ my better half Dr @Mercola &
06:44 PM on 12/12/2011
Thankfully YOU weren't on the jury and the jury felt different and the former guru now failure/convict is sitting in prison for homicide charges. Considering it is documented that he screamed for them to sit down and went on about how they'd feel they were going to die (but wouldn't) I wish they'd locked him up in a hot tent and thrown away the key....
09:19 AM on 12/11/2011
As with all things in our existence, an opposite must exist for anything to have meaning. I'm quite sure that death was not intended in any way. The lesson in life is for the individual(s) involved. The lesson to be learned at the expense of the victims is that, you must decide what limitations you set for yourself. This incident allows us to see whether we are awake and aware, or if we are sleepwalking through our very own life. A true leader teaches others how to lead, not to follow.

There was a choice that each individual made by staying in conditions that threatened their personal well-being. It ponders the question of why we do anything that poses a risk to our lives. We can sit back and decide if something is right or wrong on a personal basis, leading us to make judgments about something that we have no experience of. This incident was a choice that made an impact on the lives of the familes of the people involved, victims and/or survivors. A life lesson is learned. Only you, can and should decide what is best for you.
12:19 PM on 12/10/2011
Is This the Law of Attraction at Work?

Come on! Pretty straight forward and nothing a little applied logic wouldn't fix. If you give away your power to any Robert, Dick or Sally - the takers will be lined up at the door.
10:03 AM on 12/10/2011
Greed? Greed??? You want to talk about Greed? Well then tell us all just how much greed it took for the families of those three to break the sacred promises of those 'supposed warriors' and take James Arthur Ray for every penny they could get? Do tell?

If Mr Ray knew those three were actually phonies who would break their promises and take him for every penny they could get he would NEVER have allowed them to participate in the workshop at ANY PRICE!
01:11 AM on 12/10/2011
Remember that these were supposed to be Great Spiritual Warriors of whom James Arthur Ray is not worthy to "kiss their boots". Such people take full responsibility for their actions at ANY EVENT, if that is what they promised. They should need no written agreement. Their word should be contract enough...if they are the REAL THING, that is
09:08 PM on 12/09/2011
Law of attraction? Um, no, law of physics... and greed, arrogance and vain glory. It wasn't the law of attraction that compromised and impaired these people mentally, emotionally, physically and spiritually... nor was it the law of attraction that created the extreme heat, extreme steam, and extreme duration which killed three people and injured countless others... neither was it the law of attraction that denied and delayed the life-saving help these people needed, forcing them to remain in the extreme conditions that threatened their well-being... and it sure wasn't the law of attraction that abandoned three unconscious people in this hellhole. Most important, it wasn't the law of attraction that ripped three beautiful people from the families that loved them. It was James Ray, as confirmed by a jury of 12 people who listened to and examined several months worth of testimony and evidence, who found him guilty of negligent homicide.
08:25 PM on 12/09/2011
Let me clarify about what I wrote in my previous post, "Sometimes what we consider a negative experience is a lesson we need to learn and so we attract it." I'm not saying the people in the sweat lodge had to end up in tragedy. I think sometimes we go through experiences so we can make choices. In the case above, the attendees had to chose whether to stay or leave. In hindsight the choice would have been to leave - that being the lesson. JMHO :)
07:05 PM on 12/09/2011
Good article Eldon. I think the law of attraction can be both positive and negative. Sometimes what we consider a negative experience is a lesson we need to learn and so we attract it. I've heard that when we put an intent out there for a positive outcome, we may receive those experiences which we need to go through in order to truly attract the outcome. In addition, it may not be part of our purpose or live design to receive that outcome, so we have to call forth God's Will.