More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Elizabeth A. Sherman
 

Will Success Spoil Susan Boyle?

Posted: 04/22/09 03:13 PM ET

As the world awaits Susan Boyle's next performance, we have to ask: will the media mania, the pressures for a "total makeover," and the hungry maw of commercialism overwhelm and perhaps destroy the joie de vivre that makes her such an effective and affecting singing sensation? True, her magnificent voice, and the genuine surprise of its power and range, amazed and touched us deeply. But just as inspiring was the authenticity of her plucky personality that shone through the immediacy of the live contest. Susan's compelling self inspires us and undergirds her singing, and yet might she be unalterably changed by leaving behind her familiar (in the true sense of the word) world in her quest to become an acclaimed songstress? Launched and already half-way there, can she withstand the inevitable pressure? Will it be simply too much, too soon, and might her singing suffer as a result?

After all, something elemental and profound, beyond the obvious surprise of a dowdy, middle-aged woman delivering a beautiful song with grace and verve, brought a world audience to a communal outpouring of admiration and affection. Part of that response emanated from seeing a naturally happy individual delighting in her gift, delivering a performance as she put it, "to knock the socks off that audience." Although she comes from a village near Glasgow, she seems mercifully removed from the complexities and anxieties of the 21st century, its rambunctious pop culture, economic insecurities and political upheavals. In the midst of the frantic pace and potent worries of our time comes Susan Boyle like a messenger from a simpler dimension and old fashioned way of life. Somehow she has managed a good life without the challenges of work, marriage and family. She lives with satisfaction in her small, subsidized home sans computer and Internet access, and remains attached to and spiritually enriched by her parish community and Catholic faith. By all accounts, Susan loved and cared for her mother to the end and has benefited from taking her advice to "go for it."

At this point, Susan Boyle's singing career has embarked on the roller coaster of super celebrity with its promise of enormous financial rewards. As she takes that path, we'll feel some trepidation and surely root for her success. Although Susan exudes confidence in her gift, the soul of an artist can be fragile. Prettified for television, her palpable discomfort being interviewed and singing for Good Morning, America was painful to watch. Like it or not, the mavens of the total do-over (already encouraged by the Style section of The Washington Post -- hair, make-up, clothes, -- everything!) will relentlessly hustle her along to satisfy the potentially fleeting public appetite for all things Susan. Does she have the fortitude to withstand the all-encompassing pressures to conform to the expectations of stardom? Or will she submit to the demands for transformation and in the process lose the simple magic of her personality that connects her to our hearts? In an age of generalized fear and trembling, Susan Boyle offers a comforting reminder of the source of happiness in life, come what may -- family, friends and faith. Most of all, she communicates that lesson by singing with all her heart for herself, for us and, not a moment too soon, to give joy to a weary world. Let's hope all goes well.

 
As the world awaits Susan Boyle's next performance, we have to ask: will the media mania, the pressures for a "total makeover," and the hungry maw of commercialism overwhelm and perhaps destroy the j...
As the world awaits Susan Boyle's next performance, we have to ask: will the media mania, the pressures for a "total makeover," and the hungry maw of commercialism overwhelm and perhaps destroy the j...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hollace
03:47 AM on 04/25/2009
I you miss the point of Susan already having the things she wants. she seems to have family freinds

a town and church she is involved in. She is not a kid who's parents are getting in touch with Redbull.

She sings...she is not going to be promo spokesperson for Pepsi.....Singing not lipsinking is the product we seldom get to experience
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steamboater
Forget hope. Agitate.
09:59 PM on 04/22/2009
Boyle can still keep her persona even with a badly needed make-over. It's what's inside a perfomer that keeps her on a steady track, not what's on the outside.
photo
getoffthecross
I take social satire seriously...
04:51 PM on 04/22/2009
Ah, the "information age" in all its glory.

Used to be, when someone became an "overnight" sensation, they could go on the road and people who had only heard about them or seen them briefly, would flock to whatever venue at which the sensation would appear. Now? Now we can simply watch, hour after hour, as the media stalk her house, tells us when she's buying new hoiti-toiti clothes..."did she do her hair differently? Is she turning into a primadonna? Was she really as talented as she seems?"

Nothing the public loves more than to build someone up and then watch them fall. And now they can do it in real time. What's it matter if this reclusive lady gets skewered in the day-to-day MSM frenzy? We can always download her audition again, and THAT's the only part we care about.

Susan Boyle may soon be regretting the day she allowed her own star to shine...and Obama should be taking note. We only seem to build them up to watch them fall.
04:25 PM on 04/22/2009
Yes, Miss Boyle seemed nervous the first time we saw her interviewed on American Television. She has grown more used to the attention and I think she will be just fine. That's the nice thing about reaching goals at mid life, one is more balanced and secure.
03:16 PM on 04/22/2009
Did success spoil JK Rowling? Let creative people be rewarded for their talents and give them the credit for deciding what they want from life.
02:49 PM on 04/22/2009
Susan Boyle is successful will be about like all the others who get fame and fortune. She'll end up being driven by her managers and those who pay for her success, whether in re-arranged looks since she's female and will need a new wardrobe and "makeover".