With another report of a senior administration official charged with failure to properly pay taxes, I feel the need to state the following very obvious point. The hopes and promises of a progressive agenda rest on American's collective willingness to pay taxes to support the enactment of the proposed reforms.
Of course, this "tax underpayment" problem is not unique to the Obama administration or even to Democrats. In fact, in most cases these mistakes seem to stem from overly-complicated, burdensome, and technical tax rules. But regardless of cause or intent, these tax problems pose a particular challenge to a progressive agenda built on the the belief that collectively - through coordinated government action - we can provide a greater level of well-being to our citizens than if we allowed individuals to pursue their independent self-interest in an uncoordinated market setting.
This is a really big claim.
Any hope of proving this claim to be true (or even getting people to agree to try it out) needs to overcome two problems inherent in collective action problems - meaning situations in which our individual self-interest (e.g., I really don't want to pay taxes on that small consulting fee that I already spent) contradicts with our collective self-interest (e.g., I really want the government to be able to afford to pay me unemployment insurance in case I lose my job.)
The first problem is the risk of free riders: those who benefit from the collective outcome (e.g., willing to use unemployment insurance if needed) but do not contribute (e.g., don't report consulting income). The second problem is the requirement that those individuals designing the government action must work on behalf of the collective interest, which involves making the hard, complicated, and technical choices necessary to maximize American's overall well-being rather than considering the specific effects of their action on themselves, their friends and family, their district/state, or their party.
Reports of tax problems highlight how both of these problems can stand in the way of attaining the collective action needed to enact any part of the progressive agenda. When our leaders, or even our potential leaders, fail to contribute (in any way) to the collective good, it feeds our lack of faith in them as stewards of the incredible coercive power of government. Further, and potentially more troubling, it reinforces the notions that collective action does not work, that people will always free-ride, and that our government can not generate collective solutions. As we know, this lack of faith in government action underscores much of the "it will never work" criticism of progressive policy proposals.
You know the old saw that women (or African-Americans or immigrants or...) must be twice as good, twice as smart, twice as effective to be just as successful? I feel the same way about those pushing the progressive agenda. If you really want the country to believe us that collective, governmental solutions can make us all better off, you have to be extra-scrupulous, extra-honest, extra-hard-working, and extra-careful when paying taxes.
Following this advice might require paying taxes on things in which the tax law can be interpreted two ways, or is otherwise vague. Consider this "over-payment" an investment in our collective good, as well as an annual insurance premium in case you are ever appointed to a high-post in a presidential administration.
Excuse me now, I am off to double-check my 2008 (and 2007 and 2006 and...) returns!
|
Nancy Killefer: Obama's Chief Performance Officer
WASHINGTON — Nancy Killefer withdrew her candidacy to be the first chief performance officer for the federal government on Tuesday, saying she didn't want her...
|
|
Chief Performance Officer: Obama Names Nancy Killefer
The Associated Press reports that Nancy Killefer has been named Chief Performance Officer by President-elect Barack Obama: President-elect Barack Obama has chosen a former Clinton...
|
|
Daschle Pushed Patron For Obama Job: Dem
Tom Daschle backed the patron who paid him a million-dollar salary and supplied him with a free car and driver for a job inside the...
|
|
Killefer Wilthdraws: Read Her Letter To Obama
The White House has released the letter that Nancy Killefer wrote to President Obama requesting that he withdraw her nomination as chief performance officer. *...
|
|
Tom Daschle Withdraws Nomination For HHS Secretary
Additional reporting by Sam Stein and Rachel Weiner WASHINGTON -- Tom Daschle withdrew Tuesday as President Barack Obama's nominee to be health and human services...
|
|
Daschle Nomination Withdrawal: Was It The Right Thing To Do?
Tom Daschle, Obama's nominee for Health and Human Services Secretary, has withdrawn from contention after failing to pay taxes on a car service. The announcement...
|
|
Deliberating on Daschle
Critics of President Obama will use the Daschle incident to claim that Obama is not really about change, and is captive of the same politicians and lobbyists who have always run Washington.
|
|
Danger: Creeping Puritanism
Tom Daschle's resignation should have been accepted, however, that of Nancy Killefer should have been refused. Responses must be tailored to the "sin." Not all imperfections make a person unfit for office.
|
|
Democratic Tax Goof Follies
The Daschle-Geithner-Killefer tax goof is based on an almost-unconscious hope that the system they theoretically want to work ... won't.
|
|
Daschle's Situation, and the Small-Dollar Solution
Like many decent people, Daschle got caught in a bad system that is so corrupted by money it hardly matters whether the money is from good people with good intentions or bad people with bad intentions.
|
|
Tax Avoidance as the New "Sin"
The modern version of: "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone" has arrived. It is: "Let he (or she) who has not told his accountant to do whatever they can in order to pay the least taxes cast the first stone."
|
|
Why Obama's Well-Oiled Machine Screwed Up on Daschle and Company
The vetters are not supposed to rely on let alone accept the word of the prospective nominee that they paid what they owed.
|
|
Why Is Daschle Out and Geithner In?
Daschle isn't irreplaceable for health care reformers, but Obama would make a big mistake in appointing a replacement with any lessor convictions on a public heath care option.
|
|
The Untold Daschle Story: The Blacklisting of Progressive Economics
Though Obama won on promises to challenge Wall Street, there has been a calculated effort to stack the administration with the very Wall Street Democrats who created the problems he lamented.
|
|
Daschle's Premature Dash
The only thing more implausible than believing that a multi-millionaire with national ambitions would willfully try to defraud the IRS of $140,000 is believing that a man like that actually does his own taxes.
|
|
Are We Doing the Bidding of Conservatives?
Media coverage has been dominated with hysteria over tax mistakes already rectified, and claims of "pork" in the economic recovery bill -- all aiming to paint the new White House as hypocritical old politics.
|
|
Howard Dean for HHS or Health Czar
There's no way that Rahm Emanuel's animosity toward Dean can be explained away if they pass over him again, especially given his tremendous success at the DNC.
|
|
Obama Considers Tax on Cabinet
President Obama is mulling a controversial new tax program that would require members of his Cabinet to pay taxes owed under the Federal tax code, the White House confirmed today.
|
Here's the link: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/04/your-money/04money.html?_r=1&ref=business
'I'm not sure about that,' she said, 'I want to pay my fair share.'
Of course, she was an ex-communist who believed in big government.