In a radio address to America in 1931, George Bernard Shaw startled his audience with the following proposition: "Every person who owes his life to civilized society, and who has enjoyed . . . its very costly protections and advantages, should appear at reasonable intervals before a properly qualified jury to justify his existence," which, Shaw added, should be "summarily and painlessly terminated if he fails to justify it."
I do not advocate such a program. But every one of us who enjoys the hard-bought protections and advantages of our system of self-governance has a responsibility to justify his or her existence under it. Abner J. Mikva, who passed away on the Fourth of July at the age of 90, would clearly have passed this test with flying colors.
The Hon. Abner J. Mikva grew up in Milwaukee during the Depression. After serving as a navigator in World War II, he attended college and then entered the University of Chicago as a law student in 1948.
In his application for admission to law school, Ab declared: "I am fired up with an ambition and a desire to do well in a field of endeavor in which I can apply my reasoning powers as well as the formal education I have acquired. The logical answer is law." Ab emphasized, however, that although "my plans for applying the training of law are not yet crystallized, I have a desire to enter public service."
Inspired by the idealism of Democratic reform candidates Adlai Stevenson and Paul Douglas, who were running for Governor and Senator respectively in Illinois in 1948, Ab, a first-year law student, decided to volunteer to do some election work in Chicago's 8th Ward. This led to an exchange with a ward committeeman that demonstrated the conflicting worlds of an entrenched political organization and an idealistic young liberal:
"Who sent you?" asked the committeeman.
"Nobody."
"We don't want nobody nobody sent. We ain't got no jobs."
"I don't want a job," said Ab.
"We don't want nobody that don't want a job. Where are you from anyway?"
"University of Chicago."
"We don't want nobody from the University of Chicago in this organization."
Returning to the rather more secure confines of his legal education, Ab excelled and, indeed, served as editor-in-chief of the University of Chicago Law Review. In this capacity, Ab wrote a truly memorable letter.
In 1950, the editor-in-chief of the Harvard Law Review wrote a letter to the deans of all law schools that did not then have a law review of their own, offering to sell subscriptions to the Harvard Law Review to the deprived students of such schools at a discount.
Although the University of Chicago Law School had, in fact, published its own quite distinguished law review for some eighteen years, its existence apparently had escaped the attention of the students at Harvard. When Dean Edward Levi received the invitation from the editors of the Harvard Law Review, he passed it on to the then editor-in-chief, Ab Mikva.
In his letter responding to the invitation, Ab expressed his appreciation for the Harvard Law Review's generosity, but pointed out that the University of Chicago had a law review of its own. He suggested, however, that the editors of the Harvard Law Review might be interested in a merger of their two institutions.
Noting that there might be some disagreement over the name of the new journal, Ab, demonstrating his emerging political skills, suggested a compromise. "I suggest," he wrote, that "we adopt the first half of our name and the second half of yours. The new journal would then sensibly be known as the University of Chicago Law Review."
After graduating from Law School in 1951, Ab served as law clerk to Justice Sherman Minton of the United States Supreme Court. He then returned to Chicago to practice law, but as indicated in his law school application, his ultimate goal was public service.
Over the next twenty-five years, Ab battled the Chicago Democratic organization as a state representative, a congressman, and a private citizen, always fighting with boldness and tenacity.
Early in his law practice, for example, Ab represented Times Films in a suit against the Chicago Police Movie Review Board. Chicago was then one of the few cities where every movie that opened had to be screened by a movie review board, which, in Chicago's case, was made up of the widows of policemen. As one might expect, there were many movies the widows did not like.
Ab took the case all the way to the United States Supreme Court, which held in a landmark decision that the city was required by the First Amendment to provide prompt judicial review of each of the widows' decisions. In time, the widows' review board simply dribbled out of existence.
In 1956, Ab became the first liberal independent to wrest a seat in the Illinois House from the Chicago Democratic machine. In that role, Ab fought vigorously for fair housing and against government corruption, earning him the enmity of then-Mayor Richard J. Daley.
After ten years in the Illinois legislature, Ab was elected to the United States Congress from Illinois' 2d District in Chicago. Two years later, Mayor Daley, who insisted on always referring to Ab as that "Mr. Mifka," re-drew the district lines so as to eliminate Ab's district. Undeterred, Ab promptly moved to a Chicago suburb, where he won several more terms in the United States House of Representatives.
While in Congress, Congressman Mikva was an ardent champion of civil right and civil liberties, advocating for minority voting rights, abortion rights, gun control, and an end to the death penalty.
In 1979, President Jimmy Carter appointed Congressman Mikva to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, where he distinguished himself as one of the most prominent jurists in the nation and, in so doing, remained true to the vision he had first brought to his legal education thirty years earlier.
Judge Mikva's opinions as a jurist lay bare a keen analytical mind, a ferocious commitment to individual freedom, a deep respect for precedent, and a passion for clear, straightforward and honest exposition. In many of these decisions, Judge Mikva boldly protected core constitutional rights in a range of complex and often controversial settings.
To cite just one example, as early as 1993 Judge Mikva wrote an opinion holding unconstitutional the Pentagon's ban on gays serving in the military. Mikva explained that "the Constitution does not allow government to subordinate a class of persons simply because others do not like them," adding that "America's hallmark has been to judge people by what they do, and not by who they are." Although his decision was soon overturned, the nation eventually came around to his position eighteen years later.
After fifteen years on the bench, the last four of which as Chief Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia - a position now held, by the way, by Merrick Garland - Judge Mikva was appointed Legal Counsel to the President by President Bill Clinton. Thus, in a career spanning more than half-a-century, Judge Mikva served at both the state and federal levels, and in all three branches of the federal government.
He also found time to be a distinguished private lawyer -- with a particular bent for public issue litigation, a lecturer, an educator, and even a scholar. Indeed, after leaving the White House, Professor Mikva returned to his alma mater and, as a member of the faculty of the University of Chicago Law School, taught courses and seminars in "The Legislative Process," learning experiences that were consistently described by his students as, and I quote from student course evaluations,
"brilliant," "insightful," "enriching," and "inspiring."
In later years, Ab served as Senior Director of the University of Chicago's Mandel Legal Aid Clinic; as an international election monitor of Ukraine's contested presidential election; and as chair of the Illinois Human Rights Commission, to name just a few of his many post-government service contributions to the public good.
To add icing on the cake, in 1997 Ab and his incredible wife Zoe established the Mikva Challenge, a civil leadership program for Chicago youth that serves thousands of young people each year by getting them involved in the democratic process and by creating civic activism projects that enable them to work to improve their school and local communities.
Through it all, Ab brought a rare intelligence, wisdom, integrity, decency and generosity of spirit to all he accomplished and to all the many lives he has touched - including my own. He is, indeed, the exemplar of the public citizen.
Ab Mikva would have made even George Bernard Shaw smile.