iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Erin Smith

GET UPDATES FROM Erin Smith
 

A Mother's Guilt

Posted: 04/18/2012 11:56 am

There are all types of mothers out there; working mothers, stay at home mothers, mothers that work part time -- all sorts of arrangements. With all their differences, I'd venture to say that at least one common thread exists among them: they all have some level of guilt.

The sources of the guilt are endless: Working outside the home too much, not working outside the home and contributing to the family income, not keeping the house impeccable enough, not being attentive enough to the children when you are at home... the list goes on. While many men don't escape this phase of parenthood without any guilt, it's different due to our society's expectation that the majority of men go to work each day. With women, it's often seen as a choice, even though, in reality, it very often is a necessity.

My sense of guilt as a mother revolves around the fear of not doing enough or not being "present" (both literally and figuratively) at all times.

My 5-year-old daughter was diagnosed with Leukemia last December. For obvious reasons, she is currently not able to attend school and I am home with her. All day. Every day. For the first several months, we were literally housebound to avoid exposure to germs with her weakened immune system, with the exception of visits to the doctor. We had just moved to a new city and didn't have any babysitters. Honestly, I wouldn't have felt comfortable leaving her at that point, anyway. She is a beautiful, energetic "chatterer" who would prefer to have me engaged in some type of playful activity at all times. I usually oblige, but sometimes... well, I just can't! After I say no or encourage her to play on her own, guess what comes next... guilt. I generally always am faced with thoughts of fleeting time and the realization that one day, in the not too distant future, she is going to be a teenager and her desire for interaction with mommy will drastically dwindle. And then, before I know it, gasp -- she will be off to college!

Recently, about four months into her treatment, we found this wonderful nurse/babysitter who is extremely energetic, loves to play and is also qualified to assist with medical care, should the need ever arise. She comes a couple times a week and every time I return home, they are doing something fun and interactive like making kites, playing outside or reading books. I think most mothers would concur that it's not easy to find such a caretaker.

My little angel has become quite accustomed to spending time with me 24-7 since her diagnosis in December and doesn't like when I leave. I think it's fairly common for young children to protest when their parents leave, and we know they'll be fine five minutes after we walk out the door. Still, the guilt I feel upon leaving is immense. This morning when I broke the news to her that the babysitter was coming, huge tears started streaming down her face and she cried in desperation, "No mommy, I want to come with you! Why can't I come with you?" Stick a dagger in my heart. Here comes the guilt.

The truth of the matter was that I didn't have a meeting or some other type of appointment I had to go to. I wasn't going anywhere they didn't allow kids. I just needed some "me" time. Some quiet time to drink my coffee, listen to Howard Stern in my car if I felt so inclined, and maybe just stare at the wall in silence. But, are those good enough -- or important enough reasons?

Rationally, I know that everyone needs a break and it will make me a better mom to have some time to myself. But, when your child doesn't want you to go (and I'm not even taking into account the fact that my child has a life-threatening illness), it's hard not to feel the guilt. I also know that one day soon, God willing, she will be healthy enough to go back to school, and relearning how to be separated from me for a few hours is essential to her own well-being.

It's difficult to strike a balance between being everything our kids need us to be and maintaining our sanity and individuality. Different people need different things to feel "complete." Different people are willing to sacrifice different things for their children. One person's definition of sacrifice is different than the next. All healthy definitions are to be respected. But the fact remains that these little people are under our wing for such a short amount of time that there is the undeniable pressure to "get it right" and give everything we can now to make it better for them in the future. There is no one "right" way to do it and all we can do is our best. It is up to each of us to determine what "our best" is going to be and how we're going to pull it off.

So, here I am during my "me" time, reflecting on and writing about my guilt for not being with my child at this moment, instead of embracing the time I have to myself. Sweet irony at its best.

Sigh....

 
FOLLOW PARENTS
There are all types of mothers out there; working mothers, stay at home mothers, mothers that work part time -- all sorts of arrangements. With all their differences, I'd venture to say that at least ...
There are all types of mothers out there; working mothers, stay at home mothers, mothers that work part time -- all sorts of arrangements. With all their differences, I'd venture to say that at least ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:12 PM on 04/21/2012
I hope your daughter recovers fully and quickly. It must be so difficult to have a child with cancer. You need that "me" time to recharge, because you are also a caregiver for her in addition to your regular parental duties.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
09:51 PM on 04/29/2012
Thank you so much for the kind thoughts, roshni.
02:00 PM on 04/20/2012
I absolutely agree that childhood is fleeting and take advantage of every moment but it can be done without guilt. I chose to give up my 9-5:30 job because, when getting off work at 5:30, I would get home, make dinner, help with homework and it was bedtime and I felt a ridiculous amount of guilt (my daughter was 6 at the time). I took a lower paying job (that turned out to be a great career move and I now make more money that I ever have) with the hours of 7:30-3 so I could pick up my daughter at school and have the entire afternoon and evening with her. Best parenting choice I ever made-we are so close (she is 8 now), her schoolwork and attitude improved and my guilt disappeared. Back when I had limited weekday time, I wouldn't let her do anything without me b/c I wanted to spend time with her to lessen my guilt-obviously not a great parenting technique. Now she has time for friends and swimming and art and I still get plenty of time with her, time for myself, plus I don't have to sacrifice a career.
On a side note, I can't imagine the difficulty of having my child diagnosed with leukemia-my very best to you and your family-you sound like you are a great mom.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
05:05 PM on 04/20/2012
Good for you, kochmechanical! Now that's a success story if I've ever heard one. Sounds like everything worked out in the best interest of everyone and there are smiles all around. And, thank you for your supportive words.
01:50 PM on 04/20/2012
I still consider myself a "new" mommy, even though my little boy is nearly 7 months old. At only 24 years old, I can't afford to not work full-time. I'm still struggling with the balance of work and home. When my boy falls asleep at 8 pm and wakes up at 6 am, it's nearly impossible to get more than 3 hours a day with him. Quality time with him is far and few between! It's a struggle I'm constantly dealing with and realizing that being a mom is harder that I ever thought--but for the emotional reasons, not the busy-life situations I always thought about. It's comforting to know that I'm not the only one struggling, and that mom's in all sorts of situations deal with guilt as well.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
05:02 PM on 04/20/2012
Thanks for the comment, Megan. I totally hear you on how being a mom is so difficult on an emotional level. We have no idea how these little people are going to affect us until they are in our lives. Good luck with your balance! All we can do is our best and if we're doing that, I think everything will work out in the end.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brian464
world peace thru world wide disarmament
01:32 PM on 04/20/2012
From the post : " relearning how to be separated from me for a few hours is essential to her own well-being."

Comment:

A child should never be separated from her caregiver, so the ideal situation would be for grandma ( the main caregiver ) to take care of the child while mom is away at work.

The extended family situation is the best for every child as parents go to work and grandparents stay at home taking care of the child from the time the child is born
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
07:51 AM on 04/21/2012
What happens when the child goes to school? I'm assuming from your stance you must home school?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brian464
world peace thru world wide disarmament
12:53 PM on 04/24/2012
I do not have kids and yes,

I was home schooled.

Bonding with one main caregiver is crucial during the formative years.

Yes, homeschooling is the best for kids since they are vulnerable to be adversely influenced in a bad way if they encounter the "wrong" kids or being bullied

Off course, if a kid is close to his parents, bad influences would be mitigated since the kid would be open to discussing everything with his parents
04:50 PM on 04/21/2012
I get what you're saying, Brian, but that's not always possible. My parents are dead and the in-laws live clear across the country and, frankly, wouldn't want the responsibility.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tideh
12:38 PM on 04/20/2012
Please try not to feel guilty when time is needed for yourself. It seems like you are doing a great job, but if we don't take care of ourselves we will not be a good provider for those we love and care for. Time to yourself can lower stress and anxiety levels and lower blood pressure which can be extremely bad as we all know, if you get sick you will not be a benefit to your child. So keep your head up, & smile knowing you are doing what is best for your child and for yourself. My best to you both.
12:19 PM on 04/20/2012
My career isn't what makes me leave my children and go to work, it's putting food on the table and clothing my children. How dare you make such harsh statements about mothers. When you work full-time, you're encouraged to take a vacation, rest and regroup so you could be productive. You officially can't take a vacation from being a mother but you should be able to have a cup of coffee, go out to dinner once in while and regroup to BE A BETTER PARENT. Mommy guilt follows me around in everything that I do, whether it be when I go to work, when I come home and when I spend time with my children. I want to make sure that everything is perfect and it never will be. There is no such thing. But perhaps, we could STOP judging each other so harshly and perhaps lend a helping hand to another mother. We would be a better society and our children perhaps wouldn't pick up our anger towards others. MarcEdward, why don't you talk to a working parent (that has to work in order to survive) and see how they really feel about leaving their children all day for others to raise. It's not easy and we would like not to be judged for whatever time Mother's take for themselves.
12:00 PM on 04/20/2012
You are doing a great job. I cannot imagine what it must be like having a daughter that has cancer. I hope that she makes a full and speedy recovery. Don't let others' negative opinions make you feel bad about having a little time to yourself. I bet the whole time you are out doing something without your little girl, you are thinking of her.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
09:15 PM on 04/20/2012
Thank you, mhdg.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MDawn
10:58 AM on 04/20/2012
Wishing you some healthy (mostly guilt free) "me time" & a daughter who is happy, heathly, and back to school soon.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
03:37 PM on 04/20/2012
Thanks so much, MDawn.
10:04 AM on 04/20/2012
Erin, I feel your pain completely. I am a mother of 2 children, Tucker is 3 & Aubrey is 9mths. I also have my sister that lives with me & she has a 3yr old son named Kamryn. Kamryn was diagnosed with retinoblastoma @ 16 mths old. He has had his left eye removed due to the size of the tumor & goes to St Jude every 12 weeks. My sister has lived with me for the past 5 years so Kamryn has always been in my life, so I consider him my child as well. When i talk about my kids, I say my boys, not just Tucker. Every parent needs a time out to themselves. We all need a break now & again. I do not get many, but when I do, I enjoy them...even though I am mostly thinking about what my kids are doing while I am out on a date night...lol. And I enjoyed your story & your comments to MarcEdward. I agree with you 100% & I know all about the guilt. I wish your daughter a speedy recovery! Good luck to you & your family!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
07:55 AM on 04/21/2012
Thank you so much for the support, alishac! Sending positive wishes to Kamryn and the rest of your family as well!
08:56 PM on 04/19/2012
Keep your head up, fellow mommy. Being a good parent is one of the hardest things to be, but it seems to me like you're doing a great job.

We all need time to balance ourselves -- otherwise, how can we be our best for the people we love? My heart-felt wishes for your little girl's recovery.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
10:23 AM on 04/20/2012
Thank you so much SavvyLass! That means a lot. :)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarcEdward
likes all cats more than most people
09:47 AM on 04/19/2012
You know when you can get "me time"? When the child is sleeping. Set an early bedtime (7:00 PM works for us) and you have plenty of "me" time. When a person brings a child into the world, you have officially lost "Me time" when the child needs them, period, end of story. I have three, I owe them everything I have, because I brought them into the world. If they need me, any time, 24/7, I am there, without regard to my health, sleep, diet. I only put my eldest into preschool early because his speech therapist said he needed it. 
A number of years ago, some mom wrote a book about how one needed to surrender into parenting. She was right. I don't get why people have kids than resist being parents. What career is more rewarding than raising one's own kids? Leaving your kid to cry so one can listen to Howard Stern? You think that decades from now, when you're old and reflecting back on your life, you'll treasure the memories of listening to the radio in your car?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
01:25 PM on 04/19/2012
Wow, MarcEdward, if that wasn't a one-track, close minded, judgement-laden and above all IGNORANT response. Your cure all solution of "putting them to bed at 7," may work for YOU, but perhaps that schedule doesn't work for other families for a variety of reasons. If I put her to bed at 7, she would never see her father who is at work all day. And what about working mothers? If they came home and immediately put their children to bed, they would not get to interact with their children at all. Does that sound like a great idea for the kids?

Your argument fails on so many counts I could go on and on. Not that I need to defend myself, but I have never once let either of my children cry themselves to sleep. When the babysitter came, my daughter was no longer crying. AND, I did not leave the house for a few hours so I could listen to Howard Stern. Apparently, you missed the obvious point I was making that as human beings, we all need a few minutes to do what we need to do to recoup our mind. I happen to have a child who has cancer and unless you have been in my shoes and know the demands such a situation entails, you have no right to judge. I have always put my children above everything else. (Continued below)
09:14 PM on 04/21/2012
Don't let him get to you. I think you are doing just fine.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
01:26 PM on 04/19/2012
You put your kids to sleep at 7, which I would never do. I guarantee you get more "me" time with your tactic than I do. So, while I welcome and appreciate the "advice," perhaps you could open your mind a bit and realize that everyone's situation is different instead of applying some sort of ridiculous paradigm to everyone.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarcEdward
likes all cats more than most people
03:09 PM on 04/19/2012
Apologies if I misinterpreted your words.
You're the one who said 
This morning when I broke the news to her that the babysitter was coming, huge tears started streaming down her face and she cried in desperation, "No mommy, I want to come with you! Why can't I come with you?".... I just needed some "me" time. Some quiet time to drink my coffee, listen to Howard Stern in my car 
How did I get the wrong impression? Now of course you are correct that for sanity's sake one needs time, with one's spouse/partner, or just alone (perhaps criticizing other people's parenting decisions online). The brain needs some time to absorb and sort the moments of the day, or just to drift. My point is ONLY that such time should not come at the expense of kids' needs. That doesn't mean kids shouldn't be expected to have time on their own. By the age of 5 a kid can play with lego, dolls, stuffed animals, pencil/paper, watch Dora the Explorer, all things that can be done with a younger sibling without parenting help/interference
01:02 PM on 04/18/2012
I'm not a mom (yet), but I can imagine the guilt that moms must feel, especially after reading your post. You did a great job of conveying that guilt and how it seems inescapable. Hopefully, you'll soon see the benefit of your "me" time, and the guilt will lessen. Hopefully!

Nice job!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Erin Smith
11:21 PM on 04/18/2012
Thanks, msphenomadj. We can hope!