iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Fadi Elsalameen

Fadi Elsalameen

Posted: June 18, 2010 01:44 PM

Finding Palestine's Gandhi in Budrus

What's Your Reaction:

"If only the Palestinians believed in nonviolence." That is the common refrain regarding the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in the US. How many times have we heard, "Oh, if you just practiced nonviolence, you'd have your state in no time." Or, "Look at Gandhi and Martin Luther King. They got what they wanted for their people using nonviolence. Why don't the Palestinians do the same?"

From now on we will answer this question with one word: Budrus.

What is Budrus? Budrus is a Palestinian village near the Green Line. Budrus is also an award-winning film proving Palestinians are engaging in nonviolent resistance, and, slowly but surely, it is working.

About the film:

Budrus is an award-winning feature documentary film about a Palestinian community organizer, Ayed Morrar, who unites local Fatah and Hamas members along with Israeli supporters in an unarmed movement to save his village of Budrus from destruction by Israel's Separation Barrier. Success eludes them until his 15-year-old daughter, Iltezam, launches a women's contingent that quickly moves to the front lines. Struggling side by side, father and daughter unleash an inspiring, yet little-known, movement in the Occupied Palestinian Territories that is still gaining ground today. In an action-filled documentary chronicling this movement from its infancy, Budrus shines a light on people who choose nonviolence to confront a threat. The movie is directed by award-winning filmmaker Julia Bacha (co-writer and editor of Control Room and co-director Encounter Point), and produced by Bacha, Palestinian journalist Rula Salameh, and filmmaker and human rights advocate Ronit Avni (formerly of WITNESS, Director of Encounter Point).

If you care about a peaceful solution to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, Budrus is a must see documentary. You will be moved to tears, inspired, and awed by the courage of the people of Budrus. It demonstrates not only the anatomy of nonviolent resistance in Palestine but also the evolution of the movement as it grows from a village matter to an international cause. Courage and candor are all around, as Morrar's daughter jumps in front of an active bulldozer, forcing it into retreat with no sure knowledge she wouldn't be killed in the process. It is not a film about the nebulous idea of freedom or nationhood but about a town's determination to sustain its existence and way of life.

As Daniel Levy of New America Foundation simply put it, "After seeing this documentary, I don't think anyone here could say I knew that was gonna happen."

Watch the trailer for 'Budrus'

After the film screening, Congressman Keith Ellison (D-MN) said: "This is a story that is not often told." He went on, saying it is an important film for Washington lawmakers who often know little about the conflict. "Facts are in shorts supply in this town," he said. "Opinions are not." He then asked Ayed Morrar: "Is this movement sustainable?"

Morrar answered: "We learned a lot from Martin Luther King, and one thing for sure, this is sustainable and yields results. It is difficult to lead a people from an office. A leader must be with his people."

Congress ought to support peaceful and nonviolent education in the Palestinian territories. My hope is that they will dedicate some of the $400 million President Obama promised in aid to Palestinians to support nonviolent resistance against Israel's unjust policies. After all, it was President Obama who, in his 2009 Cairo speech, called on the Palestinians to use a nonviolent approach to resisting the occupation:

Palestinians must abandon violence. Resistance through violence and killing is wrong and does not succeed. For centuries, black people in America suffered the lash of the whip as slaves and the humiliation of segregation. But it was not violence that won full and equal rights. It was a peaceful and determined insistence upon the ideals at the center of America's founding. This same story can be told by people from South Africa to South Asia; from Eastern Europe to Indonesia. It's a story with a simple truth: that violence is a dead end. It is a sign of neither courage nor power to shoot rockets at sleeping children, or to blow up old women on a bus. That is not how moral authority is claimed; that is how it is surrendered.

Morrar's message to the Palestinian supporters was simple: "We can either accept Israel's actions against us as fate or see them as unjust actions that must be challenged nonviolently... We want a peace that is human to human, not between a slave and his master."

So many have asked, "Where is the Palestinian Gandhi? Where is the Palestinian Martin Luther King?" They are in every face in Burdrus and in every face in the nonviolent movements across the West Bank, from Bil'in to Nabi Saleh. The United States called for nonviolence, and they got it. Now they need to support it by investing in the individuals and methodologies that will allow nonviolent resistance to flourish. "The keys to the peace of the world [lie] in Washington, DC," Morrar said. Now it's time for Washington to turn the key.

 

Follow Fadi Elsalameen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Elsalameen

"If only the Palestinians believed in nonviolence." That is the common refrain regarding the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in the US. How many times have we heard, "Oh, if you just practiced nonviolenc...
"If only the Palestinians believed in nonviolence." That is the common refrain regarding the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in the US. How many times have we heard, "Oh, if you just practiced nonviolenc...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 132
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
jackstpaul
What am I supposed to write here?
11:27 AM on 06/22/2010
It's Israel that needs to have a Gandhi come forth. This "Palestinian Gandhi" is a bunch of nonsense. Stop blaming the victim. Israel is the aggressor and occupier; Palestinian violence is very minimal compared the far more extensive use, and threat of use, of violence by Israel.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wisdo
semantics shamantics
05:09 AM on 06/21/2010
Whether violent or non-violent, resistance to the Israeli occupation is legitimate because the Occupation is wrong and even the Israelis know that. But still they continue to expand the settlements.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:09 PM on 06/21/2010
If by "resistance" you mean targeting and killing civilians, which far too often is what it has been said to mean, then, no, it is not legitimate.
02:44 AM on 06/21/2010
There is a good documentary running on the BBC about how the boycott of Apartheid South Africa started off slowly and picked up speed. I sense the same thing is starting to happen with regards to Israel. When international corporations and financial institutes realize that they will be associated with the racism and misery being perpetuated against men, women and children in Gaza they will pull out.
01:56 AM on 06/21/2010
When a natural or spatial border doesn't exist then what emerges between the populations is an exchange. But why does the exchange have to be crafted? Composition as a principle lends to natural commodity exchange for intent and purpose.
12:01 AM on 06/21/2010
Why should anyone trust Israel that destroyed the old Morroccan Quarter of Jerusalem... they should be forced to rebuild that part of the old city. This was among the oldest buildings in Jerusalem destroyed by Israel, and they buried people in their homes in doing it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
gingershot
One man, one vote, from the river to the sea
11:34 PM on 06/20/2010
Palestinians are reuniting after the stunning results with the liberation of Gaza - Abbas just had to postpone West Bank elections because his Fatah-Quisling party was going to get wiped

The only reason the Palestinians are split at all is because this is the stated and implemented policy of Mossad and the American CIA as well as the American state dept - no longer - the Palestinians know a winner when they see it

Marwan Barghouti is the Palestinian Mandela - Israel is scared to death of him and has him locked up (like Mandela) - this is a symptom of Israeli weakness and cowardice and all Palestinians know this as well as everyone around the world. Israel is too scared to exchange him for Gilad S (sp?) because that's how scared they are

Israel is on the wrong side of history - has no where to turn - and is freaking out as BDS Boycott Sanction and Divestment picks up - check this out -- Oakland, California dockworkers just refused to unload an Israeli-apartheid ship this PM - yahoo!

It's time to make Isarel howl like South Africa - Pappe says it's the only way and I agree
11:11 PM on 06/20/2010
Israel continues to steal Palestinian land and provoke in order for a new pretext to kill men women and children and you say they need a Gandhi or a Martin Luther King. I think you may have it back to front. The Israeli people need to wake up and vote some peace mongers into office. Notice how the talk of boycotting Israel is picking up. We saw it work against Apartheid South Africa and it will work against Apartheid Israel.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
gingershot
One man, one vote, from the river to the sea
11:05 PM on 06/20/2010
Full Palestinian Right of Return is alive and well - argued by Ilan Pappe and Ali Abunimah at Doha in 2007 - really good talk!
46 minute talk with Q and A

This is gonna be great!

http://electronicintifada.net/v2/article6814.shtml

The Palestinians will fight until the last man standing on earth

Ilan Pappe is particulary good - says making Israel howl like South Africa is the only course of action - he rightly doesn't trust Israelis further than he can spit

Abunimah is arguing for 'One State' - since effectively Israel is already 'Dictator or Palestine - rather than a true democracy

Yossi Beilin, a Knesset member and Chairman of the Meretz-Yachad party comes off as a schmo

Free Palestine! - Full Palestinian Right of Return, One state
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chaimschwartz
06:36 PM on 06/20/2010
The Israelis have made peace with Egypt and Jordan....Hamas and the PLO cannot even make peace WITH EACH OTHER..I think they need a Ghandi more than Israel does!
06:41 PM on 06/20/2010
I believe a TRUE Ghandi-type personality would be assassinated by Hamas or the radical factions of the PLO or Islamic Jihad or Hezbollah..in about a week after he or she became known to them!...Probably sooner!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wisdo
semantics shamantics
05:11 AM on 06/21/2010
I agree probably sooner - and by Mossad.
11:55 PM on 06/20/2010
Israel and the dynasty that runs Jordan has had a close relationship going back to World War I.
06:34 PM on 06/20/2010
Before you may decide to boycott Israel I strongly suggest you watch this short gem video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iHBvunVErJU&feature=related
06:45 PM on 06/20/2010
Great video..I URGE the haters and HP staff to view this video ..and then to follow through with their "boycott"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
manoflamatzah
aka "The Wizard of Oy"
11:51 PM on 06/20/2010
very nice... thanks! I sent the link to my parents -
06:34 PM on 06/20/2010
the wall was not to keep people in but to keep out suicide bomber terrorists or haven't you heard of same.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wisdo
semantics shamantics
05:11 AM on 06/21/2010
the wall was built to steal land.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:20 PM on 06/21/2010
Funny how they waited until there was a campaign of suicide bombings to build it then, innit?

I have no fear, howerver. I am confident that you will not let small things like facts get in the way of your "narrative".
04:33 PM on 06/20/2010
Finding Palestine's Gandhi...
That's like looking for a rusty ball-bearing in a thousand haystacks.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chaimschwartz
06:21 PM on 06/20/2010
10,000!
04:22 PM on 06/20/2010
The real question is "Where is Israel going to get it's Ghandi?"
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chaimschwartz
06:20 PM on 06/20/2010
Uh..Israel is not sworn by charter or constitution to wipe out the Arabs!!! It already has made peace with Egypt and Jordan! The PLO and Hamas can't even make peace with EACH OTHER!!
12:09 AM on 06/21/2010
No Arab country has in its charter a clause calling for the wiping out of the Jews. To imply such a thing is vile slander.
08:57 AM on 06/20/2010
Lets see, Israel has repeatedly offered to give the Palestinians the West Bank, Gaza, Billions of dollars in aid, and share E. jerusalem----it has been rejected every time. Yet we have these palestinian supporters talking about "resistance" all the time----what are they resisting? Oh yeah, the very existence of Israel.
12:10 PM on 06/20/2010
Exactly..funny...no replies in 3 hours..the truth hurts the haters'hatred of Israel!!
12:14 PM on 06/20/2010
Mr Levy you seem to be the typical Jewish supporter of Israel who will not admit that Israel has been the thug in the Near East for most of it's existance.Nothing has worked to get Israel to reduce it's inclination for aggression,occupation,and blatant disregard of the International Community's call for JUSTICE for the Palestinian People.The article that you just reduced to a level of non relevant is in my opinion the only method that Israel will understand of why the British and the South African Boors decided that the occupation was not worthwhile anymore. Both Gahndi and Nelson Mandela new the great power of NON-VIOLANCE NON COOPERATION and the huge support of the International Community. To all those who think that the occupation of the Palestinian land is unjust please do the right thing and Boycott,Boycott,and Boycott.
12:21 PM on 06/20/2010
Palestinian land?? When...for even ONE DAY in recorded history..did any Palestinian entity control or öwn"that land??? Don't think too hard..the answer is: NEVER! Unless the Arabs belonged to the Ottoman Empire or were really Romans..or Jordanians..etc!
01:07 AM on 06/20/2010
A Ghandi would never be able to return PaIestine to the PaIestinians. A Ghandi would never be able to make Palestinians to return to their 1948 homes and lands. PaIestine belongs to the PaIestinians.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:37 AM on 06/20/2010
And not even Gandhi advocated pacifism in the face of a threat of death.

Max Ajl wrote recently at Mondweiss:

"The Palestinian 1st Intifada produced a thousand dead, over 100,000 injured and jailed. Overwhelmingly non-violent, Palestinians paid a remarkable price for their pacific resistance. Those who write on Palestinian non-violence, who write on Palestinians generally, generally ignore that uprising. The world ignored that uprising while it was going on."

"http://mondoweiss.net/2010/06/our-western-privilege-is-the-legacy-of-historical-violence.html#more-20916"
08:48 AM on 06/20/2010
The first intifadah was most certainly violent.
09:01 AM on 06/20/2010
Given that about 80% of the so called Palestinian refugees have never seen Israel and given that the majority of the Israeli Jews there are decendents of the over 750,000 Jews ethnically cleansed (without property) from the surrounding Arab countries and E. Jerusalem----your advocacy that these 4 million hostile Arabs enter Israel and go to "homes" that mostly do not exist, makes no sense. Unless of course you are advocating that Israel cease to exist, sort of like Hamas.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:38 AM on 06/20/2010
Anyone reading this perplexing summary by JerryLevy should read a little Morris, Pappe or Khalidi.
01:45 PM on 06/20/2010
Just because the Israelis have succeeded in making their crime stand after all these years does not erase that crime nor does it change the fact that it should be reversed.