iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Francine Hardaway

Francine Hardaway

Posted: March 25, 2011 12:50 PM

System Failure: Health Care


A friend of mine, far from indigent, had her teeth cleaned three weeks ago. She was the picture of health when she went in to the dentist, and today she is dead, a victim of everything that is wrong with our system, although not of any malpractice. She is the second person in my life to die from the most serious problem in our health care system: lack of continuity of care.

The first died of misdiagnosed malaria in an emergency room in Arizona. They sent him home telling him he had the flu, even though he told them he had just returned from Africa.

The most recent died Wednesday night only hours after being discharged from the hospital with a pic line and a supply of intravenous antibiotics and no understanding of how sick she was. No one had educated her on the seriousness of septicemia, which is what she had when she entered the hospital, or of endocarditis, which she had already developed between the first series of tests in the hospital and the second.

Why did they discharge her? Because she asked to go home. And did anyone ask if she lived alone?

Septicemia is a condition in which bacteria are in the blood. But once that bacteria lands in the heart, havoc can occur very quickly. It's easy to Monday-morning quarterback these things, but I feel they should have kept her in the hospital one more night after they found the endocarditis, just to make sure the second antibiotic was working.

And so did her eldest child, who sensed something might be going wrong and flew in that evening to stay with her mom "just in case." A former pharmaceutical rep, she was more aware of the seriousness of her mother's condition. She made what now looks like a heroic effort, upending her life to fly home.

So it was that the daughter, who tried her best to intervene, found her mother the next morning; she had passed in her sleep.

Of course there is a religious explanation for this: it was "her time."

But I don't believe that about a totally healthy person who subjects herself to a dental procedure and dies. All day I've been trying to deconstruct the incident, which -- I repeat -- was nobody's "fault."

I've concluded the health care system itself has septicemia: system-wide infection. Let's start with the fact that almost nobody lives in the town in which they grew up anymore. Aging parents to do not live with their children in America, or indeed in any developed nation. No one is really observing many single people closely, the way they observe children. A child would not have been permitted by his/her parents to walk around for three weeks with a fever and no treatment. A divorced woman? Who would know?

Add to that, the flawed studies we take as gospel: the American Heart Association recently revised its guidelines about whether people with certain heart abnormalities like mitral valve prolapse need to be on prophylactic antibiotics before dental treatment. It's now considered unnecessary, although it was necessary for the past 30 years. Perhaps it is still necessary in people above a certain age.

And what about asking people if they live alone before they are sent home from the hospital with a potentially life-threatening condition before they are stable? What about waiting to see if that second antibiotic, prescribed after the results of the last tests, has taken hold before discharging the patient?

To me, the saddest thing about the loss of my friend is that no one is to blame, and yet this should not have happened.

We don't take a systems view of health care, making sure all the pieces of the supply chain are functioning before deciding the patient will survive. Wal-Mart does a better job of keeping track of light bulbs than we do of people. Cars on an assembly line are now quality-controlled more than patients. It's time for some TQM, Six Sigma, or continuous process improvement in health care, as we have in manufacturing. Many hospitals will say they already have this, but it seems not to include the patient.


Enhanced by Zemanta

 
 
 

Follow Francine Hardaway on Twitter: www.twitter.com/hardaway

 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Francine Hardaway
Serial entrepreneur, angel, and HuffPo
05:37 PM on 03/25/2011
Yes, Andrew, it is everyone's responsibility to discuss all these things. I happen to have a lot of knowledge most people don't have, and I knew immediately her condition was serious and she should have stayed in the hospital, but I'm not a professional, and my opinion didn't count. And the people who should have warned her, didn't/
04:15 PM on 04/24/2011
Francine, just saw the story on Aurora and was happy to see I was not the only one. What is your present situation with Aurora? We are going thru the same situation here in NM and saw the class action suit in Ca and joined up for what it;s worth..our situtaion started in Oct 09 when my husband lost his job. We are now currently filing for an appeal on their offer that thru email was good but when paperwork came in it was $600 mo higher. We experienced the same situation with automated v mails, pursuit of the board of directors to get a name, lost paperowrk (one time they said my tax return was out of date??? I had to re send the same info)..I could go on. Look forward to your comments and perhaps share thru email..thx for all your efforts.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Marcia Reynolds
Executive coach
02:43 PM on 03/25/2011
Hopefully, people who need to read your post will come across it, though I fear this isn't the case. It is a sad state of affairs when health care is more about saving dollars than people. And the state of healthcare and education in Arizona, plus politicians that push fear more than hope are reasons our economy will struggle for years.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Francine Hardaway
Serial entrepreneur, angel, and HuffPo
05:39 PM on 03/25/2011
You know, it's not just Arizona, although much is wrong with Arizona. The shortcomings of the healthcare system are a national phenomenon, and saving dollars on the backs of people's lives is more common than you think.
01:56 PM on 03/25/2011
I agree with Francine that this was a tragic example of a lapse in healthcare. On the one hand, with the complexity of medicine and the variability of how people respond, it is a daunting task for the system to have a safetynet for every eventuality, including very rare ones. On the other hand, how can we as individuals and as family members head off that rare and even fatal result? I agree we need better processes to lower the risk of infections and medical mistakes. There is no good reason these should happen, or happen as often as they do now, if we institute the quality measures of other industries. So what can we as individuals do now: 1) be proactive in asking what "bad stuff" we should watch out for after a procedure and who to call 2) remind healthcare professionals of all our allergies, medicines and medical history before something new is done/performed/prescribed 3) demand healthcare professionals wash their hands and maybe even cleaning something as basic as a stethescope before they touch us. I've heard too many stories of people getting sick, hospitalized or, as Francine writes about her friend - dying - when some simple procedure and communication could have prevented it. That said, I recognize bad things will still happen. But we can certainly use better processes to try to limit it. Andrew Schorr, author ofTthe Web-Savvy Patient
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:53 PM on 03/25/2011
What? But couldn't caring about patients actually cost our holy grail, the insurance companies, more money?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:31 PM on 03/25/2011
Excellent, as usual Francine. The right's current fear of socialized medicine is so skewed and full of hate-mongering that we cannot even have intelligent discussions about solving these kinds of problems. What the system needs for both the left- and right-leaning folks is to leverage the vast knowledge and experience that our young nation has gained in medicine. Our penchant for profits has trumped the logical application of knowledge in far too many situations.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Francine Hardaway
Serial entrepreneur, angel, and HuffPo
05:40 PM on 03/25/2011
I can not understand why health care, which is a mom-and-apple-pie issue to me, has become so politicized.