More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Gahl Eden Sasson

GET UPDATES FROM Gahl Eden Sasson
 

Astrology Myths Debunked: The Truth About Your 'New' Sign

Posted: 01/18/2011 1:38 pm

Every so often, Astrology is presented with an opportunity to explain herself, and thus impart her wisdom to humankind. Such occasions, alas, usually occur when her system of symbolism is under attack, usually by people who have no knowledge of Astrology or base their dismissive notions on popular culture and misunderstandings instead of serious consideration.

In the last few days, I have received many alarmed e-mails regarding the recent Internet craze concerning the shattering "new discoveries" that the signs have shifted due to a wobble in the Earth's axis and that there is a new 13th sign called Ophiuchus.

Let me address some of these issues and assure you that your sign has not changed from whatever it was before 2011. If you thought you could upgrade to a "better" sign, you are out of luck.

  1. Astrology is based on the seasons and the relationships between the planets (called "aspects"), not what sign is located behind the sun when you were born.
  2. The signs of the Zodiac are merely symbols and metaphors that divide the year into 12 different and equal "seasons." This partition is based on the proportions of day and night experienced throughout the year. The first Zodiac sign, Aries, always begins on the first day of spring, when day and night are equal, and the amount of light will increase in succeeding days. Libra, on the other hand, always begins on the first day of fall, when the day and night are also equal, but after which the amount of light will decrease.

    Astrology postulates that, regardless of what constellation occupies the Equinox, people born in the spring will exhibit characteristics such as high energy and optimism. They will be the kind of people who spring into action, the same way that nature buds into life after its long winter slumber.

    A new study, published by Nature Neuroscience, found links between season of birth and personality. According to Professor Douglas McMahon, the study's author, "Our biological clocks measure the day's length and change our behavior according to the seasons." It is suggested that people born in the winter (e.g., Capricorns) are more at risk to suffer from Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD), schizophrenia and depression. In Astrology, similarly, Capricorn is associated with suffering, difficulties and pessimism.

  3. When Astrology was developed by the Babylonians, the constellation Aries happened to be located right behind the sign Aries during the Spring Equinox.
  4. Astrology was developed in Mesopotamia, the cradle of civilization, as a cosmic clock, most likely to help early farmers track the seasons. The idea is simple: One should plant in spring, party in summer, harvest in fall and be careful with provisions in winter.

    There is no real ram in the sky when Aries begins on March 21st. Wise ancient women and men chose a Ram to symbolize Aries because it represents the initiation of spring. When the refuters of Astrology claim that people born in Aries should be called Pisces, they are misunderstanding the symbolism behind the names. It's like saying New York City should be called "York" because it is now hundreds of years old.

  5. Astrologers and Astronomers have known about the issues presented in the "Astrology-refuting hoax" for thousands of years and chose not to include a 13th constellation.
  6. There is nothing new about the 13th constellation or the shift in the signs. The ancient Greeks, who were the first to cast astrological "Natal Charts," were quite aware of these two issues. In fact, Claudius Ptolemy wrote extensively about the 13th sign and the procession of the equinox in the second century AD. There truly is nothing new under the sun.

    Ophiuchus, the so-called 13th sign, was not adopted into Astrology because the sun barely touches the constellation during its path through the Zodiac. It also doesn't fit into the Babylonians' sexagesimal system that is based on 60 and 12 (the same system that gave us 60 minutes in an hour and two sets of 12 hours in a day).

    With all due respect, most of the people who rebuke Astrology have little knowledge of its history. Intellectual giants like Johannes Kepler (considered by many to be the father of modern astronomy), Copernicus, Tycho Brahe, Carl Jung, Benjamin Franklin and Sir Isaac Newton were all aware of these two anomalies in Astrology. They continued, however, to practice, study and develop astrological theories that resulted in amazing predictions and insights.

    For centuries, astrologers have incorporated the Earth's wobble into their understanding of the connection between the heavenly bodies and life on Earth. Ever heard about "The Age of Aquarius"? The reason we have these ages and the reason they move backward (the Age of Aquarius follows the Age of Pisces) is due to the wobble of the Earth. Thus, to claim that astrologers had not known about this phenomenon or that they chose to ignore it is simply ridiculous.

  7. Astrology is a system of symbols and metaphors designed to help us connect to the universe, just like the words and metaphors found in the various spiritual texts from around the world.

Many people claim that Astrology has no scientific backing and therefore cannot provide "real" help to humanity. I was stunned to see that this assertion in The Christian Science Monitor, a news organization owned by a church. There is no scientific proof of the resurrection of Christ, and yet the teaching of Jesus can still inspire love and compassion. There is no archeological proof of the Exodus, and yet millions live and die by the teaching of Moses. There is no evidence to support Muhammad's nightly flight on a winged horse from Mecca to Jerusalem. However, the holiest shrine for Islam, the Dome of the Rock, was built to commemorate that event on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. For hundreds of years, help and healing has been provided by systems that have no scientific proof. The power of belief is undeniable.

Handled in the right way, Astrology can help guide us to a better future. Over the last 15 years, I have seen Astrology prove herself again and again in remarkable ways to clients of all ages, races, nationalities and genders. I can only hope that she will do for you what she has done for me and thousands of others. In the words of Carl Jung, "Obviously Astrology has much to offer psychology, but what the latter can offer its elder sister is less evident."

 
 
 

Follow Gahl Eden Sasson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/gahl1

Every so often, Astrology is presented with an opportunity to explain herself, and thus impart her wisdom to humankind. Such occasions, alas, usually occur when her system of symbolism is under attac...
Every so often, Astrology is presented with an opportunity to explain herself, and thus impart her wisdom to humankind. Such occasions, alas, usually occur when her system of symbolism is under attac...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 95
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:18 AM on 01/22/2011
In your first point, you note some relationships that apply to birth date and seasons. The relationships you describe are for the Northern Hemisphere. Do the astrological signs change if you were born in the Southern Hemisphere when the relationships you describe are the opposite?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
12:02 PM on 01/22/2011
That is a super good question and I have been researching this for a while. In the time Astrology was developed most of the "High" civilizations were located in the Northern Hemisphere. Also, the majority of humanity still lives in the Northern Hemisphere. I plan to be in South Africa this coming Fall and I intend to meet with astrologers as well as research that question myself. It is a question I asked myself many a times. However, as someone who studied and practiced psychoanalysis and Jungian psychology, certain concepts that were developed in one area in the world can successfully transfer to another. Think about Christianity or Judaism that originated in the desert to answer the needs of desert nations but was transferred to jungles. I worked with Ethiopians who studied to be psychologists in Israel and they did not have an understanding of what "guilt" is and yet psychoanalysis principles could help them recover from deep rooted issues even though we did not talk about guilt. So I feel that astrology of the Northern hemisphere could be transferred successfully to the southern folks especially if their culture is very influenced in other respects from the North. Another example is Christmas celebrated on Winter solstice but in the Southern hemisphere it falls on the Summer solstice. I wish I had a better answer and I hope by the time I leave this planet to have the research to know. :)
06:11 PM on 01/19/2011
Astrology, as presented by Gahl (see his site cosmicnavigator.com) is presented as the exploration of the archetypes of humanity, he suggests that the 12 signs and 12 houses are mirrors that allow us an insight into our all too human natures. And that in differing degrees we all have a bit of every sign in us. It's interesting to see the lively debate this latest "astrology debunking" has sparked, as it certainly falls along Astrological fault lines.. If you follow Gahl's teaching you can almost pick out the "Doubting Capricorns" from the "Compassionate Cancers" and the "Let me weigh the different aspects Liberians" ... humanity, warts and all :) What a nice way to celebrate the New Year
09:26 AM on 01/19/2011
What is the physical mechanism through which the positions of stars and planets influences personality?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
12:46 PM on 01/19/2011
We do not know. The same way that we do not know the physical mechanism by which gravitation works, or love, or God...And yet, some of us engage in those concepts/activities. Also, we do not know how two particles light years away can experience the same thing (Quantum theorem)
12:57 PM on 01/19/2011
Gravity and quantum mechanical experiments produce predicable results. If you can design a personality test based on astrology that can predict a person's birthday, I know a magician who's got a cool million and some change for you.
recless
Evidence first. Believe later. Maybe.
01:58 AM on 01/19/2011
Astrology is proof you can delude just about anyone anywhere.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
03:07 AM on 01/19/2011
Thanks for the comment, I will make sure to pass it to Newton, Kepler, the Free Masons (16 of US presidents) and Augustus...I think I rather be in their company than yours lol...
03:45 AM on 01/19/2011
If you could pass it on to Newton, Kepler, and Augustus I might be more inclined to think there was something in this astrology stuff...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DakkonA
www.DisentangledReality.com
06:19 AM on 01/19/2011
Argument from authority. Just because certain well-known people who did something of note believed something else doesn't make it right.
07:07 AM on 01/19/2011
For you Aussie's, it's the sign of Cancer. ;)
07:25 AM on 01/19/2011
It is suggested that people born in the winter (e.g., Capricorns) are more at risk to suffer from Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD), schizophrenia and depression.
01:58 AM on 01/19/2011
As an astrologer who is also fielding this cyclic question: THANK YOU!!!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
03:10 AM on 01/19/2011
You are welcome...I am sure this silly storm will die away like all others. It has happened 4 years ago and 10 years ago... Ignorance is always much more noisy than wisdom
07:20 AM on 01/19/2011
True enough, most intelligent people don't waste energy on prophecy and mythological creatures.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allen Bouchard
I worship His Divine Shadow.
10:12 AM on 01/20/2011
"Ignorance is always much more noisy than wisdom"

This is why we see more about astrology and other nonsense than science in newspapers.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
09:59 AM on 01/19/2011
Many thanks, sending love from lovely Turkey...Happy Full Moon!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hueylover
carry on
01:02 AM on 01/19/2011
Interesting how all the astrological symbolism - eg, Aries = spring, etc, is utterly meaningless in the southern hemisphere!
06:54 AM on 01/19/2011
quite so-:)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
07:03 AM on 01/19/2011
It actually is not. In the Southern Hemisphere we use the aspects between the planets more than the signs and the aspects don't change with constellations and signs. Sorry to disappoint, once again, better do some research about something before one dismisses it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hueylover
carry on
03:36 AM on 01/20/2011
I am aware of the aspects etc. I was commenting on the basic symbolism, based on nature and the seasons. I also have studied astrology so please don't accuse me of a lack of research!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Angel Whitebird
Invest in America..Buy a Congressman!
09:55 PM on 01/18/2011
It makes sense to me that nothing changes the fact of when you were born..Weather there was a shift or not..nothing changes your date of birth.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
01:58 AM on 01/19/2011
I agree...all this is much to do about nothing
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DakkonA
www.DisentangledReality.com
06:00 PM on 01/18/2011
There *may* be some truth to the possibility that people born during different times of the year are affected by seasons differently.

However, astrology is self-reinforcing. If someone reads what it says about them, they may consciously or subconsciously select those traits in themselves. Though it certainly can't tell your future.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
01:56 AM on 01/19/2011
That is true not only about astrology but also psychology, economy and many so called scientific fields. It is called the uncertainty principle, when you observe something you already change it. It is part of being human...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DakkonA
www.DisentangledReality.com
06:16 AM on 01/19/2011
That has nothing to do with the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The act of observing in fields like psychology, economics etc. does not itself change reality. And psychology at the very least (economics isn't a science except where it overlaps with studying human behavior) tries to control for how the knowledge and expectations that people have to get at what is really going on.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
02:00 AM on 01/19/2011
This is true also about psychology, economy and many other so called "sciences" It is part of what is called the uncertainly principle, when you observe something, you change it. It is part of being human ;)
08:29 AM on 01/19/2011
gahl you seem to know your stuff about astronomy as well as astrology, but come on! you think astrology is up to par these "so called" sciences??? really?

Where are the reproducible experiments showing theories of astrology to be accurate? Where are the large scale, double-blind studies--after thousands of years of astrology "science"? I have yet to ever see these. In fact most large scales studies of astrology don't even show it as an effective placebo--but rather close to 50% accurate--like flipping a coin.

although psychology and economics are not the most accurate sciences (mainly due to the inconsistent and unpredictable nature of their variables), they are scrutinized under the same scientific methods as chemistry and biology.

just because a lot of people believe in something, or that it affects their life in the way they want....doesn't mean they're right--look at the tea party :)
05:59 PM on 01/18/2011
One more thing, the author could have better explained the Babylonian Zodiac division by saying 12 signs multiplied by a 30 degree space for each equals 360 degrees, which is why, in western astrology, the Sun spends the same amount of time in each sign.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DakkonA
www.DisentangledReality.com
05:57 PM on 01/18/2011
How can you debunk myths about a myth?
06:09 PM on 01/18/2011
Oh, I just worked out some rough estimates based on the well-known FACT the Earth is 4.5-4.6 billion years old.
06:21 PM on 01/18/2011
A few other FACTS
Great Year, precession or Earth wobble (as author puts it) - 25, 800 yrs.
If we were to check the Sun’s position in the Zodiac on successive Vernal Equinoxes, we would see that it will take approximately 2,150 years for the spring sun to travel through the constellation of Aquarius on its way to Capricorn. If we were to live for 25,800 years, or one great year, we would witness 12 new ages. When used correctly, the Zodiac is the master calendar or the face of a clock for the Platonic year.
05:51 PM on 01/18/2011
The author mentions that the Sun's ecliptic path "barely" passes through Ophiuchus, which is the reason he gives for its demise. However, Google "sun's ecliptic Ophiuchus" and you will see the Sun's path goes directly through this constellation. Also, the Sun's path remains in this constellation longer (about two weeks) than in Scorpio (seven days).
Also, it's interesting how western astrology recognizes the Ages, but fails to take into account the Zodiac's vernal equinox shift. In western astrology the hour hand is ticking, but the second hand has stopped. We are in Great Year 173,611. There have been 2,083,332 Ages since the Earth began. You were born in the Age of Pisces. No one living was born in the Age of Aries (when astrology began), which ended around 60 B.C., adjust your Zodiac accordingly. The Age of Aquarius arrives around 2070. I probably won't be around. Have fun!
05:49 PM on 01/18/2011
Is it so hard to google "cold reading?"
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
02:03 AM on 01/19/2011
I agree, the last comment does not make sense and its hard to argue with a ghost...the sun stays only 19 degrees in that so called "13th sign" and at the time astrology was created when signs=constellation it stayed even less. There is Sidereal astrology and Tropical astrology and most people who rebuke astrology do not understand the difference. It is like they are trying to make a minor song major not realizing it is a choice
07:00 AM on 01/19/2011
19 days seem long enough, why the urge to dismissal?
09:15 AM on 01/19/2011
I meant for astrology in general. Fortune tellers are cold readers. People who read horoscopes make them mean what they want them to mean. Explanation of astrology over.
photo
JohnFromCensornati
The End is near
05:34 PM on 01/18/2011
"Many people claim that Astrology has no scientific backing and therefore cannot provide "real" help to humanity. I was stunned to see that this assertion in The Christian Science Monitor, a news organization owned by a church. There is no scientific proof of the resurrection of Christ, and yet the teaching of Jesus can still inspire love and compassion."

Actually, in this case, it would've been more appropriate to say: "There is no scientific proof (or any other kind of proof) that faith healing works any better than astrology."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
06:59 AM on 01/19/2011
I encourage you to read many studies conducted by anthropologists on faith healing, shamanic healing, and you will see that they work miracles, and in some case superior to western medicine. We had many great healers, doctors and therapist before the so called Age of Reason. '

Hippocrates (ca. 460 BCE - ca. 370 BCE), considered the father of Western medicine, is quoted saying that a physician without knowledge of astrology has no right to call himself a healer.
Of course, much has changed since the times of Hippocrates. However, it is important to note that doctors all over the world are still initiated into their practice by taking the Hippocratic Oath.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Maria Alvarellos
02:10 PM on 01/19/2011
Had you never heard of the placebo effect? Had you never heard of cultural relativism? Do you not know that certain illnesses exist in some cultures that do not seem to exist in others therefore cures for these diseases which are culture specific are also culture specific? Faith healing and shaminic healing show that the mind is terribly powerful is all that tells you.
05:04 PM on 01/18/2011
This is a pretty bad article. At least explain that there's two zodiacs and the Western world uses a seasonal one. Spend five minutes on Wikipedia and you'll have a far more complete picture than reading anything the author wrote above.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
02:05 AM on 01/19/2011
thx for the feedback, lol, will try better next time, see above
04:45 PM on 01/18/2011
Thanks for the insightful post. It's unfortunate that some people find it seemingly impossible to open their minds to the possibilities of this ancient mythological framework. Astrology is so divisive but it also highlights the real ignorance of people to the power of symbol, archetype and myth that has shaped culture and psychology over the eons. Read some Joseph Campbell and Carl Jung, people and at least try and meet us halfway in an intelligent discourse.

If astrology didn't provide what it claims to provide, then why do well educated people continue to research and practice it to this day? It's not just the ignorant masses to subscribe to this system. There are many, many intelligent and incredibly intellectual people who understand this framework and manage to apply it with great effect.
06:46 PM on 01/18/2011
My mind is completely open. Please provide "actual" provable peer reviewed evidence. Otherwise is all noise.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
07:10 AM on 01/19/2011
peer reviewed evidence...lol...refer to the work of Galileo and Kepler as well as most astronomers until the 16th century when Astrology for political reasons was slowly banished from the academical discussions...Which I am happy to say is returning. More and more universities are now offering studies in cosmology that include astrology...Soon it will be main stream and people will be more informed about this ever growing field of human-cosmos investigation.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gahl Eden Sasson
02:06 AM on 01/19/2011
I call it the evolutionary proof. If it didn't help millions it would have disappeared like many other systems that didn't make it