iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gary Shapiro

GET UPDATES FROM Gary Shapiro
 

Mr. President, Stop the Personal Attacks

Posted: 07/23/2012 5:16 pm

Dear President Obama,

I thank you for your service to our nation and applaud your passion on many issues including health care, gay marriage and a compassionate approach to immigration reform. You are an admirable politician and a level-headed president.

But I ask you to consider how your campaign strategists, in an understandable desire to win, diminish you in their efforts to demean your opponent, Mitt Romney.

Look at how your campaign, your surrogates and your advertisements define you.

Putting aside the unauthorized comments, like from Democratic strategist Hilary Rosen who said, "Anne Romney never worked a day in her life," consider these other malicious attacks:

The attacks on Bain. You and your allies have continued to spend millions on ads attacking Mitt Romney with half-truths and allegations about Bain, often for things that never occurred or did not occur while he was there. New Jersey Mayor Corey Booker, a Democrat, found the attack "nauseating." Steve Rattner, formerly President Obama's car czar, called it "unfair." Former President Bill Clinton agreed that Romney was a successful businessman and qualified to be president. Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell, also a Democrat, called the attack "disappointing." Mitt Romney created and ran a successful company. The Bain smear campaign is beneath you. And you should apologize and fire your campaign official who said Romney committed a "felony."

The attacks on Romney's wealth. Former President John Kennedy inherited wealth. In fact, his family was worth $1 billion. While Romney certainly benefitted from his family paying for his education, his earned wealth pales in comparison. Not to mention, he worked throughout school and created Bain with his own funds. Romney capitalized on the American Dream and the entrepreneurial philosophy to create value and jobs and make money. Romney was successful. Get over it. Your campaign efforts to demonize Romney for his wealth, and even your "tax the rich" mantra, are simply unsuccessful and divisive political ploys inappropriate for a leader seeking to unite the country.

The attacks on Romney for investing overseas. You mislead the country when you say that Romney outsourced jobs while working at Bain Capital and invested money in a Chinese manufacturing company. Recently the Romney campaign released a video that refutes your attacks. When did trade and investment become an evil and disqualifying condition of becoming president? We encourage foreign investment in the U.S. and want Americans to have the freedom to invest abroad. Romney has not violated any laws and his funds are in a blind trust, yet your administration attempts to paint this as an anti-American agenda. Yet many leading Democrats, including Nancy Pelosi, and almost every pension fund, including union funds, invest abroad.

Romney as the "Other." Your campaign has capitalized on the "other guy" strategy, characterizing Romney as out of touch with the American spirit. He's too rich, he's too religious and he's too frugal. These attacks and many others are similar to Vice President Biden's concerted effort to paint Governor Romney as a foreigner, a rich Mormon and someone who is different than "normal" Americans. Politico writer Roger Simon called this the Democrat "Other" Strategy in order to portray your opponent as "the guy ... who does not act like a real American." What a sad political move -- perhaps too common in many political races.

You have substantive differences with Governor Romney on economics, tax policy, social issues and health care so there is plenty of substance to discuss. You can and should make your case to the American people that you are the better candidate on these issues.

You should hold yourself above the attacks from your campaign. They only serve to diminish you. As for Governor Romney, he too has accused you of European-style socialism -- but this is not a personal attack -- it is a judgment of your economic views. To his credit, Mr. Romney and his surrogates are not mentioning personal issues in your background.

Mr. President, if you believe in your issues, stick to them and stop the personal attacks. When you demean your opponent, you only demean yourself.

Gary Shapiro is president and CEO of the Consumer Electronics Association (CEA)®, the U.S. trade association representing more than 2,000 consumer electronics companies, and author of the New York Times bestselling book, "The Comeback: How Innovation Will Restore the American Dream." Connect with him on Twitter: @GaryShapiro

 
 
 

Follow Gary Shapiro on Twitter: www.twitter.com/GaryShapiro

FOLLOW POLITICS
Dear President Obama, I thank you for your service to our nation and applaud your passion on many issues including health care, gay marriage and a compassionate approach to immigration reform. You ar...
Dear President Obama, I thank you for your service to our nation and applaud your passion on many issues including health care, gay marriage and a compassionate approach to immigration reform. You ar...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mwade002
08:04 PM on 07/25/2012
Republicans have not stopped attacking the president and his family from day one. They have a whole media network devoted to it. Stop the personal attacks? You are barking up the wrong tree.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:43 AM on 07/25/2012
You're kidding right? What's good for the goose is good for the gander. All those personal attacks over the years, the indignation most Republican lawmakers have shown towards Obama, and now, in the middle of an election, Republicans are whiners?

GOP = grumbling old plutocrats.
04:22 PM on 07/24/2012
I wasn't aware that personal attacks were suddenly a bad thing. After all, if we've banned personal attacks from the political arena, then how are we going to claim Obama's birth certificate is fake, that he's Kenyan, or an immigrant, or a Muslim, or demand to see his college records and law degree?

After that, how are we going to deal with candidates like John Kerry by claiming that they didn't earn their military decorations? Or harass sitting presidents about their sex scandals, no matter how inappropriate it is for a congressman to be demanding to know about it?

Long story short, the president hasn't started in on Romney's record as governor of Mass., or his getting five deferrals from serving in Vietnam. He's asking about a company which Romney ran for a period of time (which period of time it is we'll leave up to debate), and about Romney's tax returns - both of which are valid points given Romney is running on his business record. Compared to the multitude of comments Romney's campaign has let slide or distorted, the president is being downright cordial. It's only good strategy for him if Romney is getting too flustered to sit back and present a level-headed defense.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Andrew Coe
Founder/Co-Owner of International Brand
04:08 PM on 07/24/2012
Frankly Obama is coming across bitter and desperate with this line of attacks. He will literally do anything to distract the public from his terrible record on the economy and the myriad of failed and broken promises he made to America. It's like he cannot understand why everyone just cannot see how great he is. It really is kind of pathetic... He has really fallen off his high horse and is having trouble dealing with the reality of his failures.
photo
devondx
Totally De-regulate all RED states=JUSTICE..
01:43 AM on 07/25/2012
...yawn...obama's winning...

It's like the GOP cannot understand why everyone just cannot see how great they are. It really is kind of pathetic...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:19 AM on 07/24/2012
How many hundreds of thousands jobs outsourced to China have you presided over?

Just a glance at your professional association says it all about you and whose side you're on. And it ain't ours.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rubellite
07:15 AM on 07/24/2012
Finally! An actual article on HP that tells the truth. Finally. I'm still in shock. Everything you said, Gary, I agree with. The way the president's campaign has been doing "business" is beneath the POTUS office. It's unseemly. Of course, most of the left of lefties here won't see that. They only see in simplistic terms of black and white. For some reason admitting that Romney has conducted the classier campaign by far makes them itchy. Face it libs, people are turned off. It's not going well for our Mr. President. Not well at all.
08:35 PM on 07/23/2012
Romney is not "too rich". What we know of him thus far is that he has confined his concerns about life to the concerns of rich people. We have had rich politicians who have looked around themselves and seen that others have concerns that go more to fundamental problems of existence like food, housing, healthcare, opportunities to earn a living, to educate their children and have tried to do something about it. "Comfort the afflicted, afflict the comfortable."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Sandy
08:27 PM on 07/23/2012
The author is using an unusual definition of "personal attack". Attacks on what Romney did at Bain is no more a personal attack than attacking ANY candidate based on what they DID at a previous job or position.

There ARE personal attacks on Romney that could have been criticized. Someone who says that Romney had money in overseas banks because he was betting against the US is criticizing a personal finance decision. But the author conflates attacks that he considers (although misguidedly) to be inaccurate with those attacks being PERSONAL. And so if the author is to be taken seriously, (which they shouldn't), then Romney's ENTIRE career, from Bain to the Olympics to the Governship would ALL be out of bounds because it is all 'personal'.

And that broadness makes it meaningless. It is a standard that could not and should not be upheld, and nobody has EVER claimed that the very careers that were touted as evidence of experience could not be subjected to scrutiny.
08:22 PM on 07/23/2012
I think it would be more accurate to say Romney was a successful financier. Businessman implies managing a production dept., a marketing dept., etc. Not much of those in high finance. He is certainly legally qualified to be President. The qualifications are not too stringent. The questions are "who is he/" "what has he done?" "what would he do as President?" Romney says that his "business experience" makes him better qualified. But it is "unfair" to try to examine that experience. Romney has taken positions on issues that are all over the map and in direct contradiction to one another. But that"s OK, those are only words. He's careful to avoid too many specifics about his time as governor. He seems to be an incredibly ephemeral candidate. If you think it's unfair for anyone to inquire too sharply into his past actions, perhaps you should find some "National Psychic" to tell us just who this guy is and what it is that he has in mind for us. Or should we just look no farther than Grover Norquist and the Koch bros.?
06:46 PM on 07/23/2012
Dream on my friend.... This is the Chicago gang we are dealing with....

From Al Capone to Rob Blago - this is part of the game
photo
devondx
Totally De-regulate all RED states=JUSTICE..
01:45 AM on 07/25/2012
the GOP is so non-confrontational and honest and open minded and

sensitive to the truth....
06:35 PM on 07/23/2012
Geesh Gary, are personal attacks suppose to be used only by right-wingers?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jameshat
06:31 PM on 07/23/2012
Is this guy high? mitt has questioned baraks patriotism, his citizen ship. calling him a socialist. totally ignring the hole the last repubilcan president called. twisitn what the president says at every turn. romeny is a big lying p*ssy. this clown should go back to the circus.
06:07 PM on 07/23/2012
This is the only safe line of attack for Obama. No one knows anything about him to complain about. What would be nice is if we knew about his Occidental College records, his Columbia College records, his Columbia Thesis paper, his Harvard College records, his Selective Service Registration, his Medical Records, his Illinois State Senate schedule and records, his law practice client list, the signed embossed paper certification of live birth, the certified copy of the original birth certificate, his Baptism record, which country's passport that was used when he visited Pakistan in 1981, how he got foreign student aid as a college student and why Michelle can no longer practice law. Why are all these things being hidden from us?
photo
devondx
Totally De-regulate all RED states=JUSTICE..
01:47 AM on 07/25/2012
he'll be attacking everything about mitt and the his GOP band of theives....

the criminal fraud and company bankruptcies created by bain are just the beginning....
photo
devondx
Totally De-regulate all RED states=JUSTICE..
05:55 PM on 07/23/2012
Romney's career defines the issues of our disastrous economy and

he IS the problem.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rubellite
07:18 AM on 07/24/2012
No. This is a referendum on Obama, not Romney. F 00 L.
photo
devondx
Totally De-regulate all RED states=JUSTICE..
01:41 AM on 07/25/2012
Since they are pushing totally oppisite beliefs ....

its gonna be a referendum on both......

and they will have to debate...Romney can't hide forever....good luck...