Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Georgia Kelly

Georgia Kelly

Posted: October 12, 2010 12:16 PM

Praxis Peace Institute (my Sonoma, CA non-profit organization) brought a group of 25 people for a 5-day seminar and tour of the Mondragón Cooperatives in the Basque region of Spain, September 13-18, 2010.

There was a popular phrase among some politicians a few years back that proclaimed, "there is no alternative" (TINA) to the status quo of neoliberal capitalism. After spending one week at the educational center of the Mondragón Cooperatives in the Basque Country of Spain, it is crystal clear: There is an alternative! And, the Basques have proven it with their model of worker-owned businesses that has flourished over the past 55 years.

So, what are the Mondragón Cooperatives? And, what is so unique about them?

Founded by a Basque Catholic priest in the 1950s, they began with one small worker-owned cooperative that made parts for washing machines. Today, with 120 businesses and nearly 100,000 workers, the Mondragón Cooperatives comprise the largest consortium of worker-owned businesses in the world. In 2007, the Mondragón Cooperatives had sales of 24 billion Euros. In 2009, when twenty-five percent of all businesses in Spain failed, less than one percent of businesses failed in the Mondragón Cooperatives. What's their secret?

Based on a philosophy of human values, respect, and equality, the cooperatives are an inspiration in demonstrating what an evolved business environment looks like. The mission of the Mondragón Cooperatives Corporation (MCC) is to create wealth within society, to foster a people society instead of a capital society, to honor work with dignity, and to limit the number of work hours. Mikel Lezamiz, educational director at MCC, says, "People are the core, not capital. This is the main point. If capital has the power, then labor is simply its tool."

Producing everything from computer chips and bicycles to washing machines and auto parts, the Mondragón Cooperative businesses produce a wide range of products and services. In fact, we learned that 25% of the products that will be produced in 2014, are not yet in production. The continual search for new products reflects their flexibility in dealing with changing times and their commitment to innovation and job creation, which are stated goals.

For entrepreneurs, the Mondragón Cooperatives include an incubation center for new products and services where they help develop and fund new projects. The MCC includes thirteen Research and Development centers (the largest R&D center in all of Europe) and its own cooperatively owned bank, Caja Laboral, with 394 branches throughout Spain. The MCC has its own social services program, which provides pensions, unemployment insurance, and medical coverage. This is in addition to those services already offered by the Spanish government!

Instruction in conflict resolution is also an integral part of MCC. When someone in our seminar asked what they would do with a worker who was inattentive or goofing off on the job, our instructor didn't hesitate a moment. "We don't believe in confrontation," he said. "We would initiate a dialogue in order to find out what is causing the problem." The focus at MCC is not punishment for bad work but interest in the individual having the problem.

Their approach of caring for the individual first is what makes Mondragón exemplary in people relations.

The Mondragón hybrid moves beyond labels like capitalist and socialist and avoids both terms in describing their cooperative model. Instead, they appear to take some of the best ideas in both systems, adding their own philosophy and values into the mix. The result is innovation and social responsibility, a constant striving for improvement and always protecting the worker-owner.

The average CEO of an MCC corporation receives six times the salary of the lowest paid worker, a far cry from U.S. corporate CEO salaries, which might exceed 300 times the lowest paid worker. To become a worker member, one must apply for an open job and invest 14,000 euros in their company. This sum can be borrowed from Caja Laboral at 1% interest over 10 years. The democratic process means one worker-owner equals one vote. There are no stocks.

With a population of about 23,000 inhabitants, the town of Mondragón is solidly middle class. There are neither mansions on the hill nor poverty in the streets. The one mansion that exists in the area is a 14th century estate that was renovated to become MCC's educational center. The many acres that surround this estate are now small farms amidst green rolling hills. The families or coops that work the land have them rent free. "They are maintaining the land," Mikel said. "For that, they pay no rent." It is viewed as an even exchange.

The American myth says we can have it all, but in Mondragón that seemed provincially (or arrogantly) naïve. Why should we even want it all? The countries and communities that value social connection, social services, and an eradication of poverty consistently appear at the top of the happiness index. The Basque region has the highest standard of living and the lowest unemployment rate in Spain and it also has the largest number of people involved in worker-owned businesses. Many participants at the Praxis seminar in Mondragón had their worldviews turned upside down in a most inspiring and hopeful manner. There is an alternative!

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:28 PM on 11/10/2010
Ahhh. A breath of fresh Life Air. Renewed Hope in Humanity is what I feel today. Spain! I am so proud of you, especially your Basque Citizens, for this wonderful work of Good Heart and Mind!

See my fellow Americans. See what is possible, even in Our Troubled Land? Like I have said, We doont have to destroy Capitalism, just make it More and Better.

I also thank the "Praxis Peace Institute" (my Sonoma, CA non-profit organization) for their journey for Truth and this report. DAN 1
02:59 AM on 10/13/2010
This kind of model is the future of sustainability and micro-distribution/economies
nothingchanges
too soon old, too late smart
02:00 AM on 10/13/2010
If only.............

Those individuals who have amassed great wealth and power in today's America, will hardly be inclined to lower their standards to achieve this type of innovation. They'll just label it socialism and turn the general populace against the very concept. Biased media outlets will see to that.

One of the problems with extreme disparity of wealth is that those with power and influence, gain more. Those without, lose what little they had.

With our political system based on the reality that whichever candidate spends the most to get elected, will be......... (94% of the time in the last election cycle), then money begets money, and any attempt to change that system will be quashed by those that have prospered so much by the way things are now. They will fight to keep what they got, and they have the financial means to win.

The Basques relate more like a family. American business is more like war. The last man standing wins it all. I just wonder if what's left will be worth having.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gus DiZerega
writer
10:46 PM on 10/12/2010
One of the greatest challenges to creating a society in keeping with our founding ideals is the Hobson's choice between corporate tyranny and the tyranny of centralized government control - a modern version of whether you'd rather be oppressed by the aristocrats or the emperor. The Mondragon cooperatives are completely in keeping with American ideals as described in our Declaration of Independence and have proven free from the worst abuses by corporate oligarchs or government elites.

Kelly has written a powerful introduction to this game-changing alternative to "pick your poison."
09:24 PM on 10/12/2010
What a great way to turn the strengths of capitalism into something that works for people as well as profit accumulation by a few. As a well satisfied customer of my solid, solvent and highly efficient credit union I can only say "bravo". More of us should interject this option into conversations about "capitalism" today. After all, in the "free market" of ideas, it SHOULD be an option. What a concept..."human capital" as a valued part and goal of capitalism. Terrific article. Well worth reading and sharing.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robbcoffee
06:17 PM on 10/12/2010
This is where culture plays a massively important role.
Unfortunately our culture will not accept anything even remotely similar to this any time soon.
We're just beginning to get around to the idea that investing in worker happiness can be good for business.
09:27 PM on 10/12/2010
I disagree completely. This "model" is far more akin to what Americans have hopefully, if wrongly, assumed that capitalism and the free market was about. We already have examples of Employee owned companies in America and there are regional cooperatives and associations. I believe it could spread like wildfire. People are hungry for a new approach and for more "humanity".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robbcoffee
08:49 AM on 10/13/2010
Simultaneously a large portion of Americans also believe all the "trickle-down" crap and in authoritarian parenting, governance, and life in general. They tend to believe that if everyone just followed the rules, the traditional mechanisms would lead to a just, friendly society.

Furthermore without support of at least some elites, no revolution goes anywhere.
Who are the big business voices in America advocating anything remotely like this?
sonoffestus
Got smart & got out!
05:49 PM on 10/12/2010
We have a very good friend , a doctor from San Sabastian Spain. He has told us about this system and the benefits of such. It will never work in the States because America has become a fearful and ignorant nation. Sheep being led to their slaughter.........................voting for their executioners, the GOP.
04:35 PM on 10/12/2010
Nice piece of mythology, but co-operatives exist in many places and have for a very long time and have been plagued by inefficiency, corruption, political infighting and a lack of long term sustainability. To pick one successful one out and claim the system works as a result is either naive or intentionally intellectually dishonest. An in dpeth analysis of the history of co-opertaives worldwide on a broad basis would likely lead to the exact opposite conclusion of what the author intends us to believe in.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gus DiZerega
writer
10:41 PM on 10/12/2010
Typical right wing clap trap, I'm afraid. There are many kinds of co-ops, some more successful than others. Worker owned and operated ones are among the most successful, and their biggest problem was passing on shares that had increased in value to the next generation of workers as the original ones retired. The Mondragon cooperatives have solved this problem.
09:18 AM on 10/13/2010
Baloney, if they were so successful they would simply shut down the greedy capitalist competition. There is absolutely nothing in any western economy (or most other economies) that prevents them from doing so with their wonderful model. If they have been around for centruies and haven't done so, it should tell you something about their sustainability to attract and retain workers, customers in an effective and efficient way. They can't, they lose in a free society and have for hundreds of years. The pathetic history of these types of organizations is documented. The only argument taht could even reasonably be entertained is that the government is conspiring with fat cat businessmen to kepe them down. I don't think anyone really belives that any more, but it is simply the only logical argument that exists as to why they haven't taken over economies, supposing that the author's conclusion is correct (which it's not).
photo
Weareonenow
Your Reality is a function of your mental software
01:11 PM on 10/13/2010
Is American capitalism successful ? in the long sweep of history the American dream is but a speck.
in time and only made possible by the abundance of natural resources found on the newly exploited American Continent and finite reserves of OIL that gave a short term boost to the world economy.

Financial wealth is just one facet of the development of humanity ( i presume that you agree that enterprise should lead to human development, happiness and peace )

America today will one day be seen for what it is . a sick and insane society ,right up there with Soviet communism as monumental failures to human development.

All human activity should lead to human happiness and development , not the accumulation of wealth by a few unhappy and clinically insane persons while the majority suffer or pine away while their human potential is wasted.
04:34 PM on 10/13/2010
"America today will one day be seen for what it is . a sick and insane society ,right up there with Soviet communism as monumental failures to human development."

Unbelievable. Comparing prosperity and freedom with absolute restriction on freedom via coercion and privation is the height of ignorance. The fact that you can write such nonsense and perhaps belive it is laughable.

I suggest you read a bit more on the long sweep of history you allude to.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NYCBri
04:19 PM on 10/12/2010
Good article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tasies
03:07 PM on 10/12/2010
That is some serious stuff you're advocating there. Can't have examples of people living within their means, and not subjugated by their ambition, clearly un-American.
09:30 PM on 10/12/2010
If "living within your means" also means there is true job security, fair and affordable housing? Yeah, actually I can see a lot of people buying in to that. Despite reality TV most Americans don't want to be the next Donald Trump...heck, despite their grudging admiration for some of his moxie, I don't think most people truly admire him or want to emulate him.
photo
BBackSoon
Hello, I must be going.
02:01 PM on 10/12/2010
Wow! I want that!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:46 PM on 10/12/2010
This is probably the best article I've ever read on Huffington Post. While I would gladly refer to the themes expressed as socialism, what's really important is the author's emphasis on human and humane values. We are people; not cogs in the neo-liberal machine.

We see a never-ending stream of good solid liberal economists writing articles here but they don't seem willing to provide a real vision of how our economy and our democracy could function. All of them talk about "creating jobs" or "stimulus programs" or "unemployment benefit extensions" or "campaign finance laws" but none of them seems willing to call for the changes we really need.

All of the classic "safety net" programs, while necessary in today's climate, are mere band-aids on the cancer of capitalism. These liberals are merely addressing the symptoms of the disease. It is the economic system itself, i.e. some perverted form of capitalism, that is the problem. Even if we come out of the current depression, we are still stuck with a system that corrupts our democracy in pursuit of profits. We are still stuck with a system where workers and even entire communities can be devastated when companies move overseas just to make a buck.

Socialism is too often painted as a tyrannical system where government bureaucrats have excessive control over our lives. In truth, socialism is an economic system that empowers people, often workers, to have more control over their lives and their society.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
avg american
It's about jobs, jobs, jobs...
02:33 PM on 10/12/2010
fanned and fav'ed... well said.
09:41 PM on 10/12/2010
There are some ideas that become transformative and I think this could be one of those. I actually think it transcends the false choice between capitalism versus socialism and "reboots" the conversation. Sort of brings some different aspects of our own Constitution and Declaration to the front....Some have forgotten that "We the people" is only the first phrase. It goes on to say, "in order to form a more perfect union" and let's not forget that one purpose of our new government WAS specifically to provide for the "general welfare" of the people and the country. If we can pass laws or formulate tax rules that currently favor corporations for their welfare as part of the country then surely we can leverage those same tools in favor of enterprises that provide these types of benefits as well. Acknowledging that they'd created a Republic of the US, Benjamin Franklin challenged "Now let's see if they can keep it". With apologies to Justice Scalia, the framework they gave us IS strong enough to craft solutions for the 21st century.