More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Giles Slade

Giles Slade

Posted: June 7, 2010 06:36 PM

Did BP Do Us a Favor?

What's Your Reaction:

The news from Louisiana about the oil spill is so terrible I can't read past the headlines. It's lucky I'm not a "professional journalist." Involuntarily, my face just turns away from the screen.

This has been going on for 50 days.

I was supposed to speak about the leak with Riki Ott, the author of the two best (by which I mean most readable and most responsible) Exxon Valdes books ( Not One Drop and Sound Truth and Corporate Myths, available here and here).

I actually wrote a list of questions and got Dr. Ott's mobile number out on the road in Louisiana. But I couldn't bring myself to hear what she had to say. I kept imagining an enormous watery desert where Hemingway once searched the horizon for shimmering Marlin. I tried to imagine being anywhere the Gulf touches when fish is no longer on the menu. More than the heartbreak of an endless and inescapable gunked-up shoreline, something inside me aches at the thought of no oysters, no shrimp, no crab and no red snapper.*

That was two weeks ago.

You'll be surprised to hear that I've decided to look on the bright side.

Bright side? Tell us, Giles, is there a bright side to this ungodly mess?

Well, let's say there is a slightly brighter side. I'll share it with you.

At last in Louisiana, there is a globally visible environmental crisis caused by our obsession with oil-based energy. The oil slick washing up on beaches from Florida to Texas can be seen from space. This crisis is so vast, so unavoidably obvious and has such devastating consequences that -- unlike climate change -- it is impossible to ignore, to dismiss or to spin. This time there aren't going to be any "oil spill deniers."

Moreover, the vastness of the spill resists our feeble ability to resolve it. There is no technological fix available to shut off the flow of crude now streaming into the Gulf of Mexico And there is no way to clean the oil out of the water and off of all the beaches. Yes, they have capped it. No, it has not stopped leaking. Everything nearby will die a slippery rust-colored death because we have created an environmental problem that scoffs at our puny technology. We are not the masters of Nature, after all, and this is not exclusively our planet even though it is true that we are the most powerful species that currently shares the space.

And there's more good news: In the midst of this crisis, public anger is growing. The president's feet are being held to the fire even if it isn't his fault. Something has to be done, and yet there is nothing decisive and definitive to do. The spill will get a whole lot worse before it ever begins to get better, if it ever does. Like I said, fish is off the menu.

BP's response is the best part of this. Because of the oil company's attempt to shift and deny responsibility, governments may be forced to seize corporate assets and to prosecute BP CEO Tony Hayward.

The beautiful part is that this might set a precedent for how to deal with profoundly bad citizenship on the part of an oil (or any other kind of) corporation. So... in its greed and irresponsibility, BP may actually have begun the work that the international agreements of Tokyo and Copenhagen could not accomplish.

In other words, BP has now generously provided the world with a truly horrific crisis that makes it imperative to deal with the fact of global corporate irresponsibility. And this is exactly what Obama should look to. To survive the crisis and to reemerge as the 'one true Prez', Obama can use his legislative gifts to make an example of BP by providing legislation stripping them of their assets and setting in place the ability to strip assets from any other corporation which similarly endangers humanity by destroying the environment that sustains and nurtures us. After all, this is what we do with drug dealers.

To facilitate this, the international legal concept of 'crimes against humanity' can be enlarged to deal with issues that threaten humanity's safety, security and well-being by irreparably destroying the natural world on which we all depend for basic human needs like 'food security'.

When this happens, we can build a statue to Mr. Hayward. I'd like to put it in a nice, open air spot where there are plenty of seagulls flying overhead and then limit the budget for cleaning it to donations from people who live on the Gulf coast and have an informed opinion about Mr. Hayward's leadership.


*Some articles about how the oil spill will impact Gulf fishing:

How the Deep Horizon Oil Spill is Affecting the Florida Seafood Industry

Nasty waters, ruined oysters

For Florida oystermen, race is on against approaching oil

Western North Carolina seafood prices starting to rise in wake of BP oil spill disaster in the Gulf of Mexico

Oil Spill Threatens Gulf Seafood

Fishermen Wait on Docks as Oil Gushes

Oil Spill Threatening Fishing Economy, Culture in Louisiana

 
The news from Louisiana about the oil spill is so terrible I can't read past the headlines. It's lucky I'm not a "professional journalist." Involuntarily, my face just turns away from the screen. Th...
The news from Louisiana about the oil spill is so terrible I can't read past the headlines. It's lucky I'm not a "professional journalist." Involuntarily, my face just turns away from the screen. Th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:14 PM on 06/12/2010
I was building a hot rod 1966 VW beetle using a 2.4 liter air cooled gas engine, a week after the spill I sold the big gas engine and bought an electric conversion for the volksrod, I and everybody need to make a serious effort to get away from relying on dead dinosaurs to kill us, we are plenty capable of doing that ourselves, just keep breeding and screwing the earth, it will come back around to bite us.
11:42 AM on 06/08/2010
Yes.....now maybe people will wake up!

Start now by going to www.dcasystems.com


DCAirSolar Systems
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Loyd Hawkins
09:18 AM on 06/08/2010
Sitting here on the beautiful Caribbean island of Bocas del Toro, Panama where the waters are crystal clear and the air is clean. Panama and Costa Rica are well on their way to becoming carbon neutral countries within the next 5-7 years. How? They refuse to allow oil drilling off of their coasts because they know an oil spill would destroy their environment. They are investing millions in mass transit. They utilize water to create energy. They demand sustainable tourism practices. They plant trees to offset what carbon is consumed. And the people here use energy conservatively. People walk and bike or take the bus/train rather than own cars. They don't run their A/C 24 hours a day, just an hour or two during the hottest part of the day and on cooler days not at all. They spend alot of time outdoors enjoying the natural beauty that surrounds them. They conserve water despite the fact this is the rainforest and it rains alot. Each individual leaves a smaller footprint on this earth than what I see back in the States where consumption is king. We could learn lessons from the people here if only we weren't so arrogant as to think that America has all the answers. Just saying...
08:58 AM on 06/08/2010
As loathsome and appalling as I found Tony Hayward for five weeks, I have come to await his arrogant obnoxious appearances with a smile. He is the perfect poster child for Big Oil. We couldn't have asked for anyone better. Of course, BP has finally figured that out so now we have the sensitive-appearing Dudley on the scene. And the media will get tired of following the catastrophe like they did with Katrina and be off to something new. And Pres. Obama does not seem able to "grasp the moment" when he is given it, as he has been given moments repeatedly, which he has seemingly squandered.

It does take a leader. Or 100 million mass marchers.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:30 AM on 06/08/2010
It is impossible to spin or deny?
Been watching the news lately? The right wing nutters are blaming the spill on environmentalists, for crying out loud, and Glenn Beck is now promoting a famous Nazi Jew hater as someone the right-wing should emulate.
Between intentionally lying, and their inability to understand anything more complicated than an egg timer, our friends on the right are quite capable of spinning and denying their way around absolutely anything.
As if that were not enough, we have the most profitable companies in the history of the planet, the oil companies, willing and able to spend hundreds of millions of dollars influencing politicians and voters so that they can continue business-as-usual. One can hope and wish that this recent disaster would be an impetus for more sustainable energy development, but I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it to come to pass.
06:25 AM on 06/08/2010
Never let a good crisis go to waste, eh? You've been paying attention.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alexandra Mandelis
Occupy.
11:37 PM on 06/07/2010
This is a great perspective to have, particularly since this formidable disaster is so difficult to comprehend.

From an international perspective, I cling to this hope, since our prime minister in Canada us an "energy man" whose oil industry friendly policies have more in common with W than Obama.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MrBadExample
Friends call me ‘exampleicious’
10:49 PM on 06/07/2010
Giles--

While it could be argued that BP is showing us exactly what's wrong with the drilling obsession we have, I fear the object lesson will be forgotten as oil gets more expensive and/or we experience supply shortages. The lessons of this catastrophe will be forgotten within a year of the successful capping of the leak(s), and most folks will care more about whether gas is up to $4/gallon. The fact that Obama is even considering relaxing the moratorium on drilling and exploration at this time is proof positive that this country fully deserves these kinds of disasters on a regular basis.
08:53 AM on 06/08/2010
but the country's people, its hard working, long suffering, people, do not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MrBadExample
Friends call me ‘exampleicious’
09:53 AM on 06/08/2010
This country's hard working, long suffering people have elected dullards on multiple occasions. Two of the three last Republicans refused to deal with our energy problems in any substansive way and told lies about being able to drill out of our problems. There was no knowledgeable geologist or oil historian who would back up their allegations, but the majority of Americans bought their lies and decided that self-sacrifice in the face of a profound mis-match between our energy needs and our energy appetite was too high a calling.

We haven't had a serious discussion about energy since Inauguration Day 1981. A majority of Americans were fine with this. They deserve what they get.
08:25 PM on 06/07/2010
I hope the BP OIL CATASTROPHE Will alert the people of our planet to see that we have to move quickly away from our dependence on oil and things made from oil such as plastic we need to change or lives drastically. What BP has done is destroy a huge chunk of the earth; we can not allow destruction like this to happen ever agean but we will We will because big oil will tell us trough the media that its safe to drill in deep water that the safety of birds and sea creatures is less important then our life style. they are doing it already oil has been pouring out for almost 50 days it s worse now then on day one we can all see that but BP tells us how much they have done and we want to believe it because its easy to believe easier dragging reusable bags to the market modifying the car to run on natural gas or ride the bus or bike. Big oil will buy the vote of who ever we elect. Next month or next year there will be another spill and another over and over
08:53 AM on 06/08/2010
Not spill. Blow-out. BLOW-OUT.
And there was another oil/gas explosion yesterday. On land.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Merle Savage
07:48 PM on 06/07/2010
The crude oil is toxic, and anyone who cleans the oily Gulf beaches needs to know the danger. Don't allow the workers to become BP's Collateral Damaged, like Exxon.
http://www.lvrj.com/news/exxon-valdez-oil-risks-spur-warning-for-gulf-cleanup-crews-93258964.html
The workers who are cleaning up the oil in the Gulf need to be aware of the chemicals that will be used. I am one of the 11,000+ cleanup workers from the Exxon Valdez oil spill (EVOS), who is suffering from health issues from that toxic cleanup, without compensation from Exxon.
I am Merle Savage, a female general foreman during the EVOS beach cleanup in 1989, which turned into 20 years of extensive health deterioration for me and 10,000+ workers. Dr. Riki Ott visited me in 2007 to explain about the toxic spraying on the beaches, and informed me that Exxon's medical records that surfaced in litigation by sick workers in 1994, had been sealed from the public, making it impossible to hold Exxon responsible for their actions. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=5632208859935499100
Beach crews breathed in crude oil that splashed off the rocks and into the air -- the toxic exposure turned into chronic breathing conditions, central nervous system problems, neurological impairment, chronic respiratory disease, leukemia, lymphoma, brain tumors, liver damage, and blood disease. http://www.silenceinthesound.com/stories.shtml
08:56 AM on 06/08/2010
One of those sick workers should get a copy of those documents from their lawyer. Parties have a right to the evidence.