It's Girl Scout cookie season, but Michigan scouts Rhiannon Tomtishen and Madison Vorva are finding other ways to support the organization's mission of "building girls of courage, confidence, and character who make the world a better place" than selling those famous Thin Mints and Tagalongs. Many varieties of Girl Scout cookies include palm oil, the No. 1 culprit behind deforestation in Southeast Asia, particularly Indonesia and Malaysia.
When Madison and Rhiannon (left) found out that Girl Scout cookies were destroying the forest homes of endangered wildlife like orangutans, pygmy elephants, and Sumatran tigers -- and displacing indigenous people -- they sprung into action. First, they stopped selling the cookies, and then launched an effort to encourage the Girl Scouts to switch to more environmentally friendly (and healthier) alternatives like canola oil. The Girl Scouts USA and their CEO Kathy Clonginer, however, have refused to act despite efforts by Girl Scouts across the country and the encouragement of organizations like the Union of Concerned Scientists and Center for Biological Diversity.
Now, thanks to a post on the animal welfare blog Please Do Not Tap on the Glass, we learned that the Girl Scouts' British sister organization, the Girl Guides, have eliminated palm oil from their cookies, and are offering to help the Girl Scouts USA and Girl Guides Canada do the same. The English bakers also found, unsurprisingly, that replacing unhealthy palm oil with olive oil and canola oil doesn't only save forests, it also resulted in a 60 to 70 percent reduction in saturated fat.
I hope the Girl Scouts USA do the same. When you read about the effects of palm oil cultivation on orangutans and other wildlife, it's pretty horrifying. Here's a recent report from Rhett Butler at MongaBay on the effects of palm oil expansion:
Michelle Desilets, executive director of the Orangutan Land Trust, says she started to see the shift about five years ago. Relegated to ever smaller fragments of forest, wild orangutans began to face starvation as their food sources were depleted, forcing them to venture into newly established oil palm plantations where they feed on the young shoots of palms, destroying the tree before it produces any oil seeds.Viewing the wild orangutans as pests, plantation managers started paying $10 to $20 for each dead orangutan -- a strong incentive for a migrant worker who may earn just $10 per day.
An oil palm concession. Photo courtesy of Flickr user H Dragon.
"Our rescue teams began to be informed of wandering wild orangutans in human settlements," Desilets told me, while cradling a baby orangutan in Nyaru Menteng. "We have found orangutans beaten to death with wooden planks and iron bars, butchered by machetes, beaten unconscious and buried alive, and doused with petrol and set alight. Since 2004, more and more orangutans in our centers have been rescued from areas within or near oil palm plantations, and over 90 percent of the infants up to three years of age come from these areas."
I think even the Cookie Monster would pass on that one. Unfortunately, so far, the Girl Scouts seem to be engaging in the type of greenwashing that one expects from giant food conglomerates like Cargill, instead of an organization that's supposed to be cultivating honesty and strong values in our nation's youth.
The Girl Scouts could be a great organization that, among other things, cultivates a love for nature and the outdoors. But it should follow the lead of its British sister organization and find a way to support itself in a way that doesn't undermine its values, or the survival of our fellow creatures. Until then, no Peanut Butter Patties, Thank U Berry Muches, or Daisy Go Rounds for me!
To get involved in the campaign for orangutan-friendly Girl Scout cookies, join Madison and Rhiannon's Facebook page.
Follow Glenn Hurowitz on Twitter: www.twitter.com/glennhurowitz
Thanks for the link: my article from The Ethical Nag: Marketing Ethics For The Easily Swayed ("Why You Should Not Buy Girl Guide Cookies This Year") is the one mentioned above in the Girl Guides Canada link - http://ethicalnag.org/2010/03/10/girl-guide-cookies/
I think the two young girls featured in your piece are role models for the stand that the entire international Guide/Scout movement COULD be trailblazing here if they weren't so hamstrung by "tradition". The Brits are already doing it - and teaching their young people a powerful lesson that, as my Mum used to say, "Doing things right is NOT the same as doing the right thing" sometimes.
Cheers,
Carolyn Thomas
Seriously, though -- these girls are acting exactly in the spirit of the Girl Scouts organization. Too bad the organization itself is having trouble practicing what it preaches.
And, to a previous commenter, yes, you can contribute directly to the Girl Scout troop of your choice by just writing a check directly to the troop!
Hopefully Girl Scouts will hear the call for change!
Keep up the great work!
Thankfully I make homemade versions of girl scout cookies. I buy their cookies but only really to support them. Is there a way to just directly donate? Maybe I just ought to do that if that's an option.