More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Greg Archer

Greg Archer

Posted: December 17, 2009 07:07 PM

Skinny Reporting Misses the Point of Ralph Lauren Boycott

What's Your Reaction:

This week's Ralph Lauren Boycott in Chicago generated, at times, up to 50 advocates for better media and advertising images, but a recent Page Six summary on nypost.com reported that "a store manager" said there were only four people in attendance.

To which this reporter has only this to say: Somebody must have photoshopped away some sanity.

2009-12-17-rsz_theone.jpeg

For what it's worth, the boycott, launched by filmmaker Darryl Roberts (America The Beautiful), is not so much about how many people venture out to rally, it's about, in part, sending out a message--through a grassroots campaign--to the corporate behemoths like Ralph Lauren to reconsider the images they are using in their ads. (By the way, it took Martin Luther King, Jr. some time to successfully launch a civil rights campaign.)

So, who needs to be heard here? The many millions of young girls and women that continue to be flooded with media images that tell them they have little or no value unless they are thin. These images are linked to promoting eating disorders, among other issues. They perpetuate the illusion that only when you achieve "thinness," will you be beautiful, adored and loved.

True, we all live in a world where this belief is rampant but it doesn't make it right, or true.

As for the Ralph Lauren Boycott, filmmaker Roberts and his posse have yet another one scheduled for 1 p.m. Sunday, Dec. 20 at the Ralph Lauren flagship store in New York City at 72nd and Madison.

Interestingly enough, that demonstration is being organized by NOW (National Organization of Women), the largest women's group in the United States. NOW's website, in fact, promotes the upcoming boycott, saying: "Get Your Photoshop Off My Body."

NOW isn't the only organization supporting Roberts' cause. The Campaign for Gender Equality, The Women's Therapy Centre Institute, IAEDP (International Association of Eating Disorder Professionals), The Canadian Obesity Network and ANAD (Anorexia Nervosa and Associated Eating Disorders) are also on board, as well as more than 5,000 people on Facebook.

Miss Indiana, Nicole Pollard is also a supporter.

Learn more about the issue at americathebeautifuldoc.com or at NOW. Catch up on how the boycott came to be in my previous blogs.

 

Follow Greg Archer on Twitter: www.twitter.com/chroniccharlie

 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:27 PM on 01/08/2010
Hmmmmm OK I LIKE women - quite a bit actually. Character tho - accounts for 90% of that - but the visual gives you the incentive or not to progress beyond that point.

IF women are naturally very thin and 6'4" - so be it.

But the scrawny unfleshed carcasses of the average "Mo-Dell" doesn't do much for me. And while these heftier chicks are much better, they all look like they could do with a quite a few less donuts and far more time on the bicycle.

That is if they own one. Or worse, can't even ride one.

Oh that's right, lifting cake into your face is working out - right - like doing weights at the gym.

I am not asking for Mizzz Muscles the Super Athlete who trains for the olympics and nothing but trains for the olympics and has a hard washboard stomach and no tits; but a woman who can run up 10 flights of stairs without needing oxygen, cigarettes and a case of donuts would be an ideal kind of starting point.

The "plus size" rhetoric is greying into fat, unfit and unhealthy.

Fat, unfit and unhealthy is being a LOSER by choice.
02:26 PM on 12/29/2009
Most ads prey on our insecurities to induce us to buy products.

Even without the skinny model controversy, RL portrays a posh upscale gentrified lifestyle in his ads.

He tempts us to buy the clothes as a way to appeal to our fragile self-esteem as faux participant in a lifestyle & world that most of us will never be part of

Doesn't virtually EVERY ad for discretionary consumer products use the "buy this product or you're a loser" paradigm? Remember kids killing each other over sneakers? Status handbags, the latest cellphone? Grey Poupon?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kristen Houghton
Author, Lifestyle Journalist, Humorist
08:26 PM on 12/17/2009
It is an unfortunate fact that millions of young girls see themselves as overweight when they are not anything but healthy. What they do to their bodies in the name of "beauty" is a form of self -punishment brought on by learned self-loathing.
How do I know so much? I spent years trying to lose those "damn 15 pounds" that were perfectly normal for my height and build. Learning self love, knowing that curves and "a little extra" are normal has to be taught.
Kudos to all who are in this grassroots movement to boycott Ralph Lauren. It's about time.

Kristen Houghton is the author of "AND THEN I'LL BE HAPPY! Stop Sabotaging Your Happiness and Put Your Own Life First" published by Globe Pequot Press
07:28 PM on 12/17/2009
Protesting clothing stores?

srsly?

Why is clothing store ads more important than ending the war?

srsly.
12:28 AM on 12/19/2009
Hey Chris, the people who work IN THE TRENCHES trying to save the lives of (mostly) girls who have an eating disorder are pretty much the only people who DO understand the problem. They are fighting a WAR, mostly trying to get the girls to see themselves as normal people and getting them to understand that the women portrayed in the ads are NOT REAL as they are shown. It is frequently a WAR against time, too, because if not caught in time, girls DIE. Did you know that if not nourished, body organs start shutting down, and once it reaches a certain point, there is NO STOPPING DEATH!!!
12:59 AM on 12/19/2009
You need to go to the ad companies and the models themselves.

bring video cameras for the confrontations. Name the names of ad execs that are making money off this. Go after photographers.

These protests just help you to help yourself to think you are doing something for a small group. I'm sorry if that upsets you but its true. I'm sorry for these girls who think that they should be a certain way but its not necessarily a street in front of a store is going to make a difference. It just gives you a bit a press between wars and lindsay lohan.

Make some videos of you confronting them people about this. Post it on the internet and keep doing it. Eventually you'll have a larger following. Then open you own ad firm that takes pride in presenting what you want to present and wanna know something you may find a niche and really get big.

But street protests are so 1990s
07:12 PM on 12/17/2009
I am one that supports this cause. And I've seen all kinds of effects that these ads have had on all the women around me and frankly its disgusting. Companies like PRL need to do some serious revamping of their products and message they are sending to their customers. Not to mention the newspapers, magazines and websites that actually publish advertisements and do the same thing. And I've seen comments about such articles about the boycott and most of them say things like "but I thought such and such of Americans were obese." Or something about everything being photoshopped so what PRL does isn't wrong." But to me it seems that those people don't know anything about the actual movement. Or else they don't see anything wrong with the images that our media shows us we need to be like. Which to me is very uneducated and sad considering the overall state our country is in right now, at least when it comes to self esteem. People like the reporter for the NYP don't want to report the news, just what suits them.