iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Greta Van Susteren

GET UPDATES FROM Greta Van Susteren
 

Give State Department's Philippe Reines a Break

Posted: 09/24/2012 7:25 pm

You may heard have that the State Department's Philippe Reines sent off an email with profanity to a member of the press as he responded to questions to the member of the media about the State Department's handling of the Libya crisis. Some are jumping him for losing his temper. Give Philippe a break. I know Philippe. He works hard for the American people. He is a good guy. He just got angry.

Don't forget -- these are very, very difficult times for people at the State Department for many reasons, including that many of them knew the ambassador who was murdered and feel a huge loss beyond what we may realize.

Yes, Philippe used profanity in responding to the media but who hasn't used profanity in his or her life, right? And if you haven't used it, and especially with the media, you might have thought about using it, right?

Don't forget: the shoe was on the other foot recently. Governor Mitt Romney's traveling press secretary Rick Gorka lost his temper and cursed out the media in Poland. Big deal --who cares that Rick Gorka lost his temper and cursed out the media (the media can be annoying...)?

So Rick lost his temper. And yes, so did Philippe. So what. It happens. People get angry. You might get angry. I do.

Bottom line -- Philippe works hard (and so does Rick). They both are probably exhausted with no sleep and much pressure. So, can we move on?

 
FOLLOW POLITICS
You may heard have that the State Department's Philippe Reines sent off an email with profanity to a member of the press as he responded to questions to the member of the media about the State Departm...
You may heard have that the State Department's Philippe Reines sent off an email with profanity to a member of the press as he responded to questions to the member of the media about the State Departm...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ed Gentner
Any farther left and I'd tip over
07:50 AM on 09/25/2012
Thank you Greta for providing a fair and balanced assessment of the e-mail exchange between Philippe Reines a member of Sectary Clinton's staff in response to CNN's use of Ambassador Chris Stevens' diary found at the wreckage of the Benghazi Counsel Office. He was upset over what can only be described at one of the truly low points in American journalism that was a blatant display of insensitivity to the Steven's family who had requested that the contents of the Ambassador's diary not be used and CNN's holding onto the personal property of the man until they had gone through what were the private thoughts. I have kept a diary for years as have many others who record their "private" thoughts and recollections that are not meant to be shared with the outside world under any circumstance.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:38 PM on 09/26/2012
Philippe Reines isn't just "a member of Secretary Clinton's staff", he is Deputy Assistant Secretary of State, and a designated spokesperson. It is unimaginable that a public relations professional in the Department of State, for crying out loud, can use profanity in dealing with media inquiries "because "he was upset." It is his job, his responsibility, in tense situations NOT to be upset.

Reines was not upset about the journal, that is a distraction. He was upset becasue Hillary Rodham Clinton is vulerable to scrutiny and criticism for irresponsilby not providing adequate security for an ambassador who clearly felt in danger.

Reines represents the downside of having an ambitous, image sensitive, POLITIICIAN as Secretary of State rather than a seasoned diplomat. He is Hillary's "image and fix it man", whose primary qualfiication is intense loyalty, not professionalism, integrity, or competence, and it shows.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ed Gentner
Any farther left and I'd tip over
08:20 PM on 09/26/2012
Hillary Clinton being ambitious, image sensitive, and a politician those are the very qualities great statesmen or stateswomen possess. Secretary Clinton has by any objective standards is one of the most effective people to hold the the office and has been an outstanding voice of the American people and the United States. Her appointment to the position is  one of the primary reasons President Obama is held in very high regard globally and has the confidence of a majority of the American people. I don't know Reines, although
his e-mail, while inmprudent, it was understandable given the circumstance at the time and certainly forgivable. 
Your argument might have legs if it weren't for the likes of John Bolton appointed as U.N. Ambassador and the cadre of political appointees from the Bush "43" Administration whose demeanor fell short of the ideal diplomatic conduct.
01:20 AM on 10/09/2012
What an amazingly clueless or deceptive line of nonsense this is. Reines is a pr flack working on behalf of Hilary Clinton and everyone in the the world knows this. The notion that he is a "good guy" is absurd. He has simply perpetuated the false premise that a video was responsible for the assassination of Ambassador Stevens and used deception when the truth was called for. The lies of this administration are a "new low."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Trollbaby
Why are cons always tryin' to ice skate uphill?
07:00 AM on 09/25/2012
These two situations are nothing alike...the pressure Gorka was under when he cursed out members of the press came from gaffes by Romney. He was tired of answering questions about the constant gaffe de jour from his boss. As you noted, Reines was under serious pressures, dealing with embassy attacks and the deaths of colleagues.

As usual, Greta tries to come off as moderate to give republicans cover. You do realize that Gorka was a press secretary, whose primary job was to DEAL with the media, right? Of course you do.

Moreover, the place the anger came from was totally different. Conservatives were gitty that one of their own would curse out members of the MSM and call out their so called liberal bias (I guess questions now have a liberal bias as well).

Btw, rational people don't get mad at institutions like the media and react with profanity, that's solely a trait of the paranoid mind.
04:27 AM on 09/25/2012
I may not agree with you often, Greta, but I do agree on this one - very common sense blog.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Trollbaby
Why are cons always tryin' to ice skate uphill?
12:02 PM on 09/25/2012
Context is everything, learn it...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dawn2dusk
REALLY!?!
03:52 AM on 09/25/2012
O J Simpson was the best thing that ever happened to your "career" You presented weak evidenc in court and now everyday on faux news. And please...the lockjaw aaargh!
01:24 AM on 09/25/2012
Greta's a total chump to fall for this. Philippe was asked a very important question, why hadn't the State Dept. cleaned the grounds of sensitive documents instead of leaving them for CNN and Al Qaeda to find?

His response wasn't a fit of pique. He diverted attention away from an egregious failure by a flurry of pointless obscenity. Sorry, Ms. Van Susteran you're being gamed.
11:40 PM on 09/24/2012
I. Agree. With. HER?
11:27 PM on 09/24/2012
Stress is high these days everywhere. Sometimes the lid pops off for a second. Get over it.

If that's all that Pilippe Reines and Rick Gorka are accused of then they're probably both better at keeping the lid on than I am under that kind of stress.

Kudos to Greta Van Susterm for framing this correctly.
12:52 AM on 09/25/2012
One word for you "Unprofessional"
12:21 AM on 10/01/2012
No, unprofessional is getting your knickers in a twist when someone tells you (or someone within earshot) to eff-off and then blabbing that to the world. Professional is saying "would you like to rephrase that in a way that I can print it?"
photo
Tribal Knowledge
Be bold and mighty forces will come to your aid!
10:01 PM on 09/24/2012
Greta,

Thank you for being a grown up. A rarity here.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:41 PM on 09/24/2012
Greta, why? Just why? Is it the money? Surely you've been prudent and saved all those big bucks. Maybe it's time to retire from the network which has done more damage to this country than any other entity within our borders. Think about it.

If you can't leave Fox, then denounce it. It's not just a job. It's dishonest propaganda designed to further a specific agenda here in the US that is anathema to what our country represented until Bush the W.

You in particular, paling around with Sarah like she wasn't way out of line and as though she had something worth while to say.

You know what? Nevermind.

What you said today. Great. Thanks.

Remember it's your choice, honesty or go back to Fox.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:27 PM on 09/24/2012
What a fair and balanced thing you are!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Democrab
Pretty far so good
09:06 PM on 09/24/2012
Oh princess softball, is this an audition for the fast rising MSNBC?
12:54 AM on 09/25/2012
Fast rising MSNBC? That is funny. They get less ratings than O'reillys 3rd run at 4am.
08:41 PM on 09/24/2012
Wow, I too am shocked that I agree with her. But she does sound the voice of reason here.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larry Braxton
10:43 PM on 09/24/2012
Earlier in her broadcast career she usually sounded like the adult in the room. However, her current employer doesn't condone that kind of behavior.
photo
obmit
There can be only one...
08:27 PM on 09/24/2012
Philippe Reines can be excused, because he is not a PR person. Rick Gorka, however, is a Press Secretary, and should know better. It's his job. Therefore his conduct is inexcusable.
08:15 PM on 09/24/2012
I'm shocked that I actually agree with Greta on something. People are understandably upset by the killing of our Ambassador and three of his colleagues. I also think that people have a right to be upset by the way in which one of our major news outlets handled this affair. Do we really want a new agency running around crime scenes and commandeering personal effects, then releasing them without the OK of the family? If so, think about it if it were one of your family.