Major American-Jewish Organizations may no Longer Back Turkey in Congress

There are serious indications that Israel and American-Jewish organizations are no longer willing to support Turkey's lobbying efforts in Washington.

The dispute between the two strategic allies began with Turkish Prime Minister Recep Erdogan harshly denouncing Israel's incursion into Gaza and accusing the Jewish state of committing crimes against humanity. He suggested that Israel be barred from the United Nations as mass demonstrations were held throughout Turkey with banners that read: "Gaza will be a grave for Israel" and "Put Israel on trial for war crimes." Israel's Consul General in Istanbul, Mordehai Amihai, told Milliyet that the consulate received hundreds of anti-Semitic e-mails every day during the fighting in Gaza.

Initially, Israeli officials expressed their displeasure through diplomatic channels. But as the anti-Israel rhetoric intensified, Israel's Deputy Foreign Minister publicly warned Turkey that Tel Aviv might retaliate by acknowledging the Armenian Genocide. Last week, Israel's Prime Minister Olmert invited the leaders of France, Britain, Germany, Italy, Spain and the Czech Republic to dinner in Jerusalem after their summit meeting in nearby Egypt. Significantly, Turkey's President Abdullah Gul, who also had attended the summit, was excluded from the dinner.

American-Jewish organizations, which had for years supported Turkey's denialist agenda on the Armenian Genocide in the U.S. Congress, were highly incensed by the Turkish condemnations of Israel. The American Jewish Committee sent a letter to Erdogan on January 8, to express its "grave concern over recent official statements" by Turkey's Prime Minister and Foreign Minister. On January 21, a second letter was sent to Erdogan, this time signed by five leading American-Jewish organizations, expressing their "profound concern over the current wave of anti-Semitic manifestations in Turkey."

In their joint letter, the American Jewish Committee, Anti-Defamation League, B'nai B'rith International, Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, and Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs complained about "gravely distressing" recent incidents: "Protestors besieging the Israeli Consulate in Istanbul have expressed their hatred of Jews. Billboards around Istanbul are full of anti-Jewish propaganda posters. The door of a Jewish-owned shop near Istanbul University was covered with a poster that said, 'Do not buy from here, since this shop is owned by a Jew.' The defacing of an Izmir synagogue has brought about the temporary closure of all but one of that city's synagogues." The American-Jewish groups also stated that the Jewish community in Turkey feels "besieged and threatened. A connection is clearly perceived between the inflammatory denunciation of Israel by Turkish officials and the rise of anti-Semitism."

Ironically, Abraham Foxman, ADL's National Director, who is now complaining to Prime Minister Erdogan about anti-Semitism in Turkey, had presented a prestigious award to him in 2005. Foxman conveniently overlooked the fact that four days before he gave that award to Erdogan, the Middle East Media Research Institute, based on a report from Hurriyet, revealed that Erdogan in 1974 had written, directed and played the lead role in a play called "Maskomya," an acronym for the triple "evils" of Masons, Komunists (Communists), and Yahudis (Jews).

Having given Erdogan one of ADL's highest awards, Foxman must have been shocked by the Turkish Prime Minister's recent criticisms of Israel. Foxman told Milliyet last week: "Turkey was our friend. We were friends. I still can't believe it. I am very sad and confused. The Jews in Turkey are threatened.... They feel encircled.... The Prime Minister spoke very harshly. We were friends. How did we come to this situation?" Jacob Isaacson, an official of the American Jewish Committee, was also unhappy with the Turkish reaction. "Once you start poisoning the well, you do not know where it leads," he said. Moreover, an unnamed American-Jewish leader was quoted as saying: "This time, we are going to face great difficulty. In the past, we defended the Turkish position, not only because Turkey was right, but also because we were friends." Yet another American-Jewish official, washing his hands from further involvement in Turkey's lobbying efforts on the Armenian Genocide, told Milliyet: "Count us completely out of this problem. We don't believe Congress should deal with it. Let Armenia and Turkey resolve it between them."

In another indication of diminishing support for Turkey among Jewish circles, Prof. Benjamin Yafet advised this writer that he had "very reliable information that all major American Jewish organizations are now fed up with Turkey and are ready to support the Armenian Genocide resolution."

It appears that this time around Israel and American-Jewish organizations will not be as forgiving as they have been in the past, in the face of persistent and vicious anti-Semitic attacks emanating from Turkey. After the loss of lobbying support from American-Jews, Pres. Obama's election, and Democratic majorities in both houses of Congress, Turkey is expected to have great difficulty in the coming months to block a renewed attempt to pass a congressional resolution on the Armenian Genocide. Faruk Logoglu, Turkey's former Ambassador to Washington, should know! He told Milliyet: "The Jewish lobby is the strongest in the United States and the only one supporting Turkey. Therefore, the letter of disappointment sent to Erdogan [by 5 Jewish groups] is of great importance."

To listen to this writer's hour-long interview with radio KZSU Stanford on this subject, please go to: radio4all.net.

Comments

[arvay]

The breakup of the unnatural romance between Turkey and Israel would be a splendid development.

Turkey is a regional power, with a strong, competent military and a rising economy. If the Turks perceive that the Israel lobby has pinned the Armenian massacre on them, that will widen the rupture. Turkey, friendly to Israel, has always been a worry to Syria -- if Turkey cools its relations with Israel, Syria may feel a bit more empowered in the region.

Eventually, this could begin a recasting of the relationship between the Turks and the Arabs. Both are edgy about the new Kurdistan, and aligning their ideas on Palestine could cement a new alliance.

Turkish response -- by its people and its leaders -- response to the Gaza massacres has been honest and heartfelt -- and in line with much of the world's reaction. Only the Americans are sheltered by their Zionist-sycophantic press from knowing the truth.

I had to laugh at this from Abe Foxman "Turkey was our friend. We were friends. I still can't believe it. I am very sad and confused. . .'

This is the tired, old "why do they hate us?" whine. Hey, the ingrates just don't understand bombing children, dispossessing hundreds of thousands and endless arrogance. Such backward people!

[arvay]

.. . and, let me add, I look forward to the day when Foxman has the same lament about the US - - -

[vtopa]

Blah blah blah....I can just see the Armenian lobby licking their chops at the opportunity to derail the Turkish lobby in congress to get support for their ridiculous crusade to make the world believe that there was an Armenian "genocide.­"

Pelase spare us the insightful analysis. The fact is that Erdogan was justified in his criticism of Israel, which has been acting like a genocidal bully not only in Gaza but in Lebanon back in 2006. The Armenian lobby (and this Armenian author) is trying to piggy-back on a tradgedy that has been unfolding in the Middle East for years. Pathetic

[Palspal2]

Zionists in the US have for a long time supported Turkey's position on the Armenian genocide for two principal reasons. First, denying the Armenian holocaust is part of the effort to posit the Jewish Holocaust as a singular event - without precursor or subsequent genocides. Secondly, Israel's policy is to reach out to non-Arab Muslim nations in the region as a way of surrounding its Arab neighbors with a non-Arab front. That is why Israel was on friendly terms with Iran until the Shah was overthrown. And it is why Israel is actively courting the Kurds of Iraq. Turkey could respond to all this by cutting off the deals to provide water and petroleum to Israel from its facilities in Ceyhan Turkey.
PS - Everyone knows there was an Armenian genocide - but get this, the same people who have successfully gotten authors arrested for denying the Jewish Holocaust are active in denying the Armenian Holocaust.

[SilviaMaria]

"But as the anti-Israel rhetoric intensified, Israel's Deputy Foreign Minister publicly warned Turkey that Tel Aviv might retaliate by acknowledging the Armenian Genocide."

"American-Jewish organizations, which had for years supported Turkey's denialist agenda on the Armenian Genocide in the U.S. Congress, were highly incensed by the Turkish condemnations of Israel."

Just one word: "HYPOCRITES"; they all should be ashamed of themselves.

And for the record, Israel also complained to the Primer Minister of my country, Spain, after some demonstrations in support of the Palestinian people in Madrid.

[mark67nyc]

What a perversion of justice that Turkey's miniscule lobbying efforts should be derailed by the behemoths of spin and lobbying. One tiny nation acts and rules like a superpower, all the while aided and abetted by our country.

I hope Obama adds some long-overdue balance to the global agenda. Yes he can!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Politicallyinterested]

Well the world can do without such biased funding.

[elavynnus]

I sympathize with the Jews living in Turkey as the actions of the Israeli government cannot be blamed on them. That being said, Turkey's stance as a "friend" of Israel cannot be used as a legitimate reason for silence. Having diplomatic relations with a country does not translate to turning a blind eye. If atrocities are being committed, it is Erdogan's right and responsibility to state his opinion.

[mikesw]

Let me get this straight.

This article is saying that American-Jewish organizations and Israelis might acknowledge another holocaust took place, not based on the evidence of it, BUT BECAUSE TURKISH LEADERS HAVE CRITICIZED ISRAEL????­??????????

This is not exactly what one would expect from those who regularly, and very correctly, express outrage over those who deny the holocaust perpetrated against the Jews.

[cathymcr]

Isreal was wrong when it commited war crimes against the people of Gaza and Turkey had a humanitarian right to condemn their actions. The demonstrations all over Europe protesting against Isreal's actions would suggest Isreal needs to take a hard look at themselves and how they treat their fellow human beings, whos land they continue to occupy. Governments need to pay attention to their populous and not always have a biased slant towards Isreal.
Fairness for all
Cathy

[thruthseeker]

It was wrong for ha mas to play with rockets..Y­ou get burned doing that.
Its time for ha mas and all palestinians to take a hard look at their charter and also try forgetting the idea of destroying Israel..
As Aristotle said LOng ago
" You may assume what you wish but you should avoid impossibilities "

[elavynnus]

Israel has to ease its economic stranglehold on Gaza. Though Hamas is not guilt-free, it is unreasonable to overlook Israel's previous actions toward Gaza.

[Politicallyinterested]

Do not bring a Greek philosopher into this. As a Greek who often reads Ancient Greek, I can tell you that our common sympathies now as well then are not with the J. wish people. The Greek language is older than H. brew as well as an older people who have written scientifically about the sociology, history and geography of areas further than mainland Greece for more than 2500 years. We also have recorded written records of goods and trading for at least 3500 years. We first translated the Old Testament. Greeks have been aware of J. wish policies for a long time and have mostly been displeased with them. Aristotle would most probably have been displeased with the sophistry, the lack of morality and the unscientific presentation of history used today by I. sraeli leaders and supporters.

[skialethia]

In a letter to F.W. De Klerk on 12 December 1989, entitled "'A Document To Create a Climate of Understanding" Nelson Mandela included a quote by Mr. Oliver Tambo. President of the ANC:

'The unfortunate thing is that people tend to be worried about the vi o lence that comes from the oppressed . . . Really, there would be no violence at all if we did not have the violence of the apartheid system.'

"From 1960 the ANC began a campaign of armed struggle of which there would later be a charge of 193 acts of te r ro rism from 1961-1963, mainly bo m bings and m u r ders of civilians.­" Similarly the KLA (Kosovo Liberation Army) started an armed resistance against the Serbs to free the Kosovars from Serb oppression.

There is no peace without justice. Oppression breeds vi o lence. Therefore the fault is with the oppressor.

Don't like the remedy? CURE THE FN DISEASE!