iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Howard Fineman

GET UPDATES FROM Howard Fineman
 

Mitt Romney Goes Viral: Countdown Day 48

Posted: 09/19/2012 5:21 pm

NEW YORK -- Mitt Romney has become the PSY of presidential politics. And that's bad news for the Republican candidate on the 48th day before Election Day.

PSY (Park Jae-sang) is, of course, the South Korean rapper whose "Gangnam Style" dance video has generated an astounding 220 million YouTube views and rocketed him to global popularity virtually overnight.

WMR (Willard Mitt Romney) is, of course, the star of a now-infamous 48-minute, surreptitiously recorded video in which he bares what appears to be the essence of what appears to be his supply-side, let-'em-eat-cake soul to like-minded rich people at a fundraiser. The only music is the "pop" generated by the uncorking of fine wine.

The video, from which The Huffington Post posted excerpts on Monday (and Mother Jones later posted in the complete, extended-play dance mix), jolted websites, Twitter feeds and cable TV -- and the Romney campaign.

Here at HuffPost, the story generated more than 150,000 reader comments, far and away a record even by the engaged standards of our very engaged readership. Tina Brown, editor of Newsweek/Daily Beast, told me last night that her site's traffic numbers spiked dramatically. They did elsewhere online and on cable, too.

Fox News was forced to interrupt its regular programming to deal with (that is, to promote) the video. The tone was interesting, which is to say, not kind to Mitt. They treated it as the car crash it was.

Looking and sounding like a skeptical detective at the scene of the accident, Fox's Neil Cavuto asked Romney if he hadn't just "kissed half the electorate goodbye" by claiming, on the video, that 47 percent of Americans are "moochers" who selfishly rely on the largesse of the federal government for food, shelter and health care even though they pay no federal income taxes.

By Wednesday, Fox was back to jamming the Democratic radar, touting a 14-year-old audio tape selectively edited to make President Barack Obama sound like a socialist believer in what Romney calls the "foreign" (but actually very American) idea of "redistributing" wealth.

The Mitt Vid story and its consequences say a lot about how campaigns are conducted in our digital day, and why all of Mitt's millions may not be enough to save him from his own aloof self.

In case you haven't noticed, we live in a place I'll call GTF America: Google, Twitter and Facebook. No amount of advertising, scripted campaign stops or TV interviews can counter the power of a single video the digital crowd suddenly demands to see. The power of word-of-mouth, amplified by those darned Internets, is almost beyond imagining, and way beyond any mere "broadcast."

Not coincidentally, the Mitt Vid was first obtained by websites.

Likewise, no amount of media "commentary" or "analysis" can match the power of voter/viewers looking at raw footage on their own, coming to their own conclusions about what they see, and then passing those conclusions (and the video link) on to others.

It's also worth noting that in these times, almost no event -- even with Secret Service in the vicinity, as was the case at that Florida fundraiser -- can be serenely and confidently viewed as off the record. Not when every phone is a video camera, and every camera is HD.

PSY's video became a sensation because it was a surprise, a startlingly catchy novelty.

WMR's video became a sensation because it was not a surprise: It confirmed every bad impression that voters have of him. The only surprise was that he actually said what people imagined he might say to people such as himself behind closed doors.

In the video, he undercuts whatever social legitimacy there was to supply-side economics, dismisses half the electorate as freeloaders and says that Middle East peace will never happen.

Romney's video proves to be a corollary to columnist Michael Kinsley's famous dictum that in politics, the biggest scandals arise when people say the most obviously true but usually unspoken things. Well, they also get in trouble when they say what they really think.

And truth is viral.

For Howard Fineman's full 2012 Countdown, click here.

 

Follow Howard Fineman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/howardfineman

FOLLOW POLITICS
NEW YORK -- Mitt Romney has become the PSY of presidential politics. And that's bad news for the Republican candidate on the 48th day before Election Day. PSY (Park Jae-sang) is, of course, the Sou...
NEW YORK -- Mitt Romney has become the PSY of presidential politics. And that's bad news for the Republican candidate on the 48th day before Election Day. PSY (Park Jae-sang) is, of course, the Sou...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,134
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (23 total)
02:55 AM on 09/23/2012
People need to know these things so here I am, here is one, Instead of taking over the student loan program the way Obama did, he should have looked into limiting the cost of tuition, the colleges are charging way too much, and the students should be doing much better academically for the big bucks, that they are paying, these highly paid professors and directors are not taking the responsibility for raising tuition cost, because the money is there, they will keep increasing the rates. There is increasing inflation when it comes to college, when demand is there, and the dollars come in, the cost will go higher. another mistake we all will pay for.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sf girl
I like my micro-bio empty.
02:24 AM on 10/12/2012
What? The president can't control tuition costs. Get a clue.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
n0n1m0us3
ellipsis
03:16 PM on 09/22/2012
No amount of spin matters. What I saw and heard on the video made me sick, Romney is a horrible person and he doesn't represent my views or attitudes at all. I don't want someone like him, who says out loud that almost half the country is "Not my problem" to represent me, because in his own words, he doesn't represent me. I don't want someone who doesn't want to work on MidEast peace and who has given up on the peace process, who thinks the Palestinians deserve the treatment they get, to represent me on the world stage.
02:34 AM on 09/23/2012
you missed his whole point, why do you think Obama is any better, he panders to you, they are only words without actions, as we have seen, I agree with Romney, its hard to change the minds of Obama the celebrity followers, so why try, changing your mind would take longer then he has, if he could at all, you cant appeal to a voter with a plan he can not identify with, I cant lower the taxes for people who don't have to pay any, so that is something that I can not offer them. that doesn't mean he don't care about you, you are just someone he can not win over for a vote for him. you people know that, but are so bias and unfair, green with envy, there are so many people who have did well in the past, after years of hard work, some with no pay for a while, and you would take it way from them, with none of your skin in the game. some only had a few hour sleep during the hard years, and were lucky they had a meal. where were people like you when the were building their wealth and struggling.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mestranger Toall
i wish i could be the person my beagle thinks i am
07:58 PM on 09/23/2012
A mans word is honorable if it is true regardless of who he affends its still the truth.What he said as we have known for a long time is exactly how it is his statement was true and you all typically blame others for what you lack. Strange idea here in america we all have the same opportunity to make something of ourselves if we work hard and push forward you cant punish someone for achieving the american dream. No one forced you to follow the path you are on thats your doing and your responsability and your alone. stop the wining get a job find you dreams or sit in a corner for a time out untill you stop your wimpering.responsability starts at home and should stop there as well ionly you are resonsable for your self if that mean you go with out so be it thats life i to have to live by those standards but heres the differance i struggle with pride cause at the end of a work day i come home and see i did it i take care of a happy family without any help just blood and sweat but i still did it get some pride of your own leach
05:33 AM on 09/22/2012
More proof that republicans hold nothing but contempt for their own constituents.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sonoflars
Growing old is mandatory, growing up is optional
07:46 AM on 09/21/2012
I understand why the very rich vote republican. I understand why the fanatic bible thumpers do. I understand racism is a factor for many. What I don't have a clue about is why a lot of senior citizens who are on Medicare or Medicaid and social security planto vote for Mitt. It's like pigs voting for Jimmy Dean.
cosmicdart
paragon of paradigms
09:26 AM on 09/21/2012
What would have happened to Social Security in 2008 if it had been privatized into the stock market the way the Republicans wanted it to be. Also without the Social Security fund to borrow from how would Republicans have paid for the last two trillion dollar wars?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
n0n1m0us3
ellipsis
03:18 PM on 09/22/2012
I think the racism factor has a LOT to do with why seniors who support him support him...they will NEVER vote for a black president...over their dead bodies eh.
photo
truthBtold99
Millions without jobs, still no economic agenda
06:37 PM on 09/20/2012
Most people who watch the video do so because they hear all the liberal babbel about the video and because they see the tag -must watch- and after they watch the video they think to themselves that they can't believe that they just wasted all that time, while some think : okay, what should I think about this? Oh I know the Dems will tell me what I'm supposed to think : Outrage.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chow Tai Tat
07:01 AM on 09/21/2012
????????????????????????????????????
cosmicdart
paragon of paradigms
08:54 AM on 09/21/2012
The babbel's in the video, and not about the video. Here the American people discover what he thunks about 'em.
05:28 AM on 09/22/2012
uh huh...and there's nothing like a republican's babble while attempting to accuse others of babbling....lol!
(please note the correct spelling - its a verb not a tower)
ael443
Fairness: treat capital gains like earned income
05:05 PM on 09/20/2012
"Brettford222
16 Fans
Become a fan
4 hours ago (12:40 PM)
Wait...what part of this video is controversial to you guys?

47% of people are going to vote for Obama no matter what. Same with Romney...probably 47% of people are going to vote for him no matter what.

There is one party that benefits from greater government dependency. They are called democrats."

Hogwash: the military are dependent on the government, as are well paid military contractors. Many of the 47% not paying Fed Income Tax ARE NOT dependent on government any more than Romney is for his low tax rate: they just make little enough money that the Earned Income Tax Credit or other deductions reduce their tax liability to zero. Republicans don't seem to mind when the wealthy or corporations end up paying no Federal income tax because of loopholes and deductions. It's only a problem when the little guy can manage it.
cosmicdart
paragon of paradigms
08:29 AM on 09/21/2012
And most of the time, any taxes that the wealthy pay are just added to the cost of doing business by increasing the cost of commodities and services to the Working Poor which in turn make the Working Poor poorer The Working Poor are the de facto tax payers for the Wealthy. We may as well have an across the board 10% Federal sales tax in exchange for the Federal Income Tax. Prices won't increase any more than they are doing now if this is done.
02:45 PM on 09/20/2012
I was traveling recently and the seat next to me was occupied by a DC staffer of a certain GOP congressman from my home state. We struck up a conversation about the list she was trying to memorize. It was from "my hero, Frank Luntz" and essentially provided "frames" for issues that put them in a "consumer-tested" context that either made the good look bad or the bad look good, depending on what the GOP was trying to accomplish. She confided that she had to insert these "magical phrases" in her boss' every speech. He kept, she said, a 3X5 card with "the message of the day." This event, where Rmoney said what he was thinking without those consumer tested buzz phrases and frameworks, reveal more than a thousand press conferences or speeches crafted by Herr Luntz.
02:27 PM on 09/20/2012
Simple choice................. for informed voters.

The Republican party is the party of ME.

The Democratic party is the party of WE.

Vote Obama / Biden

2012
02:25 PM on 09/20/2012
And what is wrong to say that roughly 47% of Americans 'mooch' off the government in some fashion, when the comments are true? Those 'moochers' are not going to vote for Romney anyway, because of their personal desire and greed to be partially supported by successful taxpayers. Why work hard in this country when we have so many 'moochers?' Gosh, why don't we all become 'moochers' and 'couch potatoes'? This liberal mentality may not be so bad after all!
03:11 PM on 09/20/2012
retired senior citizens, diabled veterans, the working poor... including republicans... are a big part of that 47% for which you have contempt.

the gop just filibustered the (paid-for) veteran's job act. shame on you.
06:37 PM on 09/20/2012
walkonby: Something in the vet. bill that republicans did not like. What was it? Start over and I bet something positive will happen. Republicans are very concerned about vet; this I know.
photo
TommoB
Restore sanity! Add Haldol to fracking fluid...
08:02 PM on 09/20/2012
Not to mention a fair few millionaires and Fortune 500 corporations.
03:53 PM on 09/20/2012
You must not be aware of what funds people receive from the govt and why. They are not "moochers." They are receiving pensions, Social Security, salaries, death benefits, disability payments, and others. And what makes Romney think that Obama's 47% consists of just those folks? I work in industry and make a salary and PAY TAXES and plan to vote for Obama. By the way, Romney is probably part of the 47% -- the fact that he won't release his taxes tells me that he didn't pay any. What a moocher.
05:33 PM on 09/20/2012
Thank you for your truth.
06:14 PM on 09/20/2012
ABron: An education is in order for you. To begin with, pensions & social security are investment citizens make expecting a return on their investments. They are not included in the 47%. I don't know where you come up with 'salaries?' Death benefits are the result of investments made during a person's life time. Disability payments are deserved income for some people, but the requirements have become very lax due to Obama's attempt to buy votes from disabled people. Food stamps is another 'moocher' program where some people deserve the benefit, but lax requirements has over blown this program. Again buying votes with taxpayer's money.
Why should Romney release more tax returns? You would not understand his returns anyway. He has professionals doing his taxes. He probably doesn't understand all the forms, either.
02:24 PM on 09/20/2012
The Republican party does not care about you. You are "THOSE PEOPE".

This is not your daddy's Republican party. They are too extreme.

They do not bother to even hide their agenda anymore.

It is time to vote all Republicans out of office.
11:13 PM on 09/20/2012
You bet! I've been saying this ever since the puppet Ronald Reagan entered high office. I vote 'Dem' party because it's the lesser of the two evils. Nevertheless, I give credit where it's due; and as far as I'm concerned Obama is the closest to being fair, personally approachable and smarter than any other president we've ever had.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MaineSenior
Not born in Maine, but I have a right to choose
04:13 PM on 09/22/2012
My father was a businessman in the 1950s, so was in a group where Ronald Reagan spoke as a representative of corporations. My memory is that it was in his 20-mule-team Borax days, but I think I'm wrong because they weren't big enough. Whoever sponsored Reagan, my father saw at the time that he was a twit. The thing that still puzzles me is that my father, nonetheless, voted for Reagan twice, plus for every other Republican during his lifetime. He would agree cordially with me that they were uninformed creeps and still vote for them. I've never understood it. I did ask him in 2004 not to cast a vote for President, as he couldn't vote for Kerry, but W wasn't worth his vote. He didn't respond, and I'll bet he voted R as always.
02:07 PM on 09/20/2012
I am richly enjoying the daily coverage of the spectacular flameout that has become the 2012 Romney/Ryan campaign. I have less than zero sympathy for Mitt Romney, Paul Ryan, and all the neocon GOP'ers who kautau to their ideological godmistress Ayn Rand. These are people who want to ruin the lives of tens of millions of their fellow Americans, so they can funnel billions of taxpayer dollars to fill their coffers. As one pundit observed, t is an obscene attempt to stage the largest "leveraged buy-out" of the world's most powerful government. Basically, Romney and Ryan want to do to America what Bain Capital did to one of the many prosperous companies it took over and then left bankrupt: load it up with debt, abscond with all the money, and leave the poor innocents broke, jobless, desperate and footing the bill.

I thank America's lucky stars that the Romney/Ryan ticket is being consigned to history's dustbin, along with dozens of other failed power grabs by corrupt extremists who were totally in it for themselves, and couldn't care less about their fellow man, unless they live in a mansion with a four-car garage and a heliopad. BUH-BYE, MITT 'N' PAUL.
01:59 PM on 09/20/2012
Oops. He accidentally let the truth slip out. I wonder what else he has said in private meetings with his cohorts. Romney is a truly phony man. Oh well, at least he can baptize the dead.
11:19 PM on 09/20/2012
He's not a true Mormon. The Mormon faith believes in being a contributor to humanity. I'm ecumenical in my beliefs, but I also honor non-christian beliefs. Mormons claim they are christian; they just don't slip into what other people think a christian should be. I don't abide by the Mormon faith, but I give it a good grade for being good Americans.
01:51 PM on 09/20/2012
This tape reveals mitt`s,as far as i`ve seen, only comfort zone......I guess he wants all of america to fit into a room full of emptiness and arrogance,that way we won`t apologize for spiting on the rest of humanity.....?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MaineSenior
Not born in Maine, but I have a right to choose
04:16 PM on 09/22/2012
Was that spiting or spitting? Either would work in the context...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
suddenfun
Subvert the dominant paradigm
01:34 PM on 09/20/2012
The top amassed great wealth through the laws, infrastructure, justice and education systems of this great country. They OWE some of that back to others struggling to climb out of difficult circumstances. Instead what they and the GOP have seen to provide is a means to stack the deck, oppress workers, rig the game and pull up the ladder behind them. THAT IS UNAMERICAN.
11:21 PM on 09/20/2012
Fight to make your education count.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:10 PM on 09/20/2012
Howard, your post is a nice splash of cold water on the fallacy of the -previously- omnipotent "negative tee vee spot", as we are now in an inter-tubes era.
Now we make up our own mind as watching tee vee continues its decline.

"And truth is viral." thank god -now maybe it won't be such a rarity.