So this Tuesday my husband and I will get up at 6:30 (early for us) and walk through the empty streets of downtown Jerusalem to a school that will be hosting the polls for national elections. This is our way of avoiding the lines that are certain to coagulate the hallways just an hour later; we have the advantage of living close by. I will choose a piece of paper representing the political party I am voting for, place it in a sealed envelope, and then stick that in a cardboard box with a slit at the top, feeling as if I am voting for school president and not for Prime Minister of a country.
We will then wander home and I will try to ignore the profound feeling of defeat that for weeks now has been growing as I have contemplated whom to vote for.
In America, I never felt as if my vote really mattered one way or another. I lived in a Blue State, so that was that; the outcome of the elections a mere formality.
Here in Israel, my vote counts for much more. This is especially true since the entire population of the country is about the same as (or less than) New York City alone.
It counts, but it also doesn't. Come Election Day, we the voters here in Israel will have the power to vote, but we will not have the power to effect a meaningful change to the state of our country. What Americans were empowered to do on November 4th of this year is an opportunity that still eludes us.
I'll explain. First of all, it seems that a lot of people think that Israelis are voting for Prime Minister on Tuesday, with a choice between Ehud Barak, Binyamin Netanyahu and Tzipi Livni. This is not true. We are voting for political parties. The greater the number of votes a political party receives, the more seats (if any) it has in the Knesset. The winning candidate for Prime Minister will be the one who can successfully form a government, leaving the rest of the Knesset members to form the opposition.
So an Israeli voter faces the task of deciding whether to vote for one of the big three parties, each led by the candidates for Prime Minister, or to "throw away the vote" on a smaller party.
One of these three parties will end up running things from now on--and who are they? Well, let's run down the list. Ehud Barak was a disaster as Prime Minister a decade ago; appointing him Defense Minister was already a joke in the first place. Where he gets off running for Prime Minister again is a mystery to me. But I don't really have to worry about him, because it is highly unlikely that he can win.
Then there's Tzipi Livni of the current ruling party, Kadima. Bizarrely, her campaign theme is "change" even though she represents the incumbent party. If she's so bent on change, what's been stopping her? And what exactly is Kadima's platform, anyway?
The party was formed specifically in order to push forward the disengagement from Gaza ("Kadima" means "onward" in Hebrew). Well, that was 2005. And the disengagement itself was carried out with all of the finesse of a World War II-era tank, creating consequences that burden the country irrevocably to this day.
As for Livni's much-vaunted promise of "change"... Where was all this "change" as Hamas was amassing its supply of rockets? Where was this "change" as Israel's education system crumbled and its environmental policies stagnated? True, most of the blame for the current mess belongs with the corrupt former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, but it was Kadima's mess.
Then there's Netanyahu, another failed Prime Minister. So many people I know hate him. Left-wingers hate him because he is right-wing. Right-wingers hate him because he made unilateral concessions as Prime Minister. Yet the object of all this hatred is currently leading in the polls, and I don't hate him, to tell the truth. I don't really see why I should. I just don't see the point of him--he represents business as usual in Israeli politics, as much as Livni or Barak would.
All three of Israel's candidates for Prime Minister belong to an era that should be receding behind us, not popping up in our ballot boxes again and again. Israel needs true and lasting change: We need a government which will create a plan for a two-state solution that is realistic, has goals that can be measured, and that does not move forward until the set goals are achieved.
But with the old guard at the helm, we will not have peace. Without creativity and flexible thinking, there is no chance that this country will survive another 60 years.
Security is also a way for people to avoid the other very serious issues that are plaguing this country. The world's financial crisis is our problem, too. The worst water crisis in the country's history, air pollution, a deteriorating school system, thousands of people living in abject poverty, and immigrant populations who need all the help we can give them are just some of the challenges that a new Israeli government should be addressing.
If I believed that any of the three big parties had the capacity to bring peace, I would vote for one of them. Since I am deeply pessimistic that peace can ever be achieved with the government we get, I'm voting based on who will be best for social issues. For that reason, I will probably vote for the Green Movement-Meimad, a party whose security platform I do not really agree with, but whose leaders already have an outstanding record on Israel's social problems--more than anyone else in the Knesset. One of their top members, Alon Tal, is one of Israel's most prominent environmental activists.
I still don't feel excited about my vote. Sometimes I wonder if I'm making the wrong decision, since Meimad is a small party that is unlikely to wield much influence. But what I'm sure of is that what Israel really needs is not going to be achieved in the Knesset anytime soon, regardless of who wins.
|
Israel Bans Arab Parties From Coming Election
JERUSALEM — Israel on Monday banned Arab political parties from running in next month's parliamentary elections, drawing accusations of racism by an Arab lawmaker who...
|
|
Israeli Election: Netanyahu Says Iran Nukes Trumps Global Economy
DAVOS, Switzerland — Israeli election front-runner Benjamin Netanyahu told a session of the World Economic Forum on Thursday that preventing Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons...
|
|
Israel Rules Out Hamas Contacts, Threatens Force
HERZLIYA, Israel — Israel's foreign minister threatened Monday to keep hitting Hamas as long as it attacks Israel, ruling out negotiations with the Islamic rulers...
|
|
Avigdor Lieberman, Hard Man Of The Right, Is Israel's Kingmaker In Waiting
Avigdor Lieberman, the far-right politician campaigning on a platform that Israeli Arabs should pledge loyalty to the state or lose their right to vote, has...
|
|
Israel's Election: HuffPost Contributors Have Their Say
Israelis head to the polls tomorrow, February 10, to vote in a new government. Huffington Post contributors from Israel to Ramallah to DC have shared...
|
|
Life of an Israeli Government: Nasty, Brutish and Short
Israel's inability to stay out of the news for long is due not merely to hawkish administrations or a near-impossible region. The lack of strategic leadership is also the product of a broken political system.
|
|
Israel Election: What Does It Mean to You?
Israelis head to the polls on February 10th to vote in a new government. As the crisis in Gaza demonstrates, Israeli politics affect the world....
|
|
Israeli Elections: Do They Really Matter?
In the end, regardless of who wins, Obama's domestic priorities, bad peace process options, and Israel's inherent caution are unlikely to generate any wild surprises.
|
|
Give Us Netanyahu. Please.
Give us Netanyahu. Please. His re-ascension will help Americans realize that the false choice approach the Bush administration had been taking in Israel-Palestine affairs was flawed.
|
|
Israel Is About to Make a Misjudgement as Disastrous as Gaza
In a few days, it looks likely to re-elect Benjamin Netanyahu as Prime Minister once again. This is a man calling for the violent re-occupation of Gaza to "liquidate" its elected government.
|
|
Israel's Election: Not Our Problem
Dovish types prepared to go into mourning over the coming right-wing victory should bear history in mind when the election results come in next week. Things aren't always what they seem.
|
|
|
It's Prime Minister Netanyahu
Tuesday, the right wing coalition won a clear majority. It is, I believe, inevitable that President Peres will give Netanyahu the first shot at forming a government and that Bibi will succeed.
|
|
Israeli Elections: Terror as Top Concern
With less than a week to go before elections in Israel, the three main rivals are locked in fierce debate not about whether the devastating war in Gaza went too far, but whether it went far enough.
|
|
Hopeful, But Not Optimistic
It is difficult to be optimistic. But I can be hopeful that, with the appointment of George Mitchell, the region is getting what may very well be its last best chance at securing peace.
|
|
|
Netanyahu: Better for America, Better For Israel
It will be easier for President Obama to deal with Netanyahu than with the almost equally hawkish Tzipi Livni because Livni seems dedicated to ending the conflict.
|
|
More Miracles in Store on Israel's Election Day?
Unlike America's Obama, Israel has no great political "hero" lined up at the ballot box to save us from a nuclear Iran, Hamas terrorists in Gaza, mounting threats from the Syrians, and Hezbollah in Lebanon.
|
|
What Hamas Has Wrought
The crucial point about Hamas that is always overlooked is that at every point in their interaction with Israel and peace-seeking Palestinians, they have chosen the path of armed aggression.
|
|
Elect Livni, Not Netanyahu, to Keep Peace in Reach for Israel
Positioned to win his old job back, Netanyahu's appointment as prime minister is a likely disaster for an already elusive peace process.
|
|
Palestinians Unsure Which Israeli Leader Will Keep Gaza and the West Bank United
While the results of the coming Israeli elections are important, the most important new element in the formula is the new administration in Washington.
|
My mother was born in Jerusalem when it was Palestine. She and her family left to avoid what is euphemistically called the troubles of 1948. Like many Palestinians they would have liked to have had a vote on their fate and the fate of the land in which they were born. Instead the United Nations voted on their behalf. Now you have the right as an American Jew to move to and reside in the land in which my mother was born. She does not have the right to return to that land.
Vote wisely.
-Ilana
“A land without a people for a people without a land”
"There is no such thing as a Palestinian people... It is not as if we came and threw them out and took their country. They didn't exist."
n Golda Meir, statement to The Sunday Times, 15 June, 1969.
It is very hard to peacefully coexist with a people that you do not believe are really there. At least David Ben-Gurion was more honest about it.
“If I were an Arab leader, I would never sign an agreement with Israel. It is normal; we have taken their country. It is true God promised it to us, but how could that interest them? Our God is not theirs. There has been Anti-Semitism, the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was that their fault? They see but one thing: we have come and we have stolen their country. Why would they accept that?”
David Ben-Gurion: Quoted by Nahum Goldmann in Le Paraddoxe Juif (The Jewish Paradox),pp121
You remind me of the Jewish kids that worked with all of us during the civil rights and anti-war struggles here. Humanists. I agree with you the the state of Israel will probably not survive. Unless some Mandela come along an pulls off a reconciliation miracle.
Come here, to the US.
Frankly, I don't think honorable people can live in a state like Israel.
Maybe you want to stay to fight against he crazies. That's your choice.
But if you ever want to go, you're always welcome here.
I really appreciate the sentiment. I'd like you to know, though, that I'm not special. I have lived in New York (and miss it) but some of the most inspiring people I have met are here in Israel. People who without any doubt would have passionately supported the U.S. civil rights movement.
Israel looks different from within than it does in media depictions. Come visit.
-Ilana
You are losing support from normal citizens of the world.
War, as a political tool, is no longer an option in the 21st Century.
Zionists will be the downfall of your state.
Either way it was Israel that fired the first shot. The best defense after all is a smashing offense.
of pain to a stop immediately. Example : Uri Avnery, Israel needs a candidate for Hope.
Until there is a Palestinian state for Palestinian people there will be no peace in that part of the world.
"Amnesty accuses Hamas of eliminating opponents"
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3669623,00.html
Did the deaths of 1000+ Palestinians plus 20,000 injured solve anything? Or does Israel and its US political patrons on Capitol Hill don't care for the lives of Muslims is sub-human? If so, then don't be surprised to learn no amount of diplomacy will mitigate the question: Why do they still hate us?
How can the people who've been living there for the past several thousand years be in illegal occupation of land that Israel only recently acquired? Have you heard of time's arrow?