More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jackie K. Cooper

GET UPDATES FROM Jackie K. Cooper
 

Breaking Dawn, Part 1: Saving the Best For Last

Posted: 11/22/11 05:26 PM ET

It seems they are saving the best for last in the Twilight series. Breaking Dawn, Part 1 is the film version of the first half of the last book. The other half will appear on screens in November 2012. This first half is what Twilight fans have long been anticipating as it is the most romantic and engrossing of all the movies to date, and is sure to be a huge box office success.

This movie concerns the marriage of Edward and Bella. Yes, the vampire and the human are finally getting hitched and it is all presented just as grand and gloriously as you could want. Bella (Kristen Stewart) has never been so beautiful and Edward (Robert Pattinson) has never been as handsome. The only flaw is that she is not marrying both Edward and Jacob (Taylor Lautner). That is the only way everyone could have been satisfied.

But Jacob fans can rejoice. He is a major part of the storyline and Lautner has never been this emotionally involved with his role. He completely forces his other movie this year, Abduction, out of our minds and reinforces the belief that he does indeed have a chance at a career after Twilight is over.

Even though this movie only tells half the story of the last book, it seems complete. You are not left at the end feeling as if you have been clumsily set up for what comes later and with nothing resolved. This is as good an ending as could possibly have been had for this chapter in the lives of Bella, Edward and Jacob.

The movie is rated PG-13 due to sexual situations and a gruesome birth scene. This film is definitely not for the younger kids as it will give rise to questions about sex and childbirth. Still each sequence is handled in good taste.

The movie is beautifully photographed with lush settings taking over for the rain soaked greenery of Washington state. Director Bill Condon is focused on the romantic elements of Melissa Rosenberg's screenplay while still staying true to all of the basic plotlines developed by novelist Stephanie Meyer.

Some will dismiss this movie out of hand as being one of "those" movies that is not worth watching. They will be wrong. This film provides a compelling story, supported by strong acting. Stewart, Pattinson and Lautner are completely absorbed by their roles and are at ease in the relationships they have to enact. They have a history together now and it pays off. There is also a strong supporting cast who are totally familiar to the audience by now and who slide comfortably back into the skin of the characters they portray.

If you have never seen a Twilight film then this is a good one with which to start. If you are already a fan of the series, this is the best movie adaptation yet. It totally entertains while it is setting up the story for the final chapter. It will be a long time to wait for the conclusion but this film will be worth watching over and over in the interim.

I scored Breaking Dawn, Part 1 a rising 7 out of 10.

 
 
 
It seems they are saving the best for last in the Twilight series. Breaking Dawn, Part 1 is the film version of the first half of the last book. The other half will appear on screens in November 2012.
It seems they are saving the best for last in the Twilight series. Breaking Dawn, Part 1 is the film version of the first half of the last book. The other half will appear on screens in November 2012.
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:11 PM on 11/23/2011
I haven't seen any of the films so I am not in a position to agree or disagree with your review. I have however read the books and IMHO the last book was the only one worth reading so you're probably correct (even though I can't get past the wooden acting I see in the trailers enough to go see the films). However, I can't help but react when you write, "This film is definitely not for the younger kids as it will give rise to questions about sex and childbirth."

I know this one sentence does not a thesis make, but it exemplifies many of the problems we have as a society in the US regarding sex, sex ed and all of the ramifications thereof. What the heck would be so bad about answering questions about sex and childbirth? Perhaps if we weren't so darned repressed about sex, we wouldn't have so many unplanned teenage pregnancies, STDs, sexual assaults, abortions and child sexual abuse (to name but a few). Ignorance is NOT bliss when it comes to sex ed and abstinence-only does NOT work. The earlier we start conversations (or even just the willingness to have conversations), the better off we'll be. So avoid your child's exposure to the film because it's gruesome, fine. But don't avoid the sexual element because you don't want to answer questions; your child will be better off after your conversation.
11:12 AM on 11/23/2011
You seem to be in disagreement with pretty much every other critic in the country.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jackie K. Cooper
author, entertainment critic, southerner
03:22 PM on 11/23/2011
And your point is..........
08:45 PM on 11/23/2011
I've made my point several times, but you've screen out every comment that specifically disagrees with you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Film Shark
I love cinema.
09:48 AM on 11/23/2011
I'm not a 'Twilight' fan. This was my first 'Twilight' movie. I found it quite entertaining. You can jump right into 'Breaking Dawn' and not miss a beat of the entire story.

Kristen Stewart is a talented actress. If you're not convinced, rent 'Adventureland' (she works at an amusement set in the 1980s) or 'The Runaways' (she plays rock musician, Joan Jett). She brings a moody quality to her performance which I find refreshing from actresses that act too hyper.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HermaO
Conservatism is intellectual laziness.
07:57 AM on 11/23/2011
We clearly haven't seen the same movie.
The actors all looked detached if not completely constipated, the wolf history was handled very poorly, with the most ridiculous scene of the movie being their mind-conference on the beach, and the rest was just plain boring.
The worst part of all was I think the music: loud, whiny, and not subtle at all.
11:12 AM on 11/23/2011
If you post anything that mentions how the other critics all hated it etc... they screen out your comment. I'm surprised yours got through.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:40 AM on 11/23/2011
I totally agree. I found it a vast improvement in every respect from the other three, it was even beautiful, and all flaws can be blamed on a wacky 4th source novel, not the cast or director. Thanks for the fairness!
11:21 PM on 11/22/2011
Wow, a great review that I totally agree with. Thanks for not over thinking the whole thing either way. It's a very faithful adaptation of a novel, the actors were great and as a Twilight fan I walked away happy and satisfied. Can't ask for more than that.