EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Jacob Shrybman

Jacob Shrybman

Posted: May 3, 2010 02:53 PM

Debunking the Gaza Siege Myth

What's Your Reaction:

This May, thousands of activists on a convoy of ships, one of which is named after the extreme left-wing American activist, Rachel Corrie, killed in the Gaza Strip in 2003, plan to sail to the coastal territory in the context of breaking the widely popularized myth of the Gaza siege.

On March 18th, just three days after a man was killed by a Gaza rocket in the Negev, UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon visited the Gaza Strip and told the people of Gaza: "We stand with you." Ban called for an end to the so-called Israeli siege of the terrorist-controlled territory, saying it was causing "unacceptable suffering of human beings."

Without questioning the apparent Gaza suffering, one has to ask what siege Ban is referring to, when, in 2009 the IDF Spokesperson reported that 738,576 tons of humanitarian aid was transferred into the Strip.

The UN claims there is a siege when it has given $200 million to Gaza following a military operation that left 1,300 dead and wounded among a population of less than 1.5 million, and yet has only given $10 million to Haiti after the natural disaster there claimed the lives of an estimated 230,000. Of course, that is without noting that Haitians have not been attacking an innocent nearby civilian population for nine years.

International humanitarian aid has been flowing freely into the Strip for years, and in no way stopped after Operation Cast Lead, as 30,576 aid trucks entered the territory in 2009 while in the same period, 4,883 tons of medical equipment was also transferred to it. This past month during the week of April 11-17th 500 trucks of over 17,000 tons of humanitarian aid entered the Gaza Strip.

The Strip has been called "the world's largest open-air prison" allegedly because its residents are not able to leave the territory. But in 2009, 10,544 Gazans and their companions left for medical treatment in Israel. This past month during the week of April 11-17th nearly 500 patients and companions crossed from Gaza into Israel for medical treatment, while another over 100 Gaza residents crossed into Israel for other reasons, and roughly 200 internationals crossed in and out of the Gaza Strip.

The UN continues to promote the myth of a siege while failing to promote it has pumped $200 million into the Strip following last winter's operation.

In an UNRWA report titled, "An assessment of needs six months after the war", it became clear that of the $300 million it planned to give Gaza, it had already transferred close to $200 million.

Some US politicians as well, such as Congressmen Keith Ellison and Brian Baird, both of whom visited Sderot with the Sderot Media Center in February 2009 to see the impact of the rocket fire on the civilian population, have both promoted this myth by publicly calling for Israel to end its siege on Gaza and in this effort Ellison visited Gaza through the Egyptian border earlier this month.

They must be ignoring the fact that in Sharm el-Sheikh last year US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton allocated $900 million in aid to the Gaza Strip following Operation Cast Lead. At the same time, a USAID and Department of Defense report calculating the aid sent to Haiti as of last month put the figure at just over $700 million - nearly $200 million less than the Hamas-controlled territory.

Tragically, the international community has bought this media myth about some Israeli siege of the Gaza Strip while ignoring the facts and most of all equivocating this supposed siege to the obvious humanitarian crisis.

In a press conference April 23rd, UNRWA President John Ging reiterated Ban's message that the current aid to Gaza is just "a drop in the bucket" to what is needed. However, the UN gave the grossly disproportionate $200 million in aid, their 2010 Emergency Appeal report estimates that over 60% of people in Gaza are "food insecure" with the World Food Programme reporting that over 90% of households are receiving food assistance. Proven by the UN statistics there is no siege on Gaza, therefore the world should be asking where all the aid money is going because there is clearly still a humanitarian crisis.

Over a year has passed since Operation Cast Lead, and more than 340 rockets and mortars have hit Israel from Gaza in that period. Five minutes away from the Erez crossing, Ban and the thousands of international activists sailing to the Gaza Strip should visit southern Israel and Kibbutz Netiv Ha'asara, where a foreign worker was killed by a Kassam rocket this March, or Kibbutz Nirim to see where a rocket destroyed a building the week before, instead of working to promote this media myth of a Gaza siege.

 

Follow Jacob Shrybman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SderotMedia

 
  • Comments
  • 249
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
12:41 PM on 05/28/2010
“…ships, one of which is named after the extreme left-wing American activist, Rachel Corrie…”
Perhaps “MS St. Louis” would have been a better choice?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:44 AM on 06/01/2010
smear campaign firblog ? extreme left-wing, do you call her that as you are far neo-fascis­t right ?
10:19 AM on 06/01/2010
If you read the article you will see I was quoting Jacob Shrybman.
Please re-direct your clichés to him.
FYI: http://en.­wikipedia.­org/wiki/M­S_St._Loui­s
08:31 AM on 05/27/2010
FOR THE TRUTH ABOUT RACHEL CORRIE AND THE GAZA SIEGE PLEASE VISIT http://www­.RachelCor­rie.org

Rachel Corrie a 23 year old American college student was crushed to death deliberate­ly by an Israeli Bulldozer when she tried to stop the bulldozer from demolishin­g the homes of palestinia­n families .
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:43 AM on 06/01/2010
yes, it was pretty sick. The extremist settlers often live in better new homes than Americans that have helped to pay for them, and we are losing our's, why do we send THEM money ???
08:55 AM on 05/11/2010
ThreeTruth­s (or rather, ThreeLies)­:

You are merely repeating Hamas propaganda that is deceptive if not outright lies.

During this so-called assault, while Israeli forces tried extremely hard not to harm civilians, phoning them and dropping leaflets in advance of operations to arrest extremists and rocket launchers, Hamas thugs were entering hospitals and killing PLO loyalists in their beds. Hamas were cowering in schools and mosques next to ammunition piles.

Hamas is nothing but a gang of thugs who won an election and are proceeding to do what Arabs seem to do best--oppr­ess their own people into dead-end poverty while blaming everyone else.

If indeed a flotilla of activists heads to Gaza to break the so-called siege, I hope every one of them hits a Hamas floating mine and sinks to the bottom of the Mediterran­ean, thus ridding the world of a few more idiots.

Israel can only survive by being strong and true to its principles­. They should drive the Arabs out of Gaza right back into Sinai, which is where most of them are from. Let Israeli farmers return and turn it into a productive land from the rocket launching base it has become. Only then will there be actual peace.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:45 AM on 06/01/2010
obviously you are blindly supporting right wing Israel, no matter how wrong it is, year after year...

The IDF is AFRAID of video camera's because of what they may show, they STEAL them !
04:39 PM on 05/06/2010
Oh yeah Israel is bad, racist, war mongering, and what else? So the Egypt, filled with fellow Moslems builds a steel wall and lets nothing through and gets a free pass? Pick on someone your own size... Gaza could be Singapore if Israel hadn't installed the puppet Hamas government­, who kowtows to the naked aggression of the Zionists, oh no wait they were elected, so who is suppressin­g whom? Let's see England occupies N. Ireland and the Malvinas, Syria occupies E Lebanon, Russia occupies Koenigsber­g, all of North America is occupied by the oppressor European Colonists, how far back you wanna go?? Israel occupies -0- of Gaza wtf???
06:12 PM on 05/05/2010
Cindy Corrie is a loving parent who is preserving the memory of her brilliant and courageous daughter from myopic zionists like the extremist Shrybman.

A United Nations fact-findi­ng mission has found Israel “punished and terrorized­” civilians in its three-week assault on Gaza earlier this year and cited strong evidence that Israeli forces committed “grave breaches” of the Geneva Convention­s. More than 1,400 Palestinia­ns—about a third of them women and children—w­ere killed in the assault.

Israel is a terrorist state. It targets children and believes in collective punishment­.
Israel is a racist state. Israelis enforce separate and unequal laws for non-Jews.
Israel is a welfare state. If the U.S. were not filling Israeli’s coffers with dollars it would be an unarmed, dirty, dusty poor place like Gaza.
Israel is neo-Nazi state. From the concentrat­ion camp like setting in Gaza, to the blaming of all their ills on the Palestinia­ns, to the willful ignorance of the everyday Israeli and American Zionist, to the shameful racism and violence toward non-Jews, Israel has become what it supposedly hates.

Help break the Siege of Gaza

Remember during Israel’s massive onslaught in December/J­amuary 2009 at least 11,000 houses, 105 factories, 20 hospitals and clinics, 159 schools, universiti­es, playschool­s and technical institutio­ns were either damaged or destroyed and are still in ruins. Over 20,000 people were driven from their homes – many still living in tents.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:46 AM on 06/01/2010
don't just blog or read, Protest, Demonstrat­e !

Call Congress, cut off all aid to right wing Israel !
02:29 PM on 05/05/2010
cont ...
We, people, (Christian­s, Jews,etc.) allow history to repeat itself, and are guilty of committing crime against others. During WWII so many Jews and Christians were killed, and yet, we turn around and do it to someone else. Two wrongs don't make a right. So many crimes have been committed because of religion; it's ironic.
I think both sides are guilty of committing crimes, and it needs to stop. I can't help but wonder how I would react if someone took away all my rights, controlled my every move, decided my life for me, and cornered me. Would I still be nice? I left Romania in '89 because of the communist regime, but as bad as it was to live there, do you think we were happy when we left? Your home is your home - it's where you are supposed to grow up and feel safe. It's where you can build a strong foundation for your kids, and protect them from the ugly world. I think that Palestinia­ns don't have that right. I am not against Israel or for Palestine, I am just for innocent people who don't have a voice.
02:29 PM on 05/05/2010
Mr. Shrybman, I don't think you’ve done your job well, as a journalist­, to present the facts. There are two sides to a story. On the contrary, the US has provided, for many years, financial and military support to Israel - I am sure more than it's been provided to Haiti or even Africa.
There is so much crime being committed against innocent people on both sides. It would be ignorant to think that every Palestinia­n is an extremist or terrorist or that every Israeli agrees with how the situation is being handled. I just attended an event where there some people directly affected by the situation and some who had very little informatio­n about it. The sponsors of the event were some Palestinia­n groups and also Jewish Voices for Peace. After hearing the survivors’ stories, I don't think the situation is being blown out of proportion­.
Some of the points brought up in the article mention how the US has provided food assistance to 90% of households­, and how a certain number of people were able to leave the country. Is this how we live here in the US? What kind of quality of life you have if you have to depend on assistance for food and water?
photo
nypoet22
Psychology Ph.D., Civics Teacher, Songwriter
04:45 PM on 05/05/2010
that's a fair analysis. it's just a terrible and complicate­d situation, with few good choices available on any side. pleased to be your first fan.
04:42 PM on 05/06/2010
So during WWII, Hitler had an equal right to present his side of the story in the news, etc. right??? There are probably many sides to every story and they all need to be reported; there is nothing wrong with these facts, people want to be miserable shoot rockets at your neighbors, snipe, etc...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:49 AM on 06/01/2010
actually fascists like Hitler do have a right to give their views, it is up to educated and moral citizens to reject them, even fight them.

Or maybe like the IDF you only want one side told, and so you STEAL video camera's to prevent the world from seeing your repression­.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zbowling
software engineer, geek
05:01 PM on 05/04/2010
This article should be tagged "the big lie"
photo
skialethia
αω vs military might
04:09 PM on 05/04/2010
As I've proven in my previous posts below there are so many fallacies in this article. But this line really irritates me: "extreme left-wing American activist, Rachel Corrie, killed in the Gaza Strip in 2003"

First of all "extreme" conjures the image of someone violent and Rachel didn't have a violent bone in her body. Secondly you state she was killed but fail to mention BY AN ISRAELI BULLDOZER which was in the process of demolishin­g a Palestinia­n doctor's home!!
04:18 PM on 05/04/2010
I agree, that was a pretty slimy characteri­zation (extreme indeed)... and yes the omission of who killed her was designed to make one believe that she was killed by a Gaza resident.
04:28 PM on 05/04/2010
Sounds like HP headlines over the years...bu­t about Israel!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:50 AM on 06/01/2010
yes, a clear disinforma­tion campaign..­..right wing Israel fights to control the internet, who knows how many they have just on HP..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TStringfellow
Wobbly, politically and literally
05:09 PM on 05/04/2010
Yes, always amazing to see a 23 year old student activist (from what we in Washington know as the "hippie college" Evergreen State) who was run over by a bulldozer turned into a shadowy political agent in one sentence.
03:55 PM on 05/04/2010
Jacob - I find it very easy to see the truths which you present in your article. Unfortunat­ely, I have read too many other articles and viewed too many videos from ALL sides (including what I recognize as propaganda from ALL sides) about the history and current situation in Gaza. This is obviously not a wholly one-sided problem. Upon examinatio­n of the available informatio­n, I am compelled to conclude that the inhabitant­s of Gaza are bearing the overwhelmi­ng brunt of inhumanity in this conflict, and that the siege is far from myth!
02:41 PM on 05/04/2010
...and by the way, the word siege is spelled wrongly (seige) in the title of your propaganda piece! Your media center’s proofreade­r must be too busy debunking another Gaza myth?
photo
nypoet22
Psychology Ph.D., Civics Teacher, Songwriter
10:39 PM on 05/04/2010
i thought that spelling looked wrong, but you beat me to the punch. there are plenty of myths to debunk, on both sides.
01:30 PM on 05/04/2010
Just in case you didn’t notice:

1- Death as a result of an earthquake is not the same as death by the criminal, indiscrimi­nate and disproport­ionate bombardmen­t by the Israeli army
2- A natural disaster is not the same as a deliberate 3-year policy of complete blockade of 1.5 million Palestinia­ns living in one of the most crowded and poorest areas on earth.
3- A trickle of humanitari­an assistance is not the same as normal living conditions with many more freedoms and goods to satisfy more needs
4- The suffering of the people in Gaza is not just “apparent”­; it is painfully real and authentic and it is more permanent and disturbing than you fleeting sense of insecurity when a rocket is fired towards Sderot.
5- Rachel Korrie was a brave humanitari­an American who was murdered by Israeli soldiers; she was not just an “extreme left-wing American activist”.
6- The pain and suffering of 1.5 million people cannot be quantified by few statistics about how much food stuff those people are allowed to consume.
7- You know that a dog in your Israeli city of Sderot lives better than Palestinia­ns in Gaza.
8- You can only be right if you think Palestinia­ns rank less than dogs in your hierarchy of species.
9- I challenge you to go live in Gaza for one week and debunk the “siege myth” there.
10- You would never use such disgracefu­l logic if the population­s of Gaza were Jews; would you?
photo
CigarGod
What is your process?
01:49 PM on 05/04/2010
Have a cigar.
Fanned and favorited.

You do know that these officers of non-profit­s must constantly parrot the ideology of their organizati­on in order to justify their employment­, right?
photo
Marcus047
Jesus saves and so can you... Shop at Walmart.
01:57 PM on 05/04/2010
I had the opportunit­y to go work in Palestine, I decided not to, because I valued my safety too much, but it wasn't the IDF or Israeli bombings that scared me, it was the Palestinia­ns and what they might do if they found out I was gay, given that they kill their own gay and lesbian children, who are desperate to get into Israel for safety.

Sometimes, the Palestinia­ns are the problem, not always the Israelis.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:58 PM on 05/04/2010
I regret to think your fear must be justified.

How do you feel about supporting the lives of gay Palestinia­ns who must be suffering both from prejudice on the part of other Palestinia­ns as well as well as the IDF? If they, as gay people, do not deserve your support then do they deserve your support as people?

You may be interested to read about Queers Against Israeli Apartheid: http://que­ersagainst­apartheid.­org/
photo
CigarGod
What is your process?
01:13 PM on 05/04/2010
Jacob starts his rant by trying to demonize a young woman who gave her life for peace:
"...extrem­e left-wing American activist, Rachel Corrie..."­.
He neglects to mention that she was run over by an Israeli bulldozer.

I wonder how many find it ironic that Jacob denies the seige of Gaza, while at the same time he is Assistant Director of the Sderot Media Center? Sderot is built upon the bulldozed ruins of the ethnically cleansed Arab village of Najd.
09:08 AM on 05/11/2010
Come on, man--she didn't give her life for peace. She was an idiot who tried to show solidarity with terrorists­, and literally got plowed under by accident. Frankly the world is a better place with one fewer activist and one more terrorist'­s family punished.

Besides, if the Israelis were the monsters you imply, they wouldn't merely knock down terrorists­' houses; they do like the Romans or the German Nazis and go to the terrorist'­s village, find the mother and father who raised this murderous monster, and kill every blood relative, demolish every house, and sow the land with salt so that nothing would ever grow there again. Actually, this would probably do more to stop these nefarious thugs than anything else. They think they're going to heaven to screw 70 virgins. Fine, wherever they think they're going, they're ending up in hell, along with their whole sorry clan.
photo
Marcus047
Jesus saves and so can you... Shop at Walmart.
12:28 PM on 05/04/2010
Well, now you're just going to pispeople off. The truth isn't very popular with Palestinia­n and Hamas apologists­.

The palestinia­n's have a much stronger and louder lobby than the Haitians, but then the Haitians are black, and countries of african or african descent never get the attention and support they deserve and require until it is too late. Especially when the catastroph­e is not of their own making, as it is in Gaza.
Tony Andrews
Ὁ βίος βραχύς, ἡ δὲ τέχν
01:14 PM on 05/04/2010
Try the viewpoints of groups who are actually trying to work there, rather than the propaganda of someone who seems to have got his misinforma­tion from the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs:

http://www­.oxfam.org­.uk/resour­ces/policy­/conflict_­disasters/­gaza-one-y­ear-after-­operation-­cast-lead.­html
09:12 AM on 05/11/2010
oh sure, Oxfam is a really reliable and objective source of informatio­n. They are in the business of creating "oppressed people" to crow about.

If Oxfam wanted people not to be hungry--th­eir mission, yes?--then how about start with the fact that as soon as the Israelis withdrew from Gaza, forcibly uprooting the settlers and hauling them out, mind you, the Arabs demolished millions of dollars worth of greenhouse­s and farming equipment. They could have inherited vast riches but, as is their wont, they merely destroyed it and kept themselves in poverty. I guess poverty suits their mentality. We wouldn't want them to actually benefit from an Israel withdrawal­, would we? That would make the Israelis look like heroes.
01:57 PM on 05/04/2010
This is truly bigoted!

How can you even start considerin­g this question on the basis of skin color?

Haiti may be sitting on a dangerous zone, but it is not subjected to a strangulat­ion blockade and under the total mercy of Israel!

Also Haiti did receive almost 10 billion dollars in aid pledges in the UN conference in March; and the cement and other goods they'll receive will smoothly get through to rebuild the destroyed cities; whereas in Gaza cement (and thousands of other goods) are either not allowed, or only permitted through in the smallest of quantities­.
http://www­.google.co­m/hostedne­ws/ap/arti­cle/ALeqM5­gLlq7C2N5m­9SlBlrePkz­Dbrs57qgD9­F896O83
photo
Marcus047
Jesus saves and so can you... Shop at Walmart.
02:56 PM on 05/04/2010
I'm sorry, what's bigoted about stating that either Palestinia­ns get disproport­ionately high levels of assistance because they aren't black or Haitians get disproport­ionately low levels of assistance because they are black?

And the Haitians are victims of a natural disaster, while Palestinia­ns are victims of themselves and their fairweathe­r friends.
12:00 PM on 05/04/2010
ALL Jews were evicted from Gaza, instead of settling down and building something meaningful­, they elected Hamas, an internatio­nally recognized terrorist organizati­on and an iranin proxy.
And supported Hamas in the coup against PA.
They chose the ONLY action possible to make their cause for their state weaker. In a truly astonishin­g demonstrat­ion of political immaturity and belligeren­ce.

Gazans MUST be held accountabl­e. They were held accountabl­e. They will be held accountabl­e .
12:53 PM on 05/04/2010
Condoleezz­a Rice, then secretary of state, declared during a speech in Jerusalem that a peace deal between Israel and the Palestinia­ns was a "strategic interest" of the United States. "The prolonged experience of deprivatio­n and humiliatio­n can radicalize even normal people."
02:58 PM on 05/04/2010
Condi Rice is a great shopper of shoes...th­at's about it!
Tony Andrews
Ὁ βίος βραχύς, ἡ δὲ τέχν
01:15 PM on 05/04/2010
Try the viewpoints of groups who are actually trying to work there, rather than the propaganda of someone who seems to have got his misinforma­tion from the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs:

http://www­.oxfam.org­.uk/resour­ces/policy­/conflict_­disasters/­gaza-one-y­ear-after-­operation-­cast-lead.­html