iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jamal Dajani

Jamal Dajani

Posted: April 16, 2010 09:46 AM

Deporting Gandhi from Palestine

What's Your Reaction:

The Israeli government's recent announcement of Army order No. 1,650 was just the latest act of provocation in a series of calculated measures to derail any possible resumption of peace negotiations. Under this new draconian measure, anyone who doesn't have a "permit" to be in the West Bank is to be considered an "infiltrator" and subject to expulsion or risk up to seven years in jail.

Expulsions and deportations are not something new for the Israeli military administrative system which was established in 1969, shortly after the occupation of the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights in the 1967 Six-Day War. At the time, the Israeli military was given the legal power to expel "infiltrators" without trial for various unspecified "security reasons."

2010-04-16-gazaerez2.jpg

Two particular Palestinian communities will be impacted by order No. 1,650: Palestinians with Gaza residencies and Palestinians with East Jerusalem residencies, as well as foreign-born residents of the West Bank. But many Palestinian and Israeli experts believe that it's the foreigners living amongst Palestinians who are the real target of the Netanyahu government. Many believe that this is part of an ongoing Israeli effort to silence dissent and crack down on international solidarity members and activists who travel to Palestinian areas to support protests and rallies, often bringing with them the eyes of the outside world.

Now that Israel has almost completed its "Separation Wall", it wants to build a "Wall of Silence" and control the flow of information and limit the presence of foreign-born eyewitnesses on the ground. The question is, why now?

A "White Intifada" has begun to take hold in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. Every Thursday and Friday, Palestinian peace activists, accompanied by members of the Israeli Peace Now movement, as well as international supporters, gather to demonstrate against what they term as Israel's "Apartheid Wall" and land and home confiscations in the villages of Bil'in, Naalin, and the Sheikh Jarah neighborhood of East Jerusalem. Volunteers from B'Tselem( the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories), document by video suspected violations of human rights by members of the security forces during those protests.

Two months ago, I witnessed a Friday demonstration in Sheikh Jarah where settlers tried to provoke peaceful demonstrators by harassing and spitting on them while Israeli Police and border patrol units watched from across the street. I was impressed by the demonstrators' calm and unfazed demeanor. Similarly, at the villages of Bil'in and Naalin, peaceful demonstrators have been brutally beaten and arrested by the Israeli army. Nevertheless, more keep coming back every week.

In February a Czech volunteer with the International Solidarity Movement was taken in the night from her house in Ramallah and deported by Israeli forces. This new order will give a blanket legal cover to the Israeli police and army to instantly deport foreign activists and aid workers spotted at demonstrations. Last December, at another demonstration I covered at Erez (Gaza-Israel Crossing), Israeli police did not engage the peaceful demonstrators who gathered calling for an end of the siege on Gaza. Instead, policemen were busy videotaping those who showed up, especially foreign nationals. Interestingly enough my Israeli Press Card was indefinitely delayed for renewal after my coverage of that story, but that's another subject on its own.

For years I've been hearing the popular question usually posed by Americans, "Where is the Palestinian Gandhi?"

During the past two trips that I've made to the Palestinian territories and Israel, I think that I discovered him/her in the eyes of the many peaceful demonstrators against the Israeli occupation. Nonviolent resistance could be the biggest threat to Israel's ability to justify it's continued military aggression and occupation of Palestinian lands. Order No. 1,650 is to neutralize the movement by deporting Gandhi.

Watch the Mosaic Intelligence Report!

 
 
 

Follow Jamal Dajani on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jamaldajani

 
 
  • Comments
  • 327
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
12:30 AM on 04/22/2010
Point #1:
This "new draconian measure" actually constitutes some minor rewordings of Order # 329, formulated in 1969 (which you refer to obliquely). Frinstance, previously an "armed infiltrator" was subject to life imprisonment; this "new draconian measure" amends that to twenty years. Very draconian. And what seems to upset you: whereas previous an "infiltrator" was anyone who entered the area illegally or didn't have a permit, from "the east bank of the Jordan, Syria, Egypt or Lebanon", that's now amended to be anyone who entered the area illegally or doesn't have a permit, from anywhere. Despite your concern, I'm not sure that allowing for the possibility of infiltrators from Monaco, in addition to the established enemies list ca. 1969, is much of a stretch, draconianmeasure-wise.
Point #2:
Is there any country anywhere that allows nonresidents without proper permits and/or who entered illegally to just continue to hang around? Particularly armed ones? I thought that was one of the basic definitions of a country, control over one's borders. But if you're conceptually opposed to that, you might be able to swing more weight trying to influence your very own country to lay off the poor illegal Mexican immigrants (who by and large have zero interest in overthrowing the US government). I know I feel my energies are more profitably applied in writing to my representatives regarding that rather than fulminating against regimes on the other side of the ocean who aren't interested in our opinions, (possibly for good reason).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
justice2008
07:52 PM on 04/22/2010
So let me see...Israeli settlers originating from Russia, New York are legal residents of the West Bank, but Palestinian Gazans are illegal?

"Particularly armed ones?"- What a funny quession, last time I was in the West Bank I only saw settlers totting arms!
10:21 PM on 04/23/2010
You mean those Jews whose families had lived in Hebron since the beginnings of Judaism thousands of years ago, according to the Bible, archaeology, DNA technology, and recorded history, were deported against their will in 1948 when the newborn Palestinian state decided to sign up to be a province of Jordan? Those "Israeli settlers originating from Russia, New York?"
07:24 AM on 04/24/2010
Yet another example of the common patronizing logic, defending the indefensible!

Point #1:
The original Israeli military order (like many other ones) is draconian enough, and most Palestinians who were deported as a result of it were regular Palestinians who “lost” their residency in the racist and unbearable labyrinths of Israeli military bureaucracy in the Occupied Territories. You only need to read the reports of NGOs and human rights organizations to learn the facts about that.

Pont #2:
You don’t defend the borders of your country by occupying another country and start throwing its people to third countries under flimsy pretexts of security! And let’s wait and see how many “armed people” will be deported as opposed to ordinary people and foreign volunteers who came to the West Bank to support the Palestinians.

Point #3: If this military order was issued by a state other than Israel and its intended targets were Jews, I don’t believe you would dare to support it or use these empty arguments to justify it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:16 AM on 05/06/2010
It does look bad when Israel is going after the NGO's, Amnesty Inter., etc., obviously so that
there is less documentation of what is going on. They are afraid of the truth it seems.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
calbears
06:28 PM on 04/19/2010
So what else is new? Israel has been stealing Palestinian land for decades. It has been deporting Palestinians or anyone else whose politics it doesn't like for decades. It has been declaring its anachronistic "ethnic" state a democracy for decades, even though Israel has no constitution, because to write one would mean confronting that inside Israel is a Palestinian population constituting 20% of Israel's citizenry. They want and deserve rights as a national minority, but to give them those would be acknowledging that someone else was on the land that Zionists wanted to create a Jewish state and those people had to be cleansed to get there. And instead of Israel at least compensating Palestinians for the theft of their property, Israel pretends like Palestinians just ran away for no reason in 1948 and when the U.N. said they could go home, Israel wouldn't let them back in. Unfortunately, for a state that remains too driven by 19th century notions of the nation as "volk," there were still Palestinians there. So maybe Israel should just become a normal modern state of all its citizens and either go home to Israel proper or else reconfigure itself as a binational state.

Because it is crystal clear that there is not going to be a Palestinian state, because Israel has practically ensured that there is no continguous land left on which to put the thing.
08:35 AM on 04/19/2010
The Palestinian Gandhi is the one who wrote, in 1938, that to take land from the Arabs to create a homeland for the Jews would be a crime against humanity.
06:56 PM on 04/18/2010
There seems to be a lot of Israeli apologists here today ......... " Its those darn Palestinians fault that they didn't just let the Israeli's steal their homes and be quiet about it "
07:12 PM on 04/18/2010
The real point are Palestinian genocidal projects and Arab rejection of any Jewish state in the ME.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
leonardox1
07:28 PM on 04/18/2010
There is one country in the Middle East capable of committing genocide with its 200 nuclear bombs.
07:48 PM on 04/18/2010
Well, most of the worlds people find apartheid states holdovers from an earlier time.

The British Raj, the American (all three Americas) gencides of the Indians, the Australians and the aborigines.. and Israel's crimes against the native people of Palestine (as it was once called).
07:46 PM on 04/18/2010
Yeah, the NERVE!

I know any Zionist on this thread would gladly accept people moving into their homes for religious reasons. Right folks?

Of course, MOST Zionists live in the US.
01:10 AM on 04/22/2010
They did. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ehud_Barak#Prime_Minister_of_Israel That didn't work either. So the pendulum swung. Maybe the other party in the dispute oughta try a change of direction once in a while, then by random chance at some point there would be two peace parties in power and something might progress.
06:40 PM on 04/18/2010
Did Gandhi ever believe that he will be rewarded with 72 virgins if he ruthlessly murdered Israeli civilians?
06:49 PM on 04/18/2010
That is a myth perpetuated by the American media ........... it is an incorrect reading of the Quran
07:11 PM on 04/18/2010
It's also on Palestinian TV
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zb326lP5RPg
07:44 PM on 04/18/2010
Actually, that ids correct.

I own a Koran, and Bible, and Talmud.

'There is nothing in the Koran about 72 virgins.
photo
Talab
I tot i taw a putty tat
06:49 PM on 04/18/2010
if we look at the first time the hebrew went in to the land of caanan they killed everything alive , this time only a little less so in gaza and the west bank but almost totally in "israel proper" and this is a "moral people"
07:09 PM on 04/18/2010
Ancient Hebrew never were as barbaric as are Fraudestinians and jihadists.
07:52 PM on 04/18/2010
That only because genocide is more difficult, these days. We have mass communication.

BTW-- Most white colonialists think that they are "moral eople," and that Godd is on their side.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
leonardox1
05:36 PM on 04/18/2010
Sometimes the truth hurts!

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/966952.html
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:35 AM on 05/06/2010
I took a look at the link. The same paper also says settlers the other day attacked a small Arab village, without reason. This goes on all the time and yet the " Israel can do no wrong " people claim it never happens. So why did an Israeli newspaper say so, and has reported this many, many times?!
05:24 PM on 04/18/2010
Yes, it's called "transfer," and is against the Geneva Convention. To which Israel is a signatory.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cohen238765
05:17 PM on 04/18/2010
I'm reading a lot of AIPAC posts here!
05:25 PM on 04/18/2010
Fraudestinians like to create fictions: people not sharing your obsessive hatred of Jews and Israel are not all members of AIPAC.
07:59 PM on 04/18/2010
Not Jews-- Zionists. Zionists are ALSO quite talented at revisionist history.

It's true, though. that most Jews are not members of AIPAC. In fact, most Jews are not Zionists.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:50 PM on 04/24/2010
I guess we have to have at least one anti-semitic smear per page ...?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:26 AM on 04/19/2010
They may not be from the US, in reality or in spirit.
04:40 PM on 04/18/2010
There is a blog on the Israel page, titled: *Hamas Alledgedly taxes poor, robs banks to fund itself*. One should read it. Just recently I read an Israeli article stating that Palestinians used to have a higher literacy rate, at 99%, than Israelis, but today the literacy rate is in the 56% range or similar. The reason is that Palestinian youth in Gaza are not going to school, but are instead being used to dig the smuggling tunnels. Illiteracy is not going to help Palestinians, or a new Palestinian State. Just my opinion. If in any other nation foreign nationals come in to agitate against the government there is also arrest and deportation of such agitators. or worse. If competing factions of a foreign entity enter a nation to agitate against each other on foreign soil, there is usually punitive action. If such factions, foreigners, and others act with the intent to damage more than one entity in an area, there is usually swift action. Israelis are not colonists. There is no other Israel anywhere. They are legal immigrants and/or were born on the Israeli soil., and therefore legal residents and citizens.It is difficult to conceive of an idea that foreigners, or Hamas agitators, are Palestinian Gandhis. Just as many in the West Bank are Jordanians, and not Palestinians, Gazans may be Egyptians and Syrians, as well as Jordanians.They hold no Palestinian citizenship, papers, or passports.
08:06 PM on 04/18/2010
Yes, destroying Palestinian schools, along with the bulldozing of 400+ Palestinian villages, DID negatively impact the literacy level of Palestinians, didn't it?

The Palestinians WERE born on native soil. However, in an apartheid colonial system, under a separate set of laws than other citizens (like, South Africa), they are vulnerable to theft and destruction of their homes, orchards, farms and business, or theft of same by squatting "settlers." with no legal recourse.

Frankly, one of the reasons why Israel is getting a major black eye in the world press is that white elitist colonial apartheid systems are no longer seen as enlightened.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheLonelyGod
The oncoming storm
08:54 PM on 04/18/2010
Do the words "Palestinian Authority" mean anything to you? If it did, you would know that the Palestinians live under their own set of laws, which are defined by their government. The situation is no more analogous to apartheid than the American occupation of Iraq.
12:49 AM on 04/22/2010
You do know that there were zero universities in the occupied territories before Israel took over in 1967, right? No? In fact any measure of living conditions; number of schools, literacy rates, life expectancy, infant mortality, even such basic things as percentage of homes with a cooking stove, were stagnant from 1948 until 1967 under the Jordanian regime, then began to rise in 1967. Israelis had some silly idea that raising the Palestinians' situation to one of the better ones among the Arabs of the Middle East would result in less animosity.
04:11 PM on 04/18/2010
*Deporting Gandhi from Palestine*...? Gandhi?..Palestine? What exactly does this refer to? It is an emotional piece with a specific intent, and the responses are similar. I have read that Israel has set up some sort of court where both Arabs and Israelis decide on specific cases for deportation. They do this together. It is not a matter of Israel doing something alone. I have read that so far there have been seven cases. Really something to start a riot about. These cases involved foreign nationals and Gaza Residents who were there for a specific purpose, namely to start and sustain unrest. The Gaza individuals as representatives of Hamas. As I understand it, it is Hamas which has prevented elections, and for that reason, Abbas is no longer an elected official. He is in his position by a decree. I have heard that there is animosity between Hamas and Fatah. Am I wrong? The PA is doing quite well, apparently. It appears to me, that before writing emotional and accusatory pieces it would be better to stir up interest in forming a coalition government, something that would further the Palestinians' cause, to see to it that Palestinians in Syria, Jordan, and Lebanon are not being deprived from citizenship on a continuous basis, or suddenly have their Jordanian citizenship and passports withdrawn. Finally, before Jordan started a war, this territory was Jordanian, not Palestinian.
08:06 PM on 04/18/2010
Check out pre-1948 maps. The area was called, "Palestine," not Jorden.
11:48 PM on 04/21/2010
check out post-1948 maps. Palestine was founded at the same time as Israel, in the West Bank and Gaza, by the very same act. And the first act of the Palestinian national state was to welcome annexation by the Kingdom of Jordan, in order that their combined forces would eliminate the Jewish State. Didn't work out that way, but they remained under Jordanian rule until 1967, having expelled every single Jew from their territory, where Jews had lived continuously since Biblical times. Jordan in fact kept its claim to ownership of the West Bank until just a few years back, which under international law would not have permitted Israel to establish an independent state for Palestinians any more than it would have permitted them to permanently annex it.
08:33 AM on 04/24/2010
"Arabs and Israelis decide [together]"..."so far....seven cases."....."involving foreign nationals and Gaza Residents who were there to start and sustain unrest”…."emotional and accusatory piece"..."territory was Jordanian".....!!! “What exactly does this refer to?”

..And yes, thank you so much for your concern for the Palestinians’ "citizenship rights" in Arab states! “It appears to me” very genuine! However I would have been more appreciative if you called for their repatriation to their homes and families in Palestine.

Also “I heard” that Israel grants its citizenship to any Jew anywhere in the world under a "right of return" and in many cases these people actually hold two citizenships; Also “I have read” that Israel denies Palestinian refugees and their descendants the right of return to their homeland. And now “it appears to me” that Israelis is putting into effect a racist military order that treats Palestinians as infiltrators in their own country!
04:02 PM on 04/18/2010
Equating Palestinians to Gandhi is totally hilarious. Palestinians must be equated with fanatic and warmongering Muslims living in Pakistan.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jad114
02:19 PM on 04/18/2010
Palestinians have a just cause. They need to be patient.

"Victory attained by violence is tantamount to a defeat, for it is momentary."- Gandhi
03:44 PM on 04/18/2010
Fraudestinians are very patient. They are ready to wait centuries to achieve their goal of destroying Israel.
photo
Amryxx
politeness rules, but with sharpened edges
03:54 PM on 04/18/2010
Do they have a secret base deep underground in Mecca, where their Elders meet once every century to plot Byzantine plots against the world?
08:07 PM on 04/18/2010
Israel has only existed for 50 years. How could they have waited cernturies?
12:39 PM on 04/18/2010
Arab propaganda is more and more ridiculous. Gandhi was smarter than Palestinians, he would have found a way to live at peace with Israelis instead of waging a perpetual and unwinable war against Jews.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newsjunkie5
12:58 PM on 04/18/2010
Is this Arab propaganda? http://www.amazon.com/dp/1851684670
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
longtimegone
my micro-bio remains empty
01:59 PM on 04/18/2010
Thanks for posting this.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:46 AM on 05/06/2010
thanks
photo
Talab
I tot i taw a putty tat
02:26 PM on 04/18/2010
Because the British have a sense of decency, unlike the Israelis , against the british , ghandi had a chance, but against the israelis, well, a palestinian Ghandi has as much chance as a jew in 1940's germany
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
longtimegone
my micro-bio remains empty
02:42 PM on 04/18/2010
I had wanted to write something similar right here, but couldn't find the proper phrasing. While I agree that what the Palestinians are forced to confront in the Israelis is more rabidly and irrationally hostile than the British Empire, I'm not sure that I would go so far as to attribute "a sense of decency" to British colonialism. To simply assert that the Zionist project is more savage in its effects than the "Bearing of the White Man's Burden" project of the British, which was heavily laden with an irony of which the British were largely unconscious, is probably sufficient. (It's "Gandhi.")
06:53 PM on 04/18/2010
exactly ................
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newsjunkie5
12:26 PM on 04/18/2010
Israel's phobia from having the truth out about its deplorable military behavior vis a vis the native Palestinian population is not only limited by trying to silence foreign activists and foreign journalists, but its own whistle-blowers. First, major case was against nuclear scientist Mordechai Vanunu who exposed Israel's WMD's program, and most recently Anat Kam for exposing extra-judicial killings.

http://articles.latimes.com/2010/apr/14/world/la-fg-israel-secrets14-2010apr14
08:12 PM on 04/18/2010
Which is why so many Israelis have moved to the US.
photo
califlefty
Oh how I miss real editors!
02:33 AM on 04/18/2010
From the tone of this post it sounds almost like storm troopers attacking innocent peaceniks. Here’s videos of these demonstrations, judge for yourself: http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2009/12/18/18633091.php Oh the brutality!!! The funny part is the end showing the protesters beating the charges in court! This demonstration doesn't rate a jamba juice on Shattuck.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
justice2008
03:11 AM on 04/18/2010
Obvious Hasbara? Who are u kidding? I can list hundreds of videos showing the brutality of IDF and settlers

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MI51PKXPUHA

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMntMb-omIE

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eh7gzUoy3vc
01:10 PM on 04/18/2010
60 Minutes Australia have been covering I/P in a reasonably balanced way.

From last year, Hate Thy Neighbour - mostly about the settlements with some protest coverage at the end.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPtW3ZYq0Wk
08:13 PM on 04/18/2010
Yep! There is even filmed testimony of Israeli brutality by former IDF members.