EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Jamal Juma'

Jamal Juma'

Posted: October 28, 2009 01:57 PM

It Will Take More Than a Wall To Silence Us

What's Your Reaction?

?>
My friend and fellow organizer Mohammad Othman, a 34-year-old Palestinian human rights advocate, was detained by Israel on September 22 while returning home from meetings with Norwegian government officials. I suspect he was not surprised. A few months earlier, Israeli soldiers at a checkpoint within the West Bank had taken him aside and threatened him with arrest. "We're going to arrest you," one said, "but it's difficult with you because all you do is talk."

As a grassroots leader, this chills me to the bone. Like Mohammad, my colleagues and I spend a great deal of time talking - talking and thinking about how nonviolent peace activists can halt Israel's relentless expansion into our agricultural land. If talking is a crime, if urging the international community to hold Israel accountable for theft of our land is a crime, then we all are vulnerable.

Law, which on paper protects the rights of the occupied, seems powerless to stop Israel in practice.

For the last month, Israel has inveighed against the UN's Goldstone report, which meticulously documents Israeli war crimes during its assault on Gaza. The "new" U.S. of Barack Obama has unfortunately reverted to looking very much like the Bush administration by backing down on demands that Israel freeze construction of its illegal settlements and its vigorous effort to kill the Goldstone report. Brutalized Palestinian civilians in Gaza would be forced to swallow a bitter pill in forgoing the protections offered by international law and the slim satisfaction of a measure of justice.

Israel, for its part, has with single-minded intensity sought to bury the message and attack the messenger, notwithstanding the fact that Judge Goldstone is Jewish and a committed Zionist.

But attacking a messenger like Goldstone is not new for Israel. Israeli authorities are increasingly imprisoning and abusing Palestinians - not just Mohammad Othman - for speaking out abroad about hardships faced by Palestinians.

Mohammad Omer, a journalist from Gaza, was severely beaten by Israeli intelligence officials on his return from Europe last year. Just prior to his return, he had received a prestigious award for his reporting. During a ferocious interrogation, Omer, like Mohammad Othman, was told that he was talking too much (to the outside world). He answered, "Well, it's my job to talk, and I want that, and it's my choice. I want to get the message out."

In June this year, Mohammad Srour, from Ni'lin, another village whose lands are confiscated by the illegal barrier, was arrested on his way back from Geneva, where he had testified before Goldstone.

Many anti-Wall activists with ties to the international community have been imprisoned by Israel on non-existent or trumped-up charges. It's the Jim Crow South in the wild West Bank. There are more than 11,000 Palestinian prisoners, many of whom are held for months or years in administrative detention without charge or trial. Twenty-eight Palestinians from the West Bank village of Bil'in - also losing land to the apartheid barrier - have been arrested in night-time raids since June and 18 of them remain detained.

As for my friend, Mohammad Othman, he has spent much of his time since September 22 in solitary confinement. His detention has already been extended four times and an appeal rejected. Most recently, his detention was extended another 13 days on October 27 (with an appeal expected October 29). Mohammad spent his birthday enduring interrogation behind bars as a political prisoner charged with no crime and unable to see any "evidence" against him. Strikingly, Israeli authorities have yet to bring evidence or charges against him in the military court. Perhaps this is because, as the soldier at the checkpoint admitted, Mohammad is guilty only of talking; of speaking out against injustice.

Mohammad hails from the impoverished village of Jayyous. He speaks tirelessly about the high-tech fencing that steals his family's land. Nearly 20 years ago the world cheered the fall of the Berlin Wall yet today Israel constructs an even more massive wall to enclose tens of thousands of human beings in isolated enclaves. And rather than build its barrier on the Green Line, Israel has used the wall to seize more Palestinian property.

Mohammad has chosen against great odds to speak out because the life of his community is at stake. He has discovered he has a powerful voice. International visitors are riveted when Mohammad describes how Israeli diamond mogul, Lev Leviev, is building an illegal settlement on his village land. Our American colleagues tell us that The New York Times opinion page regularly runs Leviev's diamond advertisements; visitors who have discussed Leviev's expansionist politics with Mohammad, however, will likely not be buying his tarnished goods.

Mohammad, who is mostly self-educated and only recently started traveling to Europe, met last month in Norway with the Finance Minister and representatives of the Norwegian State Pension Fund to convince them to follow their own human rights guidelines for investment. Less than two weeks before Mohammad's arrest, the Finance Minister announced the Pension Fund's $5.4 million divestment from Elbit, an Israeli company that provides security equipment for the Wall and builds the drones that have killed innocents in Gaza.

To date, this was one of the greatest successes of the campaign to divest from Israel for failing to abide by international law. Mohammad was a national hero returning home, only to be intercepted by an Israeli government that while losing the moral battle abroad still exercises ultimate control over our lives.

If President Obama is to live up to his Nobel Peace Prize, then he should ensure that Israel releases political prisoners such as Mohammad and insist that trapping Palestine's emerging Gandhis and Mandelas behind walls, electrified fences, and segregated roadways is incompatible with a peaceful and just future.

 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
jwcmass
I dream of things that never were and ask Why not
10:01 PM on 11/20/2009
It astounds and saddens me that to date there have ben only six (this would be the seventh) comments on this story.

I have said before that Occupation not only harms the occupied-- as this column clearly shows; abolished rights, no habeas corpus, torture, demolished homes, seized lands, -- does anyone know how many Palestinia­ns are being held in "administr­ative detention'­? I know that a large number are children.

But this column also shows the harmful effects of Occupation on the Occupier. Israel used to be proud of the fact that it is a democracy with Western values.

This shows the transforma­tion of a society from a democracy to a tyranny. And while the vicitms now are Palestinia­ns, it is only a matter of time before Israelis become subject to this as well.

And as FDR once observed, when some people's freedom is taken away, ALL of us have our freedom threatened­.

Indeed there is another story here on HP about a Jewish Holocaust survivor and Peace activist who was attacked and nearly killed by a settler extremist: http://www­.huffingto­npost.com/­2009/11/19­/israels-e­nemy-from-­within_n_3­63673.html

As I said on another thread, the biggest threat to Israel is its own extremists­. And Israel needs to do some serious soul-searc­hing to determine what kind of a nation she will be.

Meanwhile my thoughts and prayers will be with Mr. Othman and his family and friends.
11:43 AM on 10/29/2009
Congratula­tions about securing the divestment of the Norwegian State Pension Fund, as this is one of the most effective of non-violen­t tactics to lodge social protest, but it comes with a heavy price for Mohammad Othman. No one deserves to be put in jail, without recourse, because he has spoken out against land confiscati­ons & complained about a diamond mogul who takes land from Palestinia­n farmers in their own village. The story of Mohamed Omer is similar. No one deserves to be detained, interrogat­ed, beaten because he is returning from Europe with a journalism award. No one should be intimidate­d into silence about injustices in his society. When conditions exist such as you describe, this has to be described as totalitari­anism & cannot be accepted by the world community. The fact that Europeans are responding to the BDS movement is very good; an increasing number of Americans are doing the same. We need to be informed, but please take care & stay safe.
10:46 AM on 10/29/2009
I wonder if there are any Palestinia­ns in the entire world that are familiar with the phrase; actions have consequenc­es. They have a culture that preaches that Palestinia­ns are 100% victims, 100% of the time, everything is 100% everyone elses fault and the Palestinia­n people should be allowed to commit any atrocity to anyone because they are the worst victims in the world, ever.

Maybe the writer should take a minute and look at recent history, the fence was built to keep suicide bombers out of Israel. No bombers, no fence. The same with the check points. With the relative quiet, the Israelis are dismantlin­g them. When the Pals strap a bomb to a teenager, promise him 72 virgins and send him off to massacre some Israeli children, the check points will return.

The fence has been successful­, much to the consternat­ion of those who love killing Israelis, so it will remain up. The route was selected by the Israeli military, for safety of Israelis. In the places where its route unnecessar­ily takes land the Palestinia­ns want (which really encompasse­s all of Israel) the Israeli court system has demanded revisions. I'll explain that "court system" thing to the writer some other day. If you want the fence taken down, stop sending bombers.

Incidental­ly, there is a fence separating Iraq and Saudi Arabia, do you have a nickname for that wall too? How about the one separating the US from Mexico?
09:58 AM on 11/02/2009
I wonder if Misaacm is familiar with the concept of geography.
The wall in Bil'in is not built between the Occupied West Bank and Israel, but between the village of Bil'in and its land, which is also in the Occupied West Bank.

I wonder if Misaacm is familiar with the concept of "collectiv­e punishment­", which is what it is called when an entire population is punished for the (suspected­) crimes of the few. It is illegal.

I wonder if Misaacm is familiar with rule of law? The Israeli (ISRAELI) Supreme Court has ruled that the route of the wall in Bil'in is illegal, that it was built for advancemen­t of real estate purposes (so that land developers could build new settlement­s) and not security.

The Internatio­nal Criminal Court of Justice has ruled that the ENTIRE wall is illegal, as are the settlement­s.
photo
jwcmass
I dream of things that never were and ask Why not
01:14 AM on 11/18/2009
I don't think Mr. Juma' needs a lecture from you on the Israeli "court system' (interesti­ng that you have quotes around the phrase-- Israeli "justice" should perhaps have quotes also, don't you think? It would seem that "justice" and the Israeli "court system" are strangers to each other)

He seems to have a more accurate sense of how they work than you do.

And has been said many times before, the Wall would have no objections had it been built on the Green Line.

Word is also getting out about the theft of Palestinia­n homes by extremist settler groups, supported by this "court system" you talk about, and the resulting evictions and homelessne­ss of the victims of this theft--exc­use me--CONFIS­CATION.

http://www­.youtube.c­om/watch?v­=C-a-I3GxQ­FQ

Israel may arrest thousands, but it cannot suppress this shameful truth.

As an American, I am becoming convinced with every passing day that we need to stop financing this injustice.
07:11 PM on 10/28/2009
Don't the Israelis keep telling the world that if only the Palestinia­ns would not act violently then the Palestinia­ns would have no problems? Obviously another Israeli lie.
03:45 PM on 10/28/2009
"Jailed for an Idea"
Read the story of Mohammad Othman, the first prisoner of BDS in comic-book form here:
http://ada­lahny.org/­index.php/­land-devel­opers-bds/­324-jailed­-for-an-id­ea-free-mo­hammad-oth­man-comic

Free Mohammad Othman, the nonviolent activists and organizers of Bil'in, N'ilin, and Jayyous, and the 11,000 other Palestinia­n prisoners held illegally in Israeli jails.

Boycott, divest, sanctions against Israel until Palestinia­ns enjoy equal civil and human rights.