More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
James Peron

GET UPDATES FROM James Peron
 

Republican Bungling Confirmed: Gay Bullies Exonerated

Posted: 05/13/11 08:01 PM ET

Earlier this month I reported on the kerfuffle over King & Spalding taking on legal representation for the Republican Party in their efforts to retain the Defense of Marriage Act and official marriage apartheid.

To the public it appeared that K&S had taken the case and then dropped the case. Religious right pundits and Republicans, but I repeat myself, argued nasty gay bullies had intimidated one of the largest legal firms in the country to drop a client. There was a great deal of blather and blubbering from those whom H.L. Mencken called Boobus americanus.

I argued that this simplistic, almost-conspiracy theory was surely false. The contract with the Republicans was very authoritarian, one stripping hundreds of K&S employees of First Amendment rights. I suggested that K&S also would have been required to drop existing clients under the contract and said it was more likely that K&S "was telling the truth" on the matter of it not being properly vetted within the firm.

Now the Blog of the Legal Times has given more details on the case, putting to rest the talking points of critics on the right.

Conservative lawyer, Paul Clement, took the case on behalf of the firm, but he had not presented the case to the firm for approval. The firm's vetting committee did not see the contract until after Clement had signed it.

J. Sedwick Sollers, a member of the vetting committee, said "our standard client/matter review process was not followed," and that Clement had believed the "firm would accept the matter." Sollers, who says he recruited Clement to work for the firm, said this "was an unfortunate misunderstanding with a friend."

Clement signed a contract with the Republican House leadership on April 14. But the vetting committee was only given the contract to review four days later. In other words, Clement signed on behalf of the law firm, before the firm had approved the contract. When the committee reviewed the contract on the 19th, they rejected it.

As I suggested back on the 1st, the reason for rejecting the contract had more to do with "Republican bungling" than with gay bullies that were made boogeymen by various members of the right-wing choir. As wrong as they have been proven to be in this case, don't expect acknowledgment of their error, let alone retraction.

The gay bully theory is too good a talking point for their base to be rejected. They constantly attack and work to deny one segment of the community their rights and then, when the people they attack complain about it, the right plays the victim card. When members of the fundamentalist tight attempt to impose religion in state schools, and are shunned, they play the victim because they can't impose their theology on others through government mandate.

Consider how Andrew Shirvell was literally obsessed with his hatred for University of Michigan Student Body President Chris Amrstrong. Shirvell was infuriated that Armstrong was elected in spite of being openly gay.

Shirvell began stalking Armstrong, to the point of standing outside his home in the middle of the night to keep an eye on him. He made all sorts of accusations him against online. To make matters worse, Shirvell was working for the Michigan Attorney General at the time. While initially protected by his boss, he was eventually fired when his superiors discovered he was writing his anti-Armstrong blog while on the clock, had used his office phone in attempting to get Armstrong fired from an internship in the House of Representatives, and then lied to investigators about what he had done.

Even after all this, Shirvell says "he is the real victim" and that Armstrong is the bully. Playing the "bully card" is now a standard tactical maneuver for the religious right, even as they, themselves, blatantly bully others.

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:26 PM on 05/18/2011
I love how the "Gay bullies" can muster so many people to the cause as to put any business in danger if they don't comply... and yet they are just a tiny minority that needs no representation...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NoSandwiches
08:50 AM on 05/16/2011
Facts are never a problem. Fox reports and the viewer decides. In their minds it was gay bullies. That is how it shall remain forever and when Texas puts it in the history books, that is how it shall read.

The truth will never make a difference to them.
02:33 PM on 05/15/2011
"When members of the fundamentalist tight ..."

A typo, shurely, but true - oh so true. They ARE "tight" (in a certain anatomical area, anyway).
jack27
Freethinker
12:46 PM on 05/15/2011
Mr. Peron, thank you very much. For a while, I actually thought there was something to the claim that King & Spaulding bowed to pressure not to take this case. As one who believes that everyone is entitled to legal representation (whether or not I agree with them), I'm grateful that you took the time to set the record straight.

I look forward to reading City Limits.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atwill
Proud Father of a gay son.
10:43 AM on 05/15/2011
When gays fight for their civil rights, they are called bullies. but when religious leaders say "Gays are an abomination and will burn in hell and should be cured of their mental illness" this is called being caring and loving in the name of Jesus. I can't type what I really think of these insane religious leaders on here, it will never post, so let me say this. Any and all religious leaders who preach agasint homosexuals should be put in prison for preaching and encouraging and promoting hate and violence. You are guilty of hate crimes. You should be dragged from the pulpit infront of your SHEEP, handcuffed and haued off.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Silvey
Writer/Bleeding Heart Liberal
01:17 PM on 05/15/2011
It's a strange world when hating someone is considered a virture and loving someone is a mortal sin. I think it is so funny that Lesbains usually get a free pass because the preachy sorts get off imagining what they do to each other in bed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atwill
Proud Father of a gay son.
03:28 PM on 05/15/2011
100% right. thanks.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ronniesbrain
man is the only animal that blushes, or needs to.
03:33 PM on 05/15/2011
I wonder if these zealots realize just how unchristian their views are.
Justin Werner
"And so it will make us mad."
08:12 AM on 05/15/2011
Standard tactics of the homophobes on the extreme right. I have watched this kind of thing all the 30-some years since I recognized the truth about my orientation as a young teenager. The really sad thing is that rank-and-file followers of these people do not think critically about the actions of their "leaders", so when their "leaders" make unfounded accusations, they take it as a gospel truth. As a gay man, the lies and distortions of the very vocal homophobes have had real repercussions on my
life.

For over 30 years I've had to listen to how horrible I am, how depraved, how dangerous, how [fill-in-the-blank-with-pejorative] I am. It's a wonder any LGBT man or woman can even function in a toxic environment like this. But things have gotten dramatically better the last 10 years or so. The public is finally beginning to have the collective awareness that we are people, too. We are people who have families and loving committed relationships (over 17 years with my partner, now), who hold jobs, and who are contributors, both fiscally and socially to this nation.

For the first time in my adult life I have some degree of hope about my place in this country, and the tactics of the anti-LGBT politicians will not be allowed to take away what I and other LGBT citizens of this nation have gained. What a bully I am.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
MJinCanada
Safe from zombies until my 2nd cup of coffee
08:39 PM on 05/15/2011
Well, you know, obviously your loving relationship with the same partner for 17 years caused some devout "Christian" Republican to cheat on his second wife and ruin his marriage. ;-J

*Hugs* to both of you!
Justin Werner
"And so it will make us mad."
11:54 PM on 05/16/2011
Thank you very much, that's very kind.

And of course, the secret to the longevity of our relationship is the thrill we get knowing that we're somehow causing all sorts of straight marriages to crash-and-burn at random simply by our existence. It really adds spice to our lives. :-)
09:07 PM on 05/14/2011
What I find breath-taking, but no longer suprising, is the single minded fervor with which people who identify themselves as devoted worshippers of God-is-love preach hatred, and not just for gays!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
dwillisno1
Learning to Butt Heads Without Being Buttheads
08:18 PM on 05/14/2011
Conservatives and the religious right do not know the difference between "The Bully Pulpit", and "Pulpit Bullies"
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
LeftLeanWing
RightKickFoot
09:27 AM on 05/15/2011
The Pulpit Bullies' Bully Pulpit
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NeoLiberal
11:07 AM on 05/14/2011
Bullies?

Very Orwellian. Yes is no. Up is down. War is peace.

Newspeak.

Or could we now call it Newt-speak...
10:53 AM on 05/14/2011
Nothing new in the religious right trying to depict gay people as the persecutors and haters because we fight back against their hatred and their relentless attempts to turn back the clock and make their anti-gay bigotry mainstream once again. They also like to claim that we represent an utterly minuscule percentage of the population, which is intended to demonstrate just how abnormal we are, BUT we're also all "incredibly wealthy" (despite the fact that, according to reputable studies, gays on average actually earn substantially less than their straight peers when all other factors except sexual orientation are eliminated). This explains our otherwise inexplicable and sinister ability to get our way, since it couldn't possibly be that "normal" heterosexuals are increasingly rejecting the right's hatred of us of their own free will. How could they be when we're so obviously repellent?
So maybe the gay-hating right can explain why, to pick just one example, if gays are so easily able to bully society into getting their way, it remains lawful in 29 states to discriminate against us in employment - 39 years after the first state, Wisconsin, banned it.
Oh, and according to the right-wingers, in the aftermath of Prop 8 we vicious gay bullies assaulted a little old lady who opposed gay marriage. Naturally she was black, since the right-wingers (of all people) like also to slander us nowadays with the charge that we "wealthy over -privileged gays" are racists.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RMankovitz
Researcher, inventor, entrepreneur, author
11:52 PM on 05/13/2011
Real bullying is certainly not in short supply these days. Occasionally, you even can see attempts at cyberbullying/stalking online, and I have been a target on occasion.

Fortunately, HuffPo has a remarkably effective group of moderators that are able to restrain such behavior on this forum, while balancing the need for an open forum. I would like to take this opportunity to thank all of them.

Roy Mankovitz, Director
http://www.MontecitoWellness.com
A research organization
01:47 PM on 05/14/2011
As a psychotherapist, I am involved in a study on the habits of adult cyberbullies and cyberstalkers. One of the tasks our group has undertaken is to evaluate a variety of techniques to discourage such behavior, unfortunately with very limited success.

An interesting point is that many believe by posting anonymously, their real identity is protected. They seem to be oblivious that with today’s technology, just like a phone call, their posts can be traced right back to them. The shock on their faces when law enforcement comes knocking on the door is worth all the effort, especially if children are involved.

To see if you have been or are a victim:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyberstalking

Some of the work I contributed to with organizations and law enforcement:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyber-bullying

We are working diligently to pass legislation worldwide to criminalize such behavior.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RMankovitz
Researcher, inventor, entrepreneur, author
02:59 PM on 05/14/2011
It has been an honor and pleasure to have worked with you and other members of your group around the world, sharing on HuffPo in furtherance of this extremely important study, and I look forward to your followup activities and the final report. Although it may start out as just an annoyance for some adults, when children, women, and minorities become involved, this predatory behavior can be life-threatening.

For now, I have to agree that fear and embarrassment of discovery, and potential incarceration, are the major deterrents to cyberbullying/stalking.

All the best with your work.

Roy Mankovitz
10:31 PM on 05/13/2011
I hardly think that taking the US government as a client is a controversial thing. I can see how any rational law partner would do just as he did without first getting it vetted.
11:07 PM on 05/13/2011
Really? Even if they were forced to cancel contracts with multiple other clients due to the terms of the federal contract? Even if they were forced to try to limit their partners 1st amendment rights? Doesn't really sound like the kind of client many companies would be looking for.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeffrey Marks
06:32 AM on 05/14/2011
Have you ever read a US government contract? They are nothing if not onerous.
10:07 PM on 05/13/2011
"The gay bully theory is too good a talking point for their base to be rejected. They constantly attack and work to deny one segment of the community their rights and then, when the people they attack complain about it, the right plays the victim card."
photo
Victoria Tripple
Atheist Scientist
09:58 PM on 05/13/2011
this is the first case that I have followed this closely, and I protested against prop 8, so perhaps I am biased.....but the arguments the anti-equality side/prop 8 defenders were making were laughably poor........this all seems like a such a charade, but I am all for it happening more promptly than it is.......disappointed in the long in between times.........and then there is the whole Republican hypocrisy on spending (this is expensive) and first amendment rights etc
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
antaeus
Marriage Equality Is Here
09:35 PM on 05/13/2011
Xenophobes always claim persecution. Doing so permits them to rationalize their acts of aggression against others.