More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jamie Wetherbe

GET UPDATES FROM Jamie Wetherbe
 

Lesbians Are Forever: A Gay Take on Kay Jewelers' Commercials

Posted: 01/18/12 06:19 PM ET

'Tis the season for retail love, and, as jewelers would have it, a time to prove your love in diamonds. Even though matrimony is on the decline -- 20 percent fewer adults are married now than in 1960, due in part to the rise of living in sin and the Kardashians -- the ooey-gooey jewelry ads started pre-Chriatmas, and thanks to Valentine's Day, the ubiquitous spots will continue until the snow melts (our hearts).

The commercials seem to bother almost everyone, although they must trigger some man to head to the mall or they wouldn't air. As a lesbian, I find the ads particularly annoying. The closest thing I'm going to get this year to watching a gay proposal on TV is Hillary Clinton's address to the U.N. on global gay rights. I just wish girlfriend had gotten down on one knee.

Here's a trio of ghosts from holiday ads past, courtesy of Kay Jewelers. If you have a jewelry gem to share, please post below. And if you do get engaged this holiday season, mazel tov.

"Empty Box"

This commercial tries to up the trendy factor with its "Office"-style shots, and I feel really connected to Sarah and Henry after joining them on their vacation. Unfortunately, the groom confuses love with a leg cramp. I give them six months.

"Closed-Captioning"

After seeing this ad, I believe love should have the option of closed-captioning. It would up the communication between couples and act as a relationship transcript to prove to my girlfriend, once and for all, that she never said anything about not wanting another cat. But it's the last few seconds of this ad that are more priceless than the watch. Somehow, the deaf girlfriend saying, "Read my lips," seems as offensive as her boyfriend buying her a CD.

"Benchmark"

Welcome to the world's dullest and cheapest relationship. They met on what appears to be a loading dock. First date, coffee shop; first kiss, a stoop. And his perfect spot to propose? A bench. I bet that crappy ring cost $100, and they're saving (missionary-style) sex for marriage.

 
 
 

Follow Jamie Wetherbe on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jamiewetherbe

 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
07:44 AM on 01/21/2012
And you know for a fact your girlfriend isn't of the One And Done mindset when it comes to marriage regardless of the gender combination of the people involved because...?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Diana Scrimger
02:31 PM on 01/20/2012
It is people like you that make a mockery of marriage. Hopefully when the Yes on Prop 8 side wins in court that means that is Marriage is between a man and a woman then I will get to have my wedding ring! It is worht waiting for!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dael Sumner
Gogito Ergo Opine
07:35 PM on 01/21/2012
And, it's people like you that make a mockery of America and all it stands for...
04:57 PM on 01/23/2012
I've seen your commentary on HuffPost articles relating to gay rights for a few days now and I can only conclude one thing: you seem very interested in gay rights topics for no apparent reason. Same-sex marriage does not affect your heterosexual marriage in any way, shape, or form. You can believe that marriage is for a man and a woman and partake of marriage in that way only if it suits you. It does not suit those of us who are taxpaying citizens and are being denied equal rights under secular law.

This country was founded on freedom and equality of man. That should not mean only those people who you deem worthy. It should mean all of us.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:11 PM on 01/20/2012
I hate diamonds; I don't like big jewelry; all I ever wanted was the gold band...which I now have. :)

We bought them at a small shop in my wife's hometown the day before we got married and they are a beautiful coppery color gold that is typical for portugal.
07:15 AM on 02/14/2012
I don't much like diamonds either. They are not rare. They are not valuable in anything other than the lives lost to harvest them, or the money stolen from those who buy them to make DeBeers and others rich beyond comprehension. The diamond industry created an entire "traditional" about a diamond representing eternal love and marriage to sell diamonds, and it worked like a charm. Diamonds are gorgeous, and I will wear heirloom diamonds that have been in my family for years, and I'll buy them at estate sales if they are more than 100 years old, but I will never, under any circumstances, ever buy a new diamond from Kays or any other jewelry chain. I prefer the semi-precious stones such as Quartz, Tiger's Eye, Amethyst, etc.
01:05 PM on 01/20/2012
I proposed on our anniversary this year and, knowing my fiancee's opinion on the matter, gave her a twist-tie ring in a beautiful box and told her to pick out whatever she wanted anywhere she chose. Knowing also of her loathing for hetero-oriented marketing gluttons such as Kay, I know we won't be going to the mall for our rings.

Local or artisan jewelers with repurposed or meaningful stones and/or wood seems to be on the docket so far.

All I know is that whatever ring she chooses, it will look beautiful on her because it will reflect her own radiance. That's all that matters.
03:15 PM on 01/23/2012
but, still, you did the whole proposal thing. you sound so evolved except for that part.
04:36 PM on 01/23/2012
It's not like I got down on one knee. How does proposing make me un-evolved? How do you suppose lesbians who wish to get married get that across to one another--by telekinesis?
06:32 PM on 01/19/2012
Can something finally be done about those annoying straight viagra commercials? Ugh!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CMB1969
raging moderate
04:00 PM on 01/19/2012
Kay Jewelers pitches its message to clueless straight men because they are proportionally far more likely to find the whole ring-buying experience to be baffling and alien--they are, hence, far more likely to be swayed by an unsubtle ad campaign that makes it abundantly clear that their bumbling patronage is appreciated. Show some empathy.
09:09 AM on 01/19/2012
Ahh yes, Kay Jewelers. Because nothing says "I love you" like stuff bought in a mall.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ioan Lightoller
Proud Married Gay Pagan Man
04:25 PM on 01/19/2012
Ummmm, I think the commericials stink, but not all of us can go to designer jewelers.
04:34 PM on 01/19/2012
Who says you even need jewelry? But if you want it, why not save up for the good stuff - by which I mean a local artist doing unique and/or custom work. You probably won't have to save as much as you think, because you're not paying for a "name", and it will mean a lot more to you as a couple, and as individuals, than some bit of dreck from a major retailer, however expensive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mindy Czech
Cindy's wife for life.
02:04 AM on 01/20/2012
Seriously. I saved up for awhile to get my wife's ring, and she saved for mine plus put tax return money towards it (our favorite color is purple and our stone is tanzanite, plus we like white gold so it's a bit pricey) but other than that, we only buy our jewelry while on cruises because it's pretty inexpensive and all we can afford. The ring Cindy got me for our anniversary while in Cozumel would have cost probably $700 in the states, but with the fine art of haggling and because we were the only ship in port that day, we got it down to $150. Not everyone can afford Tiffany's or whatever, but what I got is just as lovely, gorgeous and meaningful, regardless of the price or label.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
forkuu
terrible typist-no patience- no political party
12:57 AM on 01/19/2012
its not a losing battle i know the advertiser will wake up and realize that they are ignoring a very wealthy part of the population....which has a lot of people in powerful positions and friends in high places...