More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jan Shepherd

GET UPDATES FROM Jan Shepherd
 

Relax and Re-Frame Distorted Thinking

Posted: 05/06/10 10:23 AM ET

Thanks to the many of you who posted or emailed in response to the question, "Which of the distorted thinking patterns is most relevant for you?" As you might expect, there were as many answers as there were patterns. But, many of you had a question for me, "What can I do about them?" Good question. The answer is, "a great deal." The process is called Relax and Reframe.

The first step in dealing with these patterns is to realize that they are occurring. So observe what's going on and then relax. Just take it easy on yourself. Many of these patterns can make you crazy with negative self-judgments that can quickly turn you from being your own ally to your own enemy. And negative self-judgments have a way of blinding us by shifting the focus away from the distorted thinking and on to the pain that they cause. Until I recognized that, I had no way to deal with them.

The secret for me was for me to be willing to replace the negativity with loving. I had to remove the self-judgments and replace them with self-acceptance and self-love. In other words, whether I liked what was going on or not, I had to accept it before I could change it. I had to acknowledge the truth that it was happening, no matter what, and work with myself the way a loving parent works with a child learning to walk. If I stumbled I'd gently picked myself up, told myself I loved me, that I was learning and try again.

But as powerful as the loving is, it's not enough. The loving can ease the pain created by negative self-judgments, but it takes changes in thinking and behavior to transform the old destructive patterns into productive new ones.

Once you've learned to relax by accepting and loving yourself exactly as you are, it's time to reframe. Reframing lets us see things in a different way than we have seen them in the past. And we reframe almost the same way we relax, by removing judgments.

The distorted thinking patterns share many things in common and chief among them are the judgments they contain such as right and wrong, good and bad -- and it's all about me or its all about them. Take polarized thinking, for example. That's the pattern where you see things as black or white or good or bad. Because there is no middle ground, things are one way or another and our behavioral choices become very limited.

For me sometimes it was no cookies or the whole box of cookies. At other times I binged which made me bad or I dieted which made me good. These patterns don't only apply to food. They can apply to any situation that throws us out of balance. It could be how we are with a significant other, how we deal with our various projects or how we react in the workplace with our boss or employees. It is something that we do internally to distort what is actually going on and turn it against ourselves. For me, it was a food issue that emphasized my distorted thinking. But virtually all of this discussion probably applies to what your issue might be. Remember, liberation is the goal.

Here are four steps I used in reframing distorted thinking patterns:

1. Recognize that it is happening. Instead of just automatically reacting to a situation, no matter how charged or tense or uncomfortable, take a few moments to sort things out before taking an action. You can take a few breaths or take a walk. I learned that sometimes the best reaction is to take no further action at all (like after eating the third cookie).

2. No matter how many alternatives you see to a situation try to find just one more. Then look at each alternative and ask yourself, "Which is most appropriate for me? Which will get me closer to my goal? Which one makes nothing more important than the loving? Which one serves me the best?" Then try that alternative. For me it was reminding myself that three cookies are only so many calories and that is the same number as a serving of steak so I really didn't "blow it" like I was used to telling myself. Then I would throw the rest of the bag of cookies away so I wouldn't be tempted to eat them.

3. Try not to make things personal or take things personally. They rarely are. Most of us vent and blame others when in fact we are angry at our own behavior and ourselves. So when others take it out on you, they are probably just dealing poorly with their own stuff. And when you are thinking about blaming someone else, it's probably a good idea to look inside first. And then relax. It's okay. Take it easy on yourself and make nothing more important than the loving.

This was particularly helpful to me in recognizing both my strengths and weaknesses. If something or someone did push one of my buttons, I knew there was something for me to learn about myself -- that actually the person was doing me a favor. There was a particular episode where a young man was being a bully, which was irritating me to no end. When I realized that I was upset was because I was a bully to myself, a whole new world of self-care opened up for me. I didn't go and eat because I was upset that the person was acting like a bully. I just removed myself from his presence, recognized that it had nothing to do with me, didn't take it personally and praised myself for my growth.

4. This all takes awhile. Awhile to recognize it. Awhile to get it. Awhile to practice it. Awhile to get it down. A long while to master it (maybe even a lifetime). But you will get it and you will, in time, make it a part of you natural behavior.

We'll continue to explore distorted thinking patterns and their role in transformation in my next blog. As always, I look forward to your comments, emails (janshep@aol.com) and those tweets.

 
Thanks to the many of you who posted or emailed in response to the question, "Which of the distorted thinking patterns is most relevant for you?" As you might expect, there were as many answers as the...
Thanks to the many of you who posted or emailed in response to the question, "Which of the distorted thinking patterns is most relevant for you?" As you might expect, there were as many answers as the...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:05 PM on 05/10/2010
I think of myself as an optimistic person. I even try to get other people to look at the bright side of things. But, I realized that my self-talk is very pessimistic. I always think of the negative things that could happen instead of the positive. I beat up on myself better than anybody else ever could. I'm trying to reframe my outlook on things. I remind myself that there is an equal chance that an outcome will be positive instead of negative. This really helps in "talking myself down."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jag Carrao
03:13 PM on 05/08/2010
This is so helpful, thank you for sharing your wisdom. It's such an inspiration. I've been trying to drop 5 pounds, and your advice is helping me keep the right frame of mind.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Anne Naylor
Celebrant, Weddings and Other Blessings
07:51 AM on 05/08/2010
Thanks, Jan. I can relate with what you are saying here.

I had a really full week and the negative chatter got switched on because my batteries were flat - just well used actually.

So the remedy is to switch off and re-fill with my own spirit, to re-connect with the truth about me (which is very good) and have a good sleep, which I find puts a lot of things back into perspective. Going out for a walk and drinking plenty of water also helps me back into balance. Life is sweet once again.

With love and appreciation to you,
Anne
11:40 PM on 05/06/2010
The pep talk/self love is never the first thing that comes to my mind when I've made an error. However, as I get older it seems like I eventually arrive there! I'm going to give your recognize technique a shot. Thanks!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Social Construct
Go left, young man.
10:13 PM on 05/06/2010
First, I must confess that, for whatever reason, I am as skeptical about the self help industry somewhat less than I am about organized religion. That being said, if one finds wisdom, maturity or enlightenment from a source, whether self help, religion or any combination of the endless ways and methods there are in the world, I support the result, even though I may be reluctant to fully support the tools used. The author presents sound advice, especially the avoiding labeling ordinary human thought processes into black/white, good/bad categories. Good luck to us all on the meandering journey we call life.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jan Shepherd
01:31 AM on 05/07/2010
I don't consider my self a self-help "professional." More of walking proof that one can and does change/transform. I do know we all have to help ourselves, with support and guidance from wherever we can get it, including professionals in all arena's. And that growth is a process to which there is no magic.... but there are tricks. Thanks for sharing.
01:23 PM on 05/07/2010
So true. We are all on a journey. Dr. Amen calls the negitive thoughts "ants" (automatic neg thoughts). Wayne Dyer calls them "meems" (or virus's of the mind). I have heard Dr. Northrup say people go negitive because it's easier. Replacing these thoughts with love and gratitude takes work. We are so programmed that it's easy to fall back to the old ways of thinking. When you have loving, positive, grateful thoughts your brain lights up like a christmas tree. And when you practice random acts of kindness the serotonin levels for the giver, the receiver and the observer of the kind act shoots way up! I wish more people understood that they have the power to change just by their thoughts and emotions rather then getting a Rx to solve their problems. Have a lovely weekend. xo :)
01:27 PM on 05/07/2010
Ps....I wish more people would spend time and blog of this section of Huff Post. Too much time on politics etc. which is probably making people sick and they don't even know it. Trying to control things when they can't (I do the same) when all their power is right within themselves. (you can tell I read a lot of material from Hay House!)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:03 AM on 05/07/2010
I think you would agree that there are times and people for whom professional help can be immensely helpful.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Social Construct
Go left, young man.
09:47 AM on 05/08/2010
Absolutely.
07:20 PM on 05/06/2010
"For me sometimes it was no cookies or the whole box of cookies."
....................

Know all about that dilemma.

I prefer to leave the cookies in the grocery store and opt for trail mix or fruit instead. In understanding what's going on, I know I can't be trusted with the cookies. I know a walk, jog or exercising is better than even a few of the cookies. I know that as I walk, jog, or exercise, I no longer crave the cookies.

When I break down and eat a few -- all of them, I start again the next day.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jan Shepherd
07:44 PM on 05/06/2010
once I got to understand that black and white thinking included that I was not ALWAYS powerless over
cookies I was able to SOMETIMES eat just one. I, however often CHOSE not to eat any. I do walk every day except when I don't..........got over perfectionistic thinking too......and learned to laugh at myself!!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:42 PM on 05/06/2010
I am contemplating a few persons I know who couldn't change. When they were close to the end of their lives they expressed apology, but they were never able to change. They had been traumatised early in life, and never overcame it. Nursing their hurt, like a squirrel hording a nut, became central to who they were. It happens.
07:22 PM on 05/06/2010
I spoke to two people like that today: one will move on; the other will choose the pain in return for material comforts.
04:02 PM on 05/06/2010
'This all takes awhile.' Great point. All good things happen slow, bad things happen fast.

How will you know when you are satisfied?
The strongest man is not always the most ardent climber. - William Lecky
justonequestionaday.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jan Shepherd
05:30 PM on 05/06/2010
I am learning to take good and bad out of my thinking. It's amazing how that can distort things!
07:29 PM on 05/06/2010
We have to accept responsibility for our situations in life. I use the word "responsibility," because it suggests acknowledgement, rather than self-blame. That acceptance is one of the most freeing of exercises. It removes the clutter of blame from the mind and frees one to make the changes to move on.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathaliefranks
03:43 PM on 05/06/2010
Jan I love the way you write and explain the patterns. Just last night I had a few issues come up I observed that I was in overwhelm, I then accepted this state and went to bed. This morning the overwhelm had gone and I could once again evaluate the issues from a different viewing point.

I am learning that when I have a re-action to anything I back off from the re-action take some time out and it seems to move into a different phase. One of the patterns I had was to stuff my feelings down and I also ate a lot when I was feeling stuffed. I now allow myself to have those feelings come up and let them go. My weight has dropped and my negative thinking has reduced.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jan Shepherd
04:18 PM on 05/06/2010
Thanks Natalie,

I am going to be doing a blog on emotional stuffing.
It sounds like you are taking an observational perspective. Observation is huge key as taught by many spiritual teachers. I learned it from John-Roger in his tape "Observation Key to Letting Go."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
nikanj
free the fnords
01:45 PM on 05/06/2010
Sometimes the distorted thinking belongs to someone close to you and immediately affects your
life but you don't know it. Example : my mother in law managed to convince herself that my son
was not her biological grandchild, even though there was absolutely no reason to think such a
thing. I did not know this for many years, although she began to think this during my pregnancy.
We live next door to this woman on property her family homesteaded. Imagine the conflict in
worldviews between myself and her. Had I known, I would have ordered a dna test and put the
issue to rest. Now all I can do is 'reframe' my entire experience of raising children in this woman's
back yard in light of her unfounded suspicions.

I suspect situations such as these are actually quite common.
01:30 PM on 05/06/2010
3. Cornerstone of PD. Lack of personal responsibility or recognition. If they do have insight or take responsibility, it lasts a day and the next day they act the same again. No insight that gets processed.
4. PD have a lack of impulse control and can NOT' "sit" with feelings. Go back to #1. That is why so many are busy using drugs, sex, others, being busy, whatever to avoid.
I only write this for all the people with a personality disordered person who keep beating their heads against a wall.
Even that nut bag Dr. Laura states in the front of her relationship book * Wont work with personality disordered people.....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
nikanj
free the fnords
01:47 PM on 05/06/2010
Re : PD people. Roger that. See above post.
01:30 PM on 05/06/2010
This is so interesting to me as a person who works with the mentally ill.
You never say- This won’t work if you are personality disordered.
I have watched this daily for years. No one really talks or confronts this GROWING issue in the world and a real problem. Look at wall streets anti-socials who have impulse control. (Violent people in jail do not have the impulse control criteria in tact)
Like the article on mental illness in children. Children developed personality disorders from abuse around age 2-3. Then they never are able to change if not understood and interventions implemented immediately. This is psych 101. And still it may not help them at all!!
So, in this article we have #1. Basic INSIGHT-how did I participate in my own unhappiness? How do I change myself? Let's look inside-shall we?
Personality disorders are not capable of insight-that's what makes them personality disordered.
2. Plan, step back, stay calm.... PD people must see themselves as victims because they have no insight. Plus, they have to create "drama". Throws others off and makes for "crazy making". The carnal of truth is used to manipulate and talk until you give in from exhaustion.
12:30 PM on 05/06/2010
We all have poundage and baggage to lose, don't we? (Even the venerable Oprah - God knows, we've watched her attempts at mind-body-spiritual reconditioning for years now.) While weight, per se, is not my issue (or, often, the real issue, no matter what the scales say) - old baggage is. We tend to lug it around from childhood. It demonstrates itself as anger, frustration and coping mechanisms that go out the window when emotions intrude. Jan's Relax and Reframe is yet another in a series that gives us insight into the role self-love and self-acceptance play. Why should these seemingly simple virtues prove so difficult, so demanding? Perhaps because they aren't familiar - versus the known-zone of being hard on ourselves; seeing all the warts and none of the beauty. Keep the Loving coming, Jan. Your guidance is like a mega hug in which we can wrap ourselves - on an as-needed basis!
Andrea Giambrone
photo
Toni Bernhard
I wrote How To Be Sick: A Buddhist-Inspired Guide
11:18 AM on 05/06/2010
These are all great suggestions. I love the idea of "relax and reframe." I would also recommend the technique used by Byron Katie to look at our distorted thinking. She offers a systematic method for examining the thoughts that are causing suffering. I've found that using her method, I'm able to quickly see, not only the suffering that the distorting thinking is causing me, but the invalidity of the thought in the first place. (I devote a chapter to her teachings in my book on living well with chronic illness. Through her, I was able to actually some positive sides to being sick!)

Thanks for the article.

Toni Bernhard
www.howtobesick.com
11:07 AM on 05/06/2010
Very nicely done. You are basically describing Cognitive behavioral therapy. Many of us have the critical voice or committee that undermines our confidence and self esteem. One thing I have found helpful is to visualize a dial that you can turn down the critical dialogue with. It definitely takes practice. Thanks for a nice article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathaliefranks
03:46 PM on 05/06/2010
I like this comment of turning the critical dialogue down.