iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Janet Tavakoli

GET UPDATES FROM Janet Tavakoli
 

Gold and Silver Price Manipulation

Posted: 01/25/2012 11:28 am

Many view gold as a currency alternative as central banks print money and debase their currencies. Whether or not gold is a good investment is a matter of opinion versus other alternatives.

The following chart reflects my own view of conditions that are historically good and bad for gold. Central banks' money printing on an unprecedented scale also makes the case for gold as a currency alternative.

2012-01-25-TSFonGoldScenarios.jpg
Disclosure: Precious metals make up more than 10% of my personal portfolio on average. That position is subject to change.


Among other issues that give investors pause is the apparent price manipulation in the gold and silver markets. Moreover, in the commodities markets, price manipulation isn't limited to precious metals. Last week, I posted an anecdote of price manipulation in the silver market in the 1960's: "Price Manipulation: Look for Motive."

In October 2010, Bart Chilton, a commissioner for the Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), announced an investigation into silver manipulation. In the video below, I said the Wall Street Journal wrote a nasty article about Chilton shortly thereafter. My memory was incorrect. It was much worse than that.

The article was about retiring CFTC Judge Painter after he issued an Order requesting that all of his seven open cases not be transferred to Judge Levine, another CFTC judge. Painter alleged that when Levine first took the job twenty years ago, he told Painter he had promised CFTC Chairwoman Wendy Gramm that he would never rule in favor of a complainant.

Judge Painter's order said that complainants, say, complainants about silver price manipulation or other commodities price manipulation, "run a hostile procedural gauntlet until they lose hope, and either withdraw... or settle for a pittance, regardless of the merits of the case." Painter stated that Levine "has fulfilled his vow."

It's ironic that Painter's Order referenced an earlier December 13, 2000, Wall Street Journal article about Judge Levin's appalling record: "If You've Got a Beef With a Futures Broker, This Judge Isn't for you - In Eight years at the CFTC, Levine Has Never Ruled in Favor of an Investor."

Angela ("Angie") Miles interviews Janet Tavakoli. First Business Morning News - January 25, 2012


 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:00 PM on 03/04/2012
Gold doesn't fluctuate against fiat curencies, fiat currencies fluctuate against gold. The purchasing power of gold is relatively constant, while the purchasing power of fiat currencies fluctuate. Gold is not, and has never been a good "investment" (except miners) since it will not increase in value, though it may increase in price. Hence it is a storage and protection of wealth, not a vehicle to increase wealth. The continual rise in the price of gold anticipates the delayed, but inevitable, symptoms of the ongoing, extraordinary, inflation of the money supply which, in time, will result in across the board price increases of goods and services. This anticipation may lead to a short term increase in the "value" or purchasing power of gold, but this is temporary.
02:01 PM on 01/28/2012
http://jessescrossroadscafe.blogspot.com/

28 January 2012
Registered Silver Ounces At the Comex

There are 49,436 contracts currently open for the next delivery month which is March 2012. Each contract represents 5,000 ounces. That is 247.18 million ounces of silver being traded for March delivery against a registered 36.56 million ounces. This is a subset of all the contracts going out over the year.

The is leverage of about 6.8 to 1. It 'works' because most contracts are speculative and settled for cash. Comex is not where one goes for the delivery of a large amount of silver.

I think that over time Comex will become increasingly less relevant as a price-setting mechanism for a number of commodity prices including the metals.

The failure of MF Global and the blatant cheating of the customers, both before and after the fact, will accelerate the process of failure.

It really is shocking, all the more so because so few people see it and understand its significance in the coming crisis of confidence in the US markets.

Great leaders see the big changes coming and harness them. There is no one on the horizon that fits that prescription. What I see is failure repeated, but as history indicates, not endlessly
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dtallwalk
10:06 PM on 01/25/2012
When guys like beck and fox tell you buy gold and you fall for it well don't say I did not tell you so
The price of gold in the near future will drop so fast no one will sell it fast enough to make a good return on the stuff. And the people who will loose there a--s will try to sue any one they can or try to off load it on the US government (bail out)if this country ever gets. Back on it's feet the price of gold will have to fall as well they go hand and hand
07:58 PM on 01/25/2012
Gold will be the next bubble to burst. I can only imagine the angry conservative conspiracy theories that will fly when that happens.

Buying physical gold as an investment is like buying more gasoline when the price of oil goes up.

At least when you buy equities you are buying a share(s) of the company's earnings, which are real profits.

When you buy an ounce of gold it will never be more than what it is at that moment, unless people say it is worth something else.

No thank you.

I want my investments the old fashioned way: based on more than just say-so.
04:23 PM on 01/25/2012
Every time the price of gold goes up, production goes up. The trend in the last year has been flat, so broker fees end up putting you in the loss column. My sister bought gold futures a year ago, still hasn't made her intitial investment. Brokers make money when you trade. Buy and hold. US treasuries and US munis have seen a nice run the last month or 2. I saw a 2% increase in my bond portfolio in a month. I'll take that any day.
02:50 PM on 01/25/2012
Central Bankers around the world are buying Gold like crazy. Millionaires and billionaires are secretly buying gold. When the German government decided to bail out Greece, the German people bought gold because they see where the Euro is heading (to zero). The only people not buying gold are the poor and the misinformed. Gold is Money for the last 5,000 years. The Dollar is paper, not backed by gold for only the last 41 years. When the faith in the dollar runs out, the world will need a new currency. They will reject another paper currency. The Central Bankers are getting ready to introduce new currencies backed by real money (Gold).
photo
BBackSoon
Hello, I must be going.
12:48 PM on 01/25/2012
The value of my portfolio varies depending on how much gas I have in my car, but I still would never mess with gold. When it was $300 or so maybe, but can it really go up much more? The fact that gold only has value because people will buy gold just seem silly to me. And I think the small investors will end up getting burned sooner or later.

If you feel otherwise, that is fine, buy away, but leave me out of it.
11:55 AM on 01/25/2012
It is becoming clearer all the time that the game is fixed, while being marketed to an unsuspecting public as the salvation. It is really the same for art work. Ghastly atrocities trading in the 100s of millions for ego. Or is it really ego, possibly the parlor game to increase the general value with proper deceit in marketing.
06:21 PM on 01/25/2012
Do you mean atrocities by Cezanne, Monet, Cassat, Van Gogh ? I would give your right arm for one og those.