iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Janet Tavakoli

GET UPDATES FROM Janet Tavakoli
 

Third World America: 'Fast-Tracking to Anarchy'

Posted: 08/25/2010 7:02 pm

My last post about Arianna Huffington's new book, Third World America: How Our Politicians are Abandoning the Middle Class and Betraying the American Dream talked about the Great Recession, the Great Bailout, and the Great Cover-Up of financial crimes.

Among the future consequences of not fixing our national problems will likely be an increase in social unrest and an increase in crime. A look at Chicago's problems may serve as a call to action for America's middle class. Chicago's city budget is in dire straits. That's also true of the state of Illinois, California, New York and other areas. In Chicago, the same mismanagement that deepened our fiscal crisis has caused a crisis in essential city services.

The police department provides just one example. Sunday's Chicago Tribune reported that in 31 days, there were 303 shot and 33 dead:

"Crime has been holding steady in Chicago in recent years. Through July, there have been 1,089 shootings in the city, a 2.4 percent decrease over last year."

According to the newspaper, it's a "typical" July. Yet there is nothing typical about it when you look beyond the numbers. The first problem is that the numbers are flat-out unacceptable in any year in any city in the U.S. It is inexplicable that citizens of Chicago have tolerated this situation in poorer neighborhoods for decades. The second problem is a new problem. Years of complacency by Chicago's middle and upper classes have brought the crisis to their doorstep.

In recent years, incompetent and ill-qualified people have been promoted to "leadership" positions. Hiring and exam giving has declined, and the police department is undermanned and demoralized. Even worse is the fragging officers take from politicians, unqualified people in police "administration," and from the local media.

Spiraling Out of Control: Open Season on Cops

The title of this post comes from "A City at War With Itself," a commentary written by Lt. John Andrews, a 25-year veteran of the Chicago Police Department:


Most horrific for Chicago is that in less than 60 days, Chicago has lost 3 of its police officers, killed by gunfire as victims of robberies. It seems no one is safe in our city anymore.

Chicago's homicide rate this year currently stands toe-to-toe with the total number of military forces killed in both Afghanistan and Iraq.

Thugs, gangs and renegade groups run the streets and neighborhoods, intimidating and victimizing the decent citizens of this city. They go mostly unchallenged and unchecked by a totally demoralized police force that is dangerously understaffed and still out-gunned on the
streets.


Lt. Andrews describes in detail a police department demoralized by scandals and corruption. He names those who received promotions based on political pull rather than merit or suitability for responsibility. Moreover, police fear reprisals from political special interest groups when using necessary force:

When asked, most will freely tell you that they do not want to place themselves, their families and livelihoods at risk from a perceived Machiavellian police superintendent or other incompetent "bosses" that could lead them into legal trouble that would risk their liberty and freedom (jail).


Update: Lt. Andrews now faces backlash for bringing these matters to light. See "In Third World America Expect to Be Investigated, as Lt. John Andrews Is Being Investigated, for Speaking Up," Huffington Post, August 28, 2010.

Even during televised speeches at the recent funerals of police officers, public officials speak out of both sides of their mouths. On the one hand, they decry the apparent targeted shootings of police officers -- one of whom, Michael Bailey, was wearing his uniform after just coming off duty from a night of guarding the mayor's house -- and on the other hand, they say that of course, police must follow proper procedures and work within the law (and often pause for effect).

Of course, everyone agrees the police must follow proper procedures, but the subtext of the message delivered at an officer's funeral is repellant. These thinly-disguised campaign speeches suggest the police force needs to be careful not to bring these tragedies upon themselves. Perhaps they think police should round up suspects and put them in Monty Python's comfy chair.

If the goal is to help police officers follow proper procedures at all times, then politicians and the police superintendent have to staff the force with well-qualified recruits (this means creating a reasonable qualification exam), remove corrupt "leaders" by reversing ridiculous promotions, and promote qualified officers based on merit. The police force desperately needs manpower and both physical and leadership back-up. Officers confident that their authority is respected, their judgment is trusted, and their tools are equal to a dangerous and difficult job will produce better results than people who have been left hanging out to dry, while their colleagues are massacred.

Media Strafing

Local media has lost the plot. A couple of days ago, an off-duty police officer shot and killed an armed home invader who had kicked in his door. The officer reportedly lives on a block with five or six other police officers. The intruder allegedly has a history of wrongdoing and invaded a suburban home with another man. He posed as a cable worker and bound and gagged his victims. Yet, some news reports described the intruder as a "victim" and said the off-duty officer was not charged, as if charges should have even been an issue. According to comments posted at Second City Cop, WGN's televised news unwisely showed the police officer's home, identified his neighborhood, and zoomed in on his home address.

Mug Mile

Formerly "safe" and "upscale" neighborhoods have become the targets of "wildings." James Carlini, a Contributing Commentator to WTN News, gave an eyewitness account of his experience of Chicago's "land sharks" at the premier shopping district known as the Magnificent Mile, or Mag Mile:

Coming back to the John Hancock to pick up my car at around 9PM, I noticed several little bands of four to five juveniles walking around sizing up people as they walked down the streets. Luckily we were already in our car, but I could sense that these "gangsta wannabes" were up to no good.


There were some arrests made that night but very suspicious that there was no mention in the mainstream media. There have been incidences like this before but never a mention or a caution. Why? Afraid to report on the truth or were you told not to report on the truth?

One of Carlini's readers noted that Mayor Richard Daley seems to live in a bubble:

I think [Mayor Daley] should go out in the evening without his hit squad protecting him with the firearms he professes to hate so much. That would be six more highly-paid police officers who could patrol the downtown streets that you and I walk down -- unarmed.


Buy Back America

If nothing else good comes out of our crisis, perhaps it will serve as a wake-up call for the entire nation. It's time to put our shoulders to the wheel to solve our problems.

Doing nothing is not an option for America. Much of poor America, especially in our major cities, has been Third World America for decades. Soon the urban middle classes and even upper classes will become better acquainted with that world.

Washington's political corruption and mismanagement has the same roots as Chicago's. As Arianna points out, on a national level, we need "the mother of all reforms:"

"That is why the first step toward stopping our relentless transformation into Third World America has to be breaking the choke hold that special interest money has on our politicians." (Third World America, 172)


On a local level, Chicago will have to fix its own problems by breaking the choke hold of special interest groups. On a national level, it will take a Constitutional amendment requiring full public financing for political campaigns (for starters). Our politicians have shown us how willing they are to be owned by special interest groups that will buy votes, buy a campaign, or just buy them off. As Arianna explains: "If someone's going to own the politicians, it might as well be the American people."

Third World America will be published September 7 and is available here.

Additional Information Added on August 27, 2010 in response to comments:

I chose James Carlini's report, because I thought it might interest city officials to know that tourists are feeling intimidated; it's bad for business. It turns out he lives in Illinois (not Wisconsin) and grew up in Chicago. Contrary to some commenters' assumptions, he is not intimidated by Chicago. I could have chosen from several unprecedented incidents (some occurred on Mag Mile) among my neighbors and friends, but Mr. Carlini is a writer and there was a link to his internet article. Likewise, I didn't have a link to the story about multiple shots fired into WGN's window on Mag Mile, since it was underreported, but the eyesore of a board that replaced it made the Tribune Tower less attractive for tourists and shoppers. (The board was up for several weeks, and the window has since been replaced.)

Incidents on Mag Mile are underreported by the media, unless an incident happens to a reporter. On July 14, Chicago Tribune reporter John Thomas was mugged "on the (not so) Mag Mile." Here's an excerpt of his account:


I was mugged Monday on the Mag Mile. Right in front of the glitzy Coach store. In broad daylight. Surrounded by literally hundreds of people.

Here's what went down: I walked up to the bus stop at the corner of Michigan and Grand to take the 151 to my home in Lakeview. I sat down on the black metal railing that fences off one of the large flower gardens, put down my bag of groceries and pulled out my new iPhone to check my e-mail and send a text message to my wife letting her know I would be home soon.

The sidewalk was packed with tourists and shoppers, but I felt a strange energy when a kid, probably about 14, sat down close to me on my left while the guy he walked up with stood on my right. It just felt wrong.

Then, literally in a flash, the kid on my left grabbed my iPhone and tried to bolt. I had heard all of the warnings about people snatching iPhones and iPods, but because the street was so crowded I never thought it could happen there and then.

But when it did, I instinctively grabbed for the thief and somehow got a firm hold of his shirt. I used the shirt as leverage, flung him into the flower bed and then toppled down on top of him. We struggled, rolling around in the moist dirt, crushing all the newly planted flowers, and I thought I had him subdued.

Click here to read the rest.


I never mentioned race in my post, but a few commenters brought up race and made unwarranted assumptions. Some commenters assumed "wildings" only involve black youths. Chicago is a city with a lot of diversity and gangs of every race. I mentioned a separate incident of an armed intruder being shot and killed by an off duty police officer; the armed intruder was not African American. I also mentioned three police officers were shot and killed within the past 60 days. Two were African American, one was not.

 
 
 
FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 400
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Candide33
I heart Bernie Sanders
07:44 PM on 10/09/2010
Exactly how Mexico turned into the nightmare that it is... the top 5% hold all the wealth in the country and lowered the wages that they will pay to $4 a day so the 95% that were forced into poverty turned to crime.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
mataylor16
You all want it one way. But, its the other way. -
12:15 PM on 09/22/2010
Ive long wondered why everyone gets themselves worked into a lather about urban poverty and seems entirely indifferent (or perhaps unaware of) to the plight of the rural poor, which in many cases is even more grinding. I cant help but come back to the conclusion that the individuals who bring this up care not so much about the human cost of poverty, but more about its rather lousy aesthetics when it visits the places they frequent.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SharonWantsToTalk
11:21 AM on 09/22/2010
Its too bad that it will take reaching the middle class to finally do something about crime waves, but that is exactly the only thing that causes any actions. Its a trickle up effect. Its too bad it can't trickle up far enough to reach the law makers right now. No one pays attention until its in their own back yard.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Aerows
03:47 PM on 09/12/2010
"Smaller government" advocates take note.  This is what happens when you have little government.  It's known as anarchy, which is something people such as myself are highly familiar with - we had it during Katrina.  If you want to live in a third world nation, enjoy such rights as "might makes right", "fend for yourself", "what is for dinner" and "the clothes on my back". 

If you don't think it could happen to you, or anyone you care for, you just haven't encountered the situation yet.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ipolitics123
The Left is not Liberal
12:02 AM on 09/12/2010
How hilarious that the only mugging(s) that make it into the papers in Chicago are ones that happen to a reporter. I guess the rest of us just don't count anymore.

This is what fifty years of "diversity" and "tolerance" have brought us. If you are willing to tolerate anything, you will get the lowest forms of human behavior sharing your space, and violating your space, with nary a second thought. That kid's shirt wasn't ironic, it perfectly spelled out his views on life!
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Aerows
03:52 PM on 09/12/2010
You are exactly the sort of person I don't want to tolerate any longer.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
mataylor16
You all want it one way. But, its the other way. -
12:23 PM on 09/22/2010
So what do you propose as a solution? A cultral revoulution or something?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Trittydi
Special on pap smears at Walgreen's this week ....
01:05 AM on 09/07/2010
Republicans and teabaggers are NOT interested in putting their shoulder to the wheel and fixing ANYTHING.

They are happy to have America become a third world country. They've worked long and hard for this. They are very happy. They're only worried that they won't be able to finish the job.
*
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Aerows
03:58 PM on 09/12/2010
Since teabaggers are against tolerance, can the rest of us decide not to tolerate them and their narrow-mindedness anymore?
12:59 PM on 09/03/2010
I would not be surprised to see "depression scrip" returning on a municipal, county, or even a state level in the near future -- more at:

http://wjmc.blogspot.com/2010/09/main-street-money.html

The more that government and large public corporations including Wall Street hoard money, the more likely that "depression scrip" will return -- ignoring the Main Street Depression now raging across America can only have site effects that may prove difficult for Federalism -- repairing the national economy on the backs of Main Street businesses and workers also risks a populist revolt -- in my view, the US would be better off to send some money to the masses than to have to deal with civil issues across the American countryside, especially when the national economy remains under stress...
12:50 PM on 09/01/2010
Janet,

First, I must apologize for taking so long to get back to you. As you can imagine, I have been a bit overwhelmed lately. I read both of your posts. You indeed did justice to both. Thank you for taking the time to concern yourself with the subject and continuing the message to develop more public awareness, discussion, and hopefully action. While there is a 1st amendment issue here, to me the bigger issue is the crisis situation I wrote about. I hope that message does not get lost and remains a "front burner" topic until Chicago takes the actions needed to effectively safeguard its city and its people.
FYI... I will appear as a guest on the Jim Laski Radio Show tonight at 7 pm (WGN 720 AM). We will further discuss the issues of my writing and the continuing fast-track to anarchy in Chicago. Those interested may also listen live on the Internet - http://www.wgnradio.com/shows/jimlaski/
I welcome the opportunity to discuss this further with you, if interested.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tncdel
05:54 PM on 08/30/2010
There are over 20 million illegal aliens already here in the United States. Don't believe that grossly under-stated "12 million" Pew BS trying to downplay the growing crisis. And if we let Obama give them amnesty, "free" healthcare and everything else [even a "Dream Act" to go to college!], they of course will invite all their extended family members and job-stealing amigos to come here too.

Many illegals steal skilled blue-collar type jobs paying more than most college-grad teachers get. One I know gets over $2,000 a week at an auto upholstery shop. They pay him half of whatever they charge the customer. So if they charge $1500 to reupholster car seats, he gets $750 under the table. And he can knock it out in about 3 hours, so do the math. He told me he send 90% 0f his paycheck home to his family in Mexico City, and lives here with a "girlfriend" collecting welfare & food stamps. His brother works there too.

Illegals are sucking the lifeblood out of our economy. Get rid of them, not encourage more to come by giving amnesty, etc. And our own people can do the jobs, spending their paychecks HERE, not send it out of the country somewhere else.

If you want to help stop our country from becoming Third World, then tell Obama NO amnesty or anything else for the illegals, except stiff fines and deportation!
01:59 PM on 08/31/2010
My dad was an illegal alien, I always got ahead being smarter than my peers, not because I was Hispanic. I received a college education and am a productive, working citizen of the United States. Sorry to break it to you things worked out so well for me. BTW, Regan had an amnesty of his own yet he is sainted, right?
02:10 PM on 08/30/2010
People complain about the federal government, but the federal government is a benevolent insitution compared to local governments, which are warrens of blatant corruption, nepotism, thieving and mismanagement. If you add up all your local taxes (real estate, sales, utilities, fuel, etc) you'll probabaly find they outweigh your federal tax--and you get far less in return.
08:11 AM on 09/05/2010
It's definitely like that in my home town. The cops won't even go into certain neighborhoods, and this is well known all around. Half the time if you call them, they're abusive or rude so few people call them.

Code enforcement targets new residents of poor neighborhoods and ignores slumlord violations. I once got cited for leaning a piece of cardboard--about 2 feet by 4 feet--against my trash barrel because it wouldn't fit inside. I was to clean it up within 10 days or be fined $300 and charged a minimum of $300 for city clean up. Less than a block away a mountain of trash, broken furniture, and old clothes had been piled in a front yard of a slumlord rental property for months. No citation. Of course I just tore up the cardboard and put it in the barrel, but the point is, it's a shakedown, it's got nothing to do with keeping neighborhoods clean.

Property taxes are the same way. There are properties in the worst neighborhoods with annual taxes four times that of those in the best neighborhoods. This practice turns urban blight into a sort of final stage cancer. Vacant houses in these neighborhoods often have annual tax bills in the thousands--and the homes are uninhabitable. No one will buy them, not even for a dollar.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
mataylor16
You all want it one way. But, its the other way. -
12:29 PM on 09/22/2010
Ah, good to hear from a fellow Detroiter.
photo
E4B32787
US Gov: The best that money can buy.
04:27 PM on 08/29/2010
I think the analysis of the crime situation is incomplete when I don't hear word one about Prohibition II (the war on drugs).
Prohibition creates black market cash flows, and gangs form and compete to manage the cash flows. Look what's happening in Mexico. A lot of robberies occur in order to purchase drugs.

I think pot should be legalized, and already addicted heroin and crack/cocaine addicts should be able to get maintenance prescriptions. That would break the recurring cash flow. Financial incentives to addict new users would be eliminated, because, if addicted, the addict gets a prescription. I wouldn't go full blown legalization, I'd rather keep impediments to getting addicted in so people don't get into something that's hard to get out of.

Until the drug war is revised to minimize black market cash flow, not maximize it, I can't properly evaluate the remaining crime situation. I think the black market cash flow is directly or indirectly responsible for at least half the crime.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:11 PM on 08/29/2010
Anarchy? Please. It's impossible. IF there were to be a collapse of government, people would flock to local forms of governance, much like this site, they'd be peacocking and speaking vain words in attempts at gaining "fans," much like this site's "fan" system.
11:10 AM on 08/29/2010
The Plan:

Step 1) Use funding cuts, arbitrary and conunterproductive edicts and other tools to undermine effectiveness in a government agency

Step 2) Wait for a while, then shine a bright spotlight on the agency while loudly proclaiming their ineffectiveness

Step 3) Wait a while longer, then propose that since "government" cannot do the job, "the private sector" must step in

Repeat these steps for: Education, Social Security, Law Enforcement, etc.

It's all part of the "drownin' in the bathtub" methodology.

My prediction: We'll start to see serious privatization of police duties somwehere within the next decade. Starting in the upper and upper middle class neighborhoods.
photo
Decorina
Hypocrisy means your karma ran over your dogma
05:19 PM on 08/29/2010
Check out Colorado Springs, CO. They're close. It is a bastian of right-wingers. The police take your report over the phone - no more of that wasteful follow up stuff. Oh, and the street lights only work in the rich neighborhoods.

Count the number of gated communities around the Springs. They are many - all patrolled by private cops to keep the riff raff out.
09:23 AM on 08/29/2010
Those who seek government solutions to most problems will exprience increasing dissapointment.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Elyriaohio
Stop the Monarchy
07:11 AM on 08/29/2010
The party of NO wants this recession to go so deep that we will have riots in the streets. Unfortunately, their chaos theory will work at the expense of the middle-class.