iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jehan S. Harney

Jehan S. Harney

Posted: October 16, 2010 06:38 PM

Once again, the rhetoric of Sharia taking over America has been exploited this time by Nevada Tea Party favorite Sharron Angle.

In her recent interview with the Mesquite Local News, the Republican candidate said: "Dearborn, Michigan, and Frankford, Texas are on American soil, and under Constitutional law, not Sharia law. And I don't know how that happened in the United States. It seems to me there is something fundamentally wrong with allowing a foreign system of law to even take hold in any municipality or government situation in our United States."

Obviously Angle has never visited Borough Park, Brooklyn where thousands of Hasidic Jews live their lives according to the Talmudic Law, which also has its roots in the "foreign" Middle East. A biker lane in Williamsburg was removed, against the wishes of community members, in order not to offend the religious beliefs of conservative Hasidic residents who didn't want to see women in skimpy clothing riding by everyday. Likewise, Angle's flawed logic could be used against Catholics, who follow Roman Catholic Law dictated by a "foreign" Pope who lives in Rome. The US allows abortion and divorce, which are contrary to Catholic "Sharia" (law). Many Catholics want to change US law to make it conform more to their own Sharia laws, particularly concerning abortion. Does this make Catholics "anti-American?" According to Angle's logic it would.

Sharia (meaning legislation in English) is simply the rules that govern the lives of Muslims from daily prayers and fasting to inheritance. Sharia does not -- and never will -- apply to non-Muslims. In America, Muslims have not imposed their religious beliefs on their community, unlike the Hasidics in Brooklyn or the Catholics who, for example, block stem cell research because it opposes their beliefs. If Catholics -- who unlike Muslims have political power and influence in the country -- can't overturn Roe Vs. Wade, what makes Angle or presidential hopeful Newt Gingrich think that Islamic law can even have the slightest influence on American law?

There is not a single Muslim country today that completely follows Sharia -- even Saudi Arabia. Apparently Angle hasn't read much about the Middle East or she would know that Saudi Arabia has been under attack by extremists who point out that Saudi is a monarchy, which is not allowed in traditional Sharia. Similarly, Egypt's penal code is secular and based on French law. Most of the Muslim world doesn't even follow financial Sharia laws, which forbid Reba or interest on loaned money. In more than 50 Muslim countries, there are perhaps three that practice the strict penalties or Hudud of Sharia, such as stoning, which by the way was also prescribed in the Torah for 18 crimes, including blasphemy, witchcraft and adultery.

If pure Sharia doesn't exist in Muslim countries, on what planet Angle, Newt Gringrich, David Horowitz, and Pamela Geller are living to believe that Islamic law will magically take over the United States.

Obviously Muslims are content with our freedom and democracy in America that many of them keep flocking here. They practice their Sharia within the limits of the law, respecting the different faiths and beliefs of their community. Check out Soul Mechanic! Some Muslims already sacrificed their lives saving others on 9-11 and subsequently their mixed ashes were dispersed all over Ground Zero that is now forbidden for them to have a mosque or center, even 2.5 blocks away for sensitivity reasons! Muslims are already fighting fellow Muslims in Iraq and Afghanistan whom they see as the enemies of the U.S. But the loud anti-Muslim camp is exploiting Americans' ignorance about Islam to raise their fears and subsequent dehumanization of Muslims.

Muslims now are an easy target for politicians like Angle who managed to haul $14 million in three months of her Senate campaign. Do we even know who is funding her? Where is the transparency that is crucially needed to protect America from rich people and foreign groups who want to hijack our democracy? They want to manipulate our foreign and economic policies to advance their own selfish interests at the expense of millions of Americans. Why aren't we pointing the finger at those folks instead of displacing our frustrations on Sharia?

 

Follow Jehan S. Harney on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JehanPost

 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:12 AM on 10/18/2010
I as a Eastern Christian am for complete separation of religion and politics worldwide. Moslems in the west can practice their religion freely, but they have to observe the rules of the land in the country they live in. It also means that moslems in western countries have to follow the country's rules as far as laws of marriage, inheritance and even not wearing a headscarf if the mores of a country they live in demands it. Unfortunately, the opposite does not happen if you are a non-moslem in a country that follows the Sharia as the law of the land. A non-moslem is always considered a Dhimmi or protected subjects or separate and unequal citizen, and in Saudi Arabia women would be imprisoned if they are caught not wearing a cover, and if a non-moslem dies in Saudi, he or she is not allowed to even be buried in the Saudi soil. Moslems in the west can't have it both ways i.e. live in the west and follow the Koran. I read the Koran and it contradicts with western law. Moslems want to be accepted by the west, but they won't do the same with non-moslems who live in their own country. It is time that the Koran be brought to the 21st century.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tantan75
liberalista
07:55 AM on 10/18/2010
The way this article spells it out, even a teabagger should be able to follow it. But, unfortunately they hear what they want to hear. And they would probably be offended that she compared Sharia law to Catholic or Talmudic law. You just can't reason with unreasonable people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
I just don't understand people
07:55 AM on 10/18/2010
Ah yes, the politics of fear. Crank it up. The republican trump card.
06:09 AM on 10/18/2010
I wish you the best of luck dispelling simple ignorance and bigotry against an entire people or religion. But the fact, and it is a fact, is that Sharia -does- apply to Copts and other religious minorities in Egypt and other places.
04:13 AM on 10/18/2010
As a psych grad student, watching these politicians and talk show hosts constantly pushing the Southern Strategy buttons makes me feel like the whole country is in a giant Skinner box.

Muslims! *ZAP!* Gays! *ZAP!* Socialists! *ZAP!* Scary Black People! *ZAP!* Immigrants! *ZAP!*
06:43 AM on 10/18/2010
Keep fear alive!!!
08:27 PM on 10/19/2010
Interestingly, conservative Islam shares many of those same targets.

Unbelievers! *ZAP!* Gays! *ZAP!* Socialists! *ZAP!* Jews! *ZAP!*

Maybe the old adage that there is more that unites people than divides them is more true than we thought. Except that I want no truck with either.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
03:59 AM on 10/18/2010
Sharia law doesn't sit well with many Americans, because ours is a secular government. The United States is not a theocracy, despite what some people might like to think, or tell you. We like our government 'straight up', with no religious messaging. We also like it when our government does its' able best to stay out of our daily lives to the maximum extent possible. But, 'sharia' tells people how to live, in accordance with all this religious stuff. And, people don't like it.

Some religious people are also extremely snotty, and like to think of themselves as better than everyone else. Jewish people call non-jews 'goyim', which basically means either heathen, or something you scrape off your shoe, and be careful where you step, next time. For Muslims, there's the 'infidel'.

We have our own self-righteous lifestyle micro-managers here in this country, called 'christians'. But, they mainly leave people in general the hell alone, SOMEtimes they get on the moral high horse, and start trying to give orders, and then members of the public sue the pants off the offending religious body in question, and make it 'go away'. We have these things called 'megachurches', but they have a lot fewer followers, now, that people are starting to ask Those Kinds Of Questions, the ones they should have been asking, all along, but they got all caught up in the joyousness of the Lord or whatever, and money fell out of their wallets. We'll get there.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
deluk
disgusted.
07:09 AM on 10/18/2010
No, you're a theocracy. where are the atheist/agnostic lawmakers?
07:46 AM on 10/18/2010
Not true:
Goy (Hebrew: גוי‎, regular plural goyim גוים or גויים) is a Hebrew biblical term for "nation". By Roman times it had also acquired the meaning of "non-Jew".[1] The latter is also its meaning in Yiddish.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goy

It is ok not to like religious people, but it is different to lie about them, to prove your point, whatever that is..
been2there
Facts have a liberal bias.
03:28 AM on 10/18/2010
There are plenty of verses in the Bible that can be used to justify violence; that doesn't make violence right and all but a few Christians and Jews know that. The verses in the Koran don't make violence right and all but a few Muslims know that.
Stop demonizing Islam and start condemning the violence, and only the violence. It is possible to disagree without resorting to name-calling or demonization.
photo
Ahmed Ahmad
Atheists UNITE!!
11:22 AM on 10/18/2010
Sharia Alert from the modern, moderate UAE: "Islamic court: OK to beat wife if no marks left.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/39718046/ns/world_news-mideastn_africa/
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cynthia Rays
peace in the valley seeker
01:15 AM on 10/18/2010
Americans don't want to really understand anything, They feel it is so much easier to be afraid because someone tells them to be. It would be amazing if they actually read something about Islam or what the US military is doing around the world.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
abby4ever
12:59 AM on 10/18/2010
"Sh aria (meaning legislation in English) is simply the rules that govern the lives of Mu slims from daily prayers and fasting to inheritance. "

I've never seen the scope of Sh aria so understated. I think it also covers ca pital punishment for g ays, does it not? Not to mention it's harsh---and de grading---treatment of women.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
abby4ever
01:14 AM on 10/18/2010
*its*
07:54 AM on 10/18/2010
yes, it does
photo
Ahmed Ahmad
Atheists UNITE!!
12:24 AM on 10/18/2010
UK: Muslim university students teaching death penalty for apostasy, stoning of adulterers

Wait a minute. I thought poverty was supposed to cause terrorism. So how is it that university students, who are well off enough to be there in the first place, are drawn to "Islamic extremism"? Could it be because there is so much in the texts of teachings of Islam that incites to violence and hatred? Naaaah -- to think that would be "Islamophobic"!

http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/news/article-1321264/University-urged-action-Islamic-extremists.html
01:53 PM on 10/17/2010
Islamophopia

So that's her ANGLE !

Bad pun intended !

LOL
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Saidas
10:16 AM on 10/17/2010
As if Nevada doesn't have enough problems already!
09:33 AM on 10/17/2010
A Nevadan, I will not vote for the wacky, scary Angle. But I'm done voting for Democrats in high places, so won't vote for Reid, either. Until and unless the Democratic Party stops promoting the war on teachers and public education begun by Republicans, I'm done with them, except in local races. Democrats: Demonize the unions that offer due process (not "jobs for life" as Michelle Rhee claims); pay teachers based on student achievement (absurdly unfair); massive, rapid increase in charter schools (I'd like to see some change there myself, but not in the way the powers that be seem to want it); privatize. "With friends like this, who needs enemies?" as the saying goes. There is no difference in Republican and Democratic Party education policy, as best I can tell. I won't vote for either one of them. They're demonizing labor and demanding impossibilities, and the country is sitting there clapping. We need education reform, not destruction. I won't vote for Reid, who will do Obama's bidding when the time comes to escalate the war on teachers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Corliss Holly
03:24 PM on 10/17/2010
Then roll out.
03:09 AM on 10/18/2010
I I agree with you, justateacher - well said.
08:25 AM on 10/17/2010
People trying to convince these people with facts are wasting their time because ignorance, paranoia and fear of foreigners is an essential part of being a born again in America. They are deliriously happy being delusional and in today's America they can even win elections.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
coco123
Left Coast Lefty.
09:56 PM on 10/17/2010
The born again brand of christianity is the main reason this country is so ignorant, fearful of progress,paranoid about other religions, intolerant, backward, homophobic,stop medical research, (i.e. stem cell), do I need to rant some more? The only people that benefit from it are the snake oil salesmen who are selling it, the 'Reverends' themselves. They beg for money from those who have none, and tell them to charge it. These hucksters pay themselves astronomical sums, travel in private jets, stay in five star hotels, ride in limos, spend freely, and live lavishly in every way. If we want to get to the roots of our problems, let's start with them. When thats done, perhaps we will be free to bring our educational sysyem into the 21st century, and look forward to a bright future again.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:12 AM on 10/18/2010
When William Randolph Hearst heard Billy Graham preach, he recognized exactly what you said...and gave orders to all his papers, "PUFF GRAHAM!"

A purely mystical, black and white religion that is quietistic, smug, and insular. That way "Christians" will leave the playground to the big boys...even paying the big boys to keep it all to themselves!