More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Big Bank, Little Woman

What's Your Reaction:

Over nine months ago I started the battle to reclaim my identity. I had become lost in a sea of super sized body parts, a forest of fake eyelashes and hair extensions, a desert where the wind came in rushes of oooo's and aaaahhhh's. I gave up my identity as Porn Star Penny to reclaim the woman I wish to identify as, Jennie Ketcham. Now, nine months, later I am fighting again to reclaim this identity, not because I can't see through the vast wasteland my life had become, but because the financial institution that had sworn to protect my limited amount of cash is failing to do so. My identity and savings have been stolen, and it appears Chase Manhattan can do nothing to right what has been wronged.

I recently saw the headlines on Huffington Post urging me to leave my big bank in search of a smaller, more personal bank. I skipped over the giant warnings, clicking on Tiger Woods links and Casey Johnson stories, thinking, "Chase would never screw me over, I don't have enough money for them to notice I exist." The beginning of 2010 brought hope of a porn free world, but it also brought complete financial devastation when I checked my bank account and the entire balance had been drained. The charges were pending and I could not file a fraud claim until they'd cleared, so I sat patiently awaiting the inevitable drain of my funds praying Chase would come to the rescue in the end.

In the end, my claim was denied on account of Chase being convinced the magnetic strip on the back of the card is printed in the heavens and therefore cannot be cloned. I was hurt. Infuriated. I felt as though my claim manager had personally seen to it that my claim would not pass because he receives kickbacks for every denied claim. I begged him for an answer. I knew why I'd been denied, the heavenly magnetic strip, but I didn't know where to go next. He read his apology from a script and suggested once the signed affidavit claim denial shows up in the mail, I take it up with the police.

Which made me wonder... Who else is Chase screwing and what can we, as Americans, do about it? I surfed the world wide Interweb and came across a laundry list of complaints at ConsumerAffairs.com. Here are the first three in a long list of unhappy customers.

Rich of Denver, CO October 10, 2009: A series of bad business practices including inadequate disclosure, false filings with credit agencies including a false charge for 8, double cycle billing which was not disclosed prior to billing.


TAM of MARINA DEL REY, CA October 9, 2009: I recently ran accross multiple unauthorized charges on my checking account. Immediately, I contacted CHASE claim department and reported these charges as unauthorized and fraud. The customer service told me that there is nothing could be done. I asked to have any further charges to be blocked from my account. One week later, 25 more charges appeared on my account.... I have not heard or received any form from Chase. In the mean time, I continued watching these unauthorized charges, overdaft fees and service fees appeared on my account.

Kathy of Orlando, FL October 6, 2009: On Oct 1st I made a deposit at my local branch and noticed a big discrepancy in the balance, after checking my balance online, I went into the branch to notify them of an UNAUTHORIZED charge to my debit card...I COULD NOT DISPUTE THIS CHARGE SINCE I AUTHORIZED THE CHARGE TO THAT HOTEL ONCE BEFORE.

So what do we do? Do we give the big bank a second chance as we would an adulterous partner? Is it in our best interest to open an account at a small credit union where we have names and aren't just numbers? Should we bury our money in the backyard, and if we don't have a backyard, begin shoving it in our Tempur-Pedic mattresses? Why isn't our money safe at the bank, and who can fix this problem?

My affidavit finally appeared in the mail today, two weeks after they claimed to have sent it. Tomorrow morning I'll be at the police department doing what Chase should have done for me... following through on a claim to ensure the safety of a customer's money. The big bank may have won this little battle, but I guarantee this little woman will win the war. And upon winning this war and receiving what's rightfully mine, I will do as Huffington advised and take my money elsewhere.

 

Follow Jennifer Ketcham on Twitter: www.twitter.com/becomingjennie

Over nine months ago I started the battle to reclaim my identity. I had become lost in a sea of super sized body parts, a forest of fake eyelashes and hair extensions, a desert where the wind came in ...
Over nine months ago I started the battle to reclaim my identity. I had become lost in a sea of super sized body parts, a forest of fake eyelashes and hair extensions, a desert where the wind came in ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 30
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:24 PM on 02/06/2010
I'm terribly sorry to read of this Jennifer. I wish you nothing but the best in your battle to regain what is yours. You WILL succeed!!! :-)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
revko
02:15 AM on 01/29/2010
The Money Shot !!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dreamsugar
06:31 PM on 01/28/2010
I wish MYM would put more focuses on credit unions than small banks.
02:12 PM on 01/28/2010
The FIRST THING a victim of identity theft MUST DO is go to your local SHERIFF dept and file a case for identity theft. Take every piece of evidence you can find and don't leave without a CASE NUMBER.

Then you can use that CASE NUMBER to force these guys to do the right thing.

Or sue.
12:27 PM on 01/28/2010
Last week 1-800-FLOWERS called me to let me know that they thought someone was using my debit card number to order flowers. I checked my Capital One bank account and saw that someone had gotten ahold of my debit card number and was charging flowers at various online companies. The other companies, including FTD.com, could have cared less when I spoke with them and hung up on me in mid-sentence. I immediately canceled my card and was issued a new one. Once the charges settled, they mailed me a dispute claim. Once they get that back, they will restore the amount taken from my account (7-10 days total). No problem. So, Chase can do something, they just won't. I have already moved my accounts, including business, to my credit union to get out of the central banking system. However, I keep this Capital One account because of family business I do in another state. If you do have to stay in the banking system, Capital One has at least proven that they can help the customer in a crisis. Of course, I can only speak from my own experience and advise doing your own research.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ReelBusy
I'm the Ghost of Hollywood Past
11:51 AM on 01/28/2010
CHASE,
it's what you need to do to get your money back.

They name these banks for a reason.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
JScott
John Galt's last name is McGuffin-Smithee
10:56 AM on 01/28/2010
Do we give the big bank a second chance as we would an adulterous partner? Is it in our best interest to open an account at a small credit union where we have names and aren't just numbers?

Well Duh, of course they don't get a 2nd chance, I would not have had them even in the first place.

I hope your remains of what is left is now in a CU or a local community financial institution and this will
serve as a teachable moment for a lotta folks.

Good for you!
HSC55
We will be known forever by the tracks we leave
09:26 AM on 01/28/2010
Credit theft is rampant these days. After having our credit card #'s stolen multiple times this year (and my credit union did not give us any trouble giving us our money back, by the way) our credit union has recommended people use ecash cards instead of debit cards. You can move money onto the ecash card by a simple phone transaction or using your computer. Just put on what you need for a few days or the week. The # on the card can't be used to access any of your other accounts i.e. checking or savings. The thief can only get what is on the card. These are great if you travel overseas where the greatest amount of credit card theft is happening. But these kinds of thefts are happening more and more in this country also, so I recommend everyone getting an ecash card from your credit union. Plus I can give my kids one of these cards and they just call me if they need more money on it for books or something.(they are away at college)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
staziaw
Possibly the last sane person left
08:06 PM on 01/28/2010
Wow, great suggestion! Thanks.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ecotorium
08:52 AM on 01/28/2010
I'm w Chase too. A few years ago, someone stole $1,000 from me to donate to a religious network (oh, the irony, I know). Chase replaced that - esp seeing as it had been happening to many different people (someone was trying to play robin hood, but I'm not rich). Then, last weekend, I went online to check my accounts and pay off my credit card. Someone had stolen a total of $960 from my savings - my savings! Meaning, they had to have had my card to do it (otherwise, if you charge something to my debit card, it's automatically withdrawn from my checkings). I called Chase - nothing they could do bc their system was down, even though I had to go through the 10 minute song and dance of giving all my info. Sunday morning I called and was essentially told by both the representative and supervisor (bc I was getting nowhere fast w the rep) that I was lying, bc clearly, I either gave someone my debit card, or they stole it and then brought it back to me. I live in Chicago. The charges were from Elmhurst and Des Plaines - granted not absurdly far from me, but not close and I don't venture out there often. (cont.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ecotorium
08:52 AM on 01/28/2010
(cont.) I assured them there was no possible way someone had my card. I talked to another supervisor who was much nicer and sympathetic. However, I was told nothing could be done until that Tues (I noticed the charges that previous Sat night), after the charges had been completed. I waited. Tuesday came around and the money was gone. I had to jump through many hoops and talk to many people for a very long time to get this resolved. I do, however, have my money back - but I had to fight them for it. I told them I rarely use non-chase ATMs - I was told this wasn't good enough. To be completely safe, I'd have to go to the bank and use the ATMs there (bc my theory is there was a reader on whatever Chase ATM I used and that's how they got into my account). After all is said and done, its really sad that I don't know who I'm more upset with: the jerks who stole my hard-earned cash, or the bank that didn't protect it.
10:01 PM on 01/27/2010
Keep fighting til you win the war. Don't worry about it too much. The people at Chase will learn about the way the treat their accounters badly. I feel like it's time to start with a new bank that you can trust and won't have to steal your money. I will keep praying for you that your life continues to get right back on track. You can do it Jennie.
08:19 PM on 01/27/2010
The whole "heavenly magnetic strip" thing is horseshit. Years ago while living in NYC, I had a friend who had a similar experience as yours. I can't recall if it was Chase or Citi, but it was one of the two. His wife noticed that $500 per day had been withdrawn over the course of 3 days. She asked if he had done it, but he hadn't withdrawn any money. They went to the bank and (long story short) it turns out that hundreds of their customers had the same experience. Some criminals had spoofed the magnetic strips of hundreds of accounts and started drawing out the maximum amount every day. Eventually, the bank returned all their money.

Due to my friend's story, I actually started checking my balances every other day. It sucks and is a pain, but what has happened to you is my biggest fear. I really feel for you.

You should try to find out if anyone at that bank has had the same experience recently. That would grease the wheels toward getting your money back faster. In the mean time, hang in there best you can.
08:09 PM on 01/27/2010
When you say "adulterous" I think you mean "abusive." This is financial violence, and we cannot tolerate it out of a false sense of guilt about not paying debts. Most people intend to pay back debts that they actually owe and make every effort to do so. But this is not an isolated trend. And it's clear that the banks will use every technicality trick in the book to charge a fee that leads to an overdraft that leads to another fee--and why not? How else could they be one of the only supposedly profitable businesses around these days? Enough is enough.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
07:22 PM on 01/27/2010
If you go to a smaller bank and have the same experience of getting defrauded, do you think they will treat you much differently?

Banks are in the business of making money with money - not paying out fraud claims. I expect that they'll pay only when they absolutely have to - or when they themselves will be able to get reimbursed by the government.

I'm OK with bashing the big banks, and moving money to smaller ones - but let's be realistic.
HSC55
We will be known forever by the tracks we leave
09:18 AM on 01/28/2010
Yes you will have a different experience if you go to a smaller bank. I have everything at my local credit union. If they see a suspicious charge they call me right away and ask about it. BEFORE I even see it on my statement!!! Once they missed one. All I had to do was call and report it and they took it right off. My husband travels quite a bit and is alway getting his card # stolen, especially when staying at hotels out of the country. We have NEVER had to fight our credit union to get those charges canceled and get our money back.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
04:55 PM on 01/27/2010
I moved my money to a local bank last year. To paraphrase Charlton Heston, the big banks can have my money when they pry it from my cold, dead hands.