iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm

Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm

Posted: December 9, 2010 09:05 AM

America Needs a Jobs Race to the Top

What's Your Reaction:

As last week's jobs numbers reminded us, emerging from the biggest economic crisis since the Great Depression isn't going to be easy. We need to be creative and daring. We need a moon shot -- a Jobs Race to the Top. The goal: create three million new jobs in three years. 
 
It's doable with an aggressive strategy. Here's how it could work:
 
• Take funds the U.S. now spends on economic development programs (about $170 billion) and redirect a portion to a Jobs Race to the Top competition among the country's regions, states and communities.  For it to have an effect, it needs to have the size and scope of the education Race to the Top.    
 
• Focus the competition on clean energy job creation. There is a critical national need for this and it can create all kinds of jobs for all kinds of people in all kinds of regions across the country.
 
• Devote the competition to rewarding the most effective public-private partnerships. These must be developed at the local level. Define "effective" in terms of the numbers of lasting jobs created quickly.
 
• Reward regions that build on their strengths, partner with the private sector and change public policy to drive jobs results. Take the Sunbelt states. In exchange for federal dollars to offset a company's upfront capital costs or new technology installation, these states might create a dramatically streamlined permitting process for solar farms. Or they could offer a partnership with specific private-sector solar energy producers to build out the energy generation, and ensure strong demand for renewable energy inside the region through a robust Renewable Energy Standard. 
 
The regional governments might lease land tracts at low rates, or even offer them for free.  State governments might give incentives for solar energy production.  Public utility commissions might offer ways to partner with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to streamline electric grid siting. Allow regions to partner to make their best competitive case; develop the most creative, dynamic and effective public policy, and use the federal dollars to drive technological advances and investment that might otherwise head to another country.
 
• The same analysis could be done for other regions -- including the nation's high wind areas, the best places to manufacture clean energy or energy efficiency products, regions with the potential to develop biofuels, nuclear, hydro-energy or waste-to-energy technologies.  Every region has something to offer to our clean energy future, and every region could be creating all kinds of jobs for their citizens right now -- if incentives were right.
 
• To get quick results, announce the competition in early 2011 and the winners within six months. 
 
In Michigan, we are trying our own version of this race -- focused on the lithium-ion advanced battery for the electric car, a high-tech product previously manufactured almost exclusively in Asia.
 
We offered irresistible state tax incentives for manufacturers of "advanced energy storage."  We pancaked our state incentives on top of the competitive federal Department of Energy grants to advanced battery companies and suppliers. We also created robust public-private partnerships.
 
In just over a year, we have attracted 18 domestic and international companies, projected to create 63,000 private-sector jobs in Michigan. With breathtaking speed, we built an entire advanced battery "ecosystem" for the purpose of electrifying the automobile. 
 
If the states are the laboratories of democracy, Washington can take a lesson from what is happening in Michigan.  
 
Comprehensive clean energy projects require lots of local collaboration and private sector involvement.  Without a financial carrot, the difficult regulatory changes at the local level would take years -- if not decades.  As we saw with the education Race to the Top, a financial incentive at these fiscally tight times caused states to dramatically change public policy to achieve the critical federal goal of increasing educational achievement in America. 
 
An Energy Jobs Race to the Top is likely to ensure that America will actually be at the table to feast on this explosively growing jobs sector -- instead of watching our global economic competitors eat our lunch.
 
The New Deal was about employment by the federal government. But this new era demands a private sector-focused, bottom-up approach:  jobs created by businesses through local public-private partnerships in an economic sector important to our national strength and incentivized by the federal government. 
 
The models are there. The federal experiment with Race to the Top worked. The state experiments with public-private partnerships are working -- look at Michigan.  Let's combine the two and create millions of jobs in America.  

 
 
 

Follow Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm on Twitter: www.twitter.com/govgranholm

 
 
  • Comments
  • 233
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
09:12 AM on 12/13/2010
Governor Granholm is correct -- to emerge from the biggest economic recession since the Great Depression, we need bold and courageous policies. We need local, state and federal incentives, and we need an educated workforce that can help create the new green economy. Stronger policies will help drive recovery.

A recent blog post by Julian Keniry, National Wildlife Federation, Senior Director for Campus and Community outlines Top 12 State Policies for Greener Jobs and Workforce in which state policies have encouraged job growth and economic recovery. Furthermore, the Greenforce Initiative, a partnership between the National Wildlife Federation and Jobs for the Future (funded by Bank of America Charitable Foundation & the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation) is working in 6 regions across the United States to help connect community colleges green jobs training programs to the emerging green industry.

Specifically in Michigan, the Greenforce Initiative is working with the Department of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth, the Michigan Economic Development Corporation and the Michigan Community Colleges Association to utilize Granholm’s state policies to create career pathways into the green economy. Michigan has made a huge strategic “bet” in regards to the green economy. The local economy depends on this green transition from the once heavy auto manufacturing industry to the now-increasing demand for parts in the wind, solar and battery industries.

It is critical that the public, private & non-profit sectors work together to help create the 3 million jobs America needs. As Granholm says, “It is doable with an aggressive
02:41 PM on 12/13/2010
"As Granholm says" ...

Have you read some of the others things Granholm has said over the years? I have heard plenty. Obviously, it's not what someone says that counts, it's what real 'movers and shakers' DO, that counts. We already have thousands of "experts", pundits and punters out there.
guajiro
posted 5 minutes ago
05:46 PM on 12/12/2010
I agree with the basic concept Jennifer, but is there room for the average working stiff to invest in these type of jobs? Along with your outline there should be a partnership with the smallest unit of the "public sector"; the working man. There must be an option that allows the single entrepeneur to invest in these grand schemes, otherwise it's just another corporate/government marriage proposal and we in working class America are tired of that. Thanks.
photo
paddio
We are men of honor..lies do not become us.
06:44 PM on 12/12/2010
Dead on guajiro! see my comment re. High Speed Rail....sure the large corps and banksters would get rich too, but at least you put working men and women (and they WANT to work by the way)back to work. It's pretty hard to outsource a railroad. By the way , WE build the drive trains and chassis for locomotives for the Chinese.
photo
paddio
We are men of honor..lies do not become us.
04:40 PM on 12/12/2010
“The United States is the only nation that has not built nor any plans to build >real< High Speed Rail.This gigantic hole in our economy could very well be our salvation. Every industry in every state would benefit from a project on such an enormous scale. Building roads, bridges and schools, at the end of the day employ no one afterward. HSR would thru service and maintenance employ many once it is built. To the skeptics...when Robert Moses built Jones Beach he built 10 parking lots for a thousand cars each ..when there weren't 10,000 cars in the country. Put Americans back to work in America...” right now good honest working men are taking any odd jobs they can. Many...and you can see them on the road picking up scrap metal, just to make ends meet. College graduates...not in their twenties but in their 40',50's and 60's are taking any jobs they can find.
02:24 PM on 12/12/2010
I guess not too many people interested in commenting here.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
gutenmorgen
a.k.a. crowsnest
01:20 PM on 12/12/2010
Few commentators, let alone politicians understand that employment is a cyclic affair. It actually begins in our nation with the needs/demands of approximately 350 million persons and not with "business", small or large nor with government. The 350 million need incomes to be able to satisfy their needs/demands. The incomes of most are provided either by "business" or by government. The strength of this cycle determines the degree of employment. What I have written here is not my idea. I have borrowed it from Maynard Keynes.
photo
CanuckistanCommie
I ain't no Commie but Pat Buchanan thinks so!
10:41 AM on 12/12/2010
All these ideologies may create a few jobs but they will never create enough to fix this mess. Remember that there are 49 other states that can get involved in this race.
The reality is this.
The only way America will EVER get out of this job glut is to change their spending habits.
As long as you continue buying your Apple products you continue to employ a Chinese worker to a tune of $50/week. Walmart imports 80% of it goods from China. Do you shop there?
Every time you purchase from these companies you only encourage them to continue with the status quo and they will continue to disregard the need for American jobs.
If every American spent $10,000 on Made in American products, you would create just under 50 million jobs @ $50k/yr.
And if you want to see how your personal spending habits affect the job market.
Take an inventory of everything that you have in your living room. Note cost and group by country of manufacture.
Total each amount by country and multiply by 77 million families. Take that figure and account for 80% of the costing going into wages. Take that figure and divide by $50k(medium income for an American family) . That is how many jobs you have cost in manufacturing jobs.
Now do that with your entire house.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aneesia
08:23 AM on 12/12/2010
You cannot put all of your eggs in one lithium-ion basket, especially when newer and more efficient forms of battery power are being discovered. You can influence your Federal politicians to bring home jobs to America, the jobs they sent overseas with legislation for cheap labor for their corporate brethren.
07:00 AM on 12/12/2010
Waring: Only pro-Gov Granholm comments are being allowed here.
02:55 PM on 12/11/2010
What happened to all the other comments???
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jacqmac
12:45 PM on 12/11/2010
Is this the same Gov. Jennifer Granholm who recently got all excited about 800 jobs in Sterling Heights? Is this the same Gov. Jennifer Granholm who literally did NOTHING to STOP the UAW from selling out and GIVING UP 159,000 jobs? This is no 'Race to the Top'. It's more like a stall on the race to the bottom. If this IS the same Gov. Jennifer Granholm that allowed this to happen while she was talking about creating jobs---I don't think I want to read this.
03:38 PM on 12/11/2010
Excited about 800 jobs??!! She got excited standing on stage with an embezzler, posing as a new Michigan "entrepreneur", who was about to get a huge tax-break for some non-existent project. All the more amazing was the fact that, apparently, no one on the Governor's staff knew that this "bum" was actually broke, living in a trailer park, and didn't even have a website (or internet service). And, remember, Granholm is a lawyer! Despite this, no one at the Michigan's MEDC (Michigan Economic Development Corporation) was ever held accountable. Makes you wonder why, perhaps? I think Michigan's new Governor would have made sure that at least some heads rolled, if not half those at the MEDC.
guajiro
posted 5 minutes ago
05:51 PM on 12/12/2010
"Was about to get"? You mean he didn't get it? Hmmm.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Visionary Excellence
06:12 PM on 12/10/2010
When I read about the Govs MI Battery Development plan, I think of something else I recently read. 40,000+ chemists out of work... Chemists are now a dime a dozen. If the state of Michigan wants to lead in battery development, now is the time to hire chemists. "Nearly half of all chemists are employed in manufacturing firms — plastics, pesticides, and paint, to name a few. And that's a bummer for them, because manufacturing companies are continuing to outsource their R&D and testing to small, specialized firms, cutting job opportunities for in-house chemists. The profession lost 42,000 jobs from 2008 to 2009, according to Chemical and Engineering News, and the BLS projects only a 2 percent rise in the total number of chemists employed by 2018." - by Louise Tutelian
02:11 PM on 12/10/2010
Why are only positive comments and compliments of the Governor being allowed here? Not very "democratic" if you ask me.
12:39 PM on 12/10/2010
Until the greed ultra-rich come to the understanding that the more people are employed at better salaries, there income stream will be impaired going forward. Unfortunately they're too short-sighted and invested in "what's in it for me" mentality to get it.
12:37 PM on 12/10/2010
I my opinion, this Governor has always been better at making lofty speeches and proposals (including for things she knows little about) and for granstanding (including going on stage to praise an "entrepreneur", who later turned out to be an embezzler) than actual governing. Outside of film-credits (which other states were already offering), I cannot point to one truly innovative thing that was proposed by Granholm during her tenure as Michigan's governor (and the 21st Century "Jobs" Fund, certainly, doesn't count!). Now, all of a sudden, she has all these 'brilliant ideas' for what OTHERS should do. Why did this Governor make a special "sweetheart" deal with Michigan utility companies that gave them a "guaranteed customer base"? What happened to competition in Michigan?
11:45 AM on 12/10/2010
Gordon Brown thinks so too - http://bit.ly/GBrown - message to G20: Green Jobs and Stimulus Now