iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Jennifer Newcomb Marine
 
GET UPDATES FROM Jenna Korf
 

Mother's Day vs. Stepmother's Day: Who Owns It?

Posted: 05/11/2012 12:30 pm

Mother's Day. As if divorced moms and stepmoms needed yet one more reason to feel at odds with each other.

For moms (whether divorced or not), Mother's Day might mean blackened toast and watery coffee delivered on a tray in bed, with a dandelion plucked from the backyard. We overlook the explosion in the kitchen and choose instead to bask in the glow of love and attention on this one special day, excusing ourselves from chores and life as a housemaid. We all have our own memories of how we honored our mothers as children and there's something miraculous about seeing life come full circle.

But for stepmoms, Mother's Day can trigger the deepest of hurtful emotions, serving as a reminder that although they typically perform the daily, hands-on "mothering" duties at home with their stepkids, they aren't in fact Mom and will never be recognized as such.

For divorced moms, the notion that some stepmoms feel they should be included in this day goes one step too far: She already has a consistent place in her stepchildren's lives, now she wants to encroach upon a day meant to celebrate the bond between mother and child, too?

What's true for both divorced moms and stepmoms is this: It's an uphill battle to be acknowledged for all the ways they give to their families each week. Tiny details no one else catches. Countless objects restored to their proper places. Endless messes cleaned up without thanks. Difficult emotions noticed and tended. The struggle to shape chaotic fragments of days into a cohesive and nurturing whole.

Why so much conflict over this one particular day?

Granted, there is actually a Stepmother's Day. But it's not an official or widely-recognized holiday and it falls on the Sunday after Mother's Day, a hierarchy not lost on many stepmoms. Go to any card store and you'll be lucky to find one or two meant for stepmoms among the ocean of cards festooned with flowers and curly-cued script for Mom.

But consider the fact that you can find almost as many stepfamilies as nuclear families on any neighborhood block. How can we have such a glaring absence of acknowledgment for "the other half?"

Since their day hardly seems to exist, a stepmom's longing for appreciation means the spotlight naturally turns to the Grand Dame of thanks for maternal love and devotion: Mother's Day. And it must now be shared.

That Stepmother's Day is essentially a non-event is a perfect example of society's lack of understanding about the realities of divorce-connected families today, a willful denial of the dual-household nature of divorce and remarriage.

The culture at large blindly reflects back to us what's already taking place inside many stepfamilies: The stepmom often feels like an outsider in her own stepfamily, yet is expected to step seamlessly into the role of maternal caretaker. She's not privy to the realm of authority that the two parents possess, yet is expected to bear the consequences of their decisions. She strives to provide love and nurturing to children she genuinely cares for, yet may still be seen as second best.

This holiday can highlight the most intractable problems between divorced moms and stepmoms. At our worst, there's the mother who insists on being the one and only mother in her child's life, never to be "shared" with another woman. Or there's the stepmom bent on outshining the mother, showing her how proper parenting is done.

Some stepmoms want nothing to do with Mother's Day, are perfectly happy with an unofficial day of acknowledgement and would feel odd if they were singled out. But many stepmoms do want to be appreciated on this day and don't want to be thought of as so far removed from a maternal figure that they can't somehow inhabit the same holiday.

It may be a sore point for moms to share Mother's Day because they already feel as if no one's noticing their contributions, especially if their children are younger and lack a father figure to prompt them to make cards or gifts. It's difficult to see another woman stepping into your role, without an invitation. And it can be hard to watch your ex making more of an effort to celebrate the day with his wife than he ever did before with you.

But the fact remains: we live in a world rife with divorce and remarriage. It's high time then, that we recognize there are two women taking care of our children and give each of them their due for a job well done.

So what can you do to make this day easier?

For stepmoms:

Own your holiday: Tell your family you want to celebrate Stepmother's Day and what you'd like to have happen.

Petition card companies: let Hallmark know they're overlooking a major segment of the population. (If nothing else, they're missing out on an awesome marketing opportunity!)

Send a card: if you happen to think your stepchildren's mom is raising great kids, sending her a card or email message saying so might really be appreciated.

A child does not have the maturity of an adult: If you're a custodial stepmom who wants to be acknowledged on Mother's Day because you're doing the lion's share of the caretaking, please keep in mind that stepkids might feel guilty celebrating you due to loyalty binds.

For divorced moms:

Keep your expectations in check: If your kids are really young and you're still single, or your partner isn't the best at taking the initiative and helping your kids honor the day, reach out to family and friends and, just like the stepmoms, ask for what you want and take action to make it happen.

Send her a card: Even if you're at war with the stepmom in your kid's lives, if you see her working hard to take good care of them, acknowledge her efforts with a card, text or email message.

Focus on what you have now: There are probably many things you can find to be grateful for in your relationships with your kids, so put your attention there, instead of comparing how each woman is being treated.

There's room for both stepmoms and divorced moms to be recognized, in their own way, on whichever day they choose. But like it or not, we need to ask for what we want to ensure that it happens, even though doing so might initially feel contrived and we fear lessening the importance of the gesture.

If we're to thrive in this dual-household environment, we must all adjust to these changing times. Both divorced moms and stepmoms deserve to be fully honored for our contributions and all that we bring to our families.

 
 
 
FOLLOW DIVORCE
Mother's Day. As if divorced moms and stepmoms needed yet one more reason to feel at odds with each other. For moms (whether divorced or not), Mother's Day might mean blackened toast and watery coff...
Mother's Day. As if divorced moms and stepmoms needed yet one more reason to feel at odds with each other. For moms (whether divorced or not), Mother's Day might mean blackened toast and watery coff...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:27 PM on 05/18/2012
September 13, 2000 Stepmother's Day was entered into the Congressional Record. It is a real holiday. Hallmark doesn't think there is a market for stepmothers despite looking at marriage statistics. This is my fourth year as a stepmom. I do more than my stepson's bio-mom does. His teachers adore and trust me. My husband supports me, I am no more or less a parent than he is. My in-laws haven't quite figured out that I am much more than a glorified daycare provider or a cool nanny. I love my stepson as if he were my own. And, yes, one day a year, I'd like to have THAT kind of recognition whether it be on Mother's Day or a holiday that was created just for us stepmothers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
linnwood
03:25 PM on 05/14/2012
There are birth mothers that deserve to be celebrated and stepmothers who don't......There are stepmothers that deserve to be celebrated and birth mothers who don't......Go with the one that works for you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Trixiebelle
01:45 PM on 05/14/2012
I don't like Mother's Day. I lost my mother 7 years ago and I am a stepmother with no children of my own. My oldest stepdaughter (28) never remembers me and she lived with us for three years. My youngest stepdaughter (24) always remembers me. It's an odd day. I want to be appreciated and recognized and yet at the same time, I am not really a mother. This year on mother's day my husband and I went to a movie and hung around a bookstore, my favorite thing to do. I'm glad it's over,.
notamused1001
I probably won't reply to angry responses.
01:14 PM on 05/14/2012
Yes, we should celebrate step-moms as well. Just don't eat their poisoned apples.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fallenarches
breaking it down, one fact at a time.
07:30 PM on 05/13/2012
Here's a solution... my husband brought me flowers today as a way of thanking me for what I do to support him in his efforts to be a good father to his son. Given that I didn't like my own children guilt-tripped into Mother's Day nonsense, as if they don't make me feel loved, needed and appreciate every day of their 27 and 29 year old lives, my husband's bouquet is above and beyond the call of duty, but it is sweet. My husband is WAY more appreciative of that support than my stepson is, and that's fine by me. His father is the person I'm going to spend the rest of my life with.
photo
Shadow Diver
When The Going Gets Weird, The Weird Turn Pro
08:22 AM on 05/13/2012
All this is kind of humorous when you consider that the reality is that Mothers Day is nothing more than a made up holiday, created by Hallmark, to boost sales.
10:19 PM on 05/12/2012
Absolutely! I'm very close to both of mine. They've been integral in my life.
01:33 AM on 05/12/2012
Didn't we just discuss this a few days ago?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fenrir Lokison
I luv the sci fi of Evolution and the Big Bang
08:05 PM on 05/11/2012
I gave gifts to both my aunty (who was my second mom) and my mom. I make no distinction.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
katieandtom
05:48 PM on 05/11/2012
why make it so complicated? honor your mother.
photo
SingleMomBooks
Author, The Successful Single Mom book series
05:28 PM on 05/11/2012
Mother's Day is a celebration of moms -- all moms, whether they became a (step-)mom by marriage (which I did), or a mom by giving birth (which I also did), or a single mom whose ex is with a new woman (I also did this). Let's stop trying to figure out who needs to be celebrated and just celebrate everyone.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DSevere
Deviant mind
01:08 PM on 05/14/2012
Exactly. For instance, I always had a difficult relationship with my late mother -- but my mother-in-law and I get along great; I think of her as the sane, supportive mom I never had before. So I always send her stuff on Mother's Day because I really love and appreciate her.
04:33 PM on 05/11/2012
I'm fortunate that I have a great relationship w/my stepson--he's such a great kid! However, he's not my child and he has one Mom that he calls Mom and who he buys a gift for on Mother's Day. I never expected anything on this day and he calls me by my first name. On other occasions like my birthday or holidays, he gets me a gift and card that I appreciate very much.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fenrir Lokison
I luv the sci fi of Evolution and the Big Bang
07:59 PM on 05/11/2012
I think stepmoms deserve gifts.
04:18 PM on 05/11/2012
I feel like it's a day that should be special to the kids mom, I'm all for other people having their own feelings about it and if they feel like they should be acknowledged then I say that's okay too. But I would never want to step on their Moms toes on this one. I love my step sons very much and I know that they love me :) That's all I need.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eagle48
04:11 PM on 05/11/2012
My stepson always used to spend Mother's Day with us because what his mom wanted for Mother's Day was the day for herself. Now that he has grown up, finished college and moved away, I really miss having him at our Mother's Day brunch.
03:34 PM on 05/11/2012
I don't see what's so difficult about this. If you are a child of divorced parents, you spend the day with your mother, but you call your step-mother and send her a card and a thoughtful gift. That's what I've always done, and my step-mother has always appreciated the recognition, but gets that I want to spend the day with my mother; my mother has never had a problem with my acknowledging the other maternal figure in my life, and in fact was the one who encouraged it the first Mother's day after my father's remarriage.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rickpark1
09:00 PM on 05/11/2012
how true a card and a phone call won't break the bank....