More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
James Moore

GET UPDATES FROM James Moore
 

Whodunnit to Herman?

Posted: 11/02/11 10:54 PM ET

A friend is fond of saying, "There is no truth in politics, there is only winning." He's only partly correct. Politics does have one truth in the modern era and it is simply that candidates will smear each other and do whatever is necessary to win. Of course, they don't take these actions themselves but they enlist dirt devils and leakers and unprincipled researchers who deliver portfolios of feces to their clients. And then they begin the smear campaign.

Hell, Karl Rove built a career on these practices.

The sexual harassment story about Herman Cain didn't come out of nowhere. Cain and his campaign manager are blaming Rick Perry's team, which is not unreasonable. The numbers Cain has been carrying to the top of the polls are a lot of disaffected Perry supporters who left the governor after he didn't back down from his tuition plan for children of illegal immigrants. If Cain falters, those voters will be forced to reconsider Perry.

But there has to be a decent sized universe of people who knew about the allegations against Cain that were leveled when he was at the National Restaurant Association. Any one of them, a disgruntled board member who wanted Cain removed, an employee who didn't get an advancement, or a secretary who didn't care for flirting, might have dropped the rough outlines of the story on the Politico reporter. More likely, it was one of the two women who got settlements from NRA and didn't want to see Cain as president and they picked up the phone and called the reporter and agreed to talk under certain conditions. That's the most probable scenario.

But it could have been Rick Perry's campaign or Mitt Romney's or Newt Gingrich and maybe even Ron Paul. Third party surrogates do the distasteful work for candidates so that those seeking elected office can stand on principle and deny any involvement. When George W. Bush was running for governor of Texas against Ann Richards, Karl Rove started a whisper campaign in the coffee shops of East Texas that Richards was a lesbian. Just look at all the gays and lesbians she has appointed, he suggested. The buzz finally turned into a vibration and then a bit of an earthquake and went public. W was able to simply stand back and say, "I don't know anything about it. I don't think the governor's gay." That only made the story more real and she was politically wounded in East Texas, which has long been essential to win any statewide office.

Rove facilitated Perry's transition from Democrat to Republican in Texas politics and was working with an aggressive FBI agent who had launched an investigation into Perry's opponent for the office of Texas Agriculture Commissioner. During Perry's first statewide election in 1990, he and Rove always had information about the investigation before it was made public. Rove frequently called reporters to talk about subpoenas before they had even been issued while Perry was standing in front of microphones talking about how he'd clean up the office and there'd be no federal investigations when he became agriculture commissioner. The FBI showed up in the Agriculture Commissioner Jim Hightower's office with subpoenas the day he was out of town to announce his reelection campaign. Rove and Perry leaked new material to reporters covering that story almost every day, and it destroyed the reelection of incumbent Hightower and gave Rick Perry his first statewide office in Texas. Perry knows how to leak material to reporters and he knows whom to use to get that job done efficiently and clandestinely with plausible deniability. Rove taught him.

Herman Cain is blaming his ex-senatorial consultant, who joined the Perry campaign two weeks ago, for doing the leak to Politico. Seems a little too obvious for a political professional to time something so poorly, even though Cain says he shared info on the harassment allegations with Anderson during the senate race. But what in the hell does it matter? Cain had to know this information was going to come out from someone during a presidential race. If he didn't, he's too naïve to be president. And his handling of this story doesn't create confidence in how he might manage a national crisis from the White House. Politico approached him 10 days before the story was published and asked for a response and there was nothing until the ham-handed iterations of the narrative that unfolded over the course of one news cycle.

Cain can blame Perry. And he might be right. But it doesn't really matter who did it. The information was there and he ought to have planned his messaging for when it went public. And he didn't. Now he is casting blame and parsing his language to escape incrimination.

Maybe that friend was right. "There is no truth in politics, there is only winning."

Also at: http://www.moorethink.com

 
 
 

Follow James Moore on Twitter: www.twitter.com/moorethink

 
 
  • Comments
  • 145
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
photo
ttsgw
Atheist and secular humanist
09:53 AM on 11/04/2011
I guess Herman considers being president as a cool thing. No more than that really.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:16 AM on 11/04/2011
There are so many different and revealing aspects to this very important story on "many" levels.

Since we have been observing the politics of a Presidential Election taking place, so WE the voters can choose the Candidate/ Political Party that we want elect to LEAD our Country, and since an enormous percentage of the job of being the President is to deal with and make decisions about hugely important and complicated, and sometimes potentially LIFE threatening, world issues, with the world's "leaders" friends AND ENEMIES....

making the right decision about WHO we elect to be the President and WHICH political PARTY do we want to set the "tone" and image, FOR US as a Nation, the agenda, for OUR COUNTRY'S "progress"
and who "Presidential candidate" and which "Political Party"... is intelligent enough and best capable of anticipating and steadily navigating the problems and "making" those hugely COMPLEX and important decisions on "OUR" behalf, domestically, and ESPECIALLY "foreign"...since like it or not, we live in a GLOBAL environment now with GLOBALLY connected challenges that affects ALL of us.

This Cain Scandal exemplifies the INEPT, uninformed, CHILDISH, embarrassing, SELF absorbed focus on TRIVIA, Slogans, Personality contests, and divisive games on display by the Republican PARTY and it's CANDIDATES, while our Country is "literally STRUGGLING to survive" in the WHOLE BIG WORLD PICTURE...while MILLIONS of Americans ALL over the Country are literally out in the streets saying...

"WE THE PEOPLE" are SINKING here...ENOUGH!"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nighthawlk
08:39 AM on 11/04/2011
Typical Republican's shifting the attention off the real subject to make him appear victimized.
TooManyTequilas
In Tequilas Veritas!
12:38 AM on 11/04/2011
This was never anything but a "vanity" candidacy from the get-go, designed merely to enrich ol' Herm by raising him up to that right-wing pantheon where the speaking tours, book sales, and Fox News appearances full of fulsome praise for his "story" can continue to stroke that ego. Not to mention the potential $$$ that he'll be raising in private donations from the suckers that he won't ever have to return. It was the thought of him singing his way through Presidential press conferences, however, that finally got me.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pennsanic
Be nice to the US or we'll bring you democracy too
08:31 AM on 11/04/2011
Apparently the guy spent more time promoting his books on the "campaign trail" than anything else. He's a motivational speaker, for heaven's sake--he gave up the pizza gig 15 years ago.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael D OBrien
Hey hey, my my
10:35 PM on 11/03/2011
Who did this to Herman Cain?
Herman Cain did this to Herman Cain!
The truth is the truth. The problem with Herman, like on so many issues, is HIS truth NEVER seems to stop 'evolving!'
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sobaytransplant
Obama 2012! Accept no substitute!!
06:57 PM on 11/03/2011
I do think you are a bit off base as far as the REASON why the leaked happened at this time. You seemed to think that it was probably one of the women who didn't want to see him become president, but I find that doubtful. Everyone is pointing fingers at everyone else, but I think it's more likely that it came from the RNC itself, probably by way of Karl Rove. C’mon… they were NEVER going to let Cain get the nomination. He can't WIN because he's too extreme for mainstream America. He also has no political experience and Obama would wipe the floor with him. (Let's face it... the majority of Americans won't go for that "abolish minimum wage and pay people whatever you feel like" malarkey.) When Cain started to become a problem for the party’s brand, the order was given to release the information and take him out of the running. They've had this info all along... just didn't use it until it was needed. If he DOESN'T drop out, they will start bringing more and more info out until he throws in the towel. I'm pretty sure Perry's camp wasn't involved - I think Perry is their next target. Then Bachmann. They are just thinning the herd over there…
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:45 AM on 11/04/2011
Faved. Very astute comments. The Republican Party has been THE Party of personal destruction and dirty politics for decades.

In this case Herman Cain himself actually gave them real ammunition to use with his own behavior, so Herman Cain has NO ONE to BLAME but himself....but that really wouldn't have mattered because if Republicans (the old Party establishment THUGS that are still very much alive and well) do not have REAL GUTTER politics ammunition to use in their cross-hairs of personal destruction, they just make it up, NO PROBLEM, about their own Party's candidates, as well as about Democrats. Herman would have been toast anyway.
Look no farther then what they did to John McCain in the 2000 Republican Primary.

VOLUMES could be written about the insidious cynical tactics and corrupt political strategy of the Republican power group, that's been behind the curtain for decades.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
M Cubed
My shampoo is gluten-free!
06:44 PM on 11/03/2011
Well, at least we know how Mr. Cain would react to the proverbial three o'clock phone call.............."What phone?"
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pennsanic
Be nice to the US or we'll bring you democracy too
08:31 AM on 11/04/2011
Or...don't speak to me unless I speak to you first!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:51 AM on 11/04/2011
Yes...that's definitely one occasion Herman's continuous MISSPOKEN giant mistakes due to his LACK of actual knowledge, would endanger, maybe destroy, all of us.
photo
yabastid
TexasYankee
06:29 PM on 11/03/2011
Jim, I'm a fan and a fellow Texan.My bottom line is that I think I could probably tolerate a President Romney, but certainly not Perry. The others are probably not electable. I'll probably even buy your book, as I dislike the protagonist and love the title.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:01 AM on 11/04/2011
While Romney is probably the least offensive, as well as more intelligent then the rest of the Conservative candidates (except for John Huntsman) Romney has no real convictions. He chooses to be a TOOL, not a LEADER, in his never-ending desire to be "a President" CHANGING his beliefs and his policies with the wind in whatever direction he thinks it's blowing towards the White House.

When people say Romney has no "core" they are exactly right. That's an accurate assessment of Romney's character.

Of course THAT would also be a reason for the Republican establishment BOSSES to support him.
10:27 AM on 11/04/2011
A comment was made by one of the candidates that these "introductory" broadcasts were intended ONLY for the Republicans, not for the public at large, and reflect ONLY the ways in which the candidates are attempting to secure the support of the "base." My question for them is "Don't you think that the "others" are listening, watching, and assessing the mental health and ethicacy of the candidates during these "debates" too?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aintlate
06:15 PM on 11/03/2011
Hedunnit to his own self! That's how de do!
02:57 PM on 11/03/2011
Corporate mindset - I'm the CEO, make it go away.
Political mindset - I'm a former CEO. It went away 20 years ago. It will stay that way.
Political mindset - I'm trying to get elected in the primary. I need my people to find something that will make my opponent go away.
Political mindset - I'm a voter. I want to vote for this guy. The other guys are making my guy look bad. It's not his fault. It happened 20 years ago.
Political mindset - I'm a voter. I want to vote for someone else in the same party. Heh, heh! This guy is finished.
Political mindset - I'm a voter. I would never vote for this guy nor anyone else in his party. This guy is finished. Too bad he didn't have a few more months to damage all of the other candidates.
Corporate mindset - I had to work for this guy 20 years ago. He was a jerk and he treated me badly. The money I got then was nice, but I had to change jobs and I felt horrible for months.
Political mindset - I had to work for this guy 20 years ago. He was a jerk and he treated me badly. I'll never forget it. The money I got then was nice, but I had to change jobs and I felt horrible for months. Now he wants to be President? Right. Not while I can use a telephone...
02:00 PM on 11/03/2011
There may be a Phase II to this story if accusers are able and willing to come forward with their stories.

Glad OWS is keeping the media's eyes on the most important issues of our times. Otherwise it would be all Herman all the time.

My 4th attempt to comment on this article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allen Jenkins
Virtual Ferroequinologist
01:29 PM on 11/03/2011
Given time and willingness to accept the facts, this will too surely pass...in about two weeks according to Dick Morris....

HERMAN CAIN 2012!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sobaytransplant
Obama 2012! Accept no substitute!!
07:19 PM on 11/03/2011
But... who are you going to vote for when he is forced to drop out of the race? (Becuase the GOP will never, EVER let their nomination go to a man who stands no chance of winning.) I don't really care if this guy is guilty of harassment 20 years ago or not. He IS guilty of lying and trying to cover up his own past. NOT QUALIFIED to hold the office of President of the United States. Sorry.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pennsanic
Be nice to the US or we'll bring you democracy too
08:33 AM on 11/04/2011
What does Sherry Rowlands think?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allen Jenkins
Virtual Ferroequinologist
12:44 PM on 11/04/2011
I'm glad he listened to Hillary...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
umbriago
The Tooth Shall Set My Fee
01:13 PM on 11/03/2011
I don't understand something. These harassment events are in the public record, are they not? And if not, Cain discussed them with at least one campaign aide during a senate bid several years ago, to prepare for their inevitable surfacing.

So what's the big fuss now? Why is Cain pretending he doesn't know anything about it, if the info is already out there? And why is his campaign claiming "smear" when the events are actual, and the knowledge of them has been around for years?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sobaytransplant
Obama 2012! Accept no substitute!!
07:21 PM on 11/03/2011
Well, because he originally jumped into the race as a tool to sell books... and then he started believing his own lies and his head inflated to the point where he actually thought he might become President. He lost his mind after that. Power corrupts.
12:53 PM on 11/03/2011
Looking at the entire slate of candidates one wonders "these people all want to be the head of the free world?"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:05 AM on 11/04/2011
a terrifying thought isn't it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Monte Mathews
12:48 PM on 11/03/2011
Does anyone have the sneaking suspicion that Herman Cain's campaign was really about selling books and that he's as surprised at his runaway success as anyone? That might explain why you would be so ill-prepared for the inevitable.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sobaytransplant
Obama 2012! Accept no substitute!!
07:22 PM on 11/03/2011
Absolutely! He just started believing his own hype after awhile.