Over the last few decades old-age pensions have begun to look more and more like just another unemployment benefits program -- and one without a set expiration date to worry about.
Benefits for those "disabled from work by age and invalidity" were first introduced in Germany in 1889. Then, being over 65 often meant a person could no longer work. These days it often just means one is being paid not to work.
Conventional unemployment insurance is expensive. In the U.S., repeated extensions and an unusually high unemployment rate set the price tag at $92 billion in fiscal 2012 alone. Still, that was only about 0.5 percent of GDP. Even in generous Europe these benefits amounted to just 1.6 percent of GDP in 2011.
There are also several good reasons for these programs, ranging from the old-fashioned -- income support and efficient automatic stabilizer -- to the modern -- better outcomes for job hunters. But make benefits too generous or extend them for too long and perverse effects set in. Europe is a case in point with unemployment rates ostensibly returning to the chronically high levels of the 1980s and 1990s.
What to say then about retirement benefits schemes?
First, they usually require a lot more money. Excluding disability, the U.S. Social Security Administration paid about $670 billion in Old Age and Survivors benefits to nearly 47 million people in 2013. About 20 million of them are retirees or survivors younger than 70. By contrast there were fewer than 4 million unemployment insurance beneficiaries in 2013.
The economic case for retirement pensions has also become much weaker. When work placed high physical demands on the body, old age was often synonymous with an inability to sustain oneself. Clearly, this is no longer true. Medicine and technology have both slowed physical decline and transformed the workplace.
Some will argue that public annuity programs offer an attractive form of insurance protecting individuals from outliving their savings. But this fails to explain why benefits are paid to relatively young individuals who are perfectly able to work and support themselves. Longevity risk is also fairly easy to manage so there is no obvious reason why these annuities cannot be purchased in private markets.
Finally, it is true that public pensions have become an important (and well hidden) form of income redistribution. But much of this can, and should, be accomplished instead through taxes and other existing programs -- unless the goal is to preserve the lack of transparency.
There are then good reasons to rethink and generally scale down existing public pension programs. Two important qualifiers must be added however.
First, none of these arguments applies to disability insurance for which there are more clear merits. Accidents, wars and epidemics can happen at any time and it seems plausible that the state is better able to pool these risks across different individuals and generations than the private market. The current system is prone to abuse and requires monitoring. But the core idea remains sound.
Second, a promise is a promise. This conversation must be about younger generations. Regardless of financial cost, we must honor our debts to everyone who contributed to the current system. A society that reneges on its obligations to some of its members has taken the first step towards authoritarianism.
These caveats aside, public pension programs must change. As it stands they lead to an enormous waste, not so much of money, but of human capital.
An obvious place to begin is by changing existing formulas so that benefits are not reduced when individuals choose to work until full retirement age. Alternatively, we could offer much more attractive benefits at retirement for those choosing to work longer. Both options are easy to introduce and mild experimentation can be used to optimize their design. But this can be only a start. More extensive restructuring must to be considered for future generations and others have studied the issue more than me.
Of course everyone, young and old, is free to choose not to work. Some may well prefer to concentrate their work over a few short years, and live off their private savings thereafter. Many sports and pop stars do just that. But, except for periods of child rearing or debilitating illnesses, there is no reason why society should incentivize this behavior.
In the 21st century, age is no longer a reason not to work. If Ronald Reagan and Hillary Clinton can cope with the demands of the Oval Office at 69, there is no compelling reason why millions of other talented seniors cannot be productively engaged in the workforce too. We must find ways to encourage them to do so. The future of our fast-aging societies will probably depend on that.
Vibe: Old West; urban flair Mingle with the natives: By sharing a bike. The city's new bike share program lets you pedal all over town for just dollars a day. Sunny days per year: 227 Best daytime lark: El Mercado (which the city claims is the biggest Mexican marketplace outside Mexico) in Old Market Square. Median home price: $135,000 Local flavor: Brunch at the Mad Hatter's Tea House and Café, with a $10 fishbowl mimosa Impress friends and family with: The endless selection of restaurants and patio dining on the famous River Walk
Vibe: Midwestern cozy with a high-tech spark Secret affordability sauce: Millionaires with a conscience. Thanks to civic-minded executives, private donations fund parks, arts, and sports Mingle with the natives: Hoist a local beer at Mr. Toad's, in the heart of the Old Market area Sunny days per year: 220 Best daytime lark: Seniors pay $12.50 at the world-class Henry Doorly Zoo; don't miss walking the rope bridge in the Rain Forest exhibit Median home price: $123,500 Local flavor: Wheatfields' baked goods rock; so does its senior menu, where a Grandmere Scramble or a Dusseldorf casserole goes for $8.50 Impress friends and family with: The area's numerous start-up companies, earning it the "Silicon Prairie" nickname
Vibe: Contemporary arts meet Western charm Secret affordability sauce: Two-thirds of the county land is public, making recreation a bargain; a recent 20 percent drop in housing prices Mingle with the natives at: The Rockslide Brewery downtown Sunny days per year: 260 Best daytime lark: Wander among the extensive (and quirky) outdoor sculptures Median home price: $159,800 Local flavor: Local vineyards get plenty of press, but make sure you snack on the region's impressive strawberries, sweet cherries, and peaches. (An outlying town is even named Fruita.) Impress friends and family with: The views of the Grand Valley
Vibe: Green not grimy, the city's 88 distinct neighborhoods create a European atmosphere Secret affordability sauce: Stable, diverse economy--since 2008, only Austin and Houston have added jobs faster Mingle with the natives at: Frick Park, in the city. In the summer, check out the Bowling Green (lessons are free for beginners) and in the winter, sled down the hill near Beechwood Boulevard Sunny days per year: 161 Best daytime lark: PNC Park, home of the Pirates, ranked as the No. 1 baseball field in the country by ESPN. Bleacher seats from $14 Median home price: $106,500 Local flavor: Eggs and kielbasa for breakfast at DeLuca's in the Strip district Impress your friends and family with: The view as you emerge from the Fort Pitt Tunnel. The New York Times once pronounced Pittsburgh "the only city with an entrance."
Vibe: Funky hippie meets world traveler. Secret affordability sauce: The country's sixth largest college--The University of Florida--fuels an economy more durable than most Southern cities. Mingle with the natives at: The Swamp, aka UF's Ben Hill Griffin Stadium. Tim Tebow isn't the only person to get fit running up and down the stairs here. Walk or run all you want--for free. Sunny days per year: 242 Best daytime lark: At the Florida Museum of Natural History, seniors pay $9 to watch butterflies released into the Butterfly Rain Forest Exhibit Median home price: $125,500 Local flavor: A Cuban sandwich ($8.95) at Emiliano's Café, a pioneer in the pan-Latin food movement. Impress friends and family with: The dense urban canopy, where Northern hardwoods meet Southern tropics.
Follow Joao Gomes on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ProfJoaoGomes