More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jodie Evans

GET UPDATES FROM Jodie Evans
 

Obama Must Condemn Egyptian Military

Posted: 11/21/11 10:48 PM ET

By Medea Benjamin & Jodie Evans, co-founders of CODEPINK

As we watch the Egyptian police and military viciously attack democracy activists on the streets of Cairo, using U.S. weapons, it is outrageous that the Obama administration has failed to issue a strong condemnation of this latest attempt to crush a revolution that has inspired people around the world, including millions of Americans.

During the fateful 18 days in January and February when Egyptians took to the streets by the millions to topple the brutal Mubarak dictatorship, President Obama remained largely silent, refusing to call directly for democracy until it was clear that young Egyptians were about to topple the dictator's three-decade-long rule.

In the months since then, as thousands of Egyptians have been attacked, imprisoned, sexually assaulted and murdered by their government, the United States has not merely remained silent, but has continued to provide crucial diplomatic, economic and military aid to the regime responsible for these crimes.

The latest Egyptian protests were sparked by growing anger over signs that the military leadership plans to hold on to power indefinitely. The military rulers say they will relinquish power once presidential elections are held, but have refused to commit to a plan and a timetable for handing over power to a democratically elected government.

The first of many rounds of voting for parliament is scheduled to begin November 28, but the military has not agreed to form a new government based on these elections. Moreover, it is trying to limit any civilian government from having control over the military's budget. And it has postponed a presidential election to an indefinite time late in 2012 or in 2013.

Now that the façade of a democratic transition has been ripped away and Egyptians are once again battling the military government in Tahrir Square for the future of their country, with at least 35 civilians killed since Saturday. The Obama administration remains as quiet as it was in the early days of the revolution. Such silence is both morally indefensible and politically and strategically disastrous for the United States.

The United States, with $1.3 billion in military aid to Egypt every year, supplies a large part of the Egyptian military budget. But it refuses to use its considerable leverage. During Defense Secretary Leon Panetta's visit to Egypt in October, he actually praised the Egyptian military . "I really do have full confidence in the process that the Egyptian military is overseeing," he said, "I think they're making good progress."

On Monday, November 21, White House spokesman Jay Carney only mustered up the courage to call for restraint from "all sides" -- as if the pro-democracy activists were somehow equally responsible for the violence. When asked if the generals should specify the date for a presidential election, Carney replied, "I don't want to dictate specifics to Egypt."

As during the Mubarak era, the administration appears to believe that U.S. interests, including Egypt's peace accord with Israel, are more important than the lives of the Egyptian people.

The march for freedom in Egypt cannot be stopped and when Egyptians finally rid themselves of the military government and establish a democratic system, the United States will have few friends in Egypt, or the Arab world more broadly, if it is seen as having supported the military rather than the people at this pivotal moment.

A principled U.S. position would be to immediately issue a strong condemnation of the violence unleashed by the Egyptian military on its people. The U.S. government should suspend all military aid to the Egyptian government until it stops attacking peaceful protesters, and until it releases the 12,000-plus citizens jailed since Mubarak's ouster and commits to handing over power to a transitional civilian government as soon as parliamentary elections are completed. President Obama should coordinate with other Western allies and supporters of the Egyptian government to develop a clear and strong policy in support of a rapid transition to democracy and apply the full weight of international diplomatic, economic and legal pressure on the military junta towards that end.

Anything less will be a stain on the United States that will haunt this administration, and the United States more broadly, for years to come.

Join us in signing this letter urging President Obama to condemn the military crackdown and stand with Egypt's brave citizens struggling for democracy.

Medea Benjamin and Jodie Evans are cofounders of CODEPINK: Women for Peace.

 

Follow Jodie Evans on Twitter: www.twitter.com/codepinkalert

By Medea Benjamin & Jodie Evans, co-founders of CODEPINK As we watch the Egyptian police and military viciously attack democracy activists on the streets of Cairo, using U.S. weapons, it is outrageou...
By Medea Benjamin & Jodie Evans, co-founders of CODEPINK As we watch the Egyptian police and military viciously attack democracy activists on the streets of Cairo, using U.S. weapons, it is outrageou...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 93
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
08:10 PM on 11/22/2011
You've gotta be kidding Jodie. Sometimes while I'm watching the news I can't tell if its Egypt Syria or the US beating people in the streets If he did that he would need to condemn Bloomberg, Oakland and Berkeley In Oakland the Police hurt a Veteran.
02:06 PM on 11/22/2011
he will not do that because thats whats coming here
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
rtgmath
There has got to be a better way!
02:02 PM on 11/22/2011
If Obama will not even condemn police brutality and the militarization of the police here in the United States, there is no way he can condemn Egypt's military for their response. Not rationally, at least.

Obama NEEDS to condemn the violence here at home, and make the 99% here in the US more important than the 1%.

THEN, and only then, could he speak with any conviction that the world would notice. Anything less and he would be reviled at home and abroad for his hypocrisy.

President Obama is better than any of the Republican Challengers. But what I would give for a Democratic challenger with some guts and real convictions!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CBasilJr
62 Retired Vet
02:58 PM on 11/22/2011
He has guts and real conviction.

He also realizes that the Egyptian army is faced with the same choice which was faced by Attaturk (?SP) so long ago.

Attaturk was faced with opposition from Islamic fundamentalists as well as pro-democracy advocates.

Islamic fundamentalists were going to be the obvious victors in any open conflict.

He chose maintaining his military superiority as he did not want to see the blood bath which would follow any victory by the fundamentalists.

The Egyptian army is faced with those same choices, and I believe that they will seek another ruler like Mubarik because that type of tyranny is the only one which can suppress the fundamentalists and allow everyone a choice of beliefs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CBasilJr
62 Retired Vet
02:59 PM on 11/22/2011
Without intelligence AND wisdom, anarchy reigns.
02:02 PM on 11/22/2011
Obama needs to mind his own business. It is quite obvious it doesn't matter what the US says or does. These people know nothing but bitterness and fighting. Now we should be able to see why ME countries have rulers with iron hands. It is the only way you can keep them from killing each other. We just need to make sure they don't all get nuclear weapons. That would be the end of everyone. Are there any sane people in the Islamic nation.
01:20 PM on 11/22/2011
It would seem somewhat hypocritical to me.
08:12 PM on 11/22/2011
Exactly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marignymitch
E pluribus unum percent
12:52 PM on 11/22/2011
You're kidding, right? Obama can't bring himself to criticize militarized police tactics at home. He supports authoritarianism.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cheryl tobin
Alpha Dog with my pack!
02:10 PM on 11/22/2011
It seems rather hypocritical to condemn other governments for using force when everyone knows what is going on here in America!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ennis438
12:46 PM on 11/22/2011
Again, Jodie, you are 100% correct, as usual. I could not help to hear a CNN report today that stated one of these cannisters that these Egyptian police goon squad shot at freedom fighters had "Jamestown Pennsylvania" written on it. A prime example of what our foreign aid is going. Why the silence on Egypt while the vocal attacks on Syria and Iran? Another American double standard. Egypt needs to be held to task for this brutal terrorism against freedom fighters.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JuniperSunshine
Libertarian Homeschooling Mom
12:43 PM on 11/22/2011
So giving them billions of dollars a year is "not doing enough" for the Egyptian people? What else should we do? Believe it or not, we don't actually have the right to police the entire world.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
erehwon2
12:32 PM on 11/22/2011
It's rather quaint that the author seems to think that the Egyptian military is the only thing standing in the way of unicorns and rainbows and free democracy in Egypt.
11:55 AM on 11/22/2011
I suspect that if the military stepped aside, the MB would wind up controlling the government, and democracy would gradually gice way to radical Islamism. Military sharing of power could help prevent that and help nurture democracy, but it has no credibility and the people are impatient. I suspect no good is going to come of this either way.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cathleen
11:33 AM on 11/22/2011
"it is outrageous that the Obama administration has failed to issue a strong condemnation of this latest attempt to crush a revolution that has inspired people around the world, including millions of Americans."

This would be using a "dove".

Thank you Medea and Jodie for all you do for peace and justice. And for your commitment to educating the public about what the results of the US's unnecessary wars and policies. Code Pink, Move over Aipac hit the justice balls out of the park
02:09 PM on 11/22/2011
obamas a dud. the great black hope has failed. he sold us a package and didn't deliver the goods. i have fired salespeople for doing the same.
photo
scottishboy
Born in the USA!
10:37 AM on 11/22/2011
Seriously? He's not going to condemn them, he needs them against Israel. Ask Samantha Powers about that.
10:08 AM on 11/22/2011
He needs to clean up and comment on his own back yard first. Otherwise, it's a little presumptuous to criticize other countries for their mistreatment of protesters.
Still no word on lawfully assembled protesters being pepper-sprayed in the face?
The silence is deafening.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sandy Hammer
perpetual student
11:27 AM on 11/22/2011
Exactly, and so conspicuous by it's absence. F&F
02:10 PM on 11/22/2011
i voted for obama, i thought he could handle the job but hes over his head and owned.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VoteLibertarian
Despite your politics, I like you anyway.
09:38 AM on 11/22/2011
why should he condemn them? he was the catalyst in their rise.
photo
kamachanda
Mr. President, Tear this Wall Street down!
09:25 AM on 11/22/2011
The belief that the "march for freedom in Egypt cannot be stopped" is quaint. It has been stopped before and is under a very effective attack in the United States. Freedom is a very vague concept with too many interpretations, the colonies reached for freedom by attempting to institute and grow the concept of equality under law. I think most people, seeing the fraud and thefts corporate executives and the very wealthy have gotten away with under deregulation would agree that equality under the law has been attacked and that the law now primarily exist as a controller of the "lower" classes.