More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
John Feffer

John Feffer

Posted: December 20, 2010 05:07 PM

2010-12-20-bigkorea.jpg
Ahnyoung-Joon/Associated Press

If you look closely at the AP photograph above of the South Korean marines conducting a drill on Yeonpyoeong island, you can see that their yellow headbands read tongil. That's the Korean word for reunification. With the South Korean government conducting another round of live-fire artillery drills in contested waters near North Korea, the message of the headband is unambiguous. Rather than waiting patiently for reunification to take place through negotiations, the Lee Myoung-bak administration wants to accelerate the process, by force if necessary.

When South Korea conducted live-fire drills in the area last month, North Korea responded by shelling Yeonpyeong island, killing two soldiers and two civilians. The South shelled back. This time around, the South disregarded pleas by China and Russia to postpone its military exercise. On Monday, it conducted 90 minutes of artillery shelling from Yeonpyeong island as South Korean jet fighters flew overhead. Despite initial threats to retaliate, North Korea has so far refrained from responding to what it has called a "despicable military provocation."

South Korea's resolve to go through with the test was simply a refusal to be bullied, argued many analysts, including former South Korean foreign minister Han Sung-Joo. "If each North Korean threat tied our hands, we would become hostage to their threats," he commented.

As the yellow headbands indicate, however, the current South Korean government is not just sending a message of deterrence. The Lee Myung-bak government, like its recent predecessors, sees an opportunity to break the stalemate on the peninsula. But unlike either the Kim Dae-Jung or Roh Moo-Hyun administration, Lee doesn't see a long, slow process of negotiating reunification.

When Lee looks north, he sees an ailing dictator, a struggling economy, and a desperate national-security apparatus. The WikiLeaks documents, meanwhile, suggested that China was losing patience with its North Korean ally. All of this contributed to last week's statement by the South Korean president that "unification is drawing near." The South Korean government is putting money into preparing for regime collapse in the north in much the way the Kim and Roh governments put money into engaging the north economically and politically.

The U.S. government has generally backed the South Korean government's more aggressive posture. Twenty U.S. soldiers participated in the recent live-fire drill. Joint South Korean-U.S. military exercises in these contested wars have ratcheted up the tensions. And at the United Nations, the United States has pushed for a condemnation of North Korea's November 23 artillery attack to be included in a statement otherwise designed to calm the waters. China has blocked consensus, sensibly pointing out that such a statement would only roil the waters more.

At the same time, New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson just returned from Pyongyang with the outlines of a possible deal that could bring the disputing parties back to the negotiating table. North Korea is willing to allow back UN nuclear inspectors, send fuel rods out of the country, and establish a hot line between the two Koreas and the United States. While in Pyongyang, Richardson urged the North Korean leadership to show "maximum restraint" in dealing with South Korea's drills.

Today North Korea followed Richardson's advice. Now it's the South Korean and U.S. turn to show maximum restraint. By following up on the offer on the table, all sides can step away from the precipice and go back to pursuing reunification the old-fashioned way: by talking, not fighting.

Subscribe to FPIF's World Beat here.
Sign up with FPIF on Facebook.
Follow FPIF on Twitter.
Follow John Feffer on Twitter.

 

Follow John Feffer on Twitter: www.twitter.com/johnfeffer

Ahnyoung-Joon/Associated Press If you look closely at the AP photograph above of the South Korean marines conducting a drill on Yeonpyoeong island, you can see that their yellow headbands read tongi...
Ahnyoung-Joon/Associated Press If you look closely at the AP photograph above of the South Korean marines conducting a drill on Yeonpyoeong island, you can see that their yellow headbands read tongi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 131
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
11:11 PM on 12/21/2010
This is a great article and I forwarded this to many of my friends in facebook and twitter. As a Korean American who is directly affected by the escalated tension on the Korean peninsula, I think this article is on point - that reunification should be achieved by talking, not fighting. The current Lee MB administration showcases its unpopularity. People do not trust the Lee administration's rhetoric any more. Reunification by force will cause another catastrophe to the whole people in the Korean peninsula for a while, as it did to Germany. Do we really want that? First of all, we need to have a peace treaty, some sort of trust building measure intact, so that more economic and cultural cooperations can occur between DPRK and ROK. Unfortunately, members of the Six Party Talks, China, Japan, U.S. gains so much from the maintaining the status quo. Hope Mr. Feffer's plea to the logic and reason (and also that of Selig Harrison. Bruce Cumings, Jimmy Carter) will be heard by the State Department in the Washington D.C. It is time for the U.S. to seriously think about economic way to spend taxpayers money abroad - not for war exercises and military bases, but for jobs and education here in the States. Peace is much more cheaper than going along with the Lee administration's aggressive military advances and provocations!
05:36 PM on 12/21/2010
As a Korean American and child of war survivor, I cannot support what Lee Myung-bak is doing. He clearly showed that he is willing to risk another war, and Obama and Clinton are happy to go along. Reunification has to be a process of mutual respect, reconciliation, and learning about each other. We were on our way after the 2000 summit until Lee Myung-bak took office and reversed course. The crazy lunatic dangerous leader is in the SOUTH. Thanks for a great article.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spriddler
05:57 PM on 12/21/2010
Right because Lee is the one torpedoing boats and shelling civilians,,, of wait...
05:21 PM on 12/21/2010
Once South Korea begins torpedoing North Korean ships - maybe I will buy your argument.
05:08 PM on 12/21/2010
Feffer offers a really good analysis that counteracts the popular media perspective. The reunification headbands clearly show how Lee Myung-bak is using reunification rhetoric to push for war, and clearly show what the 3 years of his presidency have been leading up to. His shift in policy toward North Korea after Kim Dae-jung and Roh Moo-hyun make it quite clear that he has contributed to instability in the Korean peninsula.
miloiki
sweet as can be
02:22 PM on 12/21/2010
Keeping things steady works for every one except the poor starving people of the North who are suffering under a despot. Time may be great for diplomats. They have the luxury of ignoring the pain.
photo
etiennemacchias
Just trying to make it through this crazy world
11:58 AM on 12/21/2010
Reunification, regardless of what means it's achieved, will benefit the Korean Peninsula in the long run. The economic and social disparities will cause initial tension and setbacks -- much like what Germany had to face -- but North Korea has much more fossil fuel deposits and arable land that the South can totally exploit. It'll be difficult at first, but it will eventually lead to prosperity for both sides.
11:27 PM on 12/21/2010
I respectfully disagree: the wrong reunification will make people's lives a lot harder. Koreans shall not exploit and discriminate the other Koreans, and there shall not be a second-class Koreans. When there is a much better way to achieve reunification, why should we go for a quick, band-aid solution? The economic and social disparities have not been completely solved in Germany and how long has Germany been reunified? It's easy for one person to detachedly observe, but it is a life-long struggle difficulties to people who would have to live through it.

Many scholars and government officials in both Korea have been doing researches regarding how to go about reunification, precisely because the means of reunification matters to the people who will live through it.

Reunification will eventually lead to prosperity for both sides, not to the government only, but for the people. The world will benefit from the reunification of Korea - definitely because U.S. can spend much less money on military spendings - or will have one less reason to keep it so high. I am a Korean American with a father and a mother who directly experienced the war. They still talk about war with such strong emotions. Korea need a peace treaty - to end the Korean War, at last. We really need not to have a war on Korean peninsula. John Feffer is exactly right. However slow, we will need to use talks. Not military threats, provocations, and unnecessary death.
11:52 AM on 12/21/2010
Give me a break. South Korea conduct live-fire drills, the North retaliated and shelled an island resulting in casualties. This time the South conducts more drills and the North "has so far refrained from responding to what it has called a "despicable military provocation."" How decent of them in light of the fact that earlier this year the North torpedoed a South Korean naval vessel (an act of war in anybody's book). But apparently that is OK, not even worth a mention in this highly biased article. Pure bilge!!
09:08 AM on 12/21/2010
It was helluva time getting the South and North "United"... with a lotta blood on all three ('3") sides!
1st side - adding western states without slavery
2nd side - keeping the south as "slave states"
3rd side - Slaves.
See "Succession Ball" in South Carolina. Interestingly, the USA backs the "Shelling."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Donald Fannin
09:07 AM on 12/21/2010
Of course you are the expert, not me. And the South Korean Politicians could not say so aloud. (Maybe only on Wikileaks) but I wonder if they really want reunification? We saw what Germany went thru when the east and west unified. Think how much worst off N.Korea is than E. Germany was. Maybe they are happier just having some family visits and sending some help to their poor northern cousins. But to actually ruin their own economy for a generation, may not be what the want. After all the Chinese could do it at any time and they don't want to. Just a thought.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TrekBear
10:08 AM on 12/21/2010
South Korea and China could jointly fund a reconstruction of the northern lands. By partnering, both nations would build rapport and trust.

Doing so is in both countries' interest: it stems the flow of likely refugees and creates a framework for development of the historically better of northern part of Korea.
02:51 PM on 12/21/2010
All those things may be true, and we're clearly outsiders, but there's been no hint that either country is interested in any joint effort to rescucitate the North. Donald is right, the North is a pauper, and the German reunification is a very good example to cite. It would be Nation-building - and we've seen how difficult THAT can be.
12:34 PM on 12/21/2010
China's primary interest in the region is stopping reunification. A reunified Korea would be yet another more powerful state on the Chinese borders. Yes the refugee situation in the event of reunification may be a problem, but the more long-term problem would be adding yet another stronger country onto the list of regional powers on Chinese maritime and land border. (Current list consists of Japan, Russia, and India)
photo
mfrantom
Proud Veteran, Minority, Southern and Conservative
08:36 AM on 12/21/2010
When you finally understand the evil dictatorship that is North Korea, you will understand why South Korea will not stand down.
08:35 AM on 12/21/2010
Oh no! ROK marines are wearing yellow headbands! I’m sure those capitalist running dogs will be surging across the 38th any day now. Nonsense. The NORKs are the problem and everyone knows it. South Korea has every right to demonstrate that it can defend itself.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
billygore2000
08:02 AM on 12/21/2010
I'm afraid even to wonder what it would be like to wake up this morning, as an ordinary person, in North Korea. The story signals anticipation of the beginning of the end for the regime there. That's encouraging. But the ordinary person waking up in North Korea today, closed off as it is, won't be able to share in the thought of good change ahead.
06:34 AM on 12/21/2010
Consider the position of China in this: On one hand, they don't want North Korea starting a nuclear war that will have consequences for them (perhaps even drawing them into a thermonuclear exchange), but on the other, they don't want a vibrant democracy sharing a border. They already have their hands full with Hong Kong and their few vocal local dissidents. Their ideal solution, then, is a continuation of the status quo. It is just as much a threat to them to have Korea unified under the South than to have a war.
In short, China will do all it can to prevent unification of the Korean peninsula.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Johnathan Plate
back just for the debt
07:48 AM on 12/21/2010
I don't think your looking at this right. China will do everything it can to prevent the population of North Korea to try and excape over its boarders.

That many poor refugees will distrupt Chinas internal security. And China also knows, no mater how big the South's economy has become, it can't afford on its own rebuilding North Korea.
09:07 AM on 12/21/2010
No, not at all, The country who does not want the unification of the Korean peninsula is USA. Because if it is unified, the USA army will have to withdraw from South Korean and Japan.

The only reason USA army staying in eastern Asia is the possible "threat" or "attack" from North Korea.

China is more than happy to see the unification of the Korean peninsula, because after that they don't have to give charity food, oil, steel etc any more. That is a big burden to them. According to the UN report, more than 50% of the humanitarian support for North Korea is China.
photo
JimInHouston
Arma virumque cano...
10:20 AM on 12/21/2010
So, where do you get all that information?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tulsey
I was Bill Hicks.
06:07 AM on 12/21/2010
China could stiffle this nonsense in a heart beat. Just another way to screw with us.
05:38 AM on 12/21/2010
The south is negotiating in the language the north respects and understands.