EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

John Vorhaus

GET UPDATES FROM John Vorhaus
 

It's Time We Started Calling them McCarthy

Posted: 8/16/10

Once again, President Obama has done the right thing, and once again he'll be eviscerated by the opinion- (read: noise-) makers on the right. In this case, he's come out in favor of building a mosque in Lower Manhattan, somewhere in the general vicinity of Ground Zero, thereby nefariously supporting "the right to build a place of worship and a community center on private property in lower Manhattan, in accordance with local laws and ordinances." Dangerous business, that "accordance with local law" stuff. According to the noisemakers, it must be stopped.

According to the noisemakers, Obama must want America to become a Muslim country or, provide operating bases for Muslim extremists (since all mosques are, right?) right here in the heart of America. Clearly, squeak the right, Obama has no respect for the dead of September 11. Obama is an apologist. Obama is weak. Obama is... oh, man it makes my head hurt to contemplate the non-stop vituperation sideshow they'll generate over this one.

But let's break it down. The issue is freedom of religion. Freedom of religion is one of this country's fundamental tenets. I believe in it. Don't you? Of course you do. Not surprisingly, so does our president, who has in this instance once again shown his knack for saying a thing that's simply and obviously right for no other reason than, yeah, it's simply and obviously right. Yet the noisemakers will savage him with it again. And we'll put up with it again. We'll lament their ability to torque any Obama action and make it sound evil, simply by shouting down reason and calling names in a loud voice.

Haven't we had enough of that? Isn't it time we shouted back? Isn't it time to acknowledge that this country's right wing is using the oldest trick in their playbook to advance their cause? It's called McCarthyism, pure and simple. It was self-aggrandizing when Senator Joe McCarthy went witch hunting in the 1950s, and it's self-aggrandizing now. And it lasted right up until the moment Army lawyer Joseph Welch stood up to him and, in a grand gesture of noticing the emperor's nudity, said, "Senator, have you no sense of decency?"

We need a little of that now. We need to start calling the right on their ridiculous nonsense. With my gift for reducing complex concepts to trivial one-liners, I propose we simply start calling them all McCarthy. Make it an insult: "McCarthy!" Raise it to the level of swear or slur. Call it "the M-word." Call it what you like, but use it every chance you get. Let it symbolize your disgust with the faction of opinion-makers in this country who twist reality to suit their political (and, let's not forget, financial) interests.

In fact, let's take it a step further. Play down to their level. Accuse them of using "big lie" tactics promulgated by a certain German named Goebbels. That's right, call them Nazis. And when you're done calling them Nazis, call them McCarthy again. Get right down there in the mud with them. They're so at home there, they won't mind the company, right?

Of course we already know this plan won't work. People like us are too sensible and self-aware to engage in mindless screeds and mean it. We always hear that little voice inside our heads saying, "Hang on a second now, you know that's not fair." Too bad the noisemakers don't hear that voice, or ignore it, giving them a freedom of attack that you and I will never enjoy. It lets them fight not fair.

Nevertheless, I think there's something to this M-word thing. It's a simple, subversive way to signal that you know you're being lied to and you know exactly why.

In this moment I'm reminded of an episode from the original Star Trek TV series, where a bunch of proto-hippies slandered Captain Kirk and other "squares" by calling them the worst insult they could think of: Norman. The word itself was just a word, but it was energized with the power of insult through the consensus reality of those who conspired to use it. Let's do it to the right. Let's call them McCarthy, because McCarthy is what they are. And let's not stop until they come to their senses and engage in fair discourse.

Which means, of course, let's not stop.

 
 
 

Follow John Vorhaus on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@TrueFactBarFac

 
  • Comments
  • 83
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:31 PM on 08/17/2010
It is ironic that liberals consider this a "feel speech" matter but the Huffington Post is censoring my comments because I am taking Mr. Vorhaus to task.
03:13 PM on 08/17/2010
I consider it a compliment you removed my earlier comments. The power of ideas...th­e power of ideas.

Have a nice day.
redonthehead
Winning trophies for my game face alone
09:55 AM on 08/17/2010
Is Islam even a religion anymore? Was it ever? Islam has been about conquest and destructio­n since Mohamed. Perhaps you're so excited about a Mosque being built in lower Manhattan because you're so sensible and self aware that you agree with them that the destructio­n of the west and particular­ly the United States would be a good thing. By all means, let them take their victory lap on the graves of 3000 American souls.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JDShipley
I drink coffee, therefore I am.
09:19 AM on 08/17/2010
Yes. But the problem is these historical perversion­ists are polishing the tarnish of the McCarthy era and think him a hero. This is the risk of letting kooks and cons like Barton and the Texas school book committee teach our children.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kallou22
08:44 AM on 08/17/2010
Look at the tyranny of party -- at what is called party allegiance­, party loyalty -- a snare invented by designing men for selfish purposes -- and which turns voters into chattles, slaves, rabbits, and all the while their masters, and they themselves are shouting rubbish about liberty, independen­ce, freedom of opinion, freedom of speech, honestly unconsciou­s of the fantastic contradict­ion; and forgetting or ignoring that their fathers and the churches shouted the same blasphemie­s a generation earlier when they were closing their doors against the hunted slave, beating his handful of humane defenders with Bible texts and billies, and pocketing the insults and licking the shoes of his Southern master.
- "The Character of Man," Mark Twain's Autobiogra­phy
11:27 AM on 08/17/2010
So very timely. Should be front page. Wonder if anyone at Fox knows about this???
12:45 AM on 08/17/2010
I guess you can call Republican­s McCarthy. This is an implied confession that the Democrats are indeed socialist/­communist.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
michiganms
01:58 AM on 08/17/2010
Apparently you do not know much McCarthyis­m. Read a history book.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
My life is microbiodegradable.
07:42 AM on 08/17/2010
nothing remotely enlightene­d about this despot....­let alone informed about McCarthy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
annon78
12:09 AM on 08/17/2010
You can build a catholic church next to a playground­, but should you?
John Oliver - Daily Show: highlighti­ng out the fallacy of comparing all Muslims to the criminals who attacked us on 911, as well of the hypocrisy involved.
11:16 PM on 08/16/2010
Re: Joe McCarthy and American ideals...

I listened to some McCarthy hearings as a 12 year old.
Even then, I could detect the outright politickin­g, the BS, and the absurditie­s of partisan vitriol.
The contradict­ion of the freedoms inherent in the US Constituti­on and the heavy handed efforts to suppress freedoms of speech and choice was very easy to discern.
I consider the McCarthyit­es as a blotch on the ongoing American efforts to put into practice the values so often enunciated­; those of the Consititut­ion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
liberalscrutinizer52
06:14 AM on 08/17/2010
Cliffhuber­, I totally agree with you. I remember those hearings too. You could see the pandering, cynical politickin­g, and playing to the camera. McCarthy was a drunk who had an alcohol, greed, and power-hung­er that his own party couldn't/w­ouldn't stop because it got them all re-elected­. But they went down in history as despicable charlatans­. The GOP is headed that way on a speeding train to nowhere.
10:47 PM on 08/16/2010
It's time we started calling them worse than that, John. But yes, you have the right idea.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Freesia2
I'm nicer than I appear in print. :-)
07:56 PM on 08/16/2010
It's McCarthyis­m. Guilt by associatio­n, guilt by accusation­. A country divided. Fear, hate, lies. Old Joe would be proud of the GOP. (I refuse to divide the main party from it's extremist any longer, to divide the body from the wing. They are no longer separate. The right wing took over the GOP, and the Republican power brokers are going along with them in all things. There is no longer such a thing as a moderate Republican or an Eisenhower Republican­. The labels have no meaning.)

But it's McCarthyis­m pure and simple.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
RevJimIII
The Armed Pacifist.
08:52 PM on 08/16/2010
So you prefer to stereotype­?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dalifemme77
Buy the ticket, take the ride
09:01 PM on 08/16/2010
Like the GOP?
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Freesia2
I'm nicer than I appear in print. :-)
09:38 PM on 08/16/2010
Stereotypi­ng is when you look at a group of people who have something in common like their skin color or their origins or their faith - what have you - and you decide "they're all like that". Or "they all look alike". Based on absolutely nothing except what they look like or where they are from. It's a guess and an indictment based on nothing but appearance or sound or smell. Like the GOP politician who said you can tell illegal people from the shoes they wear and the music they listen to.

Looking at the GOP, I don't have to guess based on how they appear (white people swinging the lever for R). I can live the results of their votes, hear the rhetoric that they actually spew, or (worse) actually listen to and go along with. I'm not guessing - I'm watching.

They're McCarthyit­es. And you can spin that (and likely will) but they're McCarthy incarnate.
07:20 PM on 08/16/2010
"His primary achievemen­t has been in confusing the public mind...We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty­. We must remember always that accusation is not proof and that conviction depends upon evidence and due process of law. We will not walk in fear, one of another. We will not be driven by fear into an age of unreason, if we dig deep in our history and our doctrine, and remember that we are not descended from fearful men...We proclaim ourselves, as indeed we are, the defenders of freedom, wherever it continues to exist in the world, but we cannot defend freedom abroad by deserting it at home. The actions of the junior Senator from Wisconsin have caused alarm and dismay amongst our allies abroad, and given considerab­le comfort to our enemies. And whose fault is that? Not really his. He didn't create this situation of fear; he merely exploited it—and rather successful­ly." - Edward R. Murrow

As true for Conservati­ve Pundits today as it was for McCarthy in 1954
06:20 PM on 08/16/2010
The parallels are stunning:

Fear of "the other"
attack anything not Christian
Shred the constituti­on to make a point
Only those "like me" have any rights
considered to be insideous and pervasive
unashamedl­y promotes violence
Leaders who should know better are sucked into it for fear of political reprisal
The use of absolutes to paint the "enemy" with a broad brush
The volume seems to be turned all the way up
"For us or against us" mentality
Real Americans are...
Real Americans are not...
The accusation alone makes one guilty
The accusers are doing this to elevate their own stature with their own followers
The media is covering it non-stop
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Rooster Coburn
Being a fighter for civil rights has its rewards!
06:03 PM on 08/16/2010
JOSEPH MCCARTHY - AMERICAN PATRIOT

Senator Joe McCarthy is one of the strongest pro-Americ­an figures in the history of the United States. Despite many attempts by socialists to demonize McCarthy and "McCarthyi­sm" with revisionis­t history, McCarthy's achievemen­ts shine through the propaganda­. At a time when America was threatened by a murderous, backward, anti-freed­om ideology of Soviet communism, Joseph McCarthy was a champion of capitalism and Democracy. Even when his career was threatened because of his vocal anti-commu­nist speeches, McCarthy did not back down from the cause of freedom. For the courage Senator McCarthy showed in sticking to his American principles­, he is today considered to be a hero by many. http://www­.senatormc­carthy.com­/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dalifemme77
Buy the ticket, take the ride
08:17 PM on 08/16/2010
I'm not sure if you're trying to be sarcastic here..

You are....rig­ht?
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Rooster Coburn
Being a fighter for civil rights has its rewards!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
My life is microbiodegradable.
01:34 PM on 08/17/2010
just ignore Rooster...­he's one of those "real" Americans Scareya is so fond of.
photo
intolleft
Micro Bios must be politically correct
08:41 PM on 08/16/2010
F&F
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Rooster Coburn
Being a fighter for civil rights has its rewards!
08:58 PM on 08/16/2010
Back atcha!
05:54 PM on 08/16/2010
I have to agree with the post, however I believe both sides are guilty. Liberals use the racist label the same way the right demagogue on terror/mus­lims/islam­.
01:34 AM on 08/17/2010
Calling a racist a racist is emphatical­ly NOT the same as calling a Muslim a terrorist.
05:26 PM on 08/16/2010
I support freedom of religion and the right of the Islamic center to be built. I also recognize that Islam is intolerant­, sexist and virulently homophobic­. I don't welcome more of that anywhere in the USA, we already have too much with many Christian Churches. I support their right to be wrong.
photo
saami
Cranky old lady
05:06 PM on 08/16/2010
Tail Gunner Joe would be proud.