More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Justin Hakuta

GET UPDATES FROM Justin Hakuta
 

Has Yoga Lost Its Soul? Part I: Selling Out and Innovating

Posted: 01/09/12 08:20 AM ET

From the Mountain to Wall Street

Gone are the days of the loin clothed yogi meditating alone on a mountaintop, unless of course said loin cloth is made of wickable polyester blend, fits your body like a glove and retails for $100 a pop and the yogi in question has worldwide appearances and a DVD series purchasable on Amazon.com. Oh, and don't forget to check their Twitter feed.

In the ancient tradition of yoga, a teacher's modest living requirements were provided by their students. "Some may offer the teacher a bag of rice, a small bowl of sugar, some clothes, a place to rest, whatever one's capacity was," said Sister Sukanya of the spiritual organization Brahma Kumaris. "The teacher just shares the knowledge with the students... there was no commercial interest involved, the only interest was the transferring of knowledge."

Fast forward to present day where yoga in the West is a booming industry. Generating $7 billion in revenue according to a recent IBIS World report, with nearly 16 million or 7 precent of U.S. adults practicing and another 18 million or 8 percent of non-practicing adults stating they are extremely interested in trying it, according to Yoga Journal, and close to 70,000 certified teachers in the U.S. based on a 2005 study by North American Studio Alliance, and almost 26,000 studios counted by IBIS and major media outlets, including the Wall Street Journal, U.S. News and Inc. Magazine, write about the popularity of teaching yoga as a career choice and you get the point: Yoga is big business.

Mainstream. Commercial. Sellout. Whatever you want to call it, yoga has achieved the level of infamous popularity, mainstream accessibility and frantic commercialization in the West to earn the title.

So what happens next in a world where yoga is being used to sell everything from yogurt, air fresheners, pain killers and cars? Has commercialization diluted the practice to the point of triviality, becoming just another easily bought, packaged and sterilized commodity?

In other words, has yoga lost its soul?

Hardly. On the contrary, there is plenty of room for innovation and authenticity that can help retain and expand the art of the craft, even amidst the commercial reality yoga currently resides in, you just have to know where (and how) to look.

Open Source Yoga

Nowadays, you can practice yoga not only at a yoga studio, but also at your local gym, office, school, hotel, grassy meadow and even at hospitals, in private homes and increasingly in prisons.

This proliferation of venues mirrors an increase of new yoga styles emerging in the West including laughter yoga, chair yoga, acro yoga, partner yoga, hiking yoga and dog yoga (that's actual dog as in canine, not downward dog) to go along with the more established, popular modern era styles including Power Yoga, Jivamukti and Bikram.

Whether you want to sweat, chant, meditate, dance or laugh, these days yoga styles are as diverse as the people that teach them and cater to a growing set of needs and interests expanding well beyond the yoga steeped in Hindu philosophy that first made its way to the West in the mid 19th century.

Yoga has also crossed gender lines. More men practice it than ever before with the U.S. military and professional sports teams from the NFL to the NBA adding yoga to their training regiment. Lebron James does yoga. Shaq does yoga. Even Hip Hop mogul Jay-Z references yoga in his music.

"There is a style of yoga for everyone... in the beginning, yoga students don't always know what they are looking for," said Clayton Horton, an Ashtanga yoga teacher since 1996 and director of Greenpath Yoga in the Philippines. "Beginning yoga students will find it helpful to snoop around to find a style of yoga that is appropriate for their mental and physical condition."

But is the yoga at an office or a school different from that offered in a gym or at a yoga studio? Fundamentally they are the same according to Rusty Wells, a Bhakti Flow teacher and founder of Urban Flow Yoga in San Francisco's South of Market neighborhood. "I hear teachers say, oh I just teach gym yoga. But whether gym yoga or hotel yoga, it's all yoga. You may have to change some of your approaches, but you can still teach the essence of [yoga] anywhere."

The more styles and venues that offer yoga, the more relevant it will be to different parts of our everyday life. Some will use yoga as therapy. Others as a way to get a workout. Others as a way to recover from injuries. Still others as a way to relax and spend time with themselves. There is even a growing body of research showing yoga's benefits on sexual performance.

With this expansion of the practice, teachers of yoga face the ongoing opportunity and the challenge of where and how to teach. The yoga studio is and will continue to be a go-to venue in which to practice yoga, but nowadays a teacher can offer classes at companies, schools, hospitals, stores and just about anywhere with four walls and a roof, or even outside if you like.

This opportunity also matches the interests of the teachers themselves, who often have other jobs and want to find a way to integrate yoga into what they already do on a part time basis, for example teaching a class at the company, school or retail store that they work for.

The future of yoga expands beyond the traditional studio's walls and within the multitude of spaces where we spend our daily lives. At the same time, yoga has the opportunity to address an ever-increasing list of needs and tastes as teachers identify creative ways to apply the ancient practice to better suit the modern urban dweller. Studios and teachers who connect to the tradition of yoga and understand how to effectively adapt, present, and teach it in a modern style and environment have the opportunity to help shape the course of yoga's speedy trajectory.

For more on yoga, click here.

For more by Justin Hakuta, click here.

 
From the Mountain to Wall Street Gone are the days of the loin clothed yogi meditating alone on a mountaintop, unless of course said loin cloth is made of wickable polyester blend, fits your body lik...
From the Mountain to Wall Street Gone are the days of the loin clothed yogi meditating alone on a mountaintop, unless of course said loin cloth is made of wickable polyester blend, fits your body lik...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:55 AM on 02/04/2012
So what is the point, other than that this author is snarky and jealous? Yoga is successful because it works. Classes are free with gym memberships, or part of expensive spaas for the yuppie yogi. So what? Would you rather we spent our money on wine or steak?
05:25 PM on 01/13/2012
(part 2)

this critique from the media too, is great as well, as long as the intention of the magazine and writers are not to sensationalize a problem but to actually ask questions in order to encourage discussion and growth.

the media and many students (not excluding myself sometimes) are often impatient for results of a million kinds. yoga however, i continue to rediscover, is a magical way to pause and slow down and reconnect with what is going on in me and then I can feel the results coming. I find assurance there. if its coming and I trust it is, it doesn't matter when (if ever) it arrives.

we cannot do anything to damage yoga. yoga is not something to sell out and own and damage no matter how hard we try. we can only damage and hold and sell out ourselves. it is important to stretch and explore the practice as we modernize and grow as people, though always hugging close to the traditions from which the practice came.
05:24 PM on 01/13/2012
phew. this is a well rounded article. this week has been the week for news to "come down hard" and critique modern yoga as a pure exersize commodity. I'm sure that fact is true along the board just not across it. it all, I think, comes down i think to intention of the teacher and intention of the student. I am finding too I don't have to talk about god to feel it as I practice or to allow my students to find some release (god or not) as they do. and even if the intention to work out is all that exists in a student, then that has to be enough. eventually those students and teachers who are not open to more will get bored and move to something else. people who want to do the fad will do that no matter what it is and the rest of us will be left to go deeper in some way. I can only speak for myself but I came to yoga in an aggressive self hating way and now my relationship with it and myself has changed. with dedication to the practice as just that (a practice) the benefits will creep in - like meditation I imagine. patthabi jois talks about this as well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o97hfhtXJwo
11:10 AM on 01/12/2012
What happens next is Yoga will saturate western culture thoroughly, and in its westernized, "barbie-ized" form. People enmasse will sign up for classes, miss the point, mistake an external desire for an intended internal experience, and wonder what the big deal was in the first place? In short it wll become just another shopping experience for so many. Unfortunately the internal experience is what we badly need, not another shopping experience. Take yoga at "authentic" yoga shops. Eschew any yoga class that has a "sexy" adjective placed in front of it, and meditate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MerrieWay
02:23 AM on 01/10/2012
Yoga is a state of mind... mindfulness. There is no panacea... turn inward and follow your truth... it is all one can do to be real, in a world that has lost its way. Hang onto what is right and action will follow, if we listen.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Justin Hakuta
03:27 PM on 01/11/2012
Thank you for sharing.

How do you practice mindfulness?

I have a meditation practice and yoga practice that helps me pay attention to what's happening in my life. I am also starting to journal as another way to be mindful.
09:00 PM on 01/09/2012
"In the ancient tradition of yoga, a teacher's modest living requirements were provided by their students."

Why speak in the past? This is still the way today in India and Nepal to name two places.,

Innovation?

Why do you consider Yoga to be simply recreational exercise?

"[b]eyond the yoga steeped in Hindu philosophy . . ."

Anything beyond the wisdom that has evolved from the Vedic lore is not yoga. It is something else.

And so yoga in the West has become a catchall for recreational activity.

How sad.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leadsled
Love-child of the ghosts of FDR and Napoleon
06:12 PM on 01/09/2012
How is this different from the entire history of Yoga? Yoga was invented in the 19th century as a way to get money out of the British wives of the Raj.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EagalObama
02:55 PM on 01/12/2012
no that's the tennis pro
01:46 PM on 01/09/2012
There is wonderful cautionary tale of the injuries that can occur within the practice of yoga in the New York Times Magazine (01.08.2012) "All bent out of shape". I have accute lateral spinal stenosis from sitting in a lotus posture most every day for 45 years. It can be extremely painful and dibilitating at times making it difficult to walk. I am in treatment now to reabilitate the nerve damage which is slow but working. I advise caution, period. Don't let your ego wreck your body, it is not worth it.
Blessings, Thomas
photo
ZenSufi
There is a secret in the Heart of Man.
02:30 PM on 01/09/2012
Did you feel discomfort or pain while in the lotus asana?
03:35 PM on 01/09/2012
Yes it was there.
09:15 PM on 01/09/2012
Thomas,

Thank you for your sound advice.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:33 PM on 01/09/2012
Nice post....I couldn't agree more. I was first exposed to yoga at a gym and it was an extremely positive and yogic experience from great teachers. It inspired me to continue study and go on to teach. I have practiced and taught yoga in both gyms and studios and have found one is not any better than the other. I have had positive (and not so positive) experiences in both settings. My interest as a teacher has always been to help people incorporate yoga into their daily lives by making it attainable and practical in real life. I want to help people break free from their thoughts and experience the full benefits of yoga and if that takes place at a gym...so be it. I also happen to be one of those who has taken to twitter to share my not so conventional teaching style @tweetasana (yoga, short and 'tweet'). I offer little daily reminders that can help keep the yoga going regardless of where you are at that moment. Some days just being reminded to breathe is a big breakthrough for a lot of people and really...that's the essence of the whole practice!
http://tweetasana.com
09:13 PM on 01/09/2012
Yoga is not about benefits but about obligations and duty. The word itself implies this.
It is not about the seeking of pleasure or of comfort or stress reduction. It is a sadhana (a spiritual path with an ultimate goal). It is integrated with all aspects of life including prayer, self sacrifice, humility, service to community and to family, cultivation of concentration, cultivation of love. In short it is a discipline.

Now where does such a discipline leads one?.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:33 PM on 01/10/2012
The consistent practice of asana along with pranayama is a discipline that can lead to physical transformation as well as emotional and spiritual, impacting all aspects of life. I do believe that stress reduction is one of many health benefits and if that is what brings one to the practice it should not be dismissed. I appreciate your comment but I don't believe it has to be an all or nothing approach. What works for one may not be the same for all and that's part of acceptance.
10:43 AM on 01/09/2012
I think it's not where you do the yoga but who you study from. I study from a teacher for whom yoga is her spiritual practice and full time 'job'. She insists on proper form for each pose or flow & focusing our breath and mind on the yoga. She also prepares us for more advanced poses by first insisting we mastering the easier ones. My benefits are 360' around my health. I've never had this degree of benefit in yoga before and this is my first yogi yoga teacher. Yoga has so many health benefits, I think it's good to find the very best teacher in your area and give it a sustained try, http://www.drbaileyskincare.com/blog/the-health-and-anti-aging-benefits-of-yoga/
photo
ZenSufi
There is a secret in the Heart of Man.
02:29 PM on 01/09/2012
Do you mean to say that "hatha yoga is her spiritual practice"?
09:09 PM on 01/09/2012
Where is the understanding that leads to moksha?

Has your teacher revealed her mind to you?

Have you opened yourself to her?

Has your teacher brought you closer to the divine source?

What grounding in scripture do you have (e.g. Upanishads)?

Is your practice integrated with a form of bhakti (devotion)?

Does your teacher perform darshan (offering to her teacher) before she commences her session?

Are you giving to charity or helping in a soup kitchen or helping a child to read?

Are you more responsive to your children, spouse, parents, and any other family members?

Has your occupation become a means for this Karma Yoga (commitment to action)?

This is a way of life and not merely the freezing of a bodily position (asana).