iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kate Orne

Kate Orne

Posted: June 11, 2010 04:12 PM

I was initially drawn to exploring the prevalence of prostitution under Islam in 2001 after encountering impoverished Afghan widows in the refugee camps of the North-West Frontier Province in Pakistan. It was shortly after 2001 when I had been invited by The Brooke to join in their efforts to document the Afghan refugees fleeing to Pakistan across the Hindu Kush mountain range, frequently carried on the backs of their horses and donkeys. After 9/11 happened, as a fellow New Yorker, I became determined to deepen my understanding of the Muslim world and its culture. The only way to understand was to get my butt over there. If these women, who have no means to support their children, were forced to sell their bodies, how would they find clients if they were not allowed to walk outside alone and without being covered in Burkas? I was told repeatedly that prostitution did not exist in Islamic countries such as Pakistan.

It took four years of research before I was finally introduced to Ms. Lubna Tayyab, the founder of SHEED Society -- at the time a very small, community-based organization. Lubna, a beautiful round woman with an infectious laugh and eyes that sparked of life, was born and raised in the community. She initially told me that entering the brothels would be impossible for a photographer. The women would never agree to be photographed, since in addition to being shunned by society, they risk being arrested and severely punished for their actions. Lubna also had my personal security in mind. But she agreed to introduce me to Madams and prostitutes passing by the office where she has provided women with free condoms and HIV/AIDS/STI education since 1995. I felt I would at least be able to interview some of them to get a better sense of who they were, what their lives were like, and learn how prostitution works in this deeply conservative, Muslim society.

What followed was three weeks of twelve to fifteen hour days of tea-drinking, waiting for the women to pass by. They would arrive either with their children or accompanied by a Madam. They would never come alone since women should not venture outdoors unaccompanied. Since so few foreigners are seen in this area, especially foreign females, some of the women appeared very hesitant upon seeing me sitting on Lubna's vinyl couch. But others found me to be like an attraction at the zoo. They curiously complimented my blue eyes, long blonde hair, fair skin -- all attributes that would be great assets in their trade. Some arrived stoned. All of them where covered according to the culture where anything above the ankle or a hint of a bra strap is considered vulgar and unacceptable, even among prostitutes.

The streets have no sign of the sex trade; there are no females waiting for customers on street corners -- unless one knows where to look. The wheeling and dealings takes place behind closed doors, while cell phones and Internet has only recently made prostitution in Pakistan more extensive. The stench that hits those not used to it is a mix of sweat, feces, cooking oil, rotten food, the penetrating exhaust from rickshaws, and, at times, sex. The area has a couple of streets lined with food and tea stalls, storefronts where one can hire musicians or entertainers, and shoe shops of all things. Many of the tea stalls also function as mini cinemas where kids left unattended while their mothers work and male adults watch TV while sipping milk tea and passing the long hours of boredom that unemployment creates. The rest is a complicated labyrinth of dark alleys where one easily gets lost and strangers rarely enter without the guidance of a local pimp.

At night, the dancing halls open for a few hours, providing customers with the entertainment of diluted traditional mujra and Bollywood dances for a few rupees. The more accomplished a girl is, the more money she is paid. But hovering in corners are owners who take most of the earnings. In 2008, a judge in Lahore's high court declared the mujra dance vulgar and banned it from stages in a gesture of good will to pacify the mullahs and the Taliban.

Late one night, Pino, a Madam, wags her finger in a sign to follow her. I quickly cover my head in my hijab, the commonly used headscarf, and conceal my camera underneath. There is a certain rush mixed with fear and confusion. I am not sure where she is taking me. A few minutes later, after being hurried through dark alleys, we enter a doorway. I follow as fast as I can, struggling up the stairs toward the second floor through complete blackness, feeling a rat brushing against my leg. A moment later, I enter a room where a TV is blaring and smoke from joints hangs heavy in the air.

A woman, surrounded by children, sits on her bed. Pino gestures for me to hurry. There is a young man, assigned by Lubna as a bodyguard and "translator." Even though his English vocabulary is extremely limited, I am glad to have him there. He tells me in a tense voice, "Picture quick, police come!" I am inside a brothel.

May You Never Be Uncovered

 

Follow Kate Orne on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kateorne

I was initially drawn to exploring the prevalence of prostitution under Islam in 2001 after encountering impoverished Afghan widows in the refugee camps of the North-West Frontier Province in Pakistan...
I was initially drawn to exploring the prevalence of prostitution under Islam in 2001 after encountering impoverished Afghan widows in the refugee camps of the North-West Frontier Province in Pakistan...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 436
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
uansari1
03:06 PM on 07/21/2010
Yes... and prostitution also jumped after the U.S. led invasion of Iraq because the women didn't have access to state welfare programs anymore to feed their children. That was Islam's fault too, right? This article sends the wrong message. Islam doesn't condone slavery or prostitution... the uneducated, poor rickshaw drivers do.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ultrabop
when bop isn't enough
10:16 AM on 07/21/2010
What? They have sex in Pakistan? No way!
02:37 AM on 06/23/2010
History shows that prostitution is the oldest profession.It thrives in developed countries likes Canada, USA, Britain and all over the world. Even in most conservative societies it is present in one shape or another. No religion of "Book" allows it. Haven't we seen in Downtown Manhatten, Toronto, Dheli etc that it is a due to the poverty that women tend to sell their bodies. Pakistan is no exception to this phenomenon.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jwwrox
High School Student
02:09 PM on 06/19/2010
This is what, in many cases, organized religion leads to. If these women could trust the local government they might ask for help, but the government is controlled by Islam (conservative Islam) and they would likely punish the women if they asked for help.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jwwrox
High School Student
02:11 PM on 06/19/2010
Very good pictures, by the way. These pictures show a lot, in this case a picture is really worth a thousand words.
09:42 PM on 06/20/2010
well, they are thrown into prison in the US as well. Prostitution is not legal here
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IndependentBadger
09:16 AM on 07/02/2010
Because of the christians. A more secular America wouldn't waste so much time and money pretending that sex is dirty and evil (when done by poor people). I never see rich "Johns" going to prison for soliciting.
09:24 AM on 06/18/2010
very sad, that no one in our authorities is doing something about it. And Doing something about is means to STOP this madness !!! No mumble Shmumber of politicians that keep promising but ACTIONS !!! Use the FBI the CIA and another 16 secret Services agencies to stop it!!

http://www.hotshotrunners.com
10:41 AM on 06/18/2010
I see that you miss bush already.

Don't worry, that's not bad.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IndependentBadger
09:17 AM on 07/02/2010
Oh, really? What, you mean some sorta invasion to eliminate prostitution, when we can't even get it eradicated in YOUR hometown? Pssh. Lotsa talk, and nothing else.
09:20 AM on 06/18/2010
It is very sad that the authorities don't stop this madness!!
Freight Brokerage USA
08:25 PM on 06/16/2010
I was disappointed with the way the authors starts her piece by saying "prostitution in Islam". It should have been "prostitution in muslim world". Just like any other religion of the world Islam doesn't allow prostitution and just like any other nation of the worls it exists in muslim world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
joeyfoto
“Écraser l'infamie!”
12:11 PM on 06/28/2010
rizvist wrote: "I was disappointed with the way the authors starts her piece by saying "prostitution in Islam". It should have been "prostitution in muslim world". Just like any other religion of the world Islam doesn't allow prostitution and just like any other nation of the worls it exists in muslim world."

And you do not think that the sexual sickness inherent in both Islam and Christianity, has anything to do with — not the existence of prostitution — but with the ugly way that prostitution is managed and prostitutes are treated, in both Christian and Muslim cultures? I do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:08 AM on 06/15/2010
Vatican hit by gay sex scandal
Vatican chorister sacked for allegedly procuring male prostitutes for papal gentleman-in-waiting

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/mar/04/vatican-gay-sex-scandal
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
muck-raker
give me liberty or give me death
07:05 PM on 06/14/2010
CBS news uncovers massive sex trade in Israel....yep

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/03/23/world/main682673.shtml
photo
Gavin Saunders
we only have each other
03:10 PM on 06/14/2010
......"kids are left unattended while their mothers work" Are these the children of the prostitutes or women who do work other than prostitution?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
George K
02:35 PM on 06/14/2010
This is a good time to look at the same situation in our own country Do a search for Prostitution and inster the date 10-14-2010 and see what shows up.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
disgustedwithall
USA not free/safer if citizen requires gun for it.
11:26 AM on 06/14/2010
Yep sure glad no sex trades or porn in USA.. as the WASPS are clean and the fundimentalists make sure do not have a $51 billion such business in USA of the UT has the most on line porn of any state. So let's slam those "Muslim's" as nothing even close to this ever happens in USA..

PS OBL and friends probably thankful you, Pat Roberts and others doing a great recruiting job for them.. as a lot recent stuff across USA full of hate/fear of "Muslims" kind of proves the point of the extremists, both "bad guys" and those "good Christians" across USA. Seems USA just cannot get enough Muslim bashing... but howl like a coyote in full Moon if anyone dares disrespect for their "good god" Kind of like slamming AFG/Mexico for "they are drug centers" but omit USA is "drug user central".. what about that ole saying in the :Good book" (implies others book is not good) about "He(she) not cast first stone (or drone missiles?) etc. Good ole "red-white-blue hypocrisy is alive and well
11:42 AM on 06/14/2010
What the h*ll are you ranting about?
Who is implying there's no sex or porn trade in the US? Everyone knows it's rampant. This article is simply trying to illuminate horrific conditions for women who are forced to prostitute themselves in these Muslim strongholds.
Why said anything about the US?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:17 PM on 06/14/2010
Agreed. Fanned.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Asmodean1
Truth is only true if based on facts.
01:54 PM on 06/14/2010
you ARE talking about _ManWithBrain_

i hope.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LBA7895
10:56 AM on 06/14/2010
Islam wants to take these people back into the 17th Century. Just what the world needs today.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
disgustedwithall
USA not free/safer if citizen requires gun for it.
11:29 AM on 06/14/2010
Seems if they did that you could go back to crusades and really show them the benefits of "Onward Christian soldiers" off to plunder, rape, kill and burn library's etc.. That ought to teach them how really good folks are supposed to act. Yep very evil bunch, they even had astrology/sciences/math etc, when most of white EU ansestors were/are still in caves (physical then, mental now?).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Asmodean1
Truth is only true if based on facts.
02:09 PM on 06/14/2010
actually they are 11th century people..... with modern weapons.
10:30 AM on 06/14/2010
Its obvious Kate Orne that you are trying to bash a religion implying that prostitution is encouraged in Islam. Your first sentence itself is very confusing. It says a lot about your mental health.

You are not well traveled at all otherwise you would have found the same conditions in India, Thailand and 100+ countries and ALL of the developed countries.

I do appreciate objective journalism what I do NOT appreciate is someone with an agenda against a religion and twisting and turning the story to fit with their hidden motive.

So whats next Kate? Story on prostitutes in India and how Hinduism is encouraging their clients and p1mps?

Kate you should be ashamed of yourself.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:51 AM on 06/14/2010
I agree totally. Fanned.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
seerickson
11:07 AM on 06/14/2010
That is interesting that you so totally miss the purpose and eloquence of her journalism. These women if they are widowed refugees or otherwise trapped into poverty even generationally, have no choice but to violate the values of their religion. Especially poignant was the photo of the pimp with his future "investment". Is it less poignant or less hypocritical because it occurs not just in the countries you mention, but in our country too? Added to that is the danger it puts them in. Women continue to be the ones most hardly used in Afghanistan and Pakistan, again that is really nothing new in war, but it is still poignant and worthy journalism.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
disgustedwithall
USA not free/safer if citizen requires gun for it.
11:31 AM on 06/14/2010
Visits most urban centers in USA and you'll find you just described them here.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaliforniaMitch
11:51 AM on 06/14/2010
I see you understood the meaning of the article. It wasn't to bash a religion but to show that people of any religion do what they have to do to survive. The article was meant to show that and if you missed that then you should just go back and read your bible and continue to live in the dark.
09:07 AM on 06/14/2010
"I was initially drawn to exploring the prevalence of prostitution under Islam in 2001"!!!!!!!!!!!!! How did you manage to come up with this statement???? I can well imagine the extent of your bias against Islam, but even for someone like your self to place prostitution under the umbrella of ANY religion is really taking it far!!! There is a huge network of sex workers in India....would i ever write "I was initially drawn to exploring the prevalence of prostitution under hinduism.."

Yes there are thousands of prostitues in Pakistan....as they are in the US, UK, Germany, Nepal etc. etc. Yes it is an inhuman trade to be a part of (i wldnt wish it upon my worst enemy!!)....Yes women end up selling thier bodies to feed themselves and thier children BUT where did Islam come into the picture....Kindly, for your credibility's sake, justify your quoted statement....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:32 AM on 06/14/2010
She is justified. Islam is the most repressive and suffocating of all religions. As an atheist, I actually believe all religions to be the embodiment of pure evil, but Islam has a special place, even among the cynical rogues gallery of con games known as "religions". It is obvious that, to be a prostitute or sex worker in any "conservative Islamic" nation would be hell on earth, and incredibly dangerous. Furthermore, seeing how sex workers are treated in the US, one imagines that, UNDER AN ISLAMIC GOVT. Things would be ten times worse. Surprise! They are!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Asmodean1
Truth is only true if based on facts.
02:02 PM on 06/14/2010
fanned.

pleased to meet you "brother"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
uansari1
03:00 PM on 07/21/2010
Clearly you've never actually had a conversation about this "repression" and "suffocation" with a Muslim woman. You should try becoming more knowledgeable rather than counting on the Islamophobe blogosphere for your education.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:36 AM on 06/14/2010
She can't, Hadia - then nobody would want to read it! Islam seems to be the current "it" word - the more sensationalistic, the better. Fan # 1.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
disgustedwithall
USA not free/safer if citizen requires gun for it.
11:33 AM on 06/14/2010
Perhaps she can use the term "Them" as it was used in about same bias manner by many racists/religions in USA as code word to refer to blacks... and sounds about same when she describes, Islam, doubt it, sub words and see how it reads.