More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kathryn Dawson

GET UPDATES FROM Kathryn Dawson
 

How Cable News Made Me Lose My Religion and My Mother

Posted: 11/22/11 01:00 PM ET

My mother passed away five months ago at the age of 80. Despite her advancing age and the knowledge that this day must eventually come, I always knew it would be one of the most difficult moments of my life, and it was. In fact, the pain of losing her has far exceeded my expectations.

I was lucky to have had a very close relationship with my mother for a good part of my life. I grew up in a rural farming region in central Virginia. Along with normal activities such as hunting and listening to country music, the values of God and country were strongly instilled. Due to my mother's influence I became very involved in my church as a teenager, and the shared activities created a strong bond between us. Mom indoctrinated me against communism, the dangers of alcohol and premarital sex. She taught me that America was "God's country."

With this background in God, country and family values, I found myself at a very conservative Bible College after high school. But despite the insularity of that experience, I eventually began to question some of the teachings that, quite frankly, had never made sense to me, such as the subservient role of women, hell, the literal interpretation of the Bible and the exclusive "truth" of evangelical Christianity. These slowly made me rethink my upbringing and the door to the possibility that there might be other "truths" out there cracked open.

After graduation, I took my first job in a small college where I met people who thought dramatically different from me, Muslims, Catholics, Mormons even atheists. I quickly found that they believed their "truths" as strongly as I believed mine. Some even tried to convert me to their way of thinking, and to large degree they were successful. Within a few years my beliefs had changed radically. I came to see that one's beliefs were mostly a product of one's upbringing, culture and place in history. In a word, I began to lose my religion.

My new beliefs and lack of Christian belief had ripened by the early 1990s, and I began to test the waters with my mother. Throughout my teens even with her faith and piety she had always been extremely open-minded, so I felt I could chance challenging her thoughts with some of my new thoughts. In retrospect, however, that decision signaled the beginning of the end to the close bond we had always shared.

Initially mom listened to me with interest, offering patient explanations why I was wrong. We would have civilized discussions, agreeing to disagree the majority of the time. In all honesty, I did not share with her the entirety of my changing religious beliefs as it would have hurt her severely, but when it came to social and political issues, I was less reticent. We had heated discussions about abortion, the death penalty, illegal immigration and health care, all the while maintaining civil discourse.

Until the late 1990s my relationship with my mother remained largely intact. But then she discovered Fox News and Rush Limbaugh, and I could not have anticipated the devastating way this would change our relationship.

In a short amount of time my open-minded and compassionate mother became someone I no longer knew or understood. She became strongly anti-immigrant, anti-choice, pro-gun, pro-corporation, and perhaps worst of all, she lost her concern for the less fortunate. The influence of Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh, Bill O'Reilly, and the other conservative talking heads had overwhelmed and transformed her. Our discussions became more heated, often ending in a battle of words.

It often felt strained to spend time together. During visits we would battle over the television. She pushed her agenda with Fox News, and to be honest, I pushed mine with Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert. Still I wondered, where had this loving woman who raised me gone? What had made her lose sight of the teachings of Christ about the poor and disadvantaged? I firmly believe that after years of imbibing this type of programming her mind had been poisoned.

But they didn't just poison her mind, they also took her money. As I now focus on settling my mother's affairs, I handle a half dozen pieces of mail per day from various right wing organizations. I've learned that this woman of meager means regularly contributed to political organizations, think tanks, PACs and other groups endorsed by her beloved Fox News.

Although it pains me now, I remember once remarking to my husband that the country would be a better place when her generation was gone. Of course, I didn't mean that I wanted my mother or any particular person of her generation to die. I simply meant that this "greatest generation" who had nobly led the world through two World Wars had become the targets of unscrupulous and ill-intentioned media shysters.

When my mother had a stroke last winter, I was thoroughly devastated. Facing the loss of this woman who had meant so much to me for so long left me feeling hollow and ashamed. Why did our last years together have to be so conflict ridden?

As much as I miss her I feel the sweetness of our relationship was tainted by unnecessary conflict over religion and politics for the last 10 years or so. I don't know what's been worse -- the pain of losing her, or the pain over our lost connection. Perhaps this is why her passing has been so very difficult for me. I don't think I had ever grieved the loss of our close relationship until now.

In the four months after my mother's stroke, her body slowly recovered but her mind did not. But in those final months she no longer cared about politics or religion. Neither did I. The only thing that really mattered was taking care of her, making sure that she had everything she needed -- which was my love and devotion. I did my best to give her both.

 
My mother passed away five months ago at the age of 80. Despite her advancing age and the knowledge that this day must eventually come, I always knew it would be one of the most difficult moments of m...
My mother passed away five months ago at the age of 80. Despite her advancing age and the knowledge that this day must eventually come, I always knew it would be one of the most difficult moments of m...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,957
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (29 total)
05:27 PM on 12/11/2011
I think you are spoiled you grew up in the greatest country in the world your mother gave you a great upbringing and you threw it all away. Rest assured when your mother donated to these groups she had you in mind she was concerned that you would lose the freedoms you take for granted we live in a world were freedom and liberty is a scarce comodity some of my family comes from Hungary the were slaughtered for there religious beliefs you don't understand what your supporting. In the history of this world only one country has fully adopted communism with out mass slaughter Sweden. The people you support will gladly dispose of you when they get power.
12:31 AM on 12/09/2011
Colbert and Stewart are overrated. I don't think the author's situation is terribly unique. I can name dozens of people who threw off the shackles of religion and conservative thought during the 70s/80s.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rgo
Vision without action is a daydream.
07:12 AM on 12/02/2011
Your article is in a certain sense to me -- courageous.
I do not think I could write as openly and honestly as you have about my mother for the whole world to see.
Many people will benefit from your honesty.
My deepest sympathy for the loss of your mother.
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
10:48 PM on 12/01/2011
Wow, I've read through some of the comments and the story above and I had no idea the whole Fox News thing was that bad.

My father, a lifelong staunch Republican, will vote for Obama . . . again. He's sick to death of the bigotry and lies and his new political passion is the massive wealth imbalance. He always thought that a conservative approach was the best way for everyone's prosperity, but now he sees that this party no longer stands for the same things he does.

Oh, and he doesn't watch Fox News either.
photo
cat lover and liberal
My lord, I have a cunning plan that cannot fail.
10:10 PM on 12/01/2011
This is so like my relationship with my parents. Over the last few years I have noticed my parents taking a scary shift to the right in their thinking. They are both in their 70s now and have always been rather moderate in their views, even a bit liberal. Now they seem suspicious of anyone who is not straight, white and Christian. I was discussing something political with my mother a while ago and asked her where she got the idea she was presenting. She admitted she watched "a little" Fox News. Although they are in Canada, the infection is spread by satellite. We don't talk politics anymore.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:09 PM on 12/01/2011
Wow... a great read. This so perfectly describes the relationships I have with many people in my life.
08:12 AM on 12/01/2011
All I can say is that there a LOT of people out there who call themselves Christian who certainly do not follow or understand the teachings of Christ. He did not teach hate, or judging others. He did not teach much of what is encouraged by many of those who have found their place on Fox News.
12:55 AM on 12/01/2011
Yes, but it sounds as if the mother remained the same, it was the daughter who changed so drastically.
09:36 PM on 11/30/2011
Sadly, I have lost grown children to the far right. They have become obnoxious, greedy people who won't tolerate anyone else's beliefs but their own. They are wealthy but so uninformed that it is sad and they are not fun to be around. Part of the reason is Faux News. Watch it sometime and see the lies and hatred that they spew.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MsMarchHare
Leader of the Zanti Misfits!
08:58 PM on 11/30/2011
My mom and dad and 2 brothers moved to Florida and within a couple of years I found myself almost totally alienated from all of them. My once Democrat, loving UAW serving and supportive family became argumentatively pro Glenn Beck and Fox to the point of paranoia. Every phone call became a political tirade with Mom or Dad asking me what I thought of Your Idiots you had to vote for, or asking me if I'd "come around yet" visits had my mom peeling my bumper stickers off my car whenever she could or complaining she couldn't be seen in my car with an Obama sticker on it. They suddenly were buying hand guns they'd never cared about before, and they also stopped caring for their fellow man. My dad, who used to volunteer at St.Vincent DePaul's thrift store, suddenly found it more important to buy Glenn Beck's latest book and fight "homo's trying to rape boys" by making sure he didn't watch Glee. I call once or twice a month now...its all I can stand.
08:56 PM on 11/30/2011
My condolences for your loss, I can't imagine losing my mother. I'm very happy for you that you were able to reconnect.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marlaannchristenson
Well when you say it like that...
08:26 PM on 11/30/2011
My condolences to you for the loss of your mother. I really appreciate your article. My mother seems like a very open person. But, she firmly believes whatever conspiracy theory that Rush, Glenn Beck, and their cohorts spew. It is terribly sad that she reduces herself to this ilk. There is no chance of open discussion with her about immigration, gay rights, etc. My father, before he passed, was a virulent right winger. My ex-father-in-law is one of those people who forwards emails of Obama being lynched. The common link between them all has been that they are relatively all financially and are afraid of what they don't understand, so they simplify their thought processes and follow the right wing spokesperson of the day. It's like loosing them to the dark side.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeff Rosenbury
06:32 PM on 11/30/2011
My condolences for your loss. May God bless and keep both you and your mother.
07:46 PM on 11/30/2011
Kathryn obviously cared deeply for her mother and morns her loss. Perhaps she could watch Fox News from time to time remembering how much it filled her mothers life with happiness in her senior years. Quite often alone and lonely the elderly prefer to live near to and watch those with comfortable views like their own. My prayer is that God blesses both of you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
enlightenedgirl
the truth will set you free
06:20 PM on 11/30/2011
What a very touching story.  We can only imagine how many other families have had to deal with this exact situation.  Our older Parents grew up with Walter Cronkite and Edward R Murrow, Men who we trusted for truth in our News.  They gave us the facts and nothing else.  Who would ever think by turning on the television set we would be watching Propaganda delivered as News, all to sell an idea for Corporate Interest directed towards our Seniors?  

Fox "News" has done a lot of damage our Nation, a Cable Network run by an Australian with his second in command being a Saudi Arabian Prince (do our Parents realize that fact?).  Their demographic is mainly 65+, with our Elderly Population the target of their misinformation.  What can we do about it?  Not much considering this Supreme Court ruled in favor of Fox News and their right to lie to it's viewers.  It's a sad, sad state we're in that's for sure...
06:35 PM on 11/30/2011
Maybe that's why they accept what they hear as fact...because traditionally the "news" has all in all been more unbiased in the past...more truthful and accurate. We younger people, getting our "news" from multiple sources mostly on the internet, see through their BS.
photo
kapalabhati
Lokah Samasta Sukhino Bhavantu
06:39 PM on 11/30/2011
Nice thought, but I think it's because, quite frankly, Fixednuze, and their offshoots, Rush and Beck, are just pretty dang good at lying.
photo
freedom is right
Just tired of all the liberal bias and hypocrisy
07:54 PM on 11/30/2011
You accuse FNC of pushing propaganda? Your entire comment is nothing but leftist anti Conservative/ anti Fox News propaganda. It's pretty obvious that there is a leftist agenda to smear Fox News because they truly are a threat to the Liberal agenda. It's a real bummer that they have ratings that leave your totally "objective" liberal news outlets in the dust huh? Like.. totally. Doesn't making claims without having any actual proof weigh on your consciences at all? Oh wait.. you're liberals.. never mind. And why don't give the age warfare a rest.. is it really necessary to create more division? Didn't you all have your fill with all the racist accusations?? You all don't have a clue of what this country is about.. you're lost. You're victims of the real propaganda being spread by people who want to tear this country down.. incredibly believing that a socialistic govt. would actually be good for us. You guys have bought it.. even sleeping out in parks for this movement to take away your freedoms... so naive and gullible are the young.
11:16 PM on 01/09/2012
So wait. You accuse lefties of believing liberal propaganda... then spew some ridiculous conservative propaganda? Do not understand.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lateef Murdock
Liberal, because it's the Christian way .
03:26 PM on 11/30/2011
I'm hard pressed to find much that is as anit- Christian as conservatism.
photo
freedom is right
Just tired of all the liberal bias and hypocrisy
07:43 PM on 11/30/2011
Confused liberal distortion...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lateef Murdock
Liberal, because it's the Christian way .
11:56 PM on 12/01/2011
Okay, I'll bite. Explain to me what I have confused and what I've distorted.