More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Katrina L. Rogers

GET UPDATES FROM Katrina L. Rogers
 

Three Thoughts on the Brewer-Obama Spat

Posted: 01/30/2012 5:34 pm

In case you've spent the last 48 hours hiding under a rock somewhere, you know about the -- what some would call animated -- exchange between President Barack Obama and Arizona Governor Jan Brewer. You've probably seen the clips of finger-point-gate and formed an opinion on the matter. I thought last week's events fell in line with what seems to be Brewer's modus operandi. I've made a list of epiphanies that yesterday's event helped foster.

One: White privilege is real and white female privilege is too.

Gov. Brewer had the audacity to do something that most people simply would not do to a sitting president. Let's be honest here, if Brewer were a man, those actions would have been seen as extremely aggressive and maybe even violent in nature.

If Brewer happened to be a Black woman, she would have been labeled the epitome of an "angry black woman," she may have even been forced to resign. Funny how our first lady has been called angry -- however, I've yet to see her put her finger in anyone's face or act belligerent in any manner.

Brewer said she felt intimidated by the president. But, when's the last time you all but charged at someone who intimidated you? Actually, who feels intimidated by a sitting president -- in public, in broad daylight, with lots of people (especially reporters) around? What was he going to do, give her "The People's Elbow"?

Two: Arizona needs a publicist.

You remember that blatantly racist immigrant thing? And the guy running for president and selecting Sarah Palin as his running-mate? What about refusing to observe Martin Luther King, Jr. Day? Or how about Brewer wants to save money so she's letting people die by cutting their insurance coverage?

Last year, I was offered the opportunity to attend an amazing all-expense paid training session for journalists. I was beyond excited until I thought about it being in Arizona. As much as I wanted to participate, I felt it necessary to stand by my beliefs and decline the invitation. I'm sure my lack of revenue to the state didn't matter much, but it felt really good to not help a state that seemingly doesn't believe in helping her citizens.

Three: President Obama gets disrespected, a lot.

To be fair, I haven't lived through that many presidents but, I've concluded that when House Majority Leader Eric Cantor say his top objective is to make sure Obama is a one-term president, it's a probably a really active and unkind climate for Obama.

I've had the opportunity to experience Tea Party people first hand. They really aren't feeling the president. In the eight years George W. Bush occupied the White House, I don't recall being impressed or proud to call him my president. I disagreed with many of his decisions and felt his administration abandoned the Gulf when we needed our government the most.

But, I also don't remember ever showing up to one of his speaking engagements sporting an assault rifle. I don't recall spitting on members of Congress who supported his legislation. I never called for the assassination of him and/or his daughters or likened Mrs. Bush to any animal. And I never would do any of those things. Why? Well, mainly because I'm sane. This environment, this pure and unadulterated loathing of all things Obama based on fanatical and disillusioned rhetoric is nothing short of amazingly pathetic.

I can't explain why Brewer thought her actions were appropriate. But I can say this: Considering how this first family has been treated since Obama became a viable candidate, it's not shocking; considering it came from Gov. Brewer, not shocking; considering she handed Obama a handwritten letter asking him to sit and discuss the "Arizona comeback" while behaving in such a manner, well, that one actually shocks me.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tom S Cedar Mill
This ain't no party, this ain't no disco.
04:20 PM on 02/02/2012
I think there are very many Whites who think that any white person is better than any black person.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Annespeaks
03:55 AM on 02/02/2012
I definitely think he is treated differently, but not sure it's about race. I think it's a general fear about the enthusiasm he generated. Nothing worse for a republicans who hates democrats than a charismatic, popular democratic leader - so they attack. They did it with Clinton, JFK, Roosevelt. They don't like change and attacking is what they know - and it has worked in the past. It's a shame and a waste of time and resources, but I don't think it's about race for the majority (of course, there are racists, but I honestly think they are the minority).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James McGill
02:06 PM on 01/31/2012
If you did what she did, you'd be very lucky if all that happened to you was to be arrested and then released.
11:44 AM on 01/31/2012
You are the one making this about race, and are drawing parallels that are completely bias and unrealistic. You need to start trying to see things as they are, and not try to paint them into something they are not. Everyone, throughout the history of our nation, has had the right and freedom to think, feel, and express what they authentically feel about the presidents who are elected to govern our country (so long as it does not cross into endangering said president). You obviously are ignorant of all of the "actual" cruelties that other presidents have faced both to their faces, and not in their presence if you are convinced that Obama has somehow suffered inappropriate abuse from this woman and her finger. If you think this interaction is newsworthy, you obviously are "living under a rock" when it comes to things that are going on in the world around us that are actually worth yours, and others time. Just be aware that your choice for writing this is very transparent and reveals YOUR beliefs. You are taking advantage of a situation that you feel you can twist and use as an excuse to state and support your own prejudice beliefs. You use this situation because it allows you to state them without having to outwardly admit that they are the very bias's that you embrace. But your attempt to project your prejudices on this governor and this situation is sad an shameful.
10:08 AM on 01/31/2012
Great article. Privilege is most certainly real in America. Pres. Obama is probably on the bottom of the privilege scale, as am I, being that we are both black males. I'm sure that can be argued by many. I honestly haven't seen the video (only pics), because I have grown immune to the audacious acts of white America in today's time. Nothing really "shocks" me either these days.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rosalee Harris
07:02 PM on 01/30/2012
Well written commentary. Thank you for elucidating the the interaction of gender and racial dynamics in this incident. Most commentary focus on race but ignore the gender aspect of what Brewer did and the historical significance of it. The idea that Black men pose a threat to the poor fragile genteel white women. That is the card that Jan Brewer was playing when she stated that she felt threatened by him. But no surprise many want to bury their head in the sand and pretend that she is not using the dog and whistle for her supporters. She is fundraising off the incident. The same incident where she felt threatened in broad daylight in front of a whole bunch of people.

She knew exactly what she was doing and no one wants to call her on it. In the past you know what women like HER did. They cried r a pe. Her behavior should have been CONDEMNED by women.
06:50 PM on 01/30/2012
I am always amazed when people forget how Bush was treated. It was hideous. I really don't think President Obama deserved a finger in the face. I would love if we could treat the office of the US Presidency with grand respect but I don't think that is going to happen soon, and I think we for sure should leave race out of it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James McGill
02:08 PM on 01/31/2012
Gov. Brewer is quite lucky that the Secret Service didn't perceive the finger-in-the-face as a threat.
03:00 PM on 01/31/2012
You cannot honestly tell me that you think what Brian Williams and Governor Brewer did are the same.