iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kenzo Shibata

GET UPDATES FROM Kenzo Shibata
 

The Battle of Chicago Teachers Union Vs. Out-of-Town Billionaires

Posted: 08/22/2012 11:32 am

In a recently released video, Chicago Teachers Union shows the games played by wealthy elites to smear the Union in the midst of heated contract negotiations. Chicago Teachers Union has maintained that it will not bargain in the press over a fair contract, but associates of Mayor Rahm Emanuel have apparently used backroom deals in Springfield, paid protesters and even members of the Michigan Tea Party to distort the public's image of the Union.

The video, "Astroturf Billionaires Vs. The Chicago Teachers Union" shows all of these tricks in graphic detail.


Full 24-minute video "Chicago Teachers Union Vs. Astroturf Billionaires"

The video begins with footage Tea Party blogger Andrew Marcus boasting about how he worked with Mayor Rahm Emanuel "against the Unions in this town." Marcus directed the film A Tale of Two Missions -- an anti-public school video featuring a candid interview with Mayor Emanuel. Tale of Two Missions was produced by a Tea Party-backed group in Michigan called the Education Action Group.


This one-minute clip shows Marcus and Edelman boasting.

The first half of the EAG video was essentially an infomercial for The Nobel Street Charter School Network while the second half was essentially a smear video against Chicago Teachers Union. In the video, Mayor Rahm Emanuel explains that charter schools seem to have a "secret sauce" to success.

It seemed strange that Emanuel, a longtime member and leader of the Democratic Party establishment would work with ultra-right wing Tea Party members to execute political goals.

The video also features a man admitting to being paid to protest at the 2012 Crane School closing hearing. The Chicago Tribune reported last February that Rahm Emanuel's associate Greg Goldner's firm Resolute Consulting, a firm that worked on Mayor Rahm Emanuel's 2002 Congressional bid, allegedly paid people to protest at these hearings. The paid protesters largely blamed Chicago Teachers Union for problems in Chicago's schools.


This one minute clip shows a man admitting to being paid to protest. However, he's unsure why he's protesting.

The video also shows Jonah Edelman, CEO of Stand for Children, the group behind "Senate Bill 7" - a "school reform" bill that did nothing to improve schools, but focused on squashing the bargaining rights of Chicago Teachers Union.

Senate Bill 7 was written specifically to take power away from the teachers union and set the stage for changes pushed by Mayor Rahm Emanuel and his appointed school board, most notably the longer school day and year.

In "Astroturf," Edelman boasts that the hurdles of a 75 percent required strike vote and the issuance of a fact-finders report would make it impossible for Chicago teachers to strike. In the end, union members who voted in the strike authorization election voted 98 percent for the option to strike and the fact finder made a decision in favor of Chicago Teachers Union. In an especially candid moment in the video, CEO Edelman explains that he "made up" the statistic that Houston students receive four more years of education compared to Chicago, a claim that was repeated over the course of Mayor Rahm Emanuel's' mayoral bid.

The video ends on a positive note showing CTU's efforts to organize not only teachers and school staff - but parents and students to support them in their battle for a fair contract.

The video can be used as an educational piece showing the power of democracy even in the face of political tricks and backroom deals.

 

Follow Kenzo Shibata on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kenzoshibata

FOLLOW EDUCATION
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:10 AM on 09/19/2012
Without getting into the debate about unions, it is absolutely necessary to measure the performance of teachers on an ongoing basis. Teaching and schools are critical to our future and to get results we need to measure the performance of the people who are driving the results.
Have you ever tried to do anything serious in life that you wanted to get results in without measuring. Did you ever try a diet to lose weight without checking your weight. You should read - Bunnies and Bagels: Map, Don’t Dream Your Way to Success - http://rsilberman.com/?p=449 - that shows that Google is measuring the effectiveness of each and every course they give their employees. If we measure our teachers the same way without doing anything else, the results of our schools will improve dramatically.
09:58 AM on 09/02/2012
Currently, this is the level of detail I can stomach on this matter:

http://www.isthectuonstrike.com
07:05 AM on 08/28/2012
Doesn't anyone think it odd that the billionaires are getting richer while the American worker is getting poorer? And doesn't anyone think it odd that Americans are being pitted against each other over dwindling tax revenue? Doesn't anyone think it odd that the newest 40,000 "new jobs" are minimum wage? Alarming how anyone could focus on teachers who are trying to educate the masses while their profession is being hard slammed for no other reason than the greed of a few... and still, shockingly sad how easy it is being done.
03:19 PM on 08/25/2012
I am a parent who volunteered in a public school classroom in " high risk area" about 75% of the kids including mine was a terror that’s how I got more involved because I cared about my child education. It's a damn shame what the teachers have to go through for eight hours with dealing with so many other issues besides teaching them. The teachers are having a hard time and adding on more hours are even worse. We need to think about the teachers emotional and mental health when we put them in these type of environments because they are only human and can take so much before breaking down. Money don't fix every problem we need to think of other solutions to accommodate our hard working teachers who I support 200%. GOVENOR YOU NEED TO INVESTIGATE THE ILLIONIOS LOTTERY!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spriddler
10:28 AM on 08/24/2012
Chicago is broke, CPS is more than broke, teachers are already paid very well compared to other urban areas, school days were some of the shortest among urban areas, performance is lagging in many schools and the CTU continues to fight every effort at reform tooth and nail.

Merit pay? Can't have that
Evaluations? Only if we can rig the system so no one has to worry about much
Handling obviously underperforming teachers? We're still gonna make it an incredibly lengthy and expensive process to get rid of them

Here is the CTU's summary of where negotiations are at right now. Read it for yourself and see who you think has unreasonable expectations.

http://www.ctunet.com/blog/excerpt/Contract_Bargaining_Update_8_22_2012.pdf
06:57 AM on 08/28/2012
Interesting comments. I wonder what qualifies you to make these comments other than being a citizen. Do you share similar views about doctors, lawyers, nurses, fireman, policemen, billionaires attempting to influence opinion in the negative? Oh... wait... it seems they just bought your thinking rights for free! Sorry, but that is exactly what is going on here. It has nothing to do with evaluations and the like. The mere fact that the largest part of every state budget is education is THE reason that billionaires are going after teachers and education in general. Teachers salaries take up the smallest part of that budget right down there with the kids. Most of the money is spent on administration, administration fighting everyone from teachers to parents, and the biggest pot goes to... textbooks, testing and technology. Of course if you are using technology at the rate some of those billionaires are hoping for, they would need to be updated yearly and upgraded to new approx. every three years. Children as young as K are already taking testis 3 x a year on the computer which is done one on one and takes approximately 1/2 hour for each student. The testing company is paid millions of school dollars a year. My favorite is the new 40 page on live evaluation of a teacher. If everyone in the country is held to this measure, all jobs will be outsourced to China...
07:00 AM on 08/28/2012
Never mind... China already OWNs a large portion of the US... This is NOT about teachers getting a free ride or what they want. It is about American opinions being bought (and easily, so it would seem) as their jobs are being downgraded at an alarming rate and people such as yourself are making it possible. Has it occurred to you who owns what you read and watch as news every day? If you think you know, try to find out. It's an interesting search and quite frightening. Again, this is not about teachers, it's about the billionaires buying the American public opinion by slanting truth to fiction. As they do away with our unions (NOT just teachers), they do away with workers rights, such as in "right to work" states which means THEY have a right to fire you w/o cause... that was a great twist on wording that the American public bought in good faith and voted for, we can all be fired w/o cause, work for far less than our experience and/or education would dictate while helping to keep costs down for billionaires and lowering the ability of Americans to fulfill the so called, and now passe, "American Dream". That dear Huffpost Super User, has been sold to China.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bowloforanges
Je pense que, donc, je suis
08:13 AM on 08/24/2012
To catch you up, here's a simplified explanation of the current sticking point on state pension reform:

Chicagoans pay twice for teacher pensions: once for local educators, and once for suburban and downstate educators.

Other Illinois residents pay once: for suburban and downstate educators.

To some this is outrageous. Every district should be responsible for supporting its own teacher retirement program.

http://blogs.chicagotribune.com/news_columnists_ezorn/2012/07/pension.html
11:17 PM on 08/23/2012
As a parent of two children who attended and graduated from neighborhood Public schools, I support thr CTU 100%!
10:57 PM on 08/23/2012
Ironic, being called radical by a union that collaborates with Lisa Fithian's Occupy Anarchists!

In reality, I think the Chicago Teachers Union is just angry about how badly I exposed them in the video linked below. I caught them on camera at an occupy/union co-coordinated protest talking about who was on the printed list of "arrestables" (teachers predetermined to get arrested).

http://youtu.be/6BARB-aSqYM

Respectfully,
Andrew Marcus
Director, "Hating Breitbart"
contact@hatingbreitbart.com
www.hatingbreitbart.com
@hatingbreitbart
09:49 AM on 08/24/2012
The Chicago Teachers Union is absolutely not "just angry" about the petty details of your ongoing dispute with them. They have some very real and deeply concerning issues that they're angry about and working diligently to change. Do not flatter yourself.
10:09 PM on 08/23/2012
The state of Illinois is broke because of public sector unions. For years and years Democrats had a quid pro quo with unions. And the deal was, campaign for us, get the vote out, get us into office and in return we'll give you the big bucks and sweatheart retirement plans. The problem is guys like Mike Madigan and John Fullerton made promises they couldn't keep. Meanwhile the State of Illinois has total debt and unfunded pension liabilities in excess of $150 billion. Moron's in Springfield keep kicking the can down the road hoping they can fleece taxpayers just long enough till they're ready to jump ship. In addition, cook county is broke, as is the city of Chicago. Daley bailed and left Rahm a gigantic fiscal hole. Meanwhile Daley goes off and is making multi millions every year in the private sector. No shame political bozo's.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
riverwester
Indignant Badger
12:33 PM on 08/23/2012
Share this information. Our public schools are under corporate attack all across this country.