iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kevin A. Hansen

GET UPDATES FROM Kevin A. Hansen
 

7 Surprising Answers To "Should We Stay Together For The Kids?"

Posted: 08/22/2012 4:00 am

Should you stay together for the kids? It's a dilemma that many spouses in troubled marriages wrestle with. Divorced couples may look back and wonder, "Should we have tried to make it work for the kids' sake?" Some reason that sacrificing their own happiness by staying in an unhappy marriage is a necessity to help ensure their children's happiness. Others ultimately decide to split because they don't want their children to learn that staying in a truly unhealthy marriage is "normal."

Which answer is right? And what do the kids think? Would they prefer that mom and dad stay together no matter what? Many people have weighed in on this topic on my SecretRegrets.com online confessional, and some are featured in my bestselling book, "Secret Regrets Volume 1: What If You Had A Second Chance?"

I've included several candid and heartfelt excerpts from both parents and children, exploring all angles of the issue. Take a look, and then tell us what you think and what your experience has been. You can comment here or anonymously at SecretRegrets.com.

Loading Slideshow...

 
 
 

Follow Kevin A. Hansen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SECRETREGRETS

FOLLOW DIVORCE
Should you stay together for the kids? It's a dilemma that many spouses in troubled marriages wrestle with. Divorced couples may look back and wonder, "Should we have tried to make it work for the kid...
Should you stay together for the kids? It's a dilemma that many spouses in troubled marriages wrestle with. Divorced couples may look back and wonder, "Should we have tried to make it work for the kid...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 96
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
03:03 PM on 08/23/2012
No pat answer to this one. Marriage doesn't always work for the kids, and divorce can also be a failure.
10:07 AM on 08/23/2012
Wow, what brave people. Sometimes it's clearly better to leave - children do not flourish in a bad environment. On the other hand, it's so hopeful to read the person who said they stayed together through a tough time and now they are happy. Each situation is unique.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Agathon
Wherever you go, there you are.
09:00 AM on 08/23/2012
people and all things change. You can change apart, and you can change back into a more mature relationship than yuou shared before drifting apart. For me, parallel thought regarding basic values and the children's welfare is what is important. Of course that parents need to be happy as well, which is why I use the term parallel. Identical thought about right and wrong, good and bad, just and unjust is virtually impossible without both parents sharing the same every-day experiences. It is natural to see the world differently over time and while different life experiences lead to different ways of interpreting the world., It is simply natural for personalities and relationships to change over time; how we change and direct the force of change is up to each individual.

Our thinking is to remain together for he children by creating respectful space for one another. My way of seeing things does not have to be "right" and hers "wrong"; the points of view can be different as long as we have respect for one another in mind and as long as the children do not have to suffer unnecessarily for our individual desires for self expression. We choose to be "right" in our own ways and when a child rearing issue comes up we discuss it and compromise as needed.

If respect is gone, however, I it may be necessary to get out, and for everyone's sake.
photo
Lykos
Nobody Never Eat No Fifty Eggs
07:32 AM on 08/23/2012
Hufflink quote: "The toughest question fighting parents face"
Is it "How do you solve forever the Israel/Palestine/etc issues so that no-one ever gets harmed or hated again?"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
smeeeee
Now take your nice red pill
07:27 AM on 08/23/2012
Americans don't let each other have secret affairs on the side. Finding a second person who can meet some of the needs unmet by the spouse can keep the marriage together long enough to get the kids raised up. And then when that's done the couple often find that they are used to each other after all, and the third party is just a part of their life.
02:28 AM on 08/23/2012
Staying for the kids only wastes your life and probably damages your kids.


Seperate, deal with each other intelligently and reasonably and NEVER diss each other to your kids or argue in their presence.

If you were adult enough to marry, you should adult enough to divorce.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Walrus Man
01:57 AM on 08/23/2012
It's not children's fault having dysfunctional and selfish parents, who give preference to their own emotions. Matrimony is a contract which implies not only love, but respect, maturity, responsibility, education, patience,friendship and some other elements, and the result=better citizens. Life itself is a daily battle where couples have an special mission: protect their own battalion. Even though, There are some cases where different vices, promiscuity, mental issues and some other situations make some marriages irremediably fail.
been2there
Facts have a liberal bias.
01:16 AM on 08/23/2012
The best answer is to really work at making the marriage work. Maybe you stop being in love, but you can at least behave civilly.
12:55 AM on 08/23/2012
Marriage is not pleasure, but a duty.
gclafontaine
Sand is a small price to pay for sandlessness.
12:15 AM on 08/23/2012
For men the choice is harder, because they will be left with every other weekend and one night a week.
07:21 AM on 08/23/2012
I wish my ex would take them that much. As of Friday, when he will have them for 36 hours total (including sleeping hours) it will have been three weeks since he's seen them. Why? Other things and other people are more important to him. The sad part? The kids say it's less stressful when they don't have to see him.
gclafontaine
Sand is a small price to pay for sandlessness.
06:45 PM on 08/23/2012
That's too bad. I'm sure he will regret it in years to come. Hopefully he changes his ways before it's too late. Good luck.
11:10 AM on 09/17/2012
Not true. We agreed 50/50. It hasn't happened once in ten months, due to him putting his energies on his current girlfriend and his 'new' life.  He actually cancelled with the kids to go to a movie. Another time they didn't want to go to his so when they were supposed to go to his two days later he 'disappeared'. Why? According to him it was punishment for blowing him off. I'm not even kidding about this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Kjellman
B*LL SH*T Proof Since 1966
11:18 PM on 08/22/2012
The SYSTEM as a WHOLE, mainly the family courts, police, the LAW, MUST abolish its ARCHAIC thought process and STOP giving favor to one parent over another. ALL parents must be 110% EQUALS. No head, no tail, no one more superior than the other. There should be IMMEDIATELY joint custody! and an EQUAL responsibility to care for the child (physically) (emotionally) and (monetarirly) PERIOD. Child support should be ABOLISHED. The MOST important thing is this. When accusations of drugs, abuse, neglect, etc made by one parent against another? MUST be INVESTIGATED like CSI. Accusations of drugs? OK drug screen! PULL THEIR DAMN HAIR! and in five minutes you will KNOW if they are doing drugs or not. My ex wife for 9+ years has ABUSED, NEGLECTED, ENDANGERED, my two little girls, 15+ cps reports, neighbor, teacher, ex boy friends, etc, corroboration, 110% EVIDENCE, and she REMAINS un touched. She is breaking all the laws and I am the one they harass! ANY reporter reading this and wants a HUGE STORY that will DECIMATE the image of CPS, the police, the Kings County D/A the mayor, Gov, cps commissioner, etc. Let me know. She has FULL BLOWN orgies with minors in her house!!! she permits DRUNK drivers to drive with MY children! WHATEVER.. nobody gives a F anyway so. thank you for your time trk387
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Kjellman
B*LL SH*T Proof Since 1966
11:08 PM on 08/22/2012
I have been divorced for 9+ years w 2 girls. They should make a LAW ANY couple that wishes 2 get divorced w/ CHILDREN, b FORCED to b sent to some ISLAND SIX MONTHS & then they decide get divorce so b it. I BET it would SAVE several marriages, never mind home lives stability so many children. Walking away some 1 w/ out children CAKE! no ties, see yeah. Children? U r 4 EVER linked them! Your a man (your life you don't get along with your ex) ETERNALLY F! She will dictate how, when, where, you can do with your children. Lives of the children will be DISRUPTED, in a normal setting they see their friends they see you. Divorce they have to LEAVE friends and they don't like that. So they opt to b w mother. Unless your Tom Cruise lol. They say that depression hurts EVERYONE, the same is divorce, everyones lives are torn apart because of ego, emotions, pride, will REMAIN like that 4 ever. ANY 1 thinking of getting married & having children, STOP, think. ESPECIALLY, young men, "that 5 min of pleasure NOT worth the ETERNAL colonoscopy exam ". Never mind STEP PARENTS. The wanna be fathers to YOUR children, vice versa. Even the DEVIL looks up divorced couples & says " damn that is F up "! trk387
10:41 PM on 08/22/2012
I'm glad I left. At first, I stayed for the kids, and because I didn't want to break his heart. After a couple years of depression and suicidal thoughts.. (Though I wan't actually willing to go through with it, so I was considering going on medication instead).. I finally asked myself.. "Aren't I important too?"

That's when I left... and wow. The difference it made not only in my life, but in my kids lives. Their behavior changed, they seem so much happier now, even my ex seems happier now. Best decision I ever made in my life.

I think it varies on the circumstances. Some people experience a "down" in their relationship, and can be helped with couples therapy. Some people have had enough, and need to walk away. If I had known how much leaving would impact my kids, and my own quality of life (for the better) I wouldn't have stayed for as long as I did.
04:41 PM on 10/02/2012
Thank you for saying that, I'm at that point in my 9 year marriage where I am now asking myself "Aren't I important too?".

I'm staying for the kids for now, but my husband has no respect for me or our boys. He's a 38yo man with the maturity of a teenager. I work FT, pay the bills, manage our finances and our (read "my") retirement (he isn't interested in saving for it), the insurance, the children, their school, activities, I just tell him when and where and sometimes he shows up. He works nights, so that's his excuse, but his coworkers are a bunch of teens and 20somethings so he feels entitled to have a life like they do. So he hangs out after work, drinks, got a DUI a few years ago because of it, but thinks it’s all OK since he was found not guilty. Still keeps up the same behavior though, I've about had it with him not coming home until 4am when I know the place closed 3 hours earlier.

It's just sad really. And he gets very angry with me when I confront him about it, so I've stopped. I just am happy to get up every day and breathe in and out. I don't worry about happiness anymore unless it's in the form of my boys. I try to keep them sheltered from his selfishness.
10:18 PM on 08/22/2012
Many times when couples get divorced they forget what is important, their children. They get so caught up in their hatred for each other that their children's needs get put to the side. You don't have to be friends with your ex spouse but, for the sake of your child, be cordial with each other. DO NOT insult your ex in front of your child, even when your kids are adults.
When my parents divorced they made a decision to do what was best for me. Even though I went between two households, the rules were consistent and so were the consequences for breaking those rules. I will always be thankful that my parents did that for me.
10:00 PM on 08/22/2012
There is no right or wrong answer, it depends on your relationship. If two people still care about each other and respect each other, I see no problem with them staying together, who knows in the end they might be happy with each other. On the other hand, if it is an abusive, cold and degrading relationship, I would hope that they end the relationship as they would be giving the children the impression that it is ok to be disrespectful and rude. Its all about individuality here look at all aspects of your relationship if at any point you think you are setting a bad example for your children BREAK UP. You are your child's biggest role model, he/she may not realize it or admit it but its the absolute truth.