iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Khulood Ghanem

GET UPDATES FROM Khulood Ghanem
 

Living Under the Bombing of Gaza

Posted: 12/22/09 09:53 AM ET

On December 27, 2008, 27-year old Khulood Ghanem was in Gaza City when Israel launched its massive three-week military assault on the captive population of Gaza. 1400 Palestinians were killed, a majority of them non-combatants and 400 of them children. Much of Gaza's infrastructure was destroyed.

Khulood kept a diary every day of the Israeli assault. In March 2009, Khulood volunteered to help with translation for a CodePink Women for Peace delegation that managed to get into Gaza for International Women's Day. Two of the delegates -- Tacoma WA resident Linda Frank and Canadian-Israeli Sandra Ruch -- learned of the existence of Khulood's diary and asked Khulood for permission to read and make public this rare personal account of living under the bombing. Khulood translated the first seven days of the diary from Arabic into rough but clear English. Linda Frank brought playwright Edward Mast into the process to adapt the text into a performance piece which has been performed several times in the Seattle area. Plans to perform the piece in other cities include solidarity events with the Gaza Freedom March on December 31, when 1300 people from 42 countries will attempt to break the siege.

A full year after the assault ended, Gaza is still in ruins. Israel has maintained sporadic attacks as well as a siege and blockade which prevent food, medical supplies, building equipment and other necessities from entering Gaza. Israel's blockade has made reconstruction impossible, and this human-created catastrophe continues. What follows is an adapted excerpt from Seven Days From A Gaza Diary, a performance for three voices adapted by Edward mast from the diary of Khulood Ghanem, Gaza, 2008-2009
-- Linda Frank and Edward Mast]

****
At 11:45 I was on my way walking in the street. I heard the first rocket, the second and the third, many quick attacks, one after one, at this moment I could see nothing, all I remember was the biggest explosion I have ever seen. I started to run away, but to where? I saw the military planes in the sky at a very low level. I was scared and started to lose consciousness. All I was thinking was how to reach a safe place. The sound of bombs and explosions was horrible, the ground was moving up and down, I said, it is not a joke, it is a real, the war has started.


I stopped beside a building looking at the sky, watching the military planes. At that moment I lost my ability to move or even to think. People, girls and children, all were shouting, running every where, it was the time for students to leave their school, I thought that if they started to attack haphazardly they will make a catastrophe. I walked a lot till I felt sick, the attacks increased and all streets started to be empty from people except the emergency and ambulance cars. I was worried about my family, sisters, brothers, friends, I tried to phone every one I knew to assure that all are safe but the attacks destroyed the telecommunication net.

My journey to Khan Younis took 3 hours. It was more safe to avoid the main street because most of the police stations that have been attacked were located at the main street. Finally I reached home. All my family were sitting glaring at the screen of the TV, shocked, pale, yellow and horrible faces, sitting like idols. I took a place beside them. The first scene was the police academy. The number of martyrs was big, about 180 in one place, the scene was horrible, really can't be described, blood in every place, severed parts, heads, hands, legs and arms, couldn't be described. I spent my whole day sitting on a chair in front of the TV. I did not expect one day that I will face such catastrophe, hour after hour, number of martyrs increased and increased.

At 8:30 this night I had a call from my sister who lived in Gaza city. She was walking beside the fence of that school, she saw the heads of young children, bags colored with their blood. One child with his blue shirt, she taught him once before, he was thrown on the ground, bleeding from all parts with no legs, he was shouting and raising his hands, but no one could help. She started to scream, what should we do? I kept silence and started to cry loudly, the vision was so hard to imagine. She started to lose her breath. I told her that is enough, please stop talking, I can't tolerate. I closed my mobile and took my diary and sat in the living room . . . .

Full text of Seven Days From A Gaza Diary at www.palestineinformation.org/GazaDiary

For more about the Gaza Freedom March: www.gazafreedommarch.org

To listen to a studio recording of Seven Days From a Gaza Diary, go here.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 283
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:32 PM on 01/09/2010
1/9/10
"Meanwhile back in the Gaza Strip, Channel 10 quoted unnamed Hamas sources as saying they managed to smuggle into Gaza weapons that would tip the balance of power between Israel and Hamas.

The report, which The Jerusalem Post could not confirm, comes after several days of intermittent rocket and mortar shell fire entering Israel, some of it fired by groups not affiliated with Hamas.

http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1262339436535&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
belyeu
02:02 PM on 12/26/2009
As you recall the Palestinians rejected the British mandate of Palestine and opted for war with the anticipation of destroying Israel.

I guess since the Palestinians could not succeed as conquers they will be able to succeed as victims.

The Palestinians have no one but themselves to blame for their situation.
06:57 PM on 12/30/2009
They weren't victims until Israel decided to become relentlessly self-interested oppressors.
08:57 AM on 12/24/2009
People will die violent deaths today around the world in regional conflicts...however, the Palestinians and their friends feel that we must always place their victimhood first. So that's what we get, year old "diary entry" of someone who does not speak against the violence from their own side. The Arabs lost the war 60 years ago and again many times over, time to move along.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheLonelyGod
The oncoming storm
11:09 AM on 12/24/2009
The Palestinians and their supporters don't want people to know that there are other conflicts and catastrophes happening around the world. If they did, then they would know that there are other peoples in much worse situations than the Palestinians. And that's something the Palestinian supporters can't let happen, because then they would lose much of their support.
photo
jwcmass
I dream of things that never were and ask Why not
09:41 PM on 12/24/2009
And your basis for this conclusion is....?
01:49 PM on 12/24/2009
At this location we are not discusing "the whole world " we are discusing the actions of Israelis in operation "Cast Lead" (although it should have been Cast Bombs) It is a losing point in any debate to use misdirection to obfusicate the argument, it is another losing point to us alegory as defense , when i look at your posts you act as if no one else has ever been in a structured debate or has any idea about the rules of one or how to identify misdirections and false alegory
Once again Hasbara talking points FAIL
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
08:02 PM on 12/24/2009
Israel would not have carried out Cast Lead if Hamas was a responsible organization. Instead Hamas fires rockets and missles into Israel in an attempt to disrupt life and to kill if possible and you act as if we should accept their actions without any complaint.
11:05 PM on 12/24/2009
Israel would have never have carried out Cast Lead if the Israelis really wanted Peace
When you Blockade a people of all of lifes necessitys that is as much of an assault as rockets are. Israel has never kept an agreement with the Palestinians so no suprise that there is no trust
04:52 PM on 12/23/2009
" Linda Frank brought playwright Edward Mast into the process to adapt the text into a performance piece which has been performed several times in the Seattle area. Plans to perform the piece in other cities include solidarity events with the Gaza Freedom March on December 31, when 1300 people from 42 countries will attempt to break the siege."

Thanks to Khulood Ghanem, Linda Frank & Edward Mast for bringing forth this presentation to the American public when our politicians & the corporate media would prefer that the Palestinians like Khulood remain voiceless.
Peabodies
We are the Many. They are the Few.
09:59 PM on 12/22/2009
Thank you Arianna, thank you CodePink, for covering this issue from the Palestinian side. What happened a year ago was godawful, and needs to be told and retold and retold.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:12 PM on 12/23/2009
YES. The unprovoked rocket attacks on Israel are indeed, godawful. So too the kidnapping of Gilad Shalit--and his ongoing captivity and the ransom negotiations for his release.

Awful too, must be the fate of Palestinian children whom are raised by parents who don't report the missile launching attacks of their neighbors. What a cruel fate, to be parented by those complicit in homicide attacks--what a conflicting message it must be.

So, shine a light, by all means. Just be sure to point it in the PROPER direction.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rachel Brownlee
05:49 PM on 12/23/2009
You've got to be kidding me!
Unprovoked rocket attacks?
Imprisoning 1.2 million people in an open air ghetto, stopping essential aid from entering, cutting off water, holding and torturing over 9000 political prisoners (including children), destroying crops, stealing land and killing innocents seems ample provocation to me.
in fact, I'd call it self defense.... as does the Geneva Convention!.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce
Atheistic-agnostic Canadian polymath
12:54 AM on 12/24/2009
I always ask those who use the rocket fire from Gaza to excuse Israel from responsibility for the deaths of Palestinians, and the deliberate attacks on the civilian infrastructure of Gaza (which constitute a war crime) two questions.

If the rocket fire from Gaza is such a concern to the Israeli government, why does the Israeli government allow many of its citizens to face it without any protection (paragraph 1714 of the Goldstone report)?

And how do you excuse the attacks on the civilian infrastructure of Gaza by the IDF that occured before any rockets flew?
photo
jwcmass
I dream of things that never were and ask Why not
01:10 AM on 12/24/2009
I think it was the author Herman Wouk who said that the beginning of the end of War lies in Remembrance.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bermanator
over the green line
01:43 AM on 12/24/2009
Your posts are much more effective when concise. Good quote.
04:05 PM on 12/22/2009
Hundreds of Israeli civilians have been murdered in cold blood. Whether rocket fire, suicide bombings or stabbings, strangulations...children and the elderly. It is very sad what has happened in Gaza, but they must have felt they had no choice to protect their citizens.
Peabodies
We are the Many. They are the Few.
10:01 PM on 12/22/2009
juicy -- "hundreds"? you sure? That's not what I read. Thousands on the other side is what I read.
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
10:46 PM on 12/22/2009
The collateral damage in Gaza was due to the tactics employed by Hamas. The group fires rockets into Israel from civilian sites and when the IDF returns fire it has a good chance of hitting civilians. When the IDF responded to the contin ued attacks by Hamas the Israeli troops wqere fired on by cowards hiding among the Gazan civilians, making a higher civilian body count impossible to avoid. Is it regrettable so many civilians were killed, of course. Who caused it to happen? Hamas.
03:47 PM on 12/24/2009
Juicyju wall up all the non jews in NYC so nothing gets in or out and see how they treat you there
09:12 AM on 12/23/2009
Stopping food and medicine from entering Gaza at the border in a blockade , well it doesnt get much more "Cold Blooded" than that . Using white phosporus bombs in a populated area ... once again hard to get much more cold blooded than that (yes even when america does it , still cold blooded) Punishing civilians for military actions they couldnt stop if they wanted to... not only cold blooded but as all of the above ...considered war crimes by "Civilized nations" Did germany argue that war crimes were necessary to protect its citizens also .....yes . Is that the company Israel want to keep in this argument?
10:16 AM on 12/23/2009
Gaza one year later. How awful, but at the same time, how deserving.if people want to play with matches, they get burned. From where are the bleeding hearts are sitting, I have no doubt, that if your neighbors were tossing hand grenades into your where perhaps your children were playing, you would sit idly by and clap your hands with delight. But there's more, the day after, and continuously for years , you are experiencing the same attacks, and reported this to your local police, who did nothing!

But then, how could you take matters into your own hands?

Where were the so-called human rights groups , the UN., and all the bleeding hearts ?
I guess, when it comes to Israel, no one can find it on the map, right?

wake up and smell the coffeeand get a life!
11:05 AM on 12/23/2009
If i was preventing those neighbors from leaving the house or working or if i had control of their power in the hoouse and turned it off when i felt like it . if their water had a control on my property and i dialed it down to a trickle .... yea i would expect them to throw handgrenades at me and anything else they could get their hands on . If my house was built after i had put a fence across their property and i had taken what i wanted .....Yep it wouldnt suprise me at all anything that they did to me or my kids. If i then had their house buldozed so they could live in a shack or a tent even in the winter i would expect them to hate me with all of their heartand not just them but anyone that loved justice would hate that oppressor . You are the one that needs to "Get Real"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eileenflemingWAWA
http://www.wearewideawake.org/
01:40 PM on 12/22/2009
During Israel's Dec/Jan assault on Gaza, "Washington provided F-16 fighter planes, Apache helicopters, tactical missiles, and a wide array of munitions, including white phosphorus and DIME. The weapons required for the Israeli assault was decided upon in June 2008, and the transfer of 1,000 bunker-buster GPS-guided Small Diameter Guided Bomb Units 39 (GBU-39) were approved by Congress in September. The GBU 39 bombs were delivered to Israel in November (prior to any claims of Hamas cease fire violation!) for use in the initial air raids on Gaza.

US tax payers provide over $30 billion annually to Israel although Israel has consistently misused U.S. weapons in violation of America's Arms Export Control and Foreign Assistance Acts.

In November 2006, Father Manuel, the parish priest at the Latin Church and school in Gaza warned the world:

"Gaza cannot sleep! The people are suffering unbelievably. They are hungry, thirsty, have no electricity or clean water. They are suffering constant bombardments and sonic booms from low flying aircraft...the cries of hungry children, the sullen faces of broken men and women who are just sitting in their hungry emptiness with no light, no hope, no love.

"These actions are War Crimes!"

The Rest:

http://wearewideawake.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1523&Itemid=227
04:59 PM on 12/22/2009
Maybe we are giving aid to the wrong people ,If we gave 30 Billion Military Aid to Palestinians For just one year and enforce a No Fly Zone over Israel bet the Israelis would clear out of the West Bank and East Jeruselem and be very willing to talk Peace
07:30 PM on 12/22/2009
Funny, Iran just gave Hamas 25 million, sure it will be well spent.
07:39 PM on 12/22/2009
And will Israelis let Hamas buy Building supplys with any of that money and allow it into gaza? Will Israel release any of the Palestinian money it has been holding . Israel wont allow Gazans to buy food and medicine and only allows 25% of donated supplys to pass into Gaza . Dont we just love Israel on the "HighGround" in its Policy
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Balzac
12:27 PM on 12/22/2009
I was very frustrated by that campaign, but also the bombardment of Beiruit as well. It is a shame that it happened and that the campaign claimed so many civilian lives. It is also a shame that this area was used for rocket and mortar fire into Israel. Why this was allowed, I don't know but that was also a problem. Then Israel responded disproportionately, which was tragic for the families of the dead, and unfortunate for diplomacy.

I strongly believe that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert had chosen a disproportionate response. Israel should begin to recognize the excesses of their own leaders, but I suppose this will not begin to happen until there is some stable security arrangements made. Israelis, and people from neighboring countries and territories adjacent to Israel should not miss the historical opportunity inherent in President Obama's administration for peace.
12:41 PM on 12/22/2009
Ok, so what should Israel do? Terrorists fired rockets into Israel on a regular basis, I mean every day for years. Israel appealed to the UN, directly to Hamas, to Abbas all to no avail. So what would you suggest?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Balzac
01:15 PM on 12/22/2009
They should have responded as if it had just happened that day, not as if it had been going on for years.

Just make an attack within reason, don't blow up any civilians, don't try to "solve" the problem in one campaign. For that matter, tell them the strike is going to happen and to clear the area, and then demolish a landmark.

Symbolism is more useful than carnage. One meaningful death can do a lot of good, lots of senseless death will never be helpful. Kill just one or a few guys who are responsible.

It was the same mistake Harry Truman made in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and FDR made in Dresden and Tokyo. Civilian casualties didn't help "win" the war, they only made the world a more grim and paranoid place to live.

And Einstein was in agreement with this understanding, and President Truman broke the agreement. It wasn't necessary to gain the surrender of Japan. Military strategists who rely on old doctrine and old rules of engagement are creating misery.

If I were a general, I would be able to slay all the generals whose thinking belongs in the last century. I'm not saying I aspire to that or I have animosity towards them, I'm just saying I would handily defeat them if all other circumstances were equal.
Thelonius
Lived in Middle East for
01:58 PM on 12/22/2009
Some perspective: the attacks with crude homemade rockets from the occupied Gaza Strip started in 2001 and took their first Israeli victim in 2004. Since then, there had been 14 Israeli victims prior to Israel's massive land, air and sea assault (Operation Cast Lead) in Dec. 2008 against 1.5 million caged and essentially defenseless Palestinians in the Gaza Strip. While tragic, hardly comparable to the 1,700 Gaza Strip Palestinians, including many innocent bystanders, women and children, killed by Israel during the same period.
Futhermore, in violation of the 17 June 2008 cease-fire agreement with Hamas, Israel permitted only 20% of the amount of essentials agreed to into the Gaza Strip which led to sporadic rocket fire into Israel (causing no casualties) by Islamic Jihad and Fatah’s Al Aqsa Brigades, not Hamas, which attempted to stop the rockets. On November 4 – the day of the U.S. presidential election - Israel crossed the border and killed six Palestinians. Hamas responded with rocket fire but also offered to extend the June 17 truce if Israel would abide by its terms. Israel refused. Hamas rocket fire resumed and although no Israeli was killed, it was used by Israel as a justification for its murderous rampage that began on December 27.
11:34 AM on 12/22/2009
Khulood Ghanem's diary is eerily familiar. Many New Yorkers who were in lower Manhattan have similar recollections of September 11 and the horror of that day. Only for Gazans, the nightmare continued every day for weeks. Those who try to justify this atrocity are the mirror image of those who justify the 9/11 attacks. "Our violence is holier than their violence" is a refrain that has been uttered for many centuries. 99% of the time, it's not true, and this is no exception.
04:08 PM on 12/22/2009
Only Israelis experience terror every day and live like it's 9/11 every day.
Peabodies
We are the Many. They are the Few.
10:07 PM on 12/22/2009
So you say, juicy. You don't live in Gaza.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rachel Brownlee
06:10 PM on 12/23/2009
"only Israelis experience terror every da and live like it's 9/11 every day."
Funny, israel has a thriving tourist industry, can't be to scary there.
Anyone planned a holiday to Gaza to year?
FAIL!
04:01 PM on 12/23/2009
So, tell me, when and where did those persons targetted by 9/11 continuoulsy fire off rockets and at whom? Or, how were children sitting on a bus in Israel guilty of attacking Palestinians? You are off your rocker and not making any sense. Sorry. Palestinians have not only declared war on Israel, they are constantly engaging in it, and every now and then they do get a measured response, sothat they will finally stop. The 9/11 crowd is yet another piece of the pie. It started in Egypt with the Muslim Brotherhood, and that little group of friendly doves first attacked other regimes in the ME. They work from the inside out as a tactic and do so in multiple countries and to undermine multiple regimes. Al Qaeda, which comes straight out of that *brotherhood* is operating all over the globe, a.o. in Afghanistan and Pakistan and India, but not only there. Their first targets, however, were Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, and a few of their operatives are even in Iran! Egypt has blockaded Gaza and Hamas as well, for their own reasons. Israel is a target because of its strategic location in the fight between Iran/Saudi Arabia. Lebanon and Gaza are useful strategic territories, and obtaining Israel would enlarge that strategic territory.
07:34 AM on 12/24/2009
MM526 - Trying to connect Gaza and 9/11 & Al Qaeda isn't very convincing.

As the occupying power Israel is the aggressor in Gaza.

You can't blame the occupation of Gaza or East Jerusalem / West Bank on Hamas or the Muslim Brotherhood.

Further, the blockade of Gaza predated by years the election of Hamas also. It was merely tightened after 2007.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TJCole
11:27 AM on 12/22/2009
When you make a sport out of firing missiles into another nations territory, that's what happens...

A pox on both your houses..!
01:01 PM on 12/22/2009
Agree. How about an account of an Israeli's experience living through the mortars and rockets fired by Hamas. There are innocents and villains on both sides, so telling only one side of the "story" is tendentious.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rachel Brownlee
06:16 PM on 12/23/2009
You can see accounts of Israeli's experiences all over youtube. Just type in Israeli settlers attack Palestinians. Should be more than enough to keep you busy!
07:11 AM on 12/24/2009
Yes we could hear the stories of the 20 Israelis who were killed by Gaza rockets from 2000-2008, then we could hear the stories of the 2000+ Gazans killed by IDF over a similar time period.

I'm all for telling both sides of the story.
11:24 AM on 12/22/2009
The truth brings out all the rabid wannabes fresh from their empathy and brain bypass operations. Just watch.
07:31 PM on 12/22/2009
You realize that statement makes you sound just like what you accuse people of.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zoooni
former C-Span junkie
10:51 AM on 12/22/2009
There is NO excuse for any people to be treated in this inhumane fashion. Terrorism has many faces,obviously. They owe Israel no thanks. If this were your land,or country,you would fight for it ,however you could.
03:14 PM on 12/24/2009
But they HAD their land all to themsleves in Gaza, and could have had the start of a country. Why didn't they?
10:27 AM on 12/26/2009
Really, they had it to them selves

The U.N. position

"Yes, the U.N. defines Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem as Occupied Palestinian Territory. No, that definition hasn't changed," the spokesman replied.

The U.S. position

The CIA World Factbook says: "West Bank and Gaza Strip are Israeli-occupied with current status subject to the Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement -- permanent status to be determined through further negotiation; Israel removed settlers and military personnel from the Gaza Strip in August 2005."

The U.S. State Department Web site also includes Gaza when it discusses the "occupied" territories.

All Israel did was move the troops to the border, when you control everything that goes in and out you are still the occupying agent. More inaccurate Zionist ideas.
10:17 AM on 12/22/2009
What a tragedy. If only the Palestinians could leave behind their corrupt "leadership," get rid of Hamas and Islamic Jihad and other hate groups, and embrace a future with statehood, building an infrastructure, developing peace and prosperity in cooperation and friendship with Israel, inviting outside investment, then peace would truly erupt in the region. Sadly, the Palestinians have been saddled with being manipulated by despotic Arab regimes, self-serving b@stards like Arafat (who walked away from a workable deal in 2000!), and religious fanatics who glorify death and murder and 'martyrdom' rather than CREATING something viable. May the day come soon when there will be a peaceful Palestine living alongside Israel in friendship for the mutual benefit of each.
03:44 PM on 12/22/2009
Its kind of hard to see mutual bennefit when Israel sends West Bank water to Illegal settlements, walls off Palestinian Farmers from their land , bulldozes homes and trees and burns trees . You cant make a treaty with a country that does not recognize international law, you know like Israel does
Peabodies
We are the Many. They are the Few.
10:09 PM on 12/22/2009
yes, Thabit.
03:17 PM on 12/24/2009
Remember Thabit, all that came about after they attacked Israel in 1967, and continued afterwards.

Since no one else recognizes "international law", and there is no enforcing power; since not everyone is "equal under the law", ther is, in fact, no valid law.
03:08 AM on 12/23/2009
luv your name :)
03:18 PM on 12/23/2009
fancy yours too!
08:30 PM on 12/23/2009
Thank you Juicy but cant return the favor
10:12 AM on 12/22/2009
Does Hamas have army barack style locations? Or do they live with their families while planning and executing operations?
11:36 AM on 12/22/2009
"Hamas lives with their families while planning and executing operations." This is an excuse for bombing civilian areas, on the theory that there may be some Hamas fighters mixed in with the civilian dead? Really?
12:43 PM on 12/22/2009
The excuse? You are duped into believing that there is no place in Gaza that is not populated. This is not true. And believe me, even if the Israelis had to sit in the middle of nowhere they would never make bombs in their houses, hospitals, schools or synagogues. The Arabs have done this for at least 60 years. As Golda said, until the Arabs care about their children this will never stop.
12:55 PM on 12/22/2009
You did not answer the question...let me try again..

Does Hamas have army barack style locations?
Or do they live with their families while planning and executing operations?
03:50 PM on 12/22/2009
By that argument since all Israeli adults are members of the army then firing rockets at Israeli settlements is justifyed warfare . That shoe fits both feet . How ever Palestinian women do not serve in the military . Palestinians do not target Israeli children with sniper rifles either but Israelis do target Palestinian children so why not rocket back
03:22 PM on 12/29/2009
"so why not rocket back"?

Because it accomplishes NOTHING!!
10:09 AM on 12/22/2009
Perhaps if Hamas was not 100% committed to the destruction of Israel, Gaza would not be in this position. The Israelis left and, in thanks, Hamas sent rockets raining down on their towns. You'd think maybe they would have tried to build a viable society but apparently not.

The Palestinians deserve a homeland but first they must renounce their stated position that Israel must be destroyed. Doesn't seem like a lot to ask.
11:45 AM on 12/22/2009
Hamas is at fault for being "100% committed to the destruction of Israel." Actually, Hamas has repeatedly stated its willingness to accept the two-state solution. To the extent anyone wants to "destroy" Israel, they wish to "destroy" the system that grants superior rights to Jews born in Brooklyn than to Palestinians born in Nazareth. The discriminatory policies legally sanctioned in Israel against its own Arab citizens would never be tolerated here, and the stateless Palestinians in the territories are much worse off, living under foreign military occupation with no rights at all.

The Israelis left Gaza? They merely pulled out their illegal settlers. They remained in control of what goes in and out. What about the stifling siege that Israel has imposed, restricting the available food, water, fuel, and medicine available to 1.5 million people? This is a blockade that caused a humanitarian crisis even before the invasion a year ago, and it still is imposed. Israel had peace from the rockets with a cease fire that lasted for months despite Israel's refusal to ease the blockade. The cease fire ended when Israel violated it with a deadly raid n early November 2008. It still could have been repaired, but Israel refused to allow any challenge to its "authority" to make Gazans miserable.

Are Hamas's rockets aimed at civilian areas in Israel morally indefensible? I think so, but how can you condemn such acts while condoning and even supporting far worse violence on many more people?
12:31 PM on 12/22/2009
"Hamas has repeatedly stated its willingness to accept the two-state solution??" On what planet did this happen? It is clearly stated in their charter that they will not accept a Jewish state - or Jews - on 'Palestinian land' under any circumstances.

So please, let's at least be accurate where empirical data is available.

I don't agree with a lot of what the Israeli government does, but I do understand that when your next door neighbor repeatedly advocates your total annihilation, it is a bit difficult to normalize relations.
12:37 PM on 12/22/2009
Oh, and that 'system' you refer to is called Zionism. It's the right of the Jewish people to return to their ancient homeland (I know you will deny this but, again, it is a fact).

Maybe you haven't been paying attention to 2,000 years of history, but the Jews have not exactly been welcomed in a lot of places on this planet - and that includes the US. Israel is the one small corner of the world that we can go to and have some control over our fate. Not a small thing. I'm not denying that the Palestinians deserve a similar right - but they have to share, which Hamas will not agree to.
Thelonius
Lived in Middle East for
02:20 PM on 12/22/2009
In 1988, on behalf of the Palestine National Council, Yasser Arafat agreed to the existence of a sovereign Jewish state in Palestine and in 1993, he accepted UNSC Resolution 242, thereby agreeing to a sovereign Jewish state within its 4 June 1967 boundaries, those accepted by all countries, including the U.S. The Palestinian leadership accepted the 2002 Arab League Beirut Initiative offering full recognition of a sovereign Israel, including exchange of ambassadors, trade, tourism etc. if Israel complied with international law and its previous commitments by withdrawing to its 4 June 1967 borders and also cooperated in achieving a "just" solution to the Palestinian refugee problem. In short, the Palestinians would accept a state comprising a mere 22% of their original homeland. Israel dismissed the offer and continued to build more illegal settler colonies in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem while at the same time dispossessing more and more Palestinians. Israeli historian Avi Shlaim has aptly summed up the truth: "[I]n very readable prose, based on facts, he surveys the history of Israel's contacts with the Arab world from 1948 to 2000, and states decisively ('The job of the historian is to judge,' he says) that the Israeli story that Israel has always stretched out its hand to peace, but there was nobody to talk to - is groundless. The Arabs have repeatedly outstretched a hand to peace - says Shlaim - and Israel has always rejected it. Each time with a different excuse." (Ha'aretz, August 11, 2005)