This is the movie: Mulholland Dr.
David Lynch gets America. America the beautiful, America the bizarre. We can discuss how "weird" he is, how inscrutable his movies can be, how much he loves oddly conceived babies, oddly shaped humans, oddly pale-faced Robert Blake, oddly obsessed Crispin Glover and his "lunch!", but the man gets what drives our subconscious, our sweet dreams, our nightmares.
So naturally, Lynch understands one of the oddest cities on earth -- Los Angeles. With his brilliant, labyrinthine Mulholland Dr., a movie that started out like a jilted starlet (it was an axed TV pilot) he digs underneath our peculiar Hollywood system -- a system that pedals dreams, desire, sex, money, magic -- dreams that have the ability to spread like a celluloid sickness all over America (especially during the 2000's. Did he know how prescient he was going to be?). Through the bright-eyes of innocent Betty (Naomi Watts, in a career defining performance), a starlet seeking fame in La La land, he presents a twisted, romantic, funny, terrifying and deeply emotional mystery involving a gorgeous amnesiac, a monster behind a diner, a persona altering box, a pair of elderly folks who slither under doors, and a director who answers to a dwarf, a mobster and a cowboy. And let's not forget Coco.
Hauntingly beautiful, poignant, funny, subversive, dark, meditative, sexual (Lynch is one of the few American directors who can actually create inspired, erotic and yet intensely emotional sex scenes) and more, Mulholland Dr. poses many questions, but offers few answers, reflecting life in all of its enigmatic complexities. And if you think it's weird that a box might be responsible for transforming a promising young actress into a suicidal starlet, rubbing herself in a tragic masturbatorial rage, then you need to spend a little more time in Los Angeles. Or on reality television. Or in your girlfriend's living room after you ditch her. Or in a director's chair. Or simply walking up and down Hollywood Blvd. between Western and Normandie.
Speaking personally, I can say that living in this city long enough, Mulholland Dr. does not seem that out of the ordinary. And this realization came to me quickly. Directly upon moving here, the very first apartment I looked at, (recommended to me at the noodle joint across from Jumbo's Clown Room at 2 AM by a weathered, drunk L.A. native waxing nostalgic about seeing Patty Duke perform her mournful "Don't Just Stand There" on Shindig!) was, unbeknownst to me, that very same apartment Miss Watts inhabited as sad, suicidal Diane. I'll never forget the creepy familiarly while walking through the grounds, searching for a landlord and knocking on a stranger's door only to be answered by a stern faced woman who treated me like a suspicious intruder. A lovely place, but, when it hit me just where I was standing, I resisted a possible rental application. I realize it's only a movie but, no. Living there seemed tantamount to beginning my new life in Roman Polanski's digs from The Tenant.
That's how powerful the picture is -- it just gets under your skin and into your bones and bubbles with your blood. It may be notoriously tough to decipher, but truly, Lynch captures the city, its vibe, its ragged romanticism, its cruelty, its impenetrable dysfunction and its absurdity (Billy Ray Cyrus is the pool cleaner. And that makes perfect sense) with his distinct brand of warped clarity. Our country's often freakish, surreal desperation to emulate or ponder the "glamour" of Hollywood is just as weird and just as affecting and just as relatable as...Winkie's dream. Mulholland Dr. is a masterpiece. "This is the girl" indeed.
And the rest of the list. Forget ten. Twenty-two sounds right:
Battle Royale, Dogville, Werckmeister Harmonies, Beau Travail, Zodiac, Adaptation, The Royal Tenenbaums, Black Snake Moan, I Heart Huckabees, Inglourious Basterds, Kill Bill Vols. 1 & 2, There Will Be Blood, Punch-Drunk Love, Oldboy, Grizzly Man, Birth,O Brother Where Art Thou?, No Country For Old Men, Talk to Her, Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans, Irreversible.
Read more Kim Morgan at her blog Sunset Gun.
Follow Kim Morgan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SunsetGunShot