One in four children goes without breakfast each morning, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. A tragedy to be sure -- but are Kellogg's breakfast products the solution?
Last week Kellogg announced its new project called Share Your Breakfast, part of a national advertising campaign. The project asks Americans to upload their breakfast photos to the Web site shareyourbreakfast.com, and for each breakfast photo shared, Kellogg Company will donate a school breakfast to a child in need -- up to $200,000 worth of (or one million) breakfasts.
Feeding hungry children sure sounds nice, but filling hungry bellies with highly-processed junk foods is hardly the answer. Let's take a look at some of the products Kellogg is promoting as part of this endeavor.
Frosted Flakes -- one of the products represented by Tony the Tiger at a National Breakfast Day event in New York last Tuesday -- contains 11 grams of sugar per three-fourths cup serving. After the first ingredient of milled corn, the next three read: Sugar, malt flavoring, and high-fructose-corn-syrup -- three forms of sugar by different names.
Nutri-Grain bars -- a product promoted as healthy -- contain more than 30 ingredients (minus the synthetic vitamins) and include high-fructose-corn syrup, artificial flavors, red #40, TBHQ, and host of other chemicals. Meanwhile, the front of the package reads: "More of the whole grains your body needs," "Good source of fiber," and "Made with real fruit." The only "real fruit" I could find is "strawberry puree concentrate" and it's listed after high-fructose-corn syrup and corn syrup. Each bar contains 11 grams of sugar and 3 grams of fiber.
Even Corn Flakes contain sugar, malt flavoring, and high-fructose-corn-syrup, listed as its second, third, and fourth ingredients. Kellogg is also offering promotions on Rice Krispies, Mini-Wheats, and Eggo Waffles -- the waffles contain partially-hydrogenated oils in addition to high-fructose-corn syrup.
But Kellogg Company knows that people are concerned about feeding their kids sugar and chemicals for breakfast every morning, so it has dedicated whole sections of its Web site to "correcting" false nutrition information. In one section, Kellogg refers to sugar as the "misunderstood nutrient." According to the Web site, "Sugar does not cause obesity, type 2 diabetes, heart disease or hyperactivity." This statement flies in the face of the most recent research and a host of mainstream studies that say the exact opposite.
One of the most recent studies, reported in TIME Magazine last year, found that consuming added sugars raises the risk for heart disease by raising cholesterol and triglycerides. The American Heart Association's (AHA) Web site states, "High intake of added sugars is implicated in numerous poor health conditions, including obesity, high blood pressure and other risk factors for heart disease and stroke." The AHA is so concerned about the amount of added sugars in the American diet that in 2009 it established upper limits for adults (none exist yet for children, oddly enough). The AHA says that women should get no more than six teaspoons a day and men no more than nine.
Most of the Kellogg's products I researched contained an average of 11 grams of sugar per serving, which is close to three teaspoons of sugar. If we assume that the average child weighs about half what the average woman weighs, then three teaspoons is the upper limit of how much a child should safely consume in one day, according to the AHA. That means the child couldn't eat any other added sugars for the rest of the day (not likely) and that he or she could only eat the single three-fourths cup serving (also, not likely). The AHA says the average American eats an alarming 22 teaspoons of added sugar a day.
According to research by the Yale Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity, children will eat cereal with less sugar if the option is made available. The report found that the industry strives to reinforce the myth that children will not eat low-sugar cereals. "The industry has funded a number of studies that find that highly-sweetened cereal is good for children, especially when compared to having no breakfast at all," the report noted. Nutrition information based on these studies is exactly what Kellogg has laced throughout its Web site. In the section on sugar, you'll find, "Keep in mind that a little sugar in foods can help the nutrition go down. For instance, picky kids might be more likely to eat presweetened cereal or drink chocolate milk. They'll love the taste and you'll love the nutrients they get from these foods." This may well be true, but a "little sugar" is a lot different than the 11 grams found in a three-fourths cup serving of Frosted Flakes.
The Rudd Center's 2009 report also found that some rather insidious advertising techniques appeared to be on the horizon. "What was once a simple marketing landscape -- television advertising during cartoons -- has morphed into a complex web of persuasive messages even adults may not perceive as marketing. Internet games and marketing through social media such as Facebook are just the beginning and do not capture digital advances that will occur in the future," it stated. With this new Kellogg campaign it appears that day has arrived.
Make no mistake, Share Your Breakfast is an advertising campaign above all else. According to a New York Times article, the campaign is the largest integrated marketing effort, with ads in broadcast, print, digital, print, and social media. The campaign asks users to upload pictures to Twitter and Facebook, in addition to posting them on Kellogg's Web site. And while Kellogg has agreed to donate up to $200,000 towards feeding hungry school children, this pales in comparison to the amount the company spends on advertising overall. The Times reports that Kellogg spent $464.9 million on advertising from January through September 2010 and $454 million from January 2009 through September 2009.
Meanwhile, the company is painting a rather rosy picture as to its motivations. "We find there's a lot of people who don't have access to breakfast," Doug VanDeVelde, Senior Vice President for marketing and innovation at Kellogg told the Times. "We just felt like as the breakfast leader, we should do something about that."
He's right, Kellogg and every other food industry giant certainly should do something about the hunger problem, but they shouldn't be filling already undernourished children with food products that are nutritionally void at best.
How about providing funds to feed kids real food for breakfast? Eggs, plain yogurt with fresh fruit, oatmeal, a fresh fruit smoothie with yogurt, milk, or nut milk, a slice of real, whole-grain bread with almond or peanut butter (skip the Skippy!). All of these breakfasts can be made in five to 10 minutes without the added sugar or hype.
Or better yet, why not apply some of that creative talent along with that large advertising budget and produce breakfasts that are nutritious enough to qualify as real foods? Then we could believe them when they say, "The best to you each morning."
This post originally appeared on Civil Eats
Follow Kristin Wartman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kristinwartman
Craig Bowron: How We Treat Heart Disease Isn't Good Enough
Pre-diabetes is at 20% and will only continue to rise exponentially...
The clock is ticking!
http://www.angrytrainerfitness.com/2011/01/top-10-breakfast-cereals/
THEN I go smoke a cigarette.
I don't make a lot of money, but I choose to buy healthy and organic foods anyway because it truly is worth it in the long run. With the prices the way they are, it's just too unrealistic for a food revolution.
The reality is that cereal manufacturers probably have excess product on hand (likely near or past the expiration date) and rather than throw it away they are providing it as 'aid' to hungry children.
Now, given the circumstances, wouldn't you rather have a bowl full of Frosted Flakes for breakfast as opposed to nothing ....were you that starving child, or their parent? I believe I would.
Also, doesn't anyone shopping notice that Kellogs cereals are EXPENSIVE! Hence there's plenty of privileged children eating cap'n crunch peanut butter cereal with hershey's chocolate milk for breakfast. Store brand oatmeal + cinnamon + diced apple + plain yogurt is cheaper and might spare the dental bills and health issues later in life.
Don't take your kids shopping -- a grocery store has more cartoon characters than saturday morning tv. They aren't on steel cut oats and bananas because its assumed a smart shopper doesn't look for cartoons to endorse nutrition.
People come complacent at doing the least amount of work for as much pay as they can get. Until schools districts start getting fresh food and demanding their caf workers put in the effort, kids will get crap to eat.
Culinary schools are a great way to do it, but we do need new approved menus that have a balance of foods. Tate tots are fine as long as they are limited and on a plate with protein and veggies.
A school here in LA was completely taken over by parents (not just the caf, but the whole school) when the parents and kids got sick of the bureaucracy getting in the way of education. They can do that here. More should.
Tater tots are great -- if they are made out of potatoes. The more you know about what is in processed food the more you won't eat it.
The Jamie Oliver experiment really just emphasized something that food corporations know and I got the feeling that he missed the fact that corporations are smarter than Jamie Oliver. Kids like things they can depend on -- something that looks like a chicken nugget is food. The food industry spends millions to psychoanalyze kids on the best way to get them to beg for corporate food. Cartoons! Familiar shapes! Win! Win! Win!
I think its great people are empowering themselves. I live in Atlanta we fully expect our mayor to take the schools back from the state, a lot of us librul cities are doing it. I have a few degrees in stuff like history, economics and geography and in my less than humble opinion the only way we are going to get things turned around is by taking them back. Here in the South politics are local, its how Atlanta stays strong, and rumor has it our mayor has been schooling Mr President, lets hope.
Until then viva LA! We have to stop being so pc and send the devils back to their exurbs. If you want to wear teabags instead of finding practical uses for them you gotta go outside the city..
I used to eat Kellogg's (unsweetened - I thought that was still safe) cereal every morning until I realized what was in it (shudder). Now I don't bother with the regular cereal aisle at all. Lucky for me I can afford to shop in the natural foods section, where I don't have to waste time reading products' ingredient labels only to find they are chemical amalgams parading as food.
In the long run Kellogg Co. will regret their unwillingness to adapt to mounting scientific evidence that processed food products are bad for our health while real, natural foods are good, as well as the increased market demand for the latter.
It's just a shame that in the meantime this corporate recalcitrance is disproportionately affecting lower income families who are less equipped to deal with the consequences. Shame.
Lori Reamer, RD
Author of The Food That Fits
Even Kix costs more than Frosted Flakes on average.
Then again, I don't think sugary cereals are bad, but should be eaten in moderation. There's a reason that you can go through a box of cereal in a week, but your only meal should not be those types of cereal.
(And let's be real, many kids end of eating cereal for breakfast, lunch, & dinner because that's all they have...)
parents that can't cook raise kids that don't eat well. cooking isn't an art. with a little practice you can master it. I argue until I am blue -- you can cook a pot au feu and have a bottle of wine with it for a lot less than it costs to go to mcdonalds. i fully realize cooking might cut into tv time, oh the horror.
sugary cereals are what I like to call a carb bomb. Most nutritionists, even the conservative ones suggest you reduce your processed carb intake. Sugary cereals are 100% processed carbs. Do the math.
(My mother was famously tight herself------I learned a bunch of tricks & habits that serve me well to this day, I'm pushing 60.)
I agree on the moderation thing tho-------we got 1 soda pop per week, no exceptions.