iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Larry Magid

Larry Magid

Posted: January 25, 2011 12:35 AM

2011-01-25-macair.jpg
11-inch MacBook Air (Credit: Apple)

Apple, in its earnings report last week, announced that Mac sales in its most recent quarter were up by 23 percent over the same quarter last year despite the popularity of the iPad, which competes with personal computers. Overall, PC sales were up only 3.1 percent in that quarter, according to Gartner.

One reason Mac sales surged is two new MacBook Air laptops, which in my opinion are the best portable PCs on the market.

I was an avid Mac user during the 1980s but have mostly used Windows for the past 20 years because I had a strong preference for lightweight laptops from Lenovo, Toshiba and Hewlett-Packard.

As a frequent business traveler, I need a small and light notebook PC, which is why I've been carrying around a 2.9-pound Lenovo X300 for the past two years. And I do carry it around. I had it in my bag constantly during the recent Consumer Electronics Show, for example, pulling it out on a moment's notice to record a radio interview, access the Web, edit a photo or a video, or fire up Microsoft Word to work on a column.

But on returning from CES, I thought it was time to try out an even lighter notebook PC, so I borrowed both an 11-inch and 13-inch MacBook Air from Apple to try out. I'm impressed by both. But because of my travel needs, I think I'll buy the 11-inch model, even though, at 2.3 pounds, it's only 0.6 pounds lighter than the 13-inch.

Despite a more cramped screen and a bit less horsepower than the 13-inch, there is something about this tiny laptop that I find appealing. I also like that it will easily fit on an airline tray or a lectern if I'm using it to give a presentation. In fact, it's so small and light that I find myself using it instead of my iPad to watch video, surf the Web or send e-mail. It's much more expensive than an iPad but has a real keyboard, a slightly larger display and two USB ports, as well as the ability to play flash video and to support external monitors. It can also run flash and thousands of Mac programs and can even run Windows if you decide to install it. The 13-inch model also has an SD card reader.

What impressed me most about the Air was the multitouch trackpad, which, unlike trackpads on most Windows machines, allows for very smooth scrolling when you use two fingers to move up and down. Other laptops support this feature, but most of the ones I've tried are choppy and not 100-percent reliable. The Air also supports iPad-like gestures such as pinching to zoom.

At a starting price of $999 for a model with a 1.4 GHz processor, 2 GB of memory and 64 GB of solid-state storage, this is definitely a pricey laptop. An 11-inch model with 128 GB of storage, 4 GB of memory and a slightly faster 1.6 GHz processor costs $1,399.

The solid-state drive, which has no moving parts, is faster and less prone to damage than a hard drive, which is one reason the machine is so expensive.

As a Windows user, the big question for me was whether I would be comfortable going back and forth between the Mac notebook and the Windows desktop machine I use in my home office. In the past, I found it awkward to switch back and forth between the two platforms. But thanks to the "cloud" and the plethora of cross-platform open-source applications, that is much less of an issue than it was.

The first thing I did when I got the new Mac was to download both the Google Chrome and Firefox browsers. With Chrome, all I had to do was enter my Gmail address and it automatically synced bookmarks, passwords and extensions with my Windows version. I used Xmarks to sync bookmarks across platforms and browsers. These browsers work on the Mac exactly as they do on Windows, so there is no learning curve whatsoever.

I also installed Microsoft Office, which is slightly different from its Windows counterpart, but similar enough. Then I installed a few open-source cross-platform programs I use, including the Audacity audio editor and FileZilla FTP program, both of which are nearly identical on both platforms.

Finally, I installed Parallels Desktop, which enables Macs to run Windows and other operating systems as a "virtual machine." I'm pleased to say that Windows runs great, and that even the Mac's trackpad worked well with Windows.

There certainly are much less expensive notebooks and netbooks on the market, and many people need only a $399 netbook to access the internet and get their work done from the road. But the Mac Air is worth considering for anyone who needs a reliable, rugged and lightweight computer.

This article first appeared in the San Jose Mercury News.

 

Follow Larry Magid on Twitter: www.twitter.com/larrymagid

11-inch MacBook Air (Credit: Apple) Apple, in its earnings report last week, announced that Mac sales in its most recent quarter were up by 23 percent over the same quarter last year despite the pop...
11-inch MacBook Air (Credit: Apple) Apple, in its earnings report last week, announced that Mac sales in its most recent quarter were up by 23 percent over the same quarter last year despite the pop...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
05:20 PM on 01/30/2011
I'm going against the trend, and am milking the last bit of life out of my 5-year-old laptop. It's been a great machine, did what I wanted it to, but the 'road warrior' telecommunications thing is just...well, I bought my first laptop when computers still basically ran DOS, and the thrill is gone, somehow. The novelty of constantly being connected(and having a telecommunications company also thereby connected to my WALLET) is over and done with. I'm digging through the computer hardware I found in the back room, and I'm going to reconstitute a working desktop out of the pieces. Maybe that makes me a stick in the mud, but I just remember the carefree days of walking down the street, and not being connected to anything. Oh, the tranquility. 

If you've got an 'on the road' job, you might be stuck with a computer with wireless/cell modem as a necessity. And, if that's the case, then something like this might be the answer. But, how much information do you NEED? That's a question everyone has to answer for themselves, and will influence how much they're going to shell out for the latest, greatest 'thing'.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:21 PM on 01/30/2011
ditto. i use mine till they fall apart
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bioluminescence
12:03 PM on 01/30/2011
Just wondering. Is this a news story, an advertorial or an advert?
11:59 AM on 01/30/2011
The MacBook Air is superior. It is not a fad device and is fully functional. The tablet is a gadget that has style, hype a cool factor but of little use. The public often falls in love with a lesser product and justifies their purchase. I have been thrilled with my Air and see little utility to an I-Pad. In terms of a e-reader the Kindle for a fraction of the price makes much more sense and yes it does not do color but if you read books it is perfect.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:49 AM on 01/28/2011
Given that the Air was actually designed by either Asus or Quanta and neither will sign a long term exclusive ODM agreement, there is a very real possibility that there will be competitive Widows system on the market within a year for a lot less money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mheister
Raconteur. Blog michaelheister.com
04:36 PM on 01/30/2011
Source?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:06 AM on 01/31/2011
Personal conversations with executives at Asus, Quanta and Apple Plus the FACT that Apple uses an ODM model.

Note that Quanta is the number one laptop maker in the world with Compal, Acer, Lenovo and Asus real close behind. Quanta is an ODM for HP, Dell, Apple, OLPC and several others. Compal is an ODM for HP, Dell and several others. Acer not only makes their own brand, but are also an ODM for several other companies. Asus not only makes their own brand but they are also an ODM for HP desktops and Apple laptops. As far as I know Lenovo only makes their own brand and are not an ODM.

All of the US based laptop brands (Dell, HP, Apple, etc.) use the ODM business model where the device is designed, manufactured and shipped from ODMs in China. All the laptop brands do is market the devices.

Note also that most of this information is widely available in the Chinese language press and some of the Asian English press.

BTW - I am not under non-disclosure, but have been involved in the business for many years and know what questions to ask and how to interpret the answers, especially the winks and nods. ODMs are proud of what they make and are bursting to tell all, but keep it sly to keep from alienating their customers (that actually know a lot about each other).
08:07 PM on 01/26/2011
The back-lit keyboard is needed on every laptop - but the price is 40% too high relative to the competition.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:03 PM on 01/25/2011
The Air is so expensive not because of its ssd storage (64gb drives cost less than $130 retail) but because it is a Mac.
08:13 PM on 01/25/2011
Just a warning regarding the MacAir: it is so thin, it does not have an internal disk drive, nor does it have a port for a thicker telephone-type ethernet connection. When I was buying it, I never even thought of asking if it had a disk drive, and ended up having to buy an attachment (as well as an ethernet-usb adapter. Other than that, it's a fabulous machine.
12:02 AM on 01/26/2011
The MacBook Air's solid state disk drive is its internal disk drive. How do you think the Air stores data without one?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Flip75
What's wrong with my micro-bio?
12:07 PM on 01/30/2011
That's all well and good, but if you do anything with CDs (whether just listening to music or burning data onto them), the Air is useless without peripherals.
07:46 PM on 01/25/2011
As with any product the consumer decides what is important. I have an Air and the iPad. Since I have no need for a full fledged computer/ laptop they are marginal products for me. The iPad is my main computing device even though I occassionally use my Air and Mac desktop. Those two are my gadgets!
07:24 PM on 01/25/2011
Smart observation. I have a MacBook Air with no desire or need for the I-Pad that is a marginal gadget.