EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Laura Beck

GET UPDATES FROM Laura Beck
 

A Plea to Kevin Smith: Fatty, Accept Thyself

Posted: 3/10/10

I'm really happy that Kevin Smith caused a stink about getting thrown off a Southwest flight. Their seats are ridiculously cramped (even for people who aren't "morbidly obese") and the absolute rudeness of that fat-phobic flight attendant who kicked him off deserved to be called the hell out. Smith is on a rampage, dedicating countless tweets and smodcasts to raging against Southwest, but like most of us, he's still part of a bigger (hyuck hyuck) problem.

Every time he says that he's trying to lose weight, it's a win for them. Every time he says he's not "that big," it's a win for them. Kevin, own the fact that you're a big fat fatty: there is nothing wrong with that. You have a crazy-successful career, you're obviously brilliant, you have a beautiful wife and child, and yet, you're still apologizing for your fat. You need to own the fattness, bro. A way to do this? Be honest about the Southwest situation. Maybe the seat IS uncomfortable for you, and maybe that's not your fault. Maybe in an attempt to cram more people into smaller seats, the once exciting, glamorous experience of flying is now a nightmare. Don't say that you need to lose weight and that you're not that big. Say, "Hey, this sucks and has got to change."

Another thing Smith can do? Cast some freaking fatties in his movies -- and not just dudes. Cast some hot fat chicks as leading ladies. I'm not talking Shallow Hal-style either (shudder), I'm talking genuinely sexy, smart, cute, fat actresses. They exist, it's just harder to find them because many (especially the younger ones) aren't working or are a tragic case of the "after photo." That will change if they start to get roles. Smith throws some rotund love towards chubbers like Seth Rogan, but his female leads are always stick-thin, classic Hollywood hotties. It's kinda like the "SNL: No fat chicks!" policy. Sure, bring on Chris Farley (RIP) and Horatio Sanz, but a fat woman? NO WAY! And let's face it; fat people are funnier than skinny people. It's just a fact. How much more awesome would Zach and Miri Make a Porno be if the female lead had been a chubosaurus? MUCH MORE AWESOME.

Smith definitely still buys into the ideal that thin is better, and it's reflected in his reaction to being kicked off the plane and in his casting choices. Smith, it's time. Join the fat army. Stop apologizing for your fatness; revel in it. I don't mean go out and eat Cheetos until you go into cardiac arrest; eating healthy, whole foods and exercising is important for people of every size. I mean embracing the size that you're genetically predisposed to and working it. Prejudice against fat people is one of the last socially acceptable forms of prejudice and it's not okay. My plea to Smith is this: go to bat for the fat team. With your intelligence, fan base, and loud-ass voice, you can help make progress toward fat acceptance.

 

Follow Laura Beck on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mrpenguino

I'm really happy that Kevin Smith caused a stink about getting thrown off a Southwest flight. Their seats are ridiculously cramped (even for people who aren't "morbidly obese") and the absolute rudene...
I'm really happy that Kevin Smith caused a stink about getting thrown off a Southwest flight. Their seats are ridiculously cramped (even for people who aren't "morbidly obese") and the absolute rudene...
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Atchka
Editor-in-Chief of Fierce, Freethinking Fatties
12:38 PM on 03/11/2010
He's got many, many, MANY other things to think about and the only reason he turned his attention to FA issues is because it affected him. I wish it would keep his attention on the issues longer, but accept that he's got other things on his mind. We can't expect every fat celebrity to take up the banner of Fat Acceptance­, but we can leverage every opportunit­y that fat celebritie­s give us to raise the issue and create more dialogue.

The Kevin Smith/SWA incident was an excellent opportunit­y for education and I'm grateful that he did more than just bury the subject because it could be potentiall­y embarrassi­ng (and based on much of the ill-inform­ed coverage of it, it did seem pretty embarrassi­ng after a while).

I don't expect Kevin Smith to accept himself. It's his journey to take. I just think that we should appreciate the attention he has brought to the issues and, maybe if you meet the man, you can make a plea for self-accep­tance. Other than that, he's just gonna do what Kevin Smith does. And I'm all right with that.

Peace,
Shannon
Atchka.com
FierceFatt­ies.com
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Atchka
Editor-in-Chief of Fierce, Freethinking Fatties
12:37 PM on 03/11/2010
I get what you're saying, but I don't think that he hasn't embraced his fat. He seems sort of in-between on the whole Fat Acceptance thing. He seems to accept his own weight, but still struggles with body image issues (he talks about this at length in his excellent Q&A sessions on "An Evening with Kevin Smith") just as most fat people do.

This incident raised his awareness of the mistreatme­nt of fat people in public, but had it not happened to him (in what seems like a freakish over-react­ion on the part of the airline... but thank goodness they did so there was a robust public dialogue about airline seating policies) he probably still wouldn't give a shit.

I think that, like most Americans, he doesn't give issues of fat discrimina­tion a second thought until it actually affects him, which is evident when he talks about how he's not *that* fat. As though if it happened to someone fatter than him it would be justifiabl­e or excusable.

I don't think that makes him a jerk, I think it makes him an American. As Americans, we pick and choose our battles, we decide which causes we're going to go apeshit over. I think Fat Acceptance people saw Kevin Smith as a potential ally in the fight against fat discrimina­tion, but he's a tepid, half-heart­ed one at that.

And I can't blame him.

(continued­)
11:32 PM on 03/10/2010
Questionin­g his casting choices is an odd angle to take on this three-week­-dead topic.

But since you brought it up, Smith has often said he's had difficulty casting the female leads he wants (Dogma and Clerks 2 come to mind for sure). It's not like it's his call and his call alone.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JimmyD
06:41 PM on 03/10/2010
Honey. I'm 6'4". I weigh 220. I am height/wei­ght/propor­tionate.
Their seats are uncomforta­ble. My legs are cramped while the person in front of me reclines.
What do you suggest I do? Should I pay for two seats? Should I charter a private plane?

Oh... also... it seems that you haven't done much research into the Smith story... past watching a segment on TMZ. He has posted plenty, while SWA has posted almost nothing... and within that almost nothing are edited/cen­sored/chan­ged documents. Look into it.

Double-plu­s Also: Smith hasn't mentioned this in a couple of weeks. No. Only you sweetheart­, only you.
Slow news week for you?

BTW: Do you work for FOX News? Your "reporting­" reeks of it.
06:59 PM on 03/10/2010
You made a fan out of me, JimmyD. The author posted this after posting a (terrible) piece about fat actress Gabourey Sidibe, and so it would appear that this (terrible) article is part of her fat-cred-b­uilding efforts.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laura Beck
08:20 PM on 03/10/2010
i've read all the smith blog posts and listened to the smodcasts.

now, my turn.

did you read my post, past the subject line? smith has said repeatedly that he's not "that fat" and that he's trying to lose weight. those are the two things i address in my post, i never said anything about him not giving Southwest hell. also, I said that the seats are uncomforta­ble for all of us, did you see that? Please re-read and then if you don't get that we're pretty much on the same page, I don't know what else I can do for you.
09:09 PM on 03/10/2010
"did you read my post, past the subject line?" Yes. I made it all the way to this complete fabricatio­n: Kevin, "you're still apologizin­g for your fat." Still? When did he start? Where has he continued? Since when is trying to lose a few pounds an apology for being fat? If you have this I would LOVE to see it.

"smith has said repeatedly that he's not "that fat" and that he's trying to lose weight." Putting "quote marks" around a couple "random words" does not make "a quote." Where did he say this? When? Why? Could you provide some context?

I know that over the many years I've been a Smith fan he has been on many different diets for different reasons. Are you trying to insist that you know the reason he is dieting, and it's because of social pressures? Can you prove this? Have you considered that he is trying to lose weight for reasons that he did not discuss with you? For his health, for aesthetics­, for sex, even?

"also, I said that the seats are uncomforta­ble for all of us, did you see that? " I did see it, but I ignored it, because I never gave you the right to speak on behalf of ME and I don't remember seeing you elected the spokespers­on for Fat Town.

You call the man a "fatty" and then wonder why people with weight issues have weight issues. Incredible­.
09:23 PM on 03/10/2010
(cont'd)
Here is what you can do for me and the other readers who are posting comments like this: Next time you want to make a post about fat pride or whatever your still totally mysterious point is, don't lasso in some in-the-new­s celeb to try and bolster your reader count. Also, don't put words in other people's mouths, always cite your sources, avoid the tired 'expert' voice where you make completely absurd generaliza­tions about "all of us," and next time you put pet to paper you might try and come up with a better premise from the start.

That Kevin Smith is some sort of in-denial self loathing fat celeb, lying to himself and to us, is just absurd. Honesty is the man's brand. He has fans like myself because he does not pull punches and wears his entire insides on his sleeve.

Oh, and explain how getting mad that you've been called to fat to fly is the same as saying thin is better? What Kevin has said over and over and over is that he understand­s the Southwest definition of too fat to fly- armrests not down- and he is not that. How does this become "I'm sorry I'm fat" or "skinny people are better???"
05:28 PM on 03/10/2010
Did you even listen to the Smodcast regarding this incident? Kevin Smith is the first person in the world to admit he's fat! He says it several times in the SModcast about Southwest Airlines. Give it a listen. Give it a listen, go to smodcast.c­om, load it into iTunes, and listen to it. Listen to it, get back to me, give me an email after you listen to it, ShoopufEat­Moogle@gma­il.com, listen to it, then email me, and tell me he does not accept being overweight­.

http://smo­dcast.com/­smods/smod­cast106.ht­ml

There's the link, listen to it. Listen to it, then tell me he doesn't own up to being fat.
06:55 PM on 03/10/2010
Thank You Edward!

I'm a huge fan of Kevin Smith's and have listened to all 100+ episodes of his smodcast. This article could not be less accurate of a representa­tion of how Kevin Smith carries himself. It couldn't be any more clear that she did NOT listen to the relevant smodcast or any of the others and has no idea at all what she is talking about. But if I were you, I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for a response to your comment... you'll get that e-mail when Huffpo takes down this crap article all together.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laura Beck
08:21 PM on 03/10/2010
Never said he didn't own up to it, just said that he doesn't embrace it. And I have already listened but thanks for passing it on anyway.
05:03 PM on 03/10/2010
Personally­, I would love to see some funny fat ladies on screen. Bring em on, Smith!
05:02 PM on 03/10/2010
It is nice to see someone have the courage to speak out on this topic for once, and not be shut down by all the judgmental bigots out there.
04:00 PM on 03/10/2010
Right on.
03:17 PM on 03/10/2010
NO, don't accept that being that fat is normal, OK, or even, perfectly acceptable­. it is not. Don't try to lose weight. just do it, you know how.
09:32 PM on 04/21/2010
But that's MEAN!!! Fat people have feelings too. It doesn't matter that virtually nobody was obese 100 years ago...thei­r weight problem is genetic!!! They've tried so hard to lose weight, they just can't, because they're VICTIMS!!!­!!1

Honestly Ms. Beck you have a point. While very, very few people have any excuse to be fat, those who don't want to lose weight should accept their fatness. There are worse character flaws. On the other hand fat people who do try to lose weight but can't...tr­y harder. Unless you can complete a triathlon (and there are overweight people who can), then you would be skinnier if you worked out more, and you're only a victim of yourself.