iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Laura Rodgers

GET UPDATES FROM Laura Rodgers
 

Nation Needs to Address Nursing Educator Shortage, Yesterday

Posted: 08/24/2012 3:47 pm

Last year, the first cohort of 79 million baby boomers entered the U.S. Medicare system, bringing with them chronic health problems and high health care expectations. Older Americans require far more health care services than their younger counterparts, making the current shortage of nurses critical. And as health care reform is enacted and millions of previously uninsured crowd into the system, even while the U.S. population continues to expand, the nursing shortage will only become more urgent.

Unfortunately, nurses can't be trained without nurse educators, and that shortage is even more dire. Last year, more than 75,000 qualified nursing applicants were turned away from nursing schools across the country, in large part because school administrators are simply unable to fill numerous vacant positions. In fact, this fall many schools will not know until the week before classes whether they will have enough faculty. Searches for deans can last for years and currently there are 64 open dean positions.

Ironically, the need for nurses comes at a time when nurses are required to make far more independent, critical judgments about care, judgments that often affect life or death outcomes. The shortage in nursing is not related to there being a technical skills gap but is related to a gap of professional nurses.

Higher Workload, Lower Salaries Discourage Nurses From Entering Academia

Several factors contribute to the scarcity of nurse educators. Unlike typical doctoral-prepared college professors who begin their academic career in their early 30s, the average nurse educator with a doctoral degree doesn't begin teaching until she or he is almost 50. They also retire earlier, leaving a small cohort of graying professors to educate the country's new nurses. These short academic careers are causing havoc for our health care system.

Less than 1 percent of nurses have doctorates, and with good reason. After taking on graduate school debt, nursing professors with doctoral degrees work longer hours and, on average, make less than nurses with bachelor's degrees. Competition for nurses with graduate degrees also lures many potential nursing professors out of academia and into lucrative private and clinical sectors that pay significantly higher salaries.

Lower salaries aren't the only reason that nursing educators are in short supply. Unrealistic expectations about academic roles can frequently result in 60 to 80-hour work weeks. Like non-nursing faculty on the tenure track, nursing faculty are expected to carry out teaching assignments, advise students, engage in scholarship and provide service to their school, their profession and their community. However, nursing faculty must also remain current in their clinical practice. This requirement is typically not taken into account by academic institutions, and doesn't play into promotion or tenure decisions. It is extremely difficult for nursing faculty to balance academic roles while enhancing expertise and maintaining clinical practice.

Interestingly, faculty salaries for other professional programs, such as engineering, business management and computer science, are far more competitive. I suspect that universities don't lack the funding. Decision-makers simply value many other professional academic programs more highly than nursing programs.

The number of doctoral graduates has remained flat even as more students enroll in graduate programs. The nation awarded just over 400 doctoral nursing degrees each year from 1965 to 2006. The shortage also threatens nursing research, which typically takes place in academic settings. This research informs nursing practice and improves patient outcomes. It is invaluable to each of us.

Financial Support, Technology and Revised Faculty Expectations Can Alleviate Shortage

Although the country is struggling with an economic recession, we must address the nursing faculty shortage before it becomes even more expensive and more burdensome. This issue should be foremost on the national health policy agenda.

Recruitment of nursing faculty should ideally begin in undergraduate nursing programs, and even in high school and junior high school, and once students get into graduate school, federal and state government programs should provide scholarships. Student loans carried by graduates of doctoral and master's programs could be reimbursed in exchange for post-graduate teaching for specified periods of time. Colleges and universities with nursing programs should reimburse school loans of junior faculty who have completed or are completing doctoral programs.

Other solutions include the integration of technologies, which will allow schools to educate more students with fewer faculty. For example, simulation labs allow students to practice taking vital signs and life-saving measures on computerized mannequins, before they practice on live patients. We would also do well to revise state nursing regulations, permitting graduate students to intern as teachers of undergraduate students, with careful oversight and mentoring by experienced nursing faculty.

Academic institutions could also address the faculty shortage by offering two options to nurse educators, a tenure track for those who choose to take on the role and full expectations of academia, and a non-tenure track for those who choose to be experts in teaching and clinical practice.

Concerned researchers have surveyed nursing professors at hundreds of schools and issued recommendations. Once new faculty have been successfully recruited, it is important not to overload them with classes, so they are able to develop as effective teachers and role models. It is equally important to lower the workload of senior faculty who serve as mentors to junior faculty. Teaching expectations should also take into account the time required for clinical practice.

The health of the nation depends on professional nurses. In the hospital, nurses provide the majority of hands-on, frontline, direct care to patients 24-hours a day -- managing complex health situations, working with families, collaborating with other health care providers -- in other words, doing the work. In the community setting, nurses provide effective health promotion and disease prevention care to individuals and communities.

Research has shown that people die without adequate nursing care. Consequently, in order to solve the nursing shortage we have to solve the nursing faculty shortage first. Addressing the nursing faculty shortage will assure that future nurses are taught to practice evidence-based nursing care professionally and safely.

 
FOLLOW IMPACT
Last year, the first cohort of 79 million baby boomers entered the U.S. Medicare system, bringing with them chronic health problems and high health care expectations. Older Americans require far more ...
Last year, the first cohort of 79 million baby boomers entered the U.S. Medicare system, bringing with them chronic health problems and high health care expectations. Older Americans require far more ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freedom Mama
Proud to be an American
01:04 PM on 08/27/2012
I agree this is a problem. My daugher wanted to major in nursing in college, but due to the shortage of instructors, they take less than a quarter of the applicants into the program. She didn't want to take a chance of working for 2 years and then not getting accepted into the program, so she chose a different major. Seems crazy to me. I keep hearing we need nurses, but there is not enough instructors to teach them.
02:21 AM on 08/27/2012
The solution is......import more Filipinos. I mean this with all love, got three Filipina RNs in my extended family.
12:42 AM on 08/27/2012
Tough question, as they often are. My 16 year old sister just had surgery for scoliosis and a nurse came in to try to give her medicine for a patient named "David." We need the right motivation as well, which narrows the search. More opportunity for education means more funding for education.
02:42 AM on 08/26/2012
Want to know there are so few nursing educators? Here's what happens: Nursing students enter training, lured by the luster of "Wanting to Make A Difference". They go through years of grueling training, learning complicated microbiology, pharmacology, pathophysiology & medical procedures. They are taught how to use that knowledge to monitor & respond to critical situations to prevent patients from dying.

Then they are thrust onto the floor, where they're expected to take care of eight, nine (or more) patients, even when studies show that for safety nurses really shouldn't have more than four at a time. They run ragged, sacrificing personal needs like food/drink, going to the bathroom & are constantly stressed from responding to life threatening situations daily. They find they don't have TIME to "make a difference". Instead they are overworked, underpaid for the level or responsibility they shoulder & are really underappreciated.

After a few years of being slowly beaten down, nurses quit. They go on to other careers with more realistic expectations & a saner environment. The more nurses driven to quit the field, the fewer there will be to educate the next batch of nurses to be worn down and thrown away. The cycle continues & patients continue to be endangered. Unless the inherent working conditions are changed to improve safety & stressors in the nursing workplace, any money spent for programs to encourage more nursing training and education will be wasted. This video gives a peek into their world: http://ow.ly/dewI7
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Xoubuo
I call it, how i see it
11:47 PM on 08/25/2012
Maybe Nursing schools should consider the Medical school Model where the first two yrs are strictly book knowledge and lecture classes with lab time. The the last two yrs can be devoted towards clinical training at any hospital they so choose. The first two yrs, colleges and univ can take more students and the last two yrs hospitals and clinics can take them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:31 PM on 08/26/2012
it doesn't take 4 years to fully educate and clinically acclimate a professional nurse and many hospital schools easily did it in TWO years intensive or 3 years with a feww weeks vacation time and they all had a proven track record of their graduates passing the state boards,minimum orientation and being safe,reliable and professional.
their bs of a college degree minimum for entry into practice is a proven failure and they refuse to "address" their own self made problem and never prepared for this either.
02:14 PM on 08/30/2012
There is PLENTY of research validating improved patient safety and inpatient clinical outcomes associated with a 4 year Nursing degree. There is no "proven failure" documented in research--saying it is so does not make it so. ADN programs produced a lot of grads with technically acceptable skills 25-40+ years ago when programs were first implemented pre Medicare/Medicaid. Hospital-based care was much different then than now, with many patients with relatively lower acuity conditions staying for up to two weeks at a time in many community-based hospitals. WE now have an explosion of biotechnology, rapidly expanding drug and implant options and a significant shift in aging-related chronic diseases with longer-living older adults having an average of 4 comorbid conditions, and much sicker patients being admitted to hospitals. Having more didactic and clinical education as acute and long-term healthcare becomes more complex is a necessity for RNs, not a spurious decision. Patients, and those of us paying taxes to fund third-party health insurance programs, deserve to have well-educated and technically competent caregivers, with both adequate technical and leadership training. That's one of the many reasons for requiring a 4 year Nursing entry level. This education policy is a not a rejection of ADNs, it is is an acknowledgement that more education and training is needed to prepare RNs who can provide effective care in a health care system that has changed in the presence of changing patient demographic and clinical characteristics.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:32 PM on 08/25/2012
They made absolutely sure that every single accredted hospital school of nursing was shut down knowing full well they would not follow through with their bright ideas on what constitutes a registered professional nurse.
They have had more than thirty years/three decades to get their rear ends in gear and fully furnish and equip the colleges and universities with THEIR aternative.
Isn't it great to have them in charge ?

I imagine having hundreds of fully prepared,ready to work, professional nurses of both the LPN and RN level graduating every single year was simply too much for the state license division to handle.
Same for the programs advancing the LPN to RN in one year.

The nation addressed nursing and destroyed it.
10:33 PM on 08/25/2012
it would be wise to recognize that we are actually out-sourcing our nursing education to other countries by importing large numbers of foreign nurses....

and it would be wise to recognize that any statistics on the nursing shortage are irrelevant if the health care systems will not fund the projection of nursing positions required...those positions don't exist if they are not funded and that funding is constantly and significantly being whittled...many nurses are experiencing additional stress over cancelled hours and shifts from this whittling...a very large number of nurses hold second, even third, jobs to ensure they can make a living...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:59 PM on 08/25/2012
why does the nation have to do it?
why not the people? the hospitals?
if you PAY them, they will come.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Catriona49
07:01 PM on 08/25/2012
Another facet needs to be examined here. I worked 36 years in medicine. I worked with a huge number of nurses, and was a preceptor for nursing students at one time. One mindset should be amended: There is a place for teaching nursing students theory, and administrative tactics and skills. Yet, the focus should remain on hands-on nursing practice. I've worked with a lot of nurses that were great at doing the staffing schedule and requesting supplies and equipment for a unit, and were woefully under experienced in actually doing patient care. We can't have all chiefs and no indians ( no disrespect intended for the use of the phrase). Trained technicians and other care providers can be invaluable. They have training, they work 'the floor' and in some instances, are more than capable of doing assessments, triage, etc. The patient should not be the last consideration on a nurses agenda. I'm all for good wages , great benefits, all of that. But the old adage 'patient advocate' needs to become paramount again. Lots of nurses leave the profession when they are in a position where they have to actually do hands on care. That's a shame, and a disservice to the patients at large.
10:15 PM on 08/25/2012
very, very true....many do not want to give patient care at the bedside...we also precept large numbers of nurses and a common theme is that their goals are management oriented and not patient care...hands-on nursing practice is not coveted...
12:22 PM on 08/25/2012
This is to all the Nurses out there,Why are the schools making it so hard for prospected students to enter a nursing program ? There is always some unexplained reason as to why there are 1-2 year waiting lists just to get into a program and each school has their own procedures or policies that require some sort of prior training or have a NURSING designation already.I hope someone can put some perspective on this,before I change to a different vocation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:41 PM on 08/26/2012
see if there are any programs with a fast track to RN either via LPN to RN or having completed your state's requirements for a liberal arts then transfer to a private program only teaching nursing 1,2, and 3-

I would even check on what the UK and ireland are offering for nursing as their standards of care are the same as in the USA- and all you have to do is sit for your state boards out here upon return.

"" they"" will never admit the failure of their garbage that college is theee requirement and that the accredited schools of nursing simply educated and trained all capable of their strict requirements and graduated professionals all without college degrees.
09:28 AM on 08/25/2012
As a professional nurse, I hold a Master's degree in Nursing Administration. Community Colleges and Universities do not pay well for nurse educators ($60-75K annually, some even less) and that is with a Masters and or PhD . Private nursing programs are charging 2-3 times more for nursing students which makes it difficult for students who want to enter the profession. Wait lists are being canceled. Prospective students are being turned away due to the lack of educators. Nurses do not want to take a $30-40K annual pay cut to go into teaching.
04:20 PM on 08/25/2012
wow so its true it is all about the money :(
Im a nursing student who have a passion for nursing and due to the shortage I will work as one for 4 years at least....I care less about the pay. My true love is helping burn victims.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freedom Mama
Proud to be an American
01:08 PM on 08/27/2012
$60K - $75K sounds like a pretty good salary to me, with a lot less stress. Something isn't adding up here.
07:53 AM on 08/30/2012
a good salary indeed, but not when one could make $100K working in the hospitals- where the job starts and ends at an almost guaranteed time..not so with teaching.

as the article points out, being an educator is not a 40 hr/wk job, and nurse educators still (either because they enjoy it or want to stay current in practice) work off shifts or weekends in direct patient care. i would have to say this makes it more stressful.
09:12 AM on 08/25/2012
I know of a school in particular in SC that purposly only admits a handful, because they dont want to handle a large class. They have at least 30 instructors but only want to admit 60 a semester. thats 2 students an instructor!!! At the same time the instructors (5 in al) at the paramedic program, handles 100 students or more!!!! and by the way you have to complete about 500 hours of hospital and truck time in there program, by SC standards and nurses just need 48 I belive! even though schools do require more time. Go Figure! And all you who live around here guess which school is guilty of this????